Trump
Re: Trump
Thrace. Greece. Paphlagonia. Mysia. Lydia. Caria. Phrygia. Cilicia. Egypt. Syria. Mesopotamia. Babylonia. Media. Susiana. Parthyene. Persia. Carmania. Bactria. Aria. Drangiana. Gedrosia. Arachosia. And so forth.
You likely at least recognise one or two there - such as Greece, Egypt, Syria, Persia, etc. - to be able to guess that I'm listing off places. But, specifically, I've pulled up a map of Alexander the Great's Empire and these are the lands and people that he conquered from just before 300 BCE.
The point I'm making by this is really quite simple.
Most of these names no longer exist. Even with the recognisable names, there are caveats. In that ancient Syria is not modern Syria, as it took in where Israel, Palestine, Jordan, etc. are too. Ancient Greece was a bunch of city states - Athens, Sparta, etc. - so it was quite a different thing to the modern country. Indeed, the notion of "countries" itself, as we'd understand it today, doesn't really hold back then.
Now, taking the standard definition of 30 years being "a generation", this was only 77 generations ago. Or, to use the Biblical "three score and ten" (70 years), as a human lifetime then this is only 33 "lifetimes", placed end-to-end, ago.
I remember watching a TV show where they had a slightly-racist "little England" UKIP voter chap who was boasting that he was "100 generations English" - the idea of the show was that they did a DNA analysis of his genetics and, yes, it turned out that he was about 20% Middle Eastern in genetic origin, in order to challenge his slightly-racist views with some scientific fact that he's talking out of his arse. I mean, right there, "100 generations English" is totally impossible, mate. England didn't exist a 100 generations ago. Indeed, even if we're generous to include the Anglo Saxons as "English" then you could only be around "50 generations Saxon", as the Romans didn't piss off to let the Saxons in until the 5th century.
Anyway, the gist of what I'm getting at is that, in terms of human lifetimes, Alexander the Great was not really that long ago and looking at a map from his time period, there's almost no names on the map that still exist. The notion of "country" wasn't even a thing, as we'd understand it.
I'm trying to put a face on that Noble Lie that is "nation". In truth, it's complete bollocks.
Tribal kinship - evolved back when your "tribe" was basically your extended family and literally were related to you - stretched and abused into an absurd notion of "false kin" that couldn't possibly be true.
World domination by "ethnic Russians"? World domination by "the Aryan Race"? The "Manifest Destiny" of American exceptionalism? World domination under Sharia Law as the planet becomes one giant Islamic State?
Utter bullshit that stinks to High Heaven. If, you know, Heaven actually existed up there, which it doesn't, as that's just another branch of the stinky bullshit tree of "magical thinking" that our species erroneously insists upon.
"This too shall pass".
Names like "United States", "Russia", "England", "France", etc. didn't exist on Alexander the Great's maps (nor would they be found on Genghis Kahn's maps either) and in a similar stretch of time going forward then there's every chance they simply won't exist on future maps either.
Understand just how fluid and fragile the notions of "nation" and "ethnicity" really are. They might seem like a solid in terms of our own individual lives, but, in the wider historical view, it's all liquid. Flowing and mixing in all directions.
What are you going to do with your "world domination" once you've got it, eh? Okay, you own the planet. What are you going to do with it?
Are you so deluded to think that if you create your chosen Utopia that it'll somehow magically last forever? When the basis of your grand vision is built on the foundation of some fluid ill-defined "ethnicity"?
You can't "win" when there's no actual end state.
In trying to explain to a friend why football fundamentally doesn't interest me, it was this lack of end state. That is, who cares if, say, Manchester United does or doesn't win this particular game or this particular season? The whole thing is eternally replayed forever after. None of it carries any individual weight because the whole process is infinite. One divided by infinity is exactly zero.
This is also what I try to point out to religious folk about their "Afterlife" too. If Hell's punishment is eternal then what's the point in it? If there is no reprieve, no rehabilitation or anything then it simply can only be nothing more than sadism. If it never ends, then it cannot achieve anything. Heaven and its eternal bliss is honestly no better either, if you think about it, but it sounds superficially more appealing. If you don't think too much to realise how much bollocks it would be. Thank goodness it's all fairy tales, in truth. Because if the universe was really like that, then it's a miserable fucking place indeed.
You likely at least recognise one or two there - such as Greece, Egypt, Syria, Persia, etc. - to be able to guess that I'm listing off places. But, specifically, I've pulled up a map of Alexander the Great's Empire and these are the lands and people that he conquered from just before 300 BCE.
The point I'm making by this is really quite simple.
Most of these names no longer exist. Even with the recognisable names, there are caveats. In that ancient Syria is not modern Syria, as it took in where Israel, Palestine, Jordan, etc. are too. Ancient Greece was a bunch of city states - Athens, Sparta, etc. - so it was quite a different thing to the modern country. Indeed, the notion of "countries" itself, as we'd understand it today, doesn't really hold back then.
Now, taking the standard definition of 30 years being "a generation", this was only 77 generations ago. Or, to use the Biblical "three score and ten" (70 years), as a human lifetime then this is only 33 "lifetimes", placed end-to-end, ago.
I remember watching a TV show where they had a slightly-racist "little England" UKIP voter chap who was boasting that he was "100 generations English" - the idea of the show was that they did a DNA analysis of his genetics and, yes, it turned out that he was about 20% Middle Eastern in genetic origin, in order to challenge his slightly-racist views with some scientific fact that he's talking out of his arse. I mean, right there, "100 generations English" is totally impossible, mate. England didn't exist a 100 generations ago. Indeed, even if we're generous to include the Anglo Saxons as "English" then you could only be around "50 generations Saxon", as the Romans didn't piss off to let the Saxons in until the 5th century.
Anyway, the gist of what I'm getting at is that, in terms of human lifetimes, Alexander the Great was not really that long ago and looking at a map from his time period, there's almost no names on the map that still exist. The notion of "country" wasn't even a thing, as we'd understand it.
I'm trying to put a face on that Noble Lie that is "nation". In truth, it's complete bollocks.
Tribal kinship - evolved back when your "tribe" was basically your extended family and literally were related to you - stretched and abused into an absurd notion of "false kin" that couldn't possibly be true.
World domination by "ethnic Russians"? World domination by "the Aryan Race"? The "Manifest Destiny" of American exceptionalism? World domination under Sharia Law as the planet becomes one giant Islamic State?
Utter bullshit that stinks to High Heaven. If, you know, Heaven actually existed up there, which it doesn't, as that's just another branch of the stinky bullshit tree of "magical thinking" that our species erroneously insists upon.
"This too shall pass".
Names like "United States", "Russia", "England", "France", etc. didn't exist on Alexander the Great's maps (nor would they be found on Genghis Kahn's maps either) and in a similar stretch of time going forward then there's every chance they simply won't exist on future maps either.
Understand just how fluid and fragile the notions of "nation" and "ethnicity" really are. They might seem like a solid in terms of our own individual lives, but, in the wider historical view, it's all liquid. Flowing and mixing in all directions.
What are you going to do with your "world domination" once you've got it, eh? Okay, you own the planet. What are you going to do with it?
Are you so deluded to think that if you create your chosen Utopia that it'll somehow magically last forever? When the basis of your grand vision is built on the foundation of some fluid ill-defined "ethnicity"?
You can't "win" when there's no actual end state.
In trying to explain to a friend why football fundamentally doesn't interest me, it was this lack of end state. That is, who cares if, say, Manchester United does or doesn't win this particular game or this particular season? The whole thing is eternally replayed forever after. None of it carries any individual weight because the whole process is infinite. One divided by infinity is exactly zero.
This is also what I try to point out to religious folk about their "Afterlife" too. If Hell's punishment is eternal then what's the point in it? If there is no reprieve, no rehabilitation or anything then it simply can only be nothing more than sadism. If it never ends, then it cannot achieve anything. Heaven and its eternal bliss is honestly no better either, if you think about it, but it sounds superficially more appealing. If you don't think too much to realise how much bollocks it would be. Thank goodness it's all fairy tales, in truth. Because if the universe was really like that, then it's a miserable fucking place indeed.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
Re: Trump
Simon Jenkins gets it in a number of ways. Implicitly, that bloviating conniption is counter-productive. Doctor: don't do that.
Yes, Donald Trump is a monster. But his agenda isn’t all bad
Trump + NetanYahoo yesterday... hopefully nobody still suspects that the lack of mention of "Jews" in the Holocaust memorial statement* was an indication to invest in concentration camp futures. Ivanka's a convert FFS.
[*] e.g. this horse poop
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world ... 60866.html
The most interesting thing for me over the last few days have been reports of conflict between Bannon and Reibus. Caveat emptor: if true.
Yes, Donald Trump is a monster. But his agenda isn’t all bad
Trump + NetanYahoo yesterday... hopefully nobody still suspects that the lack of mention of "Jews" in the Holocaust memorial statement* was an indication to invest in concentration camp futures. Ivanka's a convert FFS.
[*] e.g. this horse poop
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world ... 60866.html
The most interesting thing for me over the last few days have been reports of conflict between Bannon and Reibus. Caveat emptor: if true.
Re: Trump
Oh, it absolutely can be, as it has been.gumboot wrote:Scientific progress may also be transient.
The grand genius of Ancient Greece - Pythagoras, Archimedes, Socrates, Plato and all the rest of them - plagiarised by the Romans, who forged an Empire on its back.
But then Rome got religion, the civil empire fell and then it effectively metamorphosed into a Holy Roman Empire, with Caesar replaced by the Pope, enslaving Europe to some thousand years of Dark Age theocracy.
The Crusades. The Inquisition. Technologically backwards. Socially retarded. Economically impoverished. Basically, a right fucking shit hole.
Meanwhile, over to the East, Islam was embracing knowledge.
In fairness to the mythology, it does actually differ from Christianity in having some praise for knowledge in its holy text. There's a tale in there about a solar eclipse and everyone was fearful of what it could mean - with the ancient beliefs that it meant impending doom and such - but, fair play to Mohammed, he basically said "nope, it's just the Sun and Moon, folks. They do this sometimes. It doesn't mean anything".
Not that I defend Islam in the slightest. Bollocks remains bollocks, even if - being "Abrahamism 3.0" - it had picked up some elements of human progress like this by the 7th century, when it began. Though Mohammed is progressively anti-superstitious in confronting the "magical thinking" that solar eclipses were evil omens, he does then say "pray to Allah". So one step forward and two steps back.
Anyway, in the Islamic Empire, they set forth, in Baghdad, to build "the House of Wisdom". This was a major project to assemble the sum of all human knowledge. To, if you like, rebuild the Great Library of Alexandria on Islamic soil.
They gathered knowledge from far and wide. What are erroneously called "the Arabic Numerals" are actually of Indian origin. They invented zero and base 10 positional notation. But Islam gathered this up for their "the House of Wisdom". They also preserved the Greek and Roman legacy, where Europe itself abandoned it and forgot.
When Islam embraced knowledge, it owned the planet. When Greece and Rome embraced knowledge, they owned the planet. When the British embraced progress - the Industrial Revolution - they owned the planet. When America embraced progress, it put men on the Moon, set world culture from Hollywood and powered the Information Revolution from Silicon Valley.
Oh, this is the grand irony. Whilst I still contend that "nation" is bollocks, history tells us loud and clear that if you want your "tribe" to dominate then it needs to embrace knowledge and progress whole-heartedly. Those that did owned the planet.
But Islam lost it. It got war-like and marched on Byzantium - the Eastern Roman Empire - to capture Constantinople. Which is now Istanbul, not Constantinople. If you've a date in Constantinople, she'll be waiting in Istanbul.
As Islam pushed West to capture what now is Turkey, many of the Byzantines understandably legged it into Europe. Carrying with them "Eastern knowledge" to the Republic of Venice - usefully independent from Papal theocracy, so the knowledge was not religiously censored - kickstarting the Renaissance. Leading into the Scientific Revolution.
Oh, indeed, worryingly enough, knowledge can be transient. It can be lost and abandoned. "Alternative facts" can become dominant to actual reality.
Certainly, progress is not guaranteed. It can and has gone horribly backwards in history plenty of times already.
This is, of course, why I feel the imperative to speak out. To emphasise that all we're doing is shooting ourselves in the foot. Social progress, economic success, raised standards of living, etc. all follow from embracing the free marketplace of ideas. If America and the West have seen further in recent times then it's only because we've been standing on the shoulders of Giants. As we abandon it then - oh, look - everything's rapidly turning to shit.
So, I mean, if folks want to wallow in their "alternative facts" and pray to their made-up gods and pretend, against all biological evidence, that there's something intrinsically superior about the accident of their birth that landed them within the borders of a particular tribe then, by all means, fuck yourselves over. Knock yourselves out. Go on this temporary holiday of sheer insanity. But you will be back.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Trump
True.gumboot wrote:Scientific progress may also be transient.
Eventually, yes. It could take a billion years, mind.KlaxonCow wrote: ... But you will be back.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Trump
On that note, Robert F. Kennedy Jr - yes, that Kennedy family - and Robert De Niro - yes, also that De Niro - are offering a $100,000 reward for anyone who can "prove" that thimerosal in vaccines is "safe". This is the easiest $100,000 you will ever earn, ifthe dice were not already impossibly loaded in the same manner as the various Creationist "rewards" for "proving" evolution is true. The game is more heavily rigged than playing Russian Roulette with a fully loaded .50 calibre machine gun (in case you're wondering, De Niros son has autism, and he has become involved in anti-vaccine stuff recently).
Tangentially related to Trump, who has spouted anti-vaccine views in the past and who reportedly met Kennedy to discuss the subject just after becoming President, though as with most things Trump I have my doubts he actually understands a word he says on the subject (for example, he seems to believe every childhood vaccine is delivered all at once from a horse syringe. Really.).
Tangentially related to Trump, who has spouted anti-vaccine views in the past and who reportedly met Kennedy to discuss the subject just after becoming President, though as with most things Trump I have my doubts he actually understands a word he says on the subject (for example, he seems to believe every childhood vaccine is delivered all at once from a horse syringe. Really.).
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Trump
The real irony is I thought the internet would be human civilisation's turning point. Here we have a way to make information extremely prevalent, easy to share and as good as permanent (so long as we don't nuke each other to smithereens) and what do we go and do? Turn it into the biggest source of fake news, alternative facts and general misinformation, and the catalyst for the next dark age. Fuck me we're such a retarded, foot-shooting species.
Watched a clip of the first episode of ST:TNG earlier (was telling someone who Q is) and he was absolutely right. Humans never change.
Watched a clip of the first episode of ST:TNG earlier (was telling someone who Q is) and he was absolutely right. Humans never change.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Trump
That's untrue, it's not human nature that causes competition, it's Nature.Cloudane wrote:Humans never change.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Trump
I have a question about the Muslim ban.
Refugees are subject to a religious-minority test, right? But aren't we all minorities of one?Emo Philips wrote:Once I saw this guy on a bridge about to jump. I said, "Don't do it!" He said, "Nobody loves me." I said, "God loves you. Do you believe in God?"
He said, "Yes." I said, "Are you a Christian or a Jew?" He said, "A Christian." I said, "Me, too! Protestant or Catholic?" He said, "Protestant." I said, "Me, too! What franchise?" He said, "Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Baptist or Southern Baptist?" He said, "Northern Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist or Northern Liberal Baptist?"
He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region, or Northern Conservative Baptist Eastern Region?" He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region." I said, "Me, too!"
Northern Conservative†Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1879, or Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912?" He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912." I said, "Die, heretic!" And I pushed him over.
Re: Trump
One could argue that it's the ability to not compete, for the common good, that sets the higher animals apart.zip accident wrote:That's untrue, it's not human nature that causes competition, it's Nature.Cloudane wrote:Humans never change.
Re: Trump
How do you demonstrate that societies embraced knowledge first and then conquered the world as a consequence of that, and not that after conquering the world they were left idle and became more bookish?KlaxonCow wrote:When Islam embraced knowledge, it owned the planet. When Greece and Rome embraced knowledge, they owned the planet. When the British embraced progress - the Industrial Revolution - they owned the planet. When America embraced progress, it put men on the Moon, set world culture from Hollywood and powered the Information Revolution from Silicon Valley.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Trump
Higher?venusian wrote:One could argue that it's the ability to not compete, for the common good, that sets the higher animals apart.zip accident wrote:That's untrue, it's not human nature that causes competition, it's Nature.Cloudane wrote:Humans never change.
There are potentially infinite off-spring, and finite resources, that's nature, it's all that's needed to enforce competition. The sane way is to make competition less destructive, but you can't stop competition short of finding infinite resources.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Trump
Possibility that even now (has much happened aside from things getting signed and obviously the airports) he's just acting this nutty in order to be impeached i.e. as a trojan horse containing Pence to deliver the social reversal they wouldn't have got away with the normal mild mannered way?
Hey, grasping at straws here.
Hey, grasping at straws here.
Re: Trump
I mean... couldn't anybody claim to be a religious minority simply by being more specific about their own religion than that of the rest of the population?gumboot wrote:Refugees are subject to a religious-minority test, right? But aren't we all minorities of one?
Re: Trump
By higher I do, of course, mean https://www.merriam-webster.com/diction ... r%20mammal. This is a defining term not a descriptive term.zip accident wrote:Higher?venusian wrote:One could argue that it's the ability to not compete, for the common good, that sets the higher animals apart.zip accident wrote:That's untrue, it's not human nature that causes competition, it's Nature.Cloudane wrote:Humans never change.
There are potentially infinite off-spring, and finite resources, that's nature, it's all that's needed to enforce competition. The sane way is to make competition less destructive, but you can't stop competition short of finding infinite resources.
And don't be silly, of course you can have non-competition. What unbreakable law of nature says that a population can't be stable? You could look at "nature" and say living things don't talk, living things don't make wheels, living things don't engage in deliberate high-temperature oxidisation, they don't leave the planet. If you did do that though you'd be in danger of being wrong in the same way.

