Trump
Re: Trump
"Nature, red in tooth and claw" is somewhat overplayed.
With understandable reason, as Darwin was having to get across sometimes brutal notions of "survival of the fittest" to folks who'd be singing "All Things Bright and Beautiful" on the Sunday and viewed nature as being "God's theme park" for their own amusement.
To disabuse people of this delusion that nature was all nice, pretty, lovely and like something from a Disney animation - and the only evils of the world were the "dark Satanic mills" of human endeavour - you would have to strongly emphasise things like the parasitic wasp. A charming creature that implants its young inside a paralysed host, where its offspring consumes the host from the inside out. It basically uses other creatures as "eggs" for its young.
But, equally, you can go too far in the other direction. When we say that nature is uncaring, it must be understood as meaning that it's incapable of caring. It's not a sentient being. It's, therefore, neutrally indifferent to everything. There is no agency there. There is no guiding purpose or intent.
Nature, just as equally, evolved a mother's love for her children. Evolved the cooperative
spirit of colony animals, like ants or bees. Evolved delicious fruits so that animals would eat them to distribute their seeds far and wide, in their shit, which is a great fertiliser, of course. It has evolved plenty of cooperative symbiotic relationships like this all over the place.
(Indeed, it has been noted that if all the bees die, then we're all fucked. Some pretty crucial natural infrastructure here entirely rests on the foundations of symbiosis. This stuff is not just a curious side show. It's front and centre in how the whole thing works.)
The real point is that nature has no agenda nor ulterior motive. It can't possess that because, really, "nature" isn't even a thing. It's just a catch-all word we use to mean "stuff which is not man-made" that covers a massive plethora of independent interacting systems.
The language is all wrong here. We need to stop talking in terms of agency and motive and purpose, because these things simply aren't present.
Competition is one facet of it all, but so is cooperation too.
More over, this whole line of reasoning falls foul of "the naturalistic fallacy" anyway. Just because something is, doesn't mean it ought to be.
Disease is perfectly natural. Therefore, according to the naturalistic fallacy that that which is "natural" is always good and the way things should be, we should close all the hospitals, sack all the doctors and nurse, and abandon medical science completely.
Disease is natural. Thus, we're "supposed" to get ill and die. It's natural, so it's good. So stop trying to stop it happening.
No, that's bollocks. Just because that's the way things are, doesn't mean that that's the way they should be and we should just fatalistically accept it.
Anyway, there's a fundamental logical problem with such "it's natural" arguments. Humans are also, after all, a product of nature. We're "natural" and, therefore, you could argue that everything we've naturally come to do is, by extension, also "natural" too.
There's plenty of good things, as well as the harsh and cruel things, to be found in nature. Truth is, the real underlying rule here is "whatever the fuck works" - it has nothing to do with being good or bad, or feelings, or purpose. It's just what, at a fundamental physical level, pragmatically works.
With understandable reason, as Darwin was having to get across sometimes brutal notions of "survival of the fittest" to folks who'd be singing "All Things Bright and Beautiful" on the Sunday and viewed nature as being "God's theme park" for their own amusement.
To disabuse people of this delusion that nature was all nice, pretty, lovely and like something from a Disney animation - and the only evils of the world were the "dark Satanic mills" of human endeavour - you would have to strongly emphasise things like the parasitic wasp. A charming creature that implants its young inside a paralysed host, where its offspring consumes the host from the inside out. It basically uses other creatures as "eggs" for its young.
But, equally, you can go too far in the other direction. When we say that nature is uncaring, it must be understood as meaning that it's incapable of caring. It's not a sentient being. It's, therefore, neutrally indifferent to everything. There is no agency there. There is no guiding purpose or intent.
Nature, just as equally, evolved a mother's love for her children. Evolved the cooperative
spirit of colony animals, like ants or bees. Evolved delicious fruits so that animals would eat them to distribute their seeds far and wide, in their shit, which is a great fertiliser, of course. It has evolved plenty of cooperative symbiotic relationships like this all over the place.
(Indeed, it has been noted that if all the bees die, then we're all fucked. Some pretty crucial natural infrastructure here entirely rests on the foundations of symbiosis. This stuff is not just a curious side show. It's front and centre in how the whole thing works.)
The real point is that nature has no agenda nor ulterior motive. It can't possess that because, really, "nature" isn't even a thing. It's just a catch-all word we use to mean "stuff which is not man-made" that covers a massive plethora of independent interacting systems.
The language is all wrong here. We need to stop talking in terms of agency and motive and purpose, because these things simply aren't present.
Competition is one facet of it all, but so is cooperation too.
More over, this whole line of reasoning falls foul of "the naturalistic fallacy" anyway. Just because something is, doesn't mean it ought to be.
Disease is perfectly natural. Therefore, according to the naturalistic fallacy that that which is "natural" is always good and the way things should be, we should close all the hospitals, sack all the doctors and nurse, and abandon medical science completely.
Disease is natural. Thus, we're "supposed" to get ill and die. It's natural, so it's good. So stop trying to stop it happening.
No, that's bollocks. Just because that's the way things are, doesn't mean that that's the way they should be and we should just fatalistically accept it.
Anyway, there's a fundamental logical problem with such "it's natural" arguments. Humans are also, after all, a product of nature. We're "natural" and, therefore, you could argue that everything we've naturally come to do is, by extension, also "natural" too.
There's plenty of good things, as well as the harsh and cruel things, to be found in nature. Truth is, the real underlying rule here is "whatever the fuck works" - it has nothing to do with being good or bad, or feelings, or purpose. It's just what, at a fundamental physical level, pragmatically works.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Trump
Indeed. Nature didn't do anything. It didn't evolve ants to work together - the ants did that as a consequence of their past behaviours. As you say, there is no agency at all. In fact, using the term "Nature" really kinda anthropomorphises it more than is necessary. It's just shit that happens, and the consequences thereof.
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
Re: Trump
Ooh, I like this. Good question. Because, yes, with any correlation, we must show that we've not got the cause and effect the wrong way around.gumboot wrote:How do you demonstrate that societies embraced knowledge first and then conquered the world as a consequence of that, and not that after conquering the world they were left idle and became more bookish?KlaxonCow wrote:When Islam embraced knowledge, it owned the planet. When Greece and Rome embraced knowledge, they owned the planet. When the British embraced progress - the Industrial Revolution - they owned the planet. When America embraced progress, it put men on the Moon, set world culture from Hollywood and powered the Information Revolution from Silicon Valley.
But, I mean, you could simply go through it all case-by-case to show that.
For example, the European empires - the British, French, Dutch - needed to have the ship-building and navigational skills to get around the planet to start colonising it all. In order to conquer "the natives", then having that grossly "unfair advantage" of knowledge of Chinese gunpowder, so they could hardly lose in a "guns versus spears" battle, allowed them to violently take ownership of it all once they got there.
Rome had professional armies. Military strategies. Forged superior weapons and armour. They made good use of their Greek inheritance - which, it must be remembered, included the Spartans, who innovated and refined the military society to the finest of points. They won because they were a well-oiled machine. Though they'd never had read "the Art of War" themselves, of course, they were, indeed, the embodiment of Sun Tsu's advice that it is superior strategy, not strength, that wins battles.
From these individual examples, I guess the demonstration would simply be to say that you couldn't really conquer the world in the first place without having some "unfair advantage" in terms of knowledge at your disposal.
So the knowledge has to come first, as "world domination" ain't at all easy when the rest of the world really doesn't want to be dominated by you, as a rule, and will gladly tell you to fuck off at the point of a sword, if necessary. Thus, to extend the analogy, you need to be in possession of the superior knowledge of things like guns in order to defeat them all, as those render the point of a sword or spear a bit useless in resisting you.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
Re: Trump
Slightly more relevant than some recent posts.
Last night I dreamt I met Trump one-on-one... I talked, he listened. After which I determined to take a POTUS selfie to post in the YakYak/Refresh thread, but an attack of pins-and-needles that made it difficult to extract the mobile from my pocket. Eventually I succeeded, but before I took the photo I glanced in an adjacent mirror... but it wasn't me. Awoke. I'm not going to say what "I" said beyond: Sopel, Bannon, JFK, RFK, Jean Dixon, God and Kim Jong-un.
Last night I dreamt I met Trump one-on-one... I talked, he listened. After which I determined to take a POTUS selfie to post in the YakYak/Refresh thread, but an attack of pins-and-needles that made it difficult to extract the mobile from my pocket. Eventually I succeeded, but before I took the photo I glanced in an adjacent mirror... but it wasn't me. Awoke. I'm not going to say what "I" said beyond: Sopel, Bannon, JFK, RFK, Jean Dixon, God and Kim Jong-un.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Trump
Paywalledvenusian wrote:By higher I do, of course, mean https://www.merriam-webster.com/diction ... r%20mammal. This is a defining term not a descriptive term.zip accident wrote:Higher?venusian wrote:One could argue that it's the ability to not compete, for the common good, that sets the higher animals apart.zip accident wrote:That's untrue, it's not human nature that causes competition, it's Nature.Cloudane wrote:Humans never change.
There are potentially infinite off-spring, and finite resources, that's nature, it's all that's needed to enforce competition. The sane way is to make competition less destructive, but you can't stop competition short of finding infinite resources.
We can have cooperation in the face of external forces, but that only works when there are external forces.And don't be silly, of course you can have non-competition.
Obviously they can be, but it's usually due to predator/prey relationships. There are believed to be consequences when predator/prey relationships break down.What unbreakable law of nature says that a population can't be stable?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Matth ... nd#MammalsIn 1944, 29 reindeer were introduced to the island by the United States Coast Guard to provide an emergency food source. The Coast Guard abandoned the island a few years later, leaving the reindeer. Subsequently, the reindeer population rose to about 6,000 by 1963[6] and then died off in the next two years to 42 animals.[7] A scientific study attributed the population crash to the limited food supply in interaction with climatic factors (the winter of 1963–64 was exceptionally severe in the region).[1] By the 1980s, the reindeer population had completely died out.[2] Environmentalists see this as an issue of overpopulation. For example, ecologist Garrett Hardin cited the "natural experiment" of St. Matthew Island of the reindeer population explosion and collapse as a paradigmatic example of the consequences of overpopulation in his essay An Ecolate View of the Human Predicament.[8]
Obviously, the reindeer should be caribou (different name for the same species).
Yes, mostly the competition is much less fierce than that, but it's still there, and obligate carnivores do eat.KlaxonCow wrote:"Nature, red in tooth and claw" is somewhat overplayed.
Disney's nature series were quite good.With understandable reason, as Darwin was having to get across sometimes brutal notions of "survival of the fittest" to folks who'd be singing "All Things Bright and Beautiful" on the Sunday and viewed nature as being "God's theme park" for their own amusement.
To disabuse people of this delusion that nature was all nice, pretty, lovely and like something from a Disney animation - and the only evils of the world were the "dark Satanic mills" of human endeavour - you would have to strongly emphasise things like the parasitic wasp. A charming creature that implants its young inside a paralysed host, where its offspring consumes the host from the inside out. It basically uses other creatures as "eggs" for its young.
Absolutely. Bingo. Nature == Universe, all 100 billion galaxies of it.But, equally, you can go too far in the other direction. When we say that nature is uncaring, it must be understood as meaning that it's incapable of caring. It's not a sentient being. It's, therefore, neutrally indifferent to everything.
Was there some intelligence before the big bang? no data. There is no absolute proof either way.There is no agency there. There is no guiding purpose or intent.
Cooperation is a function of competition, which is interesting, but it's a blooming fractal and you can follow the edges until you're blue in the face without learning anything.Nature, just as equally, evolved a mother's love for her children. Evolved the cooperative spirit of colony animals, like ants or bees. Evolved delicious fruits so that animals would eat them to distribute their seeds far and wide, in their shit, which is a great fertiliser, of course. It has evolved plenty of cooperative symbiotic relationships like this all over the place.
Yes. However, cooperation depends on competition, if there is not an external to compete with, cooperation falls apart. It's why premiers of all ilks love foreign wars.Competition is one facet of it all, but so is cooperation too.
I disagree. If something is the only way things can work, then whether it ought to be or not, it is.More over, this whole line of reasoning falls foul of "the naturalistic fallacy" anyway. Just because something is, doesn't mean it ought to be.
There is some reason to suspect that some bacteria were more beneficial than we knew, and we've been messing with things we don't understand. Cancer took off big time after WW2, it could have been fallout from the Pacific nukes, but it is equally possible it was penicillin killing bacteria that we didn't know stopped cancer. There was cancer before WW2, but it was rare, and people sometimes lived until 70+ years of age then too, so it probably wasn't a change in the age of the population.Disease is perfectly natural. Therefore, according to the naturalistic fallacy that that which is "natural" is always good and the way things should be, we should close all the hospitals, sack all the doctors and nurse, and abandon medical science completely.
Disease is natural. Thus, we're "supposed" to get ill and die. It's natural, so it's good. So stop trying to stop it happening.
Cooperation against disease is a perfectly normal aspect of competition.No, that's bollocks. Just because that's the way things are, doesn't mean that that's the way they should be and we should just fatalistically accept it.
Anyway, there's a fundamental logical problem with such "it's natural" arguments. Humans are also, after all, a product of nature. We're "natural" and, therefore, you could argue that everything we've naturally come to do is, by extension, also "natural" too.
Yes, but what works is always based on competition. Whenever people try to go against competition it always goes wrong and hurts more people than it helps. Hitler and Stalin for examples.There's plenty of good things, as well as the harsh and cruel things, to be found in nature. Truth is, the real underlying rule here is "whatever the fuck works" - it has nothing to do with being good or bad, or feelings, or purpose. It's just what, at a fundamental physical level, pragmatically works.
To be very clear, Thatcher's "market forces" which were a code-name for God, are in fact aspects of competition and cooperation, and she didn't have a clue what they really are, and nor do most capitalists or any capitalist theorists.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Trump
Disney pushed the lemmings.zip accident wrote:Disney's nature series were quite good.
(I mean, an instinct to commit mass suicide? How exactly would that evolve, eh?)
Yes, it's not possible to take a mathematical model past a singularity.zip accident wrote:Was there some intelligence before the big bang? no data. There is no absolute proof either way.There is no agency there. There is no guiding purpose or intent.
But all properly scrutinised observation since that singularity has shown no deviation from natural law at any point. No exceptions.
Statistical analysis of prayer has, on average, ascertained that its effectiveness is no better than random chance plus the placebo effect. Studies that have lent slightly towards the efficacy of prayer don't clear statistical significance and are within margins for error.
If there ever was a god at some point, then she's stopped listening and follows a strict non-interventionist policy with the universe.
I refrain from saying "there are no gods" because you're right that such a statement speaks beyond the bounds of the evidence, so I prefer to say that "this is a godless universe either way".
We can't say what's outside and beyond the universe without evidence, but we can examine what's within the universe and not an iota of it confirms any outside interference.
If gods kicked off this universe then all evidence suggests that they then left it to its own devices ever since.
You could then move into the predetermination argument. Supposing the gods to be omniscient, they could have set off the universe to play out according to their will. But the universe is chaotic - sensitive to initial conditions - and we're talking about elementary-particle-level precision to line everything up perfectly, so nothing short of infinitely precise omniscience - knowing everything about the universe to infinite precision everywhere - could have done it. Or "the butterfly wings" would rapidly ruin your plans in short order.
The grand problem of such a predetermination argument would simply be "why?". If absolutely everything is preordained as a 3D line in a 4D solid, then there is no free will. There can be no "salvation" because - taking that 4D view - you're already in Hell or Heaven before you were born. Before the universe was even born. And it may not vary from this, or the predetermination argument collapses.
So, you know, if the gods kickstarted the universe as they wished it to play out, then this might solve the "where are the gods now?" problem, but it creates the greater problem of rendering the core tenets of religion pointless. Your "Afterlife" is already predetermined and you can't alter or vary it in any fashion whatsoever. Your "karma" is already fixed, so you will reincarnate as many times as has been predetermined by the gods (not that Buddhists have any gods, as it is an atheistic religion, but just an example to stress that I don't just mean it renders the familiar Abrahamic religions pointless, but that it renders all religious thought pointless).
And what does one mean by "an intelligence" anyway? The intelligence of a dolphin? The intelligence of a rat? The intelligence of a human being? An infinite "intelligence"? Existing outside spacetime, how does "an intelligence" operate without time? Or do the gods live in their own timeless time outside of time?
Well, as you note, there is no evidence - and no means to obtain the evidence - to say either or any way. But the point of questioning it is to note that this "explanation" creates more questions than answers. An intelligence complicates things towards an incomprehensible "mystical" non-answer, not simplifies things to a comprehensible conclusion that's of actual pragmatic use. The purpose of "gods" is to kick any understanding into the infinite long grass.
Ergo, per Occam's Razor, the simplest explanation is the most likely to be true. There are no gods. And, yes, that's ultimately a statistical argument, but an incredibly sound one as statistical arguments go.
This is a godless universe either way.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
Re: Trump
You can argue this particular absurd certainty with Penrose.KlaxonCow wrote:Yes, it's not possible to take a mathematical model past a singularity.zip accident wrote: Was there some intelligence before the big bang? no data. There is no absolute proof either way.
Monomania, it's a thing.
Re: Trump
https://action.donaldjtrump.com/mainstr ... ty-survey/
Boy, someone has a bit of a persecution complex, don't they?
Boy, someone has a bit of a persecution complex, don't they?
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Trump
All human created religions are (by definition, if you think about it) false. However, that doesn't mean there is no god. The anthropothic principle is good, but it doesn't explain the existence of Venus. How could Venus be necessary to life on Earth?KlaxonCow wrote:Yes, it's not possible to take a mathematical model past a singularity.zip accident wrote:Was there some intelligence before the big bang? no data. There is no absolute proof either way.There is no agency there. There is no guiding purpose or intent.
But all properly scrutinised observation since that singularity has shown no deviation from natural law at any point. No exceptions.
Statistical analysis of prayer has, on average, ascertained that its effectiveness is no better than random chance plus the placebo effect. Studies that have lent slightly towards the efficacy of prayer don't clear statistical significance and are within margins for error.
If there ever was a god at some point, then she's stopped listening and follows a strict non-interventionist policy with the universe.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Trump
I was careful in how I phrased that.Absolute_Zero wrote:You can argue this particular absurd certainty with Penrose.KlaxonCow wrote:Yes, it's not possible to take a mathematical model past a singularity.
I wouldn't have to argue it with him, as Penrose would not disagree.
The relevant bit from the video is from 29:21-ish:
You can't mathematically push your way through a singularity because all your numbers go to infinity and, as he puts it, "all hell breaks loose".The other even more unpleasant feature is that you will shortly encounter the singularity in the middle, where the spacetime curvature becomes infinite, densities become infinite, all hell breaks loose and the equations find themselves giving up somewhere down in the middle there. So, because curvature's become infinite, density's become infinite, you're stuck.
What he's doing there with his theory - which I quite like on an aesthetic level - is noting that the ultimate end state of the universe, where all mass has decayed to energy and entropy is at its maximum, could well end up looking exactly like its start state in the Big Bang. Albeit at a different scale, but he notes that, in a totally massless universe, scales are irrelevant anyway. So, if the start and end states are identical, then the end of our universe is the Big Bang of the next universe and our Big Bang was the end state of the previous universe. And it's all infinitely cyclical in both directions.
He's not trying to mathematically pass through the singularity. He's going around it.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Trump
Well, again, I was careful in how I phrased it.zip accident wrote:All human created religions are (by definition, if you think about it) false. However, that doesn't mean there is no god.
My argument was that this was a godless universe either way.
Because though we can't say anything about what's beyond or outside or possibly existing in parallel with our universe, we can say things about what's within the universe that we can observe.
And no observation has ever indicated any "divine intervention" whatsoever.
This is what I mean by "a godless universe". If there are gods, then they're not any active part of the universe by any known observation or evidence.
Yes, "there are no gods" is an intrinsically unfalsifiable statement. But that, to the extent of all our observations, we lead a godless existence regardless.
(And, sure, that's a "so far we've found no evidence" - evidence to the contrary could show up later - but, at this point, what use would it be? The gods have not proved necessary for the formation of matter, the formation of stars, the formation of the elements, the formation of star systems, the chemistry of the universe, the evolution of life, the operation of our biology, etc.. So, really, what's left for these "gods of the gap" to fulfil? If the gods are to be found in the remaining gaps in our knowledge, then these gods won't prove to be particularly important to anything. They would only be gods of the obscure fine details. We can, I feel, safely ignore them.)
Ah, well, if you're talking about the whole "fine tuning" idea, then I'm not a believer in that at all. The universe is not here for us.zip accident wrote:The anthropothic principle is good, but it doesn't explain the existence of Venus. How could Venus be necessary to life on Earth?
I defer to Neil deGrasse Tyson here:
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Trump
Worryingly so.F-ZeroOne wrote:Boy, someone has a bit of a persecution complex, don't they?
Because the reason for taking such a poll would be to use it as justification for an executive order to gag the press later on.
"See? The people want me to shut you down. This poll proves it".
One month in and Trump's contradicted the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment with his Muslim ban. Now he's going after the second half of the First Amendment, guaranteeing free speech.
He's apparently undoing the Bill of Rights, one right at a time, in chronological order.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Trump
I believe the Lexx model has it that the singularity between cycles of the big bang is such a hard reset, bringing every precondition to exactly the same state (including the PRNG that decides all the unpredictable things), that the entirety of the universe's history repeats exactly the same way every time; such that you can have oracles who know the future based on their ability to observe the pasts (despite the singularities) and, presumably, the inference that the current iteration cannot diverge from that because it never did any other time (time travel paradoxes be damned).
So there was intelligent life before the big bang. It was us.
Sorry to disappoint. Hope you weren't expecting something intelligenter.
So there was intelligent life before the big bang. It was us.
Sorry to disappoint. Hope you weren't expecting something intelligenter.
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
Re: Trump
Neatly going around the prime metaphysical issue of "something" where logic would suggest "nothing"... which is why I like it.KlaxonCow wrote:I was careful in how I phrased that.Absolute_Zero wrote:You can argue this particular absurd certainty with Penrose.KlaxonCow wrote:Yes, it's not possible to take a mathematical model past a singularity.
I wouldn't have to argue it with him, as Penrose would not disagree.
The relevant bit from the video is from 29:21-ish:
You can't mathematically push your way through a singularity because all your numbers go to infinity and, as he puts it, "all hell breaks loose".The other even more unpleasant feature is that you will shortly encounter the singularity in the middle, where the spacetime curvature becomes infinite, densities become infinite, all hell breaks loose and the equations find themselves giving up somewhere down in the middle there. So, because curvature's become infinite, density's become infinite, you're stuck.
What he's doing there with his theory - which I quite like on an aesthetic level - is noting that the ultimate end state of the universe, where all mass has decayed to energy and entropy is at its maximum, could well end up looking exactly like its start state in the Big Bang. Albeit at a different scale, but he notes that, in a totally massless universe, scales are irrelevant anyway. So, if the start and end states are identical, then the end of our universe is the Big Bang of the next universe and our Big Bang was the end state of the previous universe. And it's all infinitely cyclical in both directions.
Nevertheless he's positing information passing from previous to current in contradiction of Zip's statement.He's not trying to mathematically pass through the singularity. He's going around it.
Quite how you managed to inappropriately inject proselytizing for the church of Dork in a thread on Donald J Trump [FFS] is a true wonder of the universe. Have you heard the good news about Jesus? -- the parallels are both numerous and hilarious. Don't reply here, create a thread. You and ZA, sheesh!
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4597
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: Trump
People are peeved Scott Brown is going to be the US ambassador in NZ, apparently it's some sort of insult. Seems fair to me since we are likely to send them our last PM, John Key.
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.

