Politics Thread!

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by (o)(o) »

User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Dio »

If you posted that video as an attack on May, can I suggest that you need to think carefully about how you frame statements to avoid looking like you're having a go simply because she isn't in possession of a penis, the presence or not of which has no effect on someone's political competence.
(o)(o) wrote:
Dio wrote:But it's still far superior to the current Labour situation where they couldn't organise a pissup in a brewery. Or indeed a policy on a manifesto.

They can't even work out whether they want to be in or out of Europe, so today they've stated that they want to be both.
It's easy to mistake principled democracy for division or weak leadership (or chaos as the Tory put it in their smears).

Democratic process should embrace different views.

Right leaning press will frame this positive in a negative light of course.
That's simple nonsense. If I am to cast my vote in an informed manner, I need to have as much idea as possible what the person I'm giving it to will do afterwards, and Labour are completely failing to do that. The time for 'debate' has passed and now clear, consistent and workable policy is a requirement.

Labour's current organisational standard is about the level of student politics - limited coherent planning outside of two or three key issues. Everything else is swept under the carpet, handled on the hoof, different answers from different people or assertions of all things to all men.

Don't let your hatred for the tories blind yourself to Labour's current shabby incompetence. Wishing they were going to win will not make them win. Blaming it on the press will not make them win. There is not enough leadership there, whatever the righteous virtues of the policy - and I fear they will be simply destroyed in this election unless there's a dramatic improvement in the quality of party management.
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by gravy »

So you're going to vote tory then?
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Dio »

Doesn't matter in the slightest what I vote, this is one of the biggest Labour majorities in the country, if they lost this then they'd end up with fewer seats than the SNP.

It's likely I will stick my futile gesture in the direction of the LDs at this point, assuming their manifesto resembles 2010s. If they were the most likely winners of the seat I would likely tactically vote for Labour in the event my vote did matter, but it doesn't.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by (o)(o) »

Dio wrote:If you posted that video as an attack on May, can I suggest that you need to think carefully about how you frame statements to avoid looking like you're having a go simply because she isn't in possession of a penis.
WTF :P
Dio wrote:Don't let your hatred for the tories blind yourself to Labour's current shabby incompetence.
I'm not. My perception of the situation differ from yours.

IMO the framing of incompetence is borne from media misrepresentation.

You see an awful lot of use of terms like 'lack of leadership' (a pretty vacuous accusation in and of itself) in press pieces determined to derail Corbyn's core messages - but he's an enabler of democratic process who works from fundamental principles. Clearly there is fall out and sabotage from New Labour leaning politicians, but I'm not surprised as he's challenging the status quo. Schism is not incompetence if it's for change.

I also have fairly clear enough idea of what policies he will invoke, largely because he says what he means and means what he says, and has been consistently doing so for decades. Also they've outlined quite a lot of what they will do.

I have much more confidence in Labour than I do than the current mobsters and pathological liars.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by zip accident »

(o)(o) wrote:
Dio wrote:If you posted that video as an attack on May, can I suggest that you need to think carefully about how you frame statements to avoid looking like you're having a go simply because she isn't in possession of a penis.
WTF :P
Dio wrote:Don't let your hatred for the tories blind yourself to Labour's current shabby incompetence.
I'm not. My perception of the situation differ from yours.

IMO the framing of incompetence is borne from media misrepresentation.

You see an awful lot of use of terms like 'lack of leadership' (a pretty vacuous accusation in and of itself) in press pieces determined to derail Corbyn's core messages - but he's an enabler of democratic process who works from fundamental principles. Clearly there is fall out and sabotage from New Labour leaning politicians, but I'm not surprised as he's challenging the status quo. Schism is not incompetence if it's for change.

I also have fairly clear enough idea of what policies he will invoke, largely because he says what he means and means what he says, and has been consistently doing so for decades. Also they've outlined quite a lot of what they will do.

I have much more confidence in Labour than I do than the current mobsters and pathological liars.
Labour are for Brexit though, how does that sit with being inclusive of foreigners?
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by (o)(o) »

zip accident wrote:Labour are for Brexit though, how does that sit with being inclusive of foreigners?
I don't really understand the question - they are not mutually exclusive.

You mean free movement of foreigners?
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Dio »

(o)(o) wrote:IMO the framing of incompetence is borne from media misrepresentation.
He has a parliamentary party half of whom won't work with him. A leader has to fix that situation or it's not leading. In that situation, a great leader can show his capability to lead by one of three tacks: bringing them round to his view (visionary leadership), sensible compromise (pragmatic leadership) or replacing them (strong leadership). Any of those would be acceptable, but he's done none of it, because he is an idealist not a pragmatist, not strong, and not enough of a visionary to sell his view. He's a nice chap who'd rather convince everyone by a bit of a quiet discussion, maybe respect their views if they disagree and then ignore them and this is not the recipe for a stable political party unless nearly everyone else just happens to agree and a few loonies on the fringe can be safely ignored.

The result is there are currently two Labour parties, the parliamentary party and the leadership. How can wavering voters vote for that? What are they even voting for? Let's say you give a fuck about Trident - which I don't, personally - and in a week or two Labour drop a manifesto saying keep it (and they will) and Jeremy continues to say dump it (and he will). How is that not a mess?

And look at the shambles of Brexit. Labour do a lukewarm job of selling Remain to the north and pointing out that the real reason things are in the toilet is Conservative austerity, and as a result go into this election in the unedifying situation of choosing to offend 60% of their Remain support by going for exit or 40% of their Leave support by going remain - so they try to thread the needle (in a way that's clearly impossible to achieve, since there is no chance of a deal that can delete free movement but stay in the single market) and probably offend 100%. Nice going chaps.

For me, Labour's only big chance in this election was to lead on Remain - and I mean lead, better than they've done so far - and hope the sheer volume of noise involved kind of hid the cracks but they've blown it. Not that they really had that choice now after voting for the bloody thing, they'd already packed themselves into a corner and May knew it - thoroughly outflanked.

My prediction is that they're going to lose about 100 seats - about two thirds to the Tories, the rest to the LDs, and the LDs will pick up another 20 or so seats off the Tories, leaving a substantial Conservative majority. Worst case, they could be reduced to a party of the north of England and maybe a few bits of London. I hope I'm wrong, but I suspect it's going to be a pretty grim country by 2022. And it'll be cock all to do with the media and everything to do with a party that can't find a leader and some MPs who can pull in the same bloody direction.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Darkflame »

merman wrote:We need a progressive alliance* but Labour and Lib Dems ruling it out.
So it's a mass campaign to vote for the best chance that isn't a Tory in your constituency.

http://tactical2017.com
hmm...now to work out how best to "market" that in my timeline and feeds.

The remarks about the NHS needing to make "efficiency's" still seem pretty powerful to me. But that only works if people know how in trouble the NHS is :-/
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by zip accident »

Dio wrote:
(o)(o) wrote:IMO the framing of incompetence is borne from media misrepresentation.
He has a parliamentary party half of whom won't work with him. A leader has to fix that situation or it's not leading. In that situation, a great leader can show his capability to lead by one of three tacks: bringing them round to his view (visionary leadership), sensible compromise (pragmatic leadership) or replacing them (strong leadership). Any of those would be acceptable, but he's done none of it, because he is an idealist not a pragmatist, not strong, and not enough of a visionary to sell his view. He's a nice chap who'd rather convince everyone by a bit of a quiet discussion, maybe respect their views if they disagree and then ignore them and this is not the recipe for a stable political party unless nearly everyone else just happens to agree and a few loonies on the fringe can be safely ignored.

The result is there are currently two Labour parties, the parliamentary party and the leadership. How can wavering voters vote for that? What are they even voting for? Let's say you give a fuck about Trident - which I don't, personally - and in a week or two Labour drop a manifesto saying keep it (and they will) and Jeremy continues to say dump it (and he will). How is that not a mess?

And look at the shambles of Brexit. Labour do a lukewarm job of selling Remain to the north and pointing out that the real reason things are in the toilet is Conservative austerity, and as a result go into this election in the unedifying situation of choosing to offend 60% of their Remain support by going for exit or 40% of their Leave support by going remain - so they try to thread the needle (in a way that's clearly impossible to achieve, since there is no chance of a deal that can delete free movement but stay in the single market) and probably offend 100%. Nice going chaps.

For me, Labour's only big chance in this election was to lead on Remain - and I mean lead, better than they've done so far - and hope the sheer volume of noise involved kind of hid the cracks but they've blown it. Not that they really had that choice now after voting for the bloody thing, they'd already packed themselves into a corner and May knew it - thoroughly outflanked.

My prediction is that they're going to lose about 100 seats - about two thirds to the Tories, the rest to the LDs, and the LDs will pick up another 20 or so seats off the Tories, leaving a substantial Conservative majority. Worst case, they could be reduced to a party of the north of England and maybe a few bits of London. I hope I'm wrong, but I suspect it's going to be a pretty grim country by 2022. And it'll be cock all to do with the media and everything to do with a party that can't find a leader and some MPs who can pull in the same bloody direction.
I suspect it will be worse than that.

I think it will be a Labour win by at least 50 seats, and they won't have a clue how to govern. They will back Brexit and it will happen, and it will be a complete disaster, and they will take all the blame.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Cloudane »

Dio wrote:He has a parliamentary party half of whom won't work with him. A leader has to fix that situation or it's not leading. In that situation, a great leader can show his capability to lead by one of three tacks: bringing them round to his view (visionary leadership), sensible compromise (pragmatic leadership) or replacing them (strong leadership). Any of thoshttp://www.yakyak.org/posting.php?mode=quote&f=2&p=1667267#e would be acceptable, but he's done none of it
Tending to agree with you on these comments, having spent a lot of time over the last year or so listening to / reading the views of a few political camps and their criticisms etc (I think it's good to listen to all sides. They're not all monsters). Just for perspective of whose 'side' I'm on, I just did the political compass test again yesterday and it still identifies me as firmly in the bottom-left quadrant (halfway to communism, halfway to social anarchy - basically a soaking wet liberal) and I like what Corbyn stands for and think he's a great human being and will be voting Labour myself. But indeed, unfortunately, just being nice and agreeable isn't sufficient to work with and convince most people in the real world.

I really don't see him selling his message to half his own party never mind the country, and I think what I've seen from a lot of Corbyn supporters (including other forums in this) of seeming to just dismiss them all as a bunch of evil neoliberal red-Tory Blairite bastards who need to be cleansed from the party until they're displaced by people who think "the right way", is.. well it's disturbing on a few levels (what happens when you extend that kind of thinking to the population?) but it's also rather similar to how we treated Brexit supporters as a bunch of evil nasty racists. It just doesn't help convince anyone because as soon as you slap some condescending label on them they lose interest in what you have to say.

It's interesting with the media. I've been right there demonising them as manipulative and biased and yeah a lot are, especially the Grauniad on the left and the Daily Heil on the right - the best hope I used to have was the likes of the Independent, which is now shitty clickbait trash (ask /r/worldnews what they think of their credibility as a source, I think they'd expand on that quite a bit). Yet, I know it's another country, but seeing how Trump makes the same "I'm not shit, I don't have a low approval rating, it's just the evil mainstream media spreading fake news" argument and really trying (and in many cases succeeding) to completely discredit the media has made me think twice about writing off everything they say. Without them what have we got? All that is really doing is handing the "faith" to the politicians you agree with. Think for yourselves, question things, take biased sources with the necessarily doses of salt but don't just follow ideologies and dismiss critics of his approach as nonbelieving heretics spreading the devil's lies. I think that'll only lead to disappointment.

I'd LOVE to be wrong. I'd LOVE to wake up on a sunny day on 9th June and find there's been an unexpected Labour landslide, that the whole country's just decided to listen to the lovable old raggedy man on the bicycle (as I think many see him). I just don't really share that optimism, try as I might. I don't think he's got a cat in Hell's chance. I'd slap £100 on the Tories if they weren't already a dead cert at 1/14 (£7 profit. Not worth the hassle).
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by zip accident »

Cloudane wrote:
Dio wrote:He has a parliamentary party half of whom won't work with him. A leader has to fix that situation or it's not leading. In that situation, a great leader can show his capability to lead by one of three tacks: bringing them round to his view (visionary leadership), sensible compromise (pragmatic leadership) or replacing them (strong leadership). Any of thoshttp://www.yakyak.org/posting.php?mode=quote&f=2&p=1667267#e would be acceptable, but he's done none of it
Tending to agree with you on these comments, having spent a lot of time over the last year or so listening to / reading the views of a few political camps and their criticisms etc (I think it's good to listen to all sides. They're not all monsters). Just for perspective of whose 'side' I'm on, I just did the political compass test again yesterday and it still identifies me as firmly in the bottom-left quadrant (halfway to communism, halfway to social anarchy - basically a soaking wet liberal) and I like what Corbyn stands for and think he's a great human being and will be voting Labour myself. But indeed, unfortunately, just being nice and agreeable isn't sufficient to work with and convince most people in the real world.

I really don't see him selling his message to half his own party never mind the country, and I think what I've seen from a lot of Corbyn supporters (including other forums in this) of seeming to just dismiss them all as a bunch of evil neoliberal red-Tory Blairite bastards who need to be cleansed from the party until they're displaced by people who think "the right way", is.. well it's disturbing on a few levels (what happens when you extend that kind of thinking to the population?) but it's also rather similar to how we treated Brexit supporters as a bunch of evil nasty racists. It just doesn't help convince anyone because as soon as you slap some condescending label on them they lose interest in what you have to say.

It's interesting with the media. I've been right there demonising them as manipulative and biased and yeah a lot are, especially the Grauniad on the left and the Daily Heil on the right - the best hope I used to have was the likes of the Independent, which is now shitty clickbait trash (ask /r/worldnews what they think of their credibility as a source, I think they'd expand on that quite a bit). Yet, I know it's another country, but seeing how Trump makes the same "I'm not shit, I don't have a low approval rating, it's just the evil mainstream media spreading fake news" argument and really trying (and in many cases succeeding) to completely discredit the media has made me think twice about writing off everything they say. Without them what have we got? All that is really doing is handing the "faith" to the politicians you agree with. Think for yourselves, question things, take biased sources with the necessarily doses of salt but don't just follow ideologies and dismiss critics of his approach as nonbelieving heretics spreading the devil's lies. I think that'll only lead to disappointment.

I'd LOVE to be wrong. I'd LOVE to wake up on a sunny day on 9th June and find there's been an unexpected Labour landslide, that the whole country's just decided to listen to the lovable old raggedy man on the bicycle (as I think many see him). I just don't really share that optimism, try as I might. I don't think he's got a cat in Hell's chance. I'd slap £100 on the Tories if they weren't already a dead cert at 1/14 (£7 profit. Not worth the hassle).
Yeah, bettings probably the only way to make sense of this tragedy.

Actually, 12:1 against isn't that brilliant, it's not as if they think it's a sure thing. With the Tories 25:1 on, you'd think a Labour win would be have better odds than that, but I suppose that's the way the profit is made.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Dio »

Cloudane wrote:I really don't see him selling his message to half his own party never mind the country, and I think what I've seen from a lot of Corbyn supporters (including other forums in this) of seeming to just dismiss them all as a bunch of evil neoliberal red-Tory Blairite bastards who need to be cleansed from the party until they're displaced by people who think "the right way", is.. well it's disturbing on a few levels (what happens when you extend that kind of thinking to the population?) but it's also rather similar to how we treated Brexit supporters as a bunch of evil nasty racists.
He should have forced reselection though. Basically go back to the constituency parties and say "OK, you bloody well elected me twice, now bloody well send me MPs who'll work with me." It wasn't optional after the second landslide leadership victory if he wanted any kind of coherent party but he still wouldn't do it - I suspect partly in fear of how the press would show it but at least as much because he's not that kind of chap.
User avatar
PFVA
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14996
Joined: Fri May 24, 2002 1:40 am 0
Location: Paralel 38

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by PFVA »

Just to mention as i have seen the issue of vaccination being discussed here.

We are having a small epidemic of chicken pox. A 17 year old girl has died of it. It started in Cascais and has spread to the entire area of Lisbon and valley of the Tagus. The problem is exactly non-vaccinated young people.

It has not been worse because the people around my age weren't vaccinate back then but almost all of us had it when we were children. Vaccination came around 1980 but has never been made mandatory. The ones after that period whose parent's decided not to vaccinate them are the ones at risk. They no longer catch it so easily as we did when we were kids and no one was vaccinated, and they get it later when it's much more dangerous.

There is a campaign now with people raising signatures to make vaccination mandatory.
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Cloudane »

zip accident wrote:
Actually, 12:1 against isn't that brilliant, it's not as if they think it's a sure thing. With the Tories 25:1 on, you'd think a Labour win would be have better odds than that, but I suppose that's the way the profit is made.
Cool, not going to disagree there - will actually just open up on that subject and admit that I know fuck all about betting (only really dabble at elections, and for Brexit and Trump my pessimism was quite profitable) and am only really pretending to and talking about "dead certs" as if I do :) Thanks for reminding me, genuinely.
It'd be so nice to be proven wrong. Hence my psychology is to bet on what I don't want. Tempted to still stick a hundred on - if they win, a couple of beers to cry over are paid for. If they lose, I'll be too shocked and delighted to care about the money and consider it 'well spent'!
Dio wrote: He should have forced reselection though. Basically go back to the constituency parties and say "OK, you bloody well elected me twice, now bloody well send me MPs who'll work with me." It wasn't optional after the second landslide leadership victory if he wanted any kind of coherent party but he still wouldn't do it - I suspect partly in fear of how the press would show it but at least as much because he's not that kind of chap.
Yeah I'm not a fan of the third option you cited as "strong leadership" of just replacing the people who disagree with you.
The thing is, the people who "elected" him. Correct me if I'm wrong, but currently I stand by the theory (keep in mind I do like him myself! Just trying to have an objective eye on things) that it was mostly people hopping on the "become a member of the Labour party for about the price of a pint and vote him for leader" bandwagon, while the various MPs in his party who've been making this their business for years have been told they're wrong (but not effectively convinced why). I really think it was like a social media bubble having an actual impact on something - just it wasn't the country, it was limited to the opposition party.
Again, pessimism, admittedly. Which sucks, having been the eternal optimist. 2016 took its toll.
Post Reply