Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
I think the problem some people have had with "Rogue One" is that its not exactly the film promised by the trailer. It could even be argued, despite the X-Wings, Star Destroyers and people continuing to have a bad feeling about this, its not exactly a "Star Wars" film either. The trailer promised "Star Wars Oceans Eleven" and what you actually get is "Star Wars Saving Private Eryso". It relates to the original "Star Wars" in much the same way "Aliens" relates to "Alien". Your enjoyment of this film is probably going to depend on how much time as a kid you spent playing with your lone Stormtooper figure and wishing that you had an army of Rebels and Imperials to battle with. Pretty much the entire last third of the film is the "Star Wars" fight scene to end all "Star Wars" fight scenes; it makes the scrap at the of "Jedi" look like... well, someone playing with their lone Stormtrooper.
In my case, that time spent playing was a lot, and I enjoyed "Rogue One" immensely.
Some random thoughts:
Stormtroopers continue to fail to prove why they are the Empires elite shock troops. I really want to see that film where they earned that reputation.
Boy, the Empire and the Rebel Alliance really need to work on their computer interface design. And the Empire also needs to hire a security consultant.
It is impressive that, in this day and age of multi-billion dollar blockbusters, one can still be impressed by FX work. One effect in particular has caused some comment, but for me I had more trouble with the voices than the FX work. The soundtrack is also a bit odd - its like it wants to do its own thing but keeps getting pulled back to John Williams.
Apparently you can't fly an X-Wing unless you have a 70s porn star 'tache.
Yep, the 'droid gets all the best lines.
After everything else, I could forgive the film anything because among the many, many, many homages and references, they included the guy who very shortly after this film was set said:
"Cut the chatter, Red Two."
In my case, that time spent playing was a lot, and I enjoyed "Rogue One" immensely.
Some random thoughts:
Stormtroopers continue to fail to prove why they are the Empires elite shock troops. I really want to see that film where they earned that reputation.
Boy, the Empire and the Rebel Alliance really need to work on their computer interface design. And the Empire also needs to hire a security consultant.
It is impressive that, in this day and age of multi-billion dollar blockbusters, one can still be impressed by FX work. One effect in particular has caused some comment, but for me I had more trouble with the voices than the FX work. The soundtrack is also a bit odd - its like it wants to do its own thing but keeps getting pulled back to John Williams.
Apparently you can't fly an X-Wing unless you have a 70s porn star 'tache.
Yep, the 'droid gets all the best lines.
After everything else, I could forgive the film anything because among the many, many, many homages and references, they included the guy who very shortly after this film was set said:
"Cut the chatter, Red Two."
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
Finally saw this yesterday, quite liked it tbh. I initially liked force awakens until I saw it again and realised how much it pandered to the fans of the originals without doing anything of its own. Rogue one was at least a bit different.
Tarkin was a bit disappointing though, I wasn't actually sure how they'd have I'm appear, but I knew that they would; I cant imagine the death star without him!
I made my own cg Peter cushing a week before release:
https://www.artstation.com/artwork/1WXwK
It's putting these things into motion alongside real humans where they just can't stand up. I'm pretty sure it could have been done better, but not alot..
Star wars is gonna be an annual event from now on!
Tarkin was a bit disappointing though, I wasn't actually sure how they'd have I'm appear, but I knew that they would; I cant imagine the death star without him!
I made my own cg Peter cushing a week before release:
https://www.artstation.com/artwork/1WXwK
It's putting these things into motion alongside real humans where they just can't stand up. I'm pretty sure it could have been done better, but not alot..
Star wars is gonna be an annual event from now on!
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
Just back from watching this and this is without a doubt my favourite since the originals.
I thought it was outstanding!
I thought it was outstanding!
Lork oh lordy, my bottom's on fire!
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
You're a proper talent mate !Nixie wrote:
Tarkin was a bit disappointing though, I wasn't actually sure how they'd have I'm appear, but I knew that they would; I cant imagine the death star without him!
I made my own cg Peter cushing a week before release:
https://www.artstation.com/artwork/1WXwK
!
Lork oh lordy, my bottom's on fire!
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
Thanks man, I try! It's never good enough of course. And bare in mind with these things that animating is the harder part of bringing a human characer to life. That and I feel the 'too many chefs' analogy didn't help the movie tarkin out so much.
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
For me both synthespians were just an added bonus, a curiosity whose technicalities were over ridden by the very fundamental need for their appearance in the first place, which just fitted right in with the feel of the story.
Feck knows, I'm pissed and loving it anyway
Feck knows, I'm pissed and loving it anyway
Lork oh lordy, my bottom's on fire!
- RiK
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 16092
- Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
- PSN: Dr Thumpy
- Location: The Shire
- Contact:
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
In the movie, I agree that Tarkin was needed for the story, but i would rather they cast a real actor for the role, as though the CG actor was good, it was still only on a par with a cut scene from a game at best and stood out like a sore thumb compared to the live action. I found it jarring enough to distract from the story which was a shame.
They can get away with it with aliens and robots, but at the moment the subtle nuances of facial expression etc are just not quite there for humans, especially those who are well known faces. I know there are plenty of examples from other films where they'll get away with a face swap in an action scene, but a close up during dialogue is another matter altogether isn't it.
They can get away with it with aliens and robots, but at the moment the subtle nuances of facial expression etc are just not quite there for humans, especially those who are well known faces. I know there are plenty of examples from other films where they'll get away with a face swap in an action scene, but a close up during dialogue is another matter altogether isn't it.
RiK
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
I agree that the cg really could have been better, but I'm not sure I'd be content if they recast the role to a different actor instead. I think some of us can see cg very easily, I've gotten used to suspending my disbelief for tha sake of the story.
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
i did notice a few of the shots were pure cg - and not especially well done, it was like they'd slotted them in and hoped no one would notice, one of ships flying across a valley at the start and another one later on with some palm trees, i thought it would have looked better with a model flying on a piece of string reminded me of episodes 1-3 .
i didn't notice that cushing and fisher were cg - i was just perplexed that cushing was still alive,had to look him up when i got home
i didn't notice that cushing and fisher were cg - i was just perplexed that cushing was still alive,had to look him up when i got home
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
Thats pretty successful then!adam wrote: i didn't notice that cushing and fisher were cg - i was just perplexed that cushing was still alive,had to look him up when i got home
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
yes, i was sightly boggled that they'd done those crappy really obvious 100% cg shots of ships etc when they'd gone to all that trouble on the people, i remember thinking, haven't they got library footage they can paste those on top of?
but that might well be it, didn't have time or budget to film them - it was pretty early in the film i decided this was a cheap one because it didn't have any original actors in it
but that might well be it, didn't have time or budget to film them - it was pretty early in the film i decided this was a cheap one because it didn't have any original actors in it
- RiK
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 16092
- Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
- PSN: Dr Thumpy
- Location: The Shire
- Contact:
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
I'm obviously a bit over-sensitive to this stuff then as the Cushing one leapt out at me in the first couple of seconds..adam wrote:i didn't notice that cushing and fisher were cg - i was just perplexed that cushing was still alive,had to look him up when i got home
RiK
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
I thought they were going with a kinda 'model' look with some of the cgi, nothing bothered me about the ship stuff anyway. Tarkin and Leia were obvious. Plus some pretty lo-fi puppets!
- VNVObit
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4072
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
- PSN: VNV_Obit
- Location: London
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
Just back from watching it with the children. While I thought the film was ok it just didn't feel like a Star Wars movie. Other than Vader's cameo it could have been a n other science fiction film. Not sure why but just lacked something for me (jedis probably)
The CGI of Peter Cushing was good but Carrie Fisher's one just felt plain weird given her very recent passing (nothing to do with the actual use of CGI for that part).
Overall better than the prequel trilogy but not as good as the original trilogy or TFA for me.
The CGI of Peter Cushing was good but Carrie Fisher's one just felt plain weird given her very recent passing (nothing to do with the actual use of CGI for that part).
Overall better than the prequel trilogy but not as good as the original trilogy or TFA for me.
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
-
anon76235
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6712
- Joined: Fri Jul 23, 2004 4:52 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: tyrwmuwyru,tyweiu,
- PSN: r6wsmunwrtyurtmuwrty
- Yahoo Messenger: 567.,uim576eiw65nuw6u
- Location: rtumsrytu,sruyrtu,sytru
Re: Star Wars: Rogue One - With SPOILERS
went to see the new star wars film and that, i thought it was meant to have a black r2 d2 in it innit



