Bug reports?

Chat: here
Support: http://minotaurproject.co.uk/phpBB3/viewforum.php?f=23
Post Reply
User avatar
tenshi_alpha
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 192
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2014 6:00 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: tenshi alpha
PSN: tenshi_alpha
Location: Sheffield

Re: Bug reports?

Post by tenshi_alpha »

There's a typo in the end-game copy. It says "alteady" instead of "already" in one paragraph.

Thank you again for making this amazing game! :D
User avatar
tenshi_alpha
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 192
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2014 6:00 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: tenshi alpha
PSN: tenshi_alpha
Location: Sheffield

Re: Bug reports?

Post by tenshi_alpha »

Oh and - I'm not sure global leaderboard high scores are updating correctly at the end of normal mode. Or maybe disconnecting from the internet screws things up.

I finished the game (yay!), but while I was on the final level, our internet went out.

Even though the internet connection restored itself a few minutes later, the game didn't notice, and I couldn't get to the online leaderboard, only local scores.

So I exited the game - i.e. "Close Application", then went back in again, checked it could retrieve online scores, went to level 47 classic mode and played right the way through to the end of the game again.

And still, finishing the game for a second time didn't update the global leaderboard.

If you have a look, I'm #1 on the global leaderboard with around 95 million, but my final score was actually over 104 million.

It doesn't bother me, but since it's right at the end of the game, I think it might frustrate some players.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Bug reports?

Post by gilesgoat »

tenshi_alpha wrote:Oh and - I'm not sure global leaderboard high scores are updating correctly at the end of normal mode. Or maybe disconnecting from the internet screws things up.

I finished the game (yay!), but while I was on the final level, our internet went out.

Even though the internet connection restored itself a few minutes later, the game didn't notice, and I couldn't get to the online leaderboard, only local scores.

So I exited the game - i.e. "Close Application", then went back in again, checked it could retrieve online scores, went to level 47 classic mode and played right the way through to the end of the game again.

And still, finishing the game for a second time didn't update the global leaderboard.

If you have a look, I'm #1 on the global leaderboard with around 95 million, but my final score was actually over 104 million.

It doesn't bother me, but since it's right at the end of the game, I think it might frustrate some players.

I think we already found a little thing there that another player already reported.

What puzzles me more is the story you say you were IN-GAME when the net went down and then the game was never able to "recover" from it, that is very strange.

The way that thing works/should work is there are 2 different type of "callback" functions that should/are called when "something happens with the net" now something has to do with literally things like "IP addresses" ( but does not tell you if you can or can not see PSN , it only tells you if you are physically connected to a net ) something else has to do with "PSN reacheability" that SHOULD tell you if you can actually talk to PSN or not.

Have you tried to see if that state ( of you not being able to do anything with net ) persisted waiting a little over 5 mins ?

Must be said I tried all that stuff on in-out cables off/on while testing score tables and such, I can't say I ever noted that.

I could say "PSN is quite odd" there's NO EASY WAY to know if you are "in" or "out".

Also when a net on/off happens ( actually from an off to on ) I have to re-check some "parental controls" stuff and params, if I can NOT identify your "age" and such I have to assume "you can not use network".

However fear not your score - if highest than - is ALWAYS saved "locally" too and next time you start the game a "synch attempt" with "online" will be done.

[edit] - also keep in mind that "the way things are supposed to work" - had MANY DISCUSSIONS with Sony about this - is "simple" "if you don't have the net your score is lost, full stop" the idea of "saving locally and synch and such it's all 'our invention' for no we can't let a score go lost".

PSN is NOT the most beautiful piece of API/stuff to work with ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
PVB
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 32542
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 10:16 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: PVBuk
PSN: PVBuk
Location: Medway, U.K.

Re: Bug reports?

Post by PVB »

gilesgoat wrote:[[edit] - also keep in mind that "the way things are supposed to work" - had MANY DISCUSSIONS with Sony about this - is "simple" "if you don't have the net your score is lost, full stop" the idea of "saving locally and synch and such it's all 'our invention' for no we can't let a score go lost".

PSN is NOT the most beautiful piece of API/stuff to work with ...
Yeah, other games have similar high score table issues.

Loot Rascals' tables are all over the place;
Daily challenge scores are shown for the last six days, but end up mixing up the order of individual scores, missing scores out, etc.
The dev is trying to figure out how/why so they can fix them.
User avatar
tenshi_alpha
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 192
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2014 6:00 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: tenshi alpha
PSN: tenshi_alpha
Location: Sheffield

Re: Bug reports?

Post by tenshi_alpha »

I think maybe it just isn't recording any high scores beyond level 49, rather than being a network problem.

Which is probably good news for anyone trying to beat my score. :mrgreen:
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Re: Bug reports?

Post by gravy »

I just had it crash flipping between game modes on the title screen, not exactly sure what triggered it though
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Bug reports?

Post by gilesgoat »

tenshi_alpha wrote:I think maybe it just isn't recording any high scores beyond level 49, rather than being a network problem.

Which is probably good news for anyone trying to beat my score. :mrgreen:
Actually I think , I haven't fully check but this could be "more or less confirmed" that in fact it does save score up to level 49 and probably not at level 50.

The only thing I could say in my "defense" is that I never played up to level 49/50 I was TOO FUCKING BUSY WITH FORMS AND OTHER SHIT .. but Jeff played 49/50 a tons of time .. probably never watching the online score ..

You can probably guess by your own what could be happening here ..

No honestly what happen is there was a deadline "mostly cause the pre-order" .. then in that time we assumed "should be more than enough for" .. it wasn't .. the forms and all took much longer ..

Then we already had "the slip" of 10 May instead of 28 April .. I was already at the edge of insanity .. then we had "a few crap things there and there" happening .. I was beyond insanity ..

Then I got to a level of "ULTRA PARANOIA" I wasn't sure "if I checked enough this and that" and got to a point "I wasn't even any more sure what else to test" I could not stand any more going for the Nth > 1000 times to check "I really don't know what any more".

.. however .. as you can see - and this will add even MORE ULTRA PARANOIA next game - "all we tested wasn't enough" we missed something ...

I know it may seem/sound "absolutely incredibly silly" or "so obvious" or "look it JUST happened to me I found this" ... when you get to the stage we were near the end I can GUARANTEE you "you don't see the world any more like anyone else does" .. also "that thing that just happened to you" I can again GUARANTEE you that "especially in that stage" not even if me/Yak we try 1,000,000 of times to replicate we won't be able to get it or see it.

Some then "unexpected things that came out from FQA" made me touch some "critical bits of code in the last 3 days" at that point literally "there's no more time to test a shit if it works or not" ( well I did what I could in 3 days ) so it's been like "praying it still all works as it should".

Anyway "you find the bugs, we fix them if/when we can" :mrgreen: gets really at a point where "the developer can't find bugs any more" you kinda get "bugs blindness".

We had one "real bug" ( crash bug ) coming out once in a blue moon that for a pure stroke of luck FQA found in ONE test and NEVER been able to replicate then but they had a crash report that with that and some "comparing of ASM disasm and shit" we at least found the point where it was crashing.

The point of crash wasn't "super significant" because most difficult to find was "why and what was calling that" .. this took 2 days to figure it out, in the end "the mega crash" was ONE forgotten line of code, probably cause a "late night cut and paste" or shit like that that in the end was doing something that in 99.999% of cases "would have done absolutely nothing" and for "who knows what" in that 0.000001% of so would have made a crash.

Now when you spend around 2 days for that and you have only 1 day to test before you can send it all "for the final run" things get a bit .. "nervous" to say the least ...

Well in essence "you can't find them all out at the first go" .. not even at the second .. not even at the third .. "someone out there playing the game will something you will NEVER be able to find in your own lab/etc. " ... "it's the rule" .. :roll:
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Bug reports?

Post by gilesgoat »

gravy wrote:I just had it crash flipping between game modes on the title screen, not exactly sure what triggered it though
That's VERY curious .. I mean if you'd be flipping around LEVELS I could think "oh dear there could be thousands of reasons there" .. but flipping around game modes .. that's really strange .. I THINK in that stage doing so the only things that "flips" are a variable, a string and a song being played .. and I don't think really much else should be happening ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Junosix
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1959
Joined: Sun Jul 14, 2002 4:12 pm 0
Location: Plymouth

Re: Bug reports?

Post by Junosix »

Not a bug as such, but I have seen a few comments on a few reviews/forums about the soundtrack being quiet. I notice by default the mixer for the music is 50% and I agree that the music gets a bit lost in the background at that level, cranking it up to 100% whilst leaving the sound effects around 20-30% sorts that and it sounds great. Wondering if perhaps the levels weren't altered after the volume of the audio files was changed to satisfy the levels expected by the ATRAC software. Might be worth defaulting the music volume level to 100% on the next update?
wicked skills
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Bug reports?

Post by gilesgoat »

Junosix wrote:Not a bug as such, but I have seen a few comments on a few reviews/forums about the soundtrack being quiet. I notice by default the mixer for the music is 50% and I agree that the music gets a bit lost in the background at that level, cranking it up to 100% whilst leaving the sound effects around 20-30% sorts that and it sounds great. Wondering if perhaps the levels weren't altered after the volume of the audio files was changed to satisfy the levels expected by the ATRAC software. Might be worth defaulting the music volume level to 100% on the next update?
THERE IS A TRC ABOUT THE MAX ADMITTED LEVELS OF THE SOUNDTRACKS !

I should not be breaking an NDA about this ...
RXXXXX

Premise: -

Requirement: The application performs loudness measurement for each scene and the measurements are
within the SIE recommended value range.


Description
The application should perform loudness measurement based on ITU-R BS.1770-3 for as long as possible
and at least for 30 minutes, and confirm that the measurements are within the SIE recommended value
(-24 LKFS ±2.0) range.
Levels been measured and ALL soundtracks been "levelled" to that, that according to some musicians this seems to be a "Standard Broadcast Value" ( I suppose used in broadcast stations ).

The soundtracks levels are PRECISELY how they want them to be NOT FAIL certification, if the value goes above that "it fails" however as you can see you CAN pump it up by yourself to put "a bit louder".

Mind you .. "pump up the volume", I don't know what system people have but I can tell you even as they are there is plenty of space to pump them up.

First time we made some builds .. "they were too loud" .. and guess what ? THEY WARNED US "they ARE TOO LOUD, put them DOWN" ..

So tell those forums/reviews "they don't know the rules of music" 8)

[edit] - and NO I *DO NOT* "default to 100%" BECAUSE if I do so "they do the measure test as it comes" and goes : FAIL !
and then they mark as MUST FIX BUG that "the music is too loud".

However by letting you the possibility to pump more up "your problem if you want to break your own ears" :mrgreen:
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Junosix
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1959
Joined: Sun Jul 14, 2002 4:12 pm 0
Location: Plymouth

Re: Bug reports?

Post by Junosix »

Was the volume level of the sound effects reduced in proportion to the volume level of the music when the music was adjusted to fit the -24LKFS spec? (if so and the music/sfx levels are as you intend them then yeah, they can stop moaning and jolly well turn up the music if they want to!)
wicked skills
User avatar
Chontler
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1540
Joined: Mon Mar 07, 2011 2:21 pm 0
Location: Conwy

Re: Bug reports?

Post by Chontler »

gilesgoat wrote:
tenshi_alpha wrote:I think maybe it just isn't recording any high scores beyond level 49, rather than being a network problem.

Which is probably good news for anyone trying to beat my score. :mrgreen:
Actually I think , I haven't fully check but this could be "more or less confirmed" that in fact it does save score up to level 49 and probably not at level 50....
Yup, I can confirm this...and there I was thinking I'd finally beaten tenshi's ass, but no. grrrr. gotta go crawling back and figure out where that extra 100 million comes from.

You can't play level 50 either in classic mode either - only lets you start at 49
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: Bug reports?

Post by Dio »

Two very minor bugs in the credits. Swith's track is listed as "Barry Island" rather than "Jenny and the Giants" as was intended. And, erm, I know this is a tiny bit egotistical to mention, but, well, I was wanting to show the kids, and, um, I'm not there :D .
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Bug reports?

Post by gilesgoat »

Junosix wrote:Was the volume level of the sound effects reduced in proportion to the volume level of the music when the music was adjusted to fit the -24LKFS spec? (if so and the music/sfx levels are as you intend them then yeah, they can stop moaning and jolly well turn up the music if they want to!)
Ok there goes the story, as simple as that :

1. we had the musics
2. some musics were a bit "louder than the others"
3. musics gets adjusted so they all conform to "a standard level" - that IIRC was "the one used by Spotify ??"
4. it happens I check and find that RXXXX TRC about the -24 LKFS
5. I measure , FUCK IT'S FAR TOO LOUD ( I think it was around 12 !!! )
6. "Guys I need everything at -24" ( plus actually it you were really PUMPING up there was some distortion )
7. musicians using their own better SW adjust and trim all songs
8. we re-do all the AT9 conversion/music "bundle"
9. FUCK THE FX ARE TOO LOUD
10. FUCK I CAN NOT now change all those samples
11. hey wait a min I can trick forcing the volume of FX lower by default
12. measuring this and that ( there's a procedure for that ) ok "it fits -24"
13. fine as that as long as they measure as it is will be fine

SO yes IT IS LIKE THAT SO EVERYTHING FITS in -24 LKFS.

Now the point is, if you have like us "a good audio setup" with 6 speakers or such and you set let's say volume to "something you think should be correct" - volume of YOUR AMPLIFIER - you can use as "reference" the PS4 "background music" you will see that "soundtracks are not really that low" and that some games "almost crash your audio" as you start them.

Anyway whatever those forum/people say I say to them :

1. YOU CAN put the volume more up
2. the default settings are so THAT by spending 30 mins MEASURING LKFS they DO NOT go over the REQUIRED THRESHOLD

And I'd dare to add "if you think they are picky about the musics levels you should see all the rest" .. I even had to "modify" some of the output levels of the video signal to avoid "certain LITTLE THINGS" that they said "it's disturbing for the user" otherwise.

( but in fairness it's true, music would be too loud by default and you would see some grainy stuff when it's too black/white )
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Bug reports?

Post by gilesgoat »

Dio wrote:Two very minor bugs in the credits. Swith's track is listed as "Barry Island" rather than "Jenny and the Giants" as was intended. And, erm, I know this is a tiny bit egotistical to mention, but, well, I was wanting to show the kids, and, um, I'm not there :D .
WHAT ??!!!

.. MA DIO )(*$()#@*$()@#$ .. I bet it's been when I had to do some last minute cut & paste and change for Sony stuff .. I am QUITE SURE you WERE THERE :!: :!: How could I have forgotten you !!!

About "Jenny and the Giants" .. that comes out to me "from the blue" .. really ? .. when that was said he had to be like that ???

I SWEAR after you spend TOO MUCH TIME in FORMS AND STUFF LIKE THAT you start to get some sort of "blindness" for other things.

Does not help you can not send a bit of code around and say "guys check this out if .. " :|

Let me check a thing .. actually you can check that .. in the credits if you use left/right to select the tune at least does it show your name when your tune appears ? It should be ...

[edit] - YES you definitely are if you select the music .. WTF happened to "Elliptical Orbit" ? .. it's TOTALLY NOT in the list !! I suspect accidentally I must have deleted one line of code !!!
Last edited by gilesgoat on Mon May 15, 2017 1:02 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
Post Reply