Calling half the UK population racist is merely stating a fact. Soft racist, for the most part, as opposed to hard racist. But as a wise old crone recently said, racist means racist.Harlequin wrote:I think the berating of half the UK population as the same got there first.
Trump
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: Trump
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
Re: Trump
I think the main thing is that, even if that many people do have racial biases and prejudices, they're not necessarily Evil and Malicious with it, it's more of a subconscious thing (or "soft racist" I suppose does work, if you must label people). They do need to learn about it and acknowledge it in order to adjust accordingly.
This is a pretty good start: http://www.understandingprejudice.org/iat/
I think the question is how can we get people to learn and understand this? And I really don't think just shouting "RACIST!" at them helps. People don't like being called nasty things and being demonised, it makes them feel like shit and pushes them away, and the opportunity for education is lost.
>inb4 "but they deserve it because they're racist!", ignoring every point I just tried to make :p This is probably my last attempt.
This is a pretty good start: http://www.understandingprejudice.org/iat/
I think the question is how can we get people to learn and understand this? And I really don't think just shouting "RACIST!" at them helps. People don't like being called nasty things and being demonised, it makes them feel like shit and pushes them away, and the opportunity for education is lost.
>inb4 "but they deserve it because they're racist!", ignoring every point I just tried to make :p This is probably my last attempt.
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: Trump
How might people 'learn about it'?
We have race as a protected characteristic in British law, precisely because 'soft racism' is a big enough problem to warrant it. There is virtually no end to the positive role models from every race and religion in our society, we teach tolerance and respect in our schools, have a multicultural society which has had new peoples added to it steadily for millennia. Whoever you are, the people different to you were here first and they'll be here long after you. You are brought up to not be racist, you are legally compelled not to be racist and the media is replete with news portraying hate crime in a negative light, TV shows illustrating the harm 'soft' racism can cause, and so on.
If they haven't learned about it and adjusted (from what alternative, exactly?) already, I would love to hear what ideas anyone's got to improve on education, law and general cultural outlook.
We have race as a protected characteristic in British law, precisely because 'soft racism' is a big enough problem to warrant it. There is virtually no end to the positive role models from every race and religion in our society, we teach tolerance and respect in our schools, have a multicultural society which has had new peoples added to it steadily for millennia. Whoever you are, the people different to you were here first and they'll be here long after you. You are brought up to not be racist, you are legally compelled not to be racist and the media is replete with news portraying hate crime in a negative light, TV shows illustrating the harm 'soft' racism can cause, and so on.
If they haven't learned about it and adjusted (from what alternative, exactly?) already, I would love to hear what ideas anyone's got to improve on education, law and general cultural outlook.
Yeah, hence protected characteristics in law. If you feel like shit because someone took you to task for making someone else fell like shit for something they cannot choose to be or not be (when you have every opportunity to choose not to do it) then you are probably beyond adjustment, wouldn't you agree?People don't like being called nasty things and being demonised, it makes them feel like shit
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
Re: Trump
Not entirely convinced our "general cultural outlook" is inclusive. Exactly the opposite, I would say. From politics through football, pop star fandom, to areas of the country, and class, it's all tribal. That means there's an in-group and instantly an out-group. It's widely perceived as such and reflected in media reporting.
From birth children are pressured to pick a favourite colour, to pick a team to support, to join a gang. It's hardly surprising they also pick a favourite race and that it's their own.
From birth children are pressured to pick a favourite colour, to pick a team to support, to join a gang. It's hardly surprising they also pick a favourite race and that it's their own.
Re: Trump
Honestly I don't know how to do that sort of thing overnight. If anyone did, it would've been done by now! I think it's something that needs to bed in over generations until not being racist, sexist and other such longstanding problems is... whatever you wish to call it, in the "cultural DNA / instinct / whatever"Governmentyard wrote:If they haven't learned about it and adjusted (from what alternative, exactly?) already, I would love to hear what ideas anyone's got to improve on education, law and general cultural outlook.
We've already made great progress over the past few decades and it was going so well - it's just that in the last couple of years we've had a huge push backwards, and every indication seems to be that it's a backlash from pushing forward too hard and being dicks about it. And this thing recently of shaming those with "privilege" (male, white etc) and using reverse racism etc.
I really don't think it's helped that the racism accusation is often placed without proper meaning/evidence. Take for example all the times people have wanted a discussion about immigration and it's been dismissed nothing but pure racism to even question immigration numbers. Rather than a reasonable conversation presenting your case and evidence of why unlimited immigration is a good thing and any doubts about it can objectively only be founded on subconscious racial prejudice, they're just shamed as Evil Racists, or perhaps told they're just stupid and need to go and educate themselves, and shut down. And eventually all that simmering they do under the lid boils over.
It's easy and reasonable to be angry when you perceive injustice and prejudice. I'm just not convinced that letting those emotions take over is constructive.
Absolutely. But they've not always done this. As above, maybe they've had some concerns about immigration numbers, to pick a common present example. That doesn't mean they've set out to make anyone feel shitty about who they are - they've just had some worries about whether people are coming in over borders faster than they're going out or being born inside of them and putting some kind of excessive pressure on the services etc.Governmentyard wrote:Yeah, hence protected characteristics in law. If you feel like shit because someone took you to task for making someone else fell like shit for something they cannot choose to be or not be (when you have every opportunity to choose not to do it) then you are probably beyond adjustment, wouldn't you agree?
Re: Trump
I think its too late. Not using the term at all and inventing something else might be better.Cloudane wrote:Exactly. Which is why, as I keep saying, it needs to be directed at the people who actually warrant such a term. Rather than "well, I'm liberal so I guess I'm one too!" and encouraging this idea that everyone remotely left leaning are all the same, we need to be saying "I'm not one of those, they're not with us" IMO.Darkflame wrote:As I mentioned though, the term is applied to FAR more then just that sort of case.
Even if you use it "purely", it wont help communication when the other people dont know how your using it as its been abused to mean too much.
Have you actually asked any Trump voters why they voted for him? Or have you just gone around calling them racists?I don't see much ethical difference between being racist yourself or allowing racist policy's to happen because you value other things as more important.
Half the voting population is either one of those two things, or ridiculously ignorant of what their candidate said they would do. I dont see a 4th option.
If stating that makes me a "SJW", then I am a SJW.
If the latter, then yes, probably.[/quote]
I have read surveys and largely it would be the second thing I listed. "allowing racist policy's to happen because they value other things more important" (option 2), while others I have seen online directly in comments are mostly either trolling and proud of it (for some reason) or in deep denial about what Trump has stated. ("he didnt mean that! That was a metaphor!") - option 3 imho.
Thats antidotal though, mostly it would be ranking things as more important, and downplaying or denying the racism. (The "he just said mean things" crowd).
By all means though, propose a 4th option, because I think my logic is pretty tight;
a) Trump has made racist statements and proposed racist policy's
b) People voted for him.
Either they knew a) or they did not.
If they knew a and voted anyway, that implies they valued other things as more important. They let raciest things happen.(2)
If they didn't, they they were ignorant.(3)
--
Oh, and yes, certainly everyone is almost certainly subconsciously racist on some level. We all have bias's and its good to be aware of them to try to counter them. Thats not really the same as this though. This is conveniently ignoring explicit out in the open racism because it suits your believes elsewhere to do so.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: Trump
I think its too late. Not using the term at all and inventing something else might be better.Cloudane wrote:Exactly. Which is why, as I keep saying, it needs to be directed at the people who actually warrant such a term. Rather than "well, I'm liberal so I guess I'm one too!" and encouraging this idea that everyone remotely left leaning are all the same, we need to be saying "I'm not one of those, they're not with us" IMO.Darkflame wrote:As I mentioned though, the term is applied to FAR more then just that sort of case.
Even if you use it "purely", it wont help communication when the other people dont know how your using it as its been abused to mean too much.
Have you actually asked any Trump voters why they voted for him? Or have you just gone around calling them racists?I don't see much ethical difference between being racist yourself or allowing racist policy's to happen because you value other things as more important.
Half the voting population is either one of those two things, or ridiculously ignorant of what their candidate said they would do. I dont see a 4th option.
If stating that makes me a "SJW", then I am a SJW.
If the latter, then yes, probably.[/quote]
I have read surveys and largely it would be the second thing I listed. "allowing racist policy's to happen because they value other things more important" (option 2), while others I have seen online directly in comments are mostly either trolling and proud of it (for some reason) or in deep denial about what Trump has stated. ("he didnt mean that! That was a metaphor!") - option 3 imho.
Thats antidotal though, mostly it would be ranking things as more important, and downplaying or denying the racism. (The "he just said mean things" crowd).
By all means though, propose a 4th option, because I think my logic is pretty tight;
a) Trump has made racist statements and proposed racist policy's
b) People voted for him.
Either they knew a) or they did not.
If they knew a and voted anyway, that implies they valued other things as more important. They let raciest things happen.(2)
If they didn't, they they were ignorant.(3)
--
Oh, and yes, certainly everyone is almost certainly subconsciously racist on some level. We all have bias's and its good to be aware of them to try to counter them. Thats not really the same as this though. This is conveniently ignoring explicit out in the open racism because it suits your believes elsewhere to do so.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: Trump
I think its too late. Not using the term at all and inventing something else might be better.Cloudane wrote:Exactly. Which is why, as I keep saying, it needs to be directed at the people who actually warrant such a term. Rather than "well, I'm liberal so I guess I'm one too!" and encouraging this idea that everyone remotely left leaning are all the same, we need to be saying "I'm not one of those, they're not with us" IMO.Darkflame wrote:As I mentioned though, the term is applied to FAR more then just that sort of case.
Even if you use it "purely", it wont help communication when the other people dont know how your using it as its been abused to mean too much.
I have read surveys and largely it would be the second thing I listed. "allowing racist policy's to happen because they value other things more important" (option 2), while others I have seen online directly in comments are mostly either trolling and proud of it (for some reason) or in deep denial about what Trump has stated. ("he didnt mean that! That was a metaphor!") - option 3 imho.Have you actually asked any Trump voters why they voted for him? Or have you just gone around calling them racists?I don't see much ethical difference between being racist yourself or allowing racist policy's to happen because you value other things as more important.
Half the voting population is either one of those two things, or ridiculously ignorant of what their candidate said they would do. I dont see a 4th option.
If stating that makes me a "SJW", then I am a SJW.
If the latter, then yes, probably.
Thats antidotal though, mostly it would be ranking things as more important, and downplaying or denying the racism. (The "he just said mean things" crowd).
By all means though, propose a 4th option, because I think my logic is pretty tight;
a) Trump has made racist statements and proposed racist policy's
b) People voted for him.
Either they knew a) or they did not.
If they knew a and voted anyway, that implies they valued other things as more important. They let raciest things happen.(2)
If they didn't, they they were ignorant.(3)
--
Oh, and yes, certainly everyone is almost certainly subconsciously racist on some level. We all have bias's and its good to be aware of them to try to counter them. Thats not really the same as this though. This is conveniently ignoring explicit out in the open racism because it suits your beliefs elsewhere to do so.(ie, you hate clinton/obama/"the left" or want the status-quo changed by any means)
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: Trump
Been thinking about this over the past couple of days, and whilst I accept that it is possible that some, possibly even many, who voted for Trump, may not be or consider themselves to be racist, given the media coverage that surrounded the election and Trumps own statements you would have to have been pretty good at ignoring it not to at least have some realisation that however one may have personally felt, a vote for Trump was going to make it easier for such viewpoints to gain traction.
I believe the president of Ford said that their recently announced decision not to build a plant in Mexico was because of Trumps "business-friendly policies", which may or may not be true, but it also suggests that Ford supports a president-elect who once called Mexicans rapists.
I believe the president of Ford said that their recently announced decision not to build a plant in Mexico was because of Trumps "business-friendly policies", which may or may not be true, but it also suggests that Ford supports a president-elect who once called Mexicans rapists.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: Trump
It goes like this: Issue comes up (brought up by person who doesn't like immigration. Always by the person against it because it is a non-issue to anyone else) and they are presented with proven facts (e.g. immigrants are net contributors to society). Anti-immigration person counters with increasingly irrational things in order to not 'lose'. Patience of person with facts and no axe to grind eventually wears thin, anti-immigration person then has nothing to lose and says whatever enables them to lash out most effectively. If you are holding out for them to be treated even more reasonably than they already are you'll be waiting a lifetime. This is the thing with people who are ignorant... treating them equally puts them into this entrenched, factually incorrect, angry, spiteful stance.Rather than a reasonable conversation presenting your case and evidence of why unlimited immigration is a good thing and any doubts about it can objectively only be founded on subconscious racial prejudice, they're just shamed as Evil Racists, or perhaps told they're just stupid and need to go and educate themselves, and shut down. And eventually all that simmering they do under the lid boils over.
Now, if the conversation went like this:
"I'm worried about immigration"
"Here's a bunch of stuff which shows how it's almost certainly completely fine after all"
"Phew, I can stop worrying about it so much now. I still have my reservations but hey, thanks for the chat"
Then you'd have a case for patience.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
Re: Trump
Surely you have to accept a little racism when the alternative is pizzas made out of child prostitutes.
It doesn't matter if Trump voters are or are not racist. What they are is profoundly stupid, and stupid people are a prone to acting racist out of lack of proper insight into their own reasoning, because generalizations are how human brains work.
It doesn't matter if Trump voters are or are not racist. What they are is profoundly stupid, and stupid people are a prone to acting racist out of lack of proper insight into their own reasoning, because generalizations are how human brains work.
Re: Trump
For those who don't immediately get gumboots opener there - it took me a second, and I knew the story - a rumour was started in the US that certain pizza parlours were involved in a Hilary Clinton-organised child sex slavery operation.
No, really.
This led to some harassment of the businesses involved, including in one instance a pizza shop being raided by an armed man looking to free the "hostages". Slightly less gung-ho types who visited some of the businesses involved still don't believe they're innocent, even after being shown round the establishments concerned by the owners.
No, really.
This led to some harassment of the businesses involved, including in one instance a pizza shop being raided by an armed man looking to free the "hostages". Slightly less gung-ho types who visited some of the businesses involved still don't believe they're innocent, even after being shown round the establishments concerned by the owners.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Trump
And that's the quality of critical thought that led to so many people choosing Trump as "second worst candidate".
These are some of the people you lot are talking about trying to civilise, here... so, good luck with that.
These are some of the people you lot are talking about trying to civilise, here... so, good luck with that.
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: Trump
Can't we just tell them that whatever they want, they have now got? Given that everything in their lives will basically be the same either way, just do a better job of convincing them than breitbart or Fox or whoever...
Serious muslims banned! If you see any left, they're the ones who are basically like normal people
No one is coming in anymore, those lot over there were here all along
We've done away with benefits! That lot in the jobcentre are just friends now from queuing together for so long, we aren't paying them anything
We've brought back hanging for peados and that, all happens now in a super secret base. Your kids are safe, you don't need to "swear you'll do time" anymore.
A leading liberal professor from some gay university has proven that his lot are, indeed, full of shit after all.
Church attendances up worldwide! Godlessness is just good christian folk having an ironic, nostalgic laugh
Bill passed! Abortion clinics now a front, attendees will forcibly have even more babies fucked into them! Thousands of unborn lives saved and created!
Wind farms found to be cheaper, worse for the environment and responsible for increase in amount of marital sex and beer within 3-mile radius
Mid-east peace announced! "We realised it's all probably fine" say faith leaders.
I'ts official, science proves your child IS special (and not just because they were made out of your specific knob slime)
...I mean they buy all the other crap, right?
Serious muslims banned! If you see any left, they're the ones who are basically like normal people
No one is coming in anymore, those lot over there were here all along
We've done away with benefits! That lot in the jobcentre are just friends now from queuing together for so long, we aren't paying them anything
We've brought back hanging for peados and that, all happens now in a super secret base. Your kids are safe, you don't need to "swear you'll do time" anymore.
A leading liberal professor from some gay university has proven that his lot are, indeed, full of shit after all.
Church attendances up worldwide! Godlessness is just good christian folk having an ironic, nostalgic laugh
Bill passed! Abortion clinics now a front, attendees will forcibly have even more babies fucked into them! Thousands of unborn lives saved and created!
Wind farms found to be cheaper, worse for the environment and responsible for increase in amount of marital sex and beer within 3-mile radius
Mid-east peace announced! "We realised it's all probably fine" say faith leaders.
I'ts official, science proves your child IS special (and not just because they were made out of your specific knob slime)
...I mean they buy all the other crap, right?
Last edited by Governmentyard on Wed Jan 04, 2017 11:13 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard

