gravy wrote:What's interesting to me is if Labour seat losses are small-ish it's a valid argument that parliamentary Labour party fuck wittedness over Corbyn's leadership lost this election for them.
Alternatively you can phrase this in the way that Corbyn's inability to sell a vision to the PLP is the fault.
Excuse me for butting in again but I'd say these things take time..
Polls have been consistently underestimating Tory support for years, and Labour support is more significantly based on a lot of historically flaky voter groups, and the Tories are already pushing the line of asking people to check their conscience on the day before putting that X in Corbyn's box, and that last-minute remorse being a strong contributor to the 'shy tory' effect is thought to be a major reason that even the exit polls have been dramatically wrong in recent years.
I'm not saying it's completely out of the question that they've flubbed it that badly, because it has been a weak campaign against a very strong Labour one. I certainly think my initial predictions were vastly wrong and there's no reason I should be better here. I still struggle to see Labour actually improving much over last time, and damn straight the Tory vote will strengthen after the UKIP implosion.
gravy wrote:What's interesting to me is if Labour seat losses are small-ish it's a valid argument that parliamentary Labour party fuck wittedness over Corbyn's leadership lost this election for them.
Alternatively you can phrase this in the way that Corbyn's inability to sell a vision to the PLP is the fault. (The answer lies in the middle of course, neither side can claim much glory here).
What I'm most hopeful of is that the post-election perception will be that the strength of the campaign was based around a genuinely socialist manifesto.
The PLP's behaviour was based on the premise that actual socialism and Corbyn in particular were ballot box poison.
That may not be the case, more data available soon I'm pretty sure it's killed Tony Blair's split-away initiative stone cold dead at least
To be honest I think one of the biggest factors for recent poll swings is the Con's "haha you have to elect us" attitude. It's painfully obvious and completely back fired.
gravy wrote:What's interesting to me is if Labour seat losses are small-ish it's a valid argument that parliamentary Labour party fuck wittedness over Corbyn's leadership lost this election for them.
Alternatively you can phrase this in the way that Corbyn's inability to sell a vision to the PLP is the fault.
Excuse me for butting in again but I'd say these things take time..
Corbyn is a game changer.
Yeah, he's going to manage to lose Labour 10% of their seats against the worst Conservative campaign since Michael Howard and the greatest bungling of a strong position by a party leader ever .
I'll give you that you can argue the toss about how much of that is simply down to the collapse of UKIP, but this still smells badly of the US election situation, where a rabid core certainly know what they want but a substantial number of people are going to hold their noses and vote for the candidate they dislike least.
Dio wrote:a rabid core certainly know what they want but a substantial number of people are going to hold their noses and vote for the candidate they dislike least.
For all parties? I kind of like that. Can I be rabid core please?
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
KlaxonCow wrote:"Rabid core" sounds like it's a new musical genre that all the cool kids are listening to. Fuck dubstep, fuck piss bass. Rabid core is where it's at.
Cool kids are silly.
I think I want a T shirt with Rabid Core on top and the whole quote below that to explain it, attributed to "some geezer on the intarwebs". I wouldn't pay much for it though, maybe I can get white and DIY it?
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Dio wrote:I know, it's the Guardian, so its content is hardly a great surprise, but this manages to sum up almost my precise feelings on this election.
Meh. Graun is not going to be credible if they don't give him his due now. He's been incredibly solid throughout the campaign.
One can only imagine where we might be now, had such tomes been less perfidious, toxic and spiteful from day one. If the margins are narrow, it's the established Blairite 'left' who we can thank for five more years of this evil shit we've got now.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Ironically, it is precisely the shit-smearing from the media and the failed coup on his leadership that we have to thank for the opportunity he has right now. Sure, he probably won't win (although I actually think he will), but one thing is for certain in this campaign - if his polling hadn't been so utterly terrible, there is no way on earth May would have called the election. We would definitely have had to endure May's government until 2020 - what we're talking about here is basically a gamble between a 2 year extension, or a complete sea-change from next week. Personally, I think it's a punt worth taking.
There is no way that 22 out of 42 is 52%, especially not when 2 out of 42 is 5% (the 2 of 42 being 5% is probably a rounding error; the other, not so much).
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.