Because, in fairness to Trump, he's actually perfectly right about this blatant hypocrisy (in the criticisms of him accepting a call from the President of Taiwan, breaking the US policy of not talking directly to Taiwanese leaders, as China doesn't like that, believing Taiwan to be a breakaway province of China):
(I guess even a stopped clock is right twice a day, yes?)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
Everyone is going to have to start thinking very carefully about what they are doing, expecting things they can rely on not being said to now be said, and for status quos to be challenged, or even ignored.
Quick question: Is Trump someone's useful idiot?
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
The last 2 Presidents, Bush Junior and Obama started their mandates with a stand off with China, it does not surprise me much that Trump seeks one too.
Obama went even further in negotiating the Trans Pacific Trade, excluding China fm the Group. They did a lot of investment in Vietnam to counter power China, they have been getting closer with Mongolia with the same objective.
And now after pushing Russia away due to the Georgia and Ukraine crisis that lead to an approach between them and China, including the deal of the exploration of the Sibeian oil, Donald comes in and moves to restablish ties with Russia.
I guess the thing to consider now is how long, after Trump's sworn in, do the impeachment proceedings begin? And, with large chunks of his own party hating him, could he withstand them?
It'll have to wait until he's sworn in, because you don't impeach a President Elect, as he's technically not actually holding any office that you can impeach him out of yet, but once he's President, then all you need is something to hold against him - which, with Trump, ought to be easy to find, as even Nixon looks angellically uncorruptable, compared to the only President in modern times that still hasn't revealed his tax returns and is already being openly neptotistic to hand out jobs to the family and so forth, so there's bound to be something genuinely legally corrupt in there somewhere - and you can legally drive him out of office, for holding that office in disrepute.
(Because, ironically, though Clinton was being accused of being "the most corrupt candidate ever", that's actually Trump. Even if Clinton did everything she was accused of, most of it is not corruption, but rather cock-up. Benghazi would be negligence, but not corruption, as she's not lining her own pockets or gaining favour or benefit from it happening. The personal email server would be stupidity, but not corruption, as she's not lining her own pockets or gaining favour or benefit from it happening. And so forth. I mean, if you didn't want to vote her because you don't think it's wise to have a President that could be so negligent / stupid then that's fair enough. But labelling it "corrupt" is simply semantically wrong.
Whereas, you know, Trump is the only modern President-to-be who has not transparently revealed his tax returns before taking office. The "I'm under audit" excuse doesn't stack up, because the IRS has explicitly said that it's just fine and dandy for a Presidential candidate to show their tax returns, even under audit. They have no rules against it. Even if they had rules against it, then they'd bend their rules to allow it because this is the future President you're talking about. They'd make an exception. No, Trump is going into office, having blatantly hidden his taxes, with an illegitimate excuse, because it presumably reveals things that he doesn't want revealed. Now, that's corruption. And, likely, what he's trying to hide is yet more corruption, revealed by his finances.)
The comparison is with Labour and Corbyn.
The "grass roots" have, against the wishes of the Establishment, voted for the "outsider" that none of them like. Well, you can't "undo" democracy, but you can mount a leadership challenge / impeachment proceedings to attempt to dislodge them by legal means instead.
And, unlike with Corbyn, the "grass roots" can't directly save Trump from impeachment because that's a legal thing, which doesn't go to another vote.
But, yeah, the question is do the Republicans hate Trump enough to take that hit in getting rid of him? And the inevitable cries of "undemocratic" that'll ring out, because you are trying to legally dislodge him against the Will of the People. And, bloody hell, that means we end up with Mike Pence, who I've already stated here that I think is a vastly worst candidate to have running the country than even the mighty Trump (but the religious right will not see it my way at all and think he's "the Best President we've never had".)
Ordinarily, I'd say "no chance". Politicians love power.
But, then again, things are currently very weird in the political sphere, because I'd have said - did, in fact, say - "no chance" to Brexit and "no chance" to Trump winning and "no chance" that Corbyn would win and "no chance" that Labour would go to civil war to get rid of him and so forth. We're in uncharted territory where you can't judge things by probabilities anymore, so I'm just going with possibilities - Trump could be impeached, as that's a thing that could well happen - and then adding the "fuck knows" caveat to it all.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
IANAL nor constitutional expert, but I suspect that impeachment only applies to offences ["treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanours"] committed in office as President [+VP & civil officers].
Either way, two thirds of the Senate seems a pretty high bar to clear.
KlaxonCow wrote:
But, yeah, the question is do the Republicans hate Trump enough to take that hit in getting rid of him? And the inevitable cries of "undemocratic" that'll ring out, because you are trying to legally dislodge him against the Will of the People.
The will of the minority who voted for him. The people willed Hilary to be president.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
KlaxonCow wrote:
But, yeah, the question is do the Republicans hate Trump enough to take that hit in getting rid of him? And the inevitable cries of "undemocratic" that'll ring out, because you are trying to legally dislodge him against the Will of the People.
The will of the minority who voted for him. The people willed Hilary to be president.
Half plus 0.00001% of the people. Stupid people should still be allowed to vote, because otherwise, we're back to the middle ages where only some bishops can vote.
KlaxonCow wrote:But, yeah, the question is do the Republicans hate Trump enough to take that hit in getting rid of him? And the inevitable cries of "undemocratic" that'll ring out, because you are trying to legally dislodge him against the Will of the People.
The will of the minority who voted for him. The people willed Hilary to be president.
Half plus 0.00001% of the people.
Half plus 2% if you count only Trump+Clinton votes. If you count all the votes then it's less than half.
If you count the way people would have voted if they weren't forced into a two-party system then I'm sure it's significantly less still.
zip accident wrote:
…
I still want to know what the derivation of that word is, and how it compares to "sufragette" Um. maybe an extra 'f' Suffragette.
…
They both derive from the Latin 'suffragium' (support, ballot, vote), apparently:
Etymology Online wrote:suffragan (n.)
late 14c., "bishop who assists another bishop," especially one with no right of ordinary jurisdiction, from Anglo-French and Old French suffragan (13c.), from Medieval Latin suffraganeus "an assistant," noun use of adjective, "assisting, supporting," applied especially to a bishop, from Latin suffragium "support" (see suffrage). Related: Suffragant.
Etymology Online wrote:suffragette (n.)
"female supporter of the cause of women's voting rights," 1906, from suffrage, with French fem. ending -ette, but not in the sense in which it was in vogue at the time.
Fowler, 1926 wrote:suffragette. A more regrettable formation than others such as leaderette & flannelette, in that it does not even mean a sort of suffrage as they mean a sort of leader & of flannel, & therefore tends to vitiate the popular conception of the termination's meaning. The word itself may now be expected to die, having lost its importance; may its influence on word-making die with it!
Etymology Online wrote:suffragist (n.)
1822, "advocate of extension of the political franchise in Britain," without regard to gender, or, in the U.S., of voting rights for free blacks; from suffrage + -ist. After c. 1885 especially with reference to voting rights for women.
Etymology Online wrote:suffrage (n.)
late 14c., "intercessory prayers or pleas on behalf of another," from Old French sofrage "plea, intercession" (13c.) and directly from Medieval Latin suffragium, from Latin suffragium "support, ballot, vote; right of voting; a voting tablet," from suffragari "lend support, vote for someone," conjectured to be a compound of sub "under" (see sub-) + fragor "crash, din, shouts (as of approval)," related to frangere "to break" (see fraction). On another theory (Watkins, etc.) the second element is frangere itself and the notion is "use a broken piece of tile as a ballot" (compare ostracism). Meaning "a vote for or against anything" is from 1530s. The meaning "political right to vote" in English is first found in the U.S. Constitution, 1787.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Governmentyard wrote:Quick question: Is Trump someone's useful idiot?
Officially, he's the American electorate's useful idiot. They voted him in.
They're tired of the status quo and voted Trump because, by accident or malice, he seemed a sure fire hit for ruining the status quo one way or the other.
At least, that was the reasoning and I do understand it (I'm reminded of the Shakespearian quote: "I understand the fury in your words... but not the words"). But, well, they were wrong. Trump's appointing crooked bankers - that even he himself called crooked during the campaign - and all the usual suspects, while increasing the corruption even further with lashings of nepotism and anti-science stupidity on top.
This is not the revolutionary you've been looking for. Not at all. Quite the opposite. He'll make the cronyism and corruption much worse, in fact.
So the real quick question is: Have the American electorate been duped into being someone's useful idiot, with Trump merely the proxy and puppet in all of this?
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes