Trump
Re: Trump
I wouldn't bother.Cloudane wrote:And that is where the term and its associated derision should be directed - "we" / "the left" need to disassociate ourselves from those lunatics to regain any sort of respect in the world.
If somebody equates kicking-out-diplomats to promoting-a-nuclear-standoff, and they equate not-accepting-the-equivalence-of-diplomat-kicking-and-nuclear-standoff-promotion-like-Russia-told-us-we-should to being-a-screaming-lunatic-with-a-cellphone-who-tries-to-sexualise-a-fat-joke, is there really any kind of separation that can be drawn in those people's minds between anything at all?
There's nothing you can do to put those people right in the head. Just leave it and focus on something else altogether.
Re: Trump
I just get tired of that term being aimed at literally everyone who says anything remotely liberal. It says "you're the same as this person" and shuts down the conversation.
Same with over-eagerly throwing "isms" and "obias" around at anyone on the right.
Same with over-eagerly throwing "isms" and "obias" around at anyone on the right.
Re: Trump
Huh. Have you tried not hanging around with dickheads? I find that works pretty well.Cloudane wrote:I just get tired of that term being aimed at literally everyone who says anything remotely liberal. It says "you're the same as this person" and shuts down the conversation.
Re: Trump
That's not a solution, validating that social justice equates to being a dick is a retrograde step, an intrinsically harmful one IMHO.Cloudane wrote:This is an SJW:
And that is where the term and its associated derision should be directed - "we" / "the left" need to disassociate ourselves from those lunatics to regain any sort of respect in the world.
Fuck that. Out in the real world I've never met anyone like the idiot in that video but I have met a shit load of people with prejudiced attitudes.
And that's the real problem. Shouldn't the absolute shit load of misogynist comments in the video draw more ire?
Giving any credence to the clearly aberrant behaviour in that video and using it to mis-characterise the idea of being bothered about people is helping fuckers.
Re: Trump
That's my point though, social justice is a good thing. It's totally necessary. But "Social Justice Warrior" is a special kind of lunatic - we don't encounter them so much here as it's mostly in the US and largely their universities (unless you go to Tumblr) but they exist and their weapons are rhetoric, shouting over people, cry bullying, shaming and accusing everyone of being racist or misogynist at the drop of a hat.gravy wrote:validating that social justice equates to being a dick is a retrograde step, an intrinsically harmful one IMHO.
Yes, the problems do exist. Some groups are more privileged than others, society is still heavily white and patriarchal etc. I'd like to see this change, I'm an advocate for social justice. But when will the "warrior" types finally get it into their heads that simply engaging people with 'arguments' along the lines of "you're just a disgusting racist misogynistic white privileged pig!" - does absolutely nothing to win them over? Demonising people and treating them like scum is exactly what causes backlashes like Trump.
Are we still on with berating approximately half of the voting US population as being subhuman racist scumbags? If so, the SJW problem is far from over.
Re: Trump
As I mentioned though, the term is applied to FAR more then just that sort of case.
Half the voting population is either one of those two things, or ridiculously ignorant of what their candidate said they would do. I dont see a 4th option.
If stating that makes me a "SJW", then I am a SJW.
I don't see much ethical difference between being racist yourself or allowing racist policy's to happen because you value other things as more important.Are we still on with berating approximately half of the voting US population as being subhuman racist scumbags?
Half the voting population is either one of those two things, or ridiculously ignorant of what their candidate said they would do. I dont see a 4th option.
If stating that makes me a "SJW", then I am a SJW.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: Trump
Weren't we berating half the US voting population for voting for a subhuman racist scumbag, rather than being one themselves?
If you vote for someone who throws shit at the marginalised in society, you're going to cop some grief yourself and it's foolish to expect otherwise. Furthermore, if you vote for such a person as a reaction to overbearing criticism from SJWs then you're about as rational as a parent who gives their children cyanide to spite someone for complaining that you smoke around them. We've a thing here where people are creating a disproportionate and unhelpful response to genuine problems. These are the SJWs. In turn you get Trump voters. An equally unhelpful and disproportionate response. The only action that could warrant any respect is for someone - anyone - to stop reacting disproportionately.
I think the tendency of the now-networked US to take online stuff quite literally is also partly to blame. They don't seem to contextualise hyperbole well as a nation.
In other news the house of Representatives has voted to get rid of the ethics committee that oversees them. And the UK's top chap in the EU has bailed, having proclaimed an impending clusterfuck late last year. It's possible that we'll be praying for a few more celebrity deaths to lighten up the headlines by summer.
Still, I watched this last night, so...
If you vote for someone who throws shit at the marginalised in society, you're going to cop some grief yourself and it's foolish to expect otherwise. Furthermore, if you vote for such a person as a reaction to overbearing criticism from SJWs then you're about as rational as a parent who gives their children cyanide to spite someone for complaining that you smoke around them. We've a thing here where people are creating a disproportionate and unhelpful response to genuine problems. These are the SJWs. In turn you get Trump voters. An equally unhelpful and disproportionate response. The only action that could warrant any respect is for someone - anyone - to stop reacting disproportionately.
I think the tendency of the now-networked US to take online stuff quite literally is also partly to blame. They don't seem to contextualise hyperbole well as a nation.
In other news the house of Representatives has voted to get rid of the ethics committee that oversees them. And the UK's top chap in the EU has bailed, having proclaimed an impending clusterfuck late last year. It's possible that we'll be praying for a few more celebrity deaths to lighten up the headlines by summer.
Still, I watched this last night, so...
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
Re: Trump
Exactly. Which is why, as I keep saying, it needs to be directed at the people who actually warrant such a term. Rather than "well, I'm liberal so I guess I'm one too!" and encouraging this idea that everyone remotely left leaning are all the same, we need to be saying "I'm not one of those, they're not with us" IMO.Darkflame wrote:As I mentioned though, the term is applied to FAR more then just that sort of case.
Have you actually asked any Trump voters why they voted for him? Or have you just gone around calling them racists?I don't see much ethical difference between being racist yourself or allowing racist policy's to happen because you value other things as more important.
Half the voting population is either one of those two things, or ridiculously ignorant of what their candidate said they would do. I dont see a 4th option.
If stating that makes me a "SJW", then I am a SJW.
If the latter, then yes, probably.
Re: Trump
That's like saying the best response to Nazi propoganda would have been for Jews to make sure they don't conform to any nazi stereotypes and condemn those that did.Cloudane wrote:Exactly. Which is why, as I keep saying, it needs to be directed at the people who actually warrant such a term. Rather than "well, I'm liberal so I guess I'm one too!" and encouraging this idea that everyone remotely left leaning are all the same, we need to be saying "I'm not one of those, they're not with us" IMO.Darkflame wrote:As I mentioned though, the term is applied to FAR more then just that sort of case.
That idiot in the video is just someone being an idiot, it has nothing to do with social justice. Don't let those who have disdain for compassion use language to conflate idiocy with inclusiveness.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Trump
I think the berating of half the UK population as the same got there first.Cloudane wrote:Are we still on with berating approximately half of the voting US population as being subhuman racist scumbags? If so, the SJW problem is far from over.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: Trump
It seems to be a bit of a thing right now for companies to announce changes of plan that "save American jobs" or whatever, and for Trump to take credit for that despite however inevitable or obvious that action was in the first place and overlooking the fact that the action in context amounts to no net gain for Americans.
This seems typical of how Trump did business when he was on the other side of things, and I wonder if these companies are getting financial benefits for doing nothing but making Trump look good in the eyes of the unobservant.
Is this going to be the new get-rich(er)-quick for corporate America? Making Trump look good in return for federal money?
This seems typical of how Trump did business when he was on the other side of things, and I wonder if these companies are getting financial benefits for doing nothing but making Trump look good in the eyes of the unobservant.
Is this going to be the new get-rich(er)-quick for corporate America? Making Trump look good in return for federal money?

