My T4K review

Support Forum: http://minotaurproject.co.uk/phpBB3/viewforum.php?f=22
User avatar
Spider-Dan
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 29
Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2003 11:32 am 0

My T4K review

Post by Spider-Dan »

Bought the Steam version of T4K today, sat down with it for a little over an hour and got to around level 30 or so. I had very high hopes as I LOVED TxK. Unfortunately, I was disappointed.

Let's start with the good stuff. The graphics are crisp and the resolution is a step up from TxK's 720P. The control is tight and the sound effects are great. The impressive new visual effects let you know right out of the gate that this is not the same game as TxK.

Um. So now on to the problems.

Music:
Looking through the soundtrack files, it appears that the only "new" tracks in this game are the "demake" unreleased MOD versions of some tracks that are on the T2K soundtrack CD (and various ports). However, I didn't actually get to that, as (through the first 30 levels) all the songs are from the T2K soundtrack CD. This is, frankly, a terrible way to open the game. I understand that you need filler and that you don't want to do a straight port of the TxK soundtrack, but the T2K title music combined with the T2K CD tracks is basically Tempest X3. If you're going to use entirely recycled music, the least you can do is put the unreleased demake tracks front facing. This is the first Llamasoft game I've ever played where the music selection just felt... lazy. T3K had new songs front-facing (with T2K songs buried in the later levels) and TxK had an amazing entirely new soundtrack, so I don't understand why this game is putting 20-year-old remix tracks that were already featured in Tempest 3000 front and center. (And on a related note: if you're going to use a straight legacy soundtrack, why no tunes from T3K?)

Gameplay:
I've played a lot of Llamasoft games; I know that visual frenzy is the brand. This is the first one where I have had a problem both hearing and seeing powerups. There isn't a distinctive powerup sound like T2K's, and for some reason, there seems to be some sort of transparency/dither effect on powerups. So whereas in TxK - which was still a graphically busy game - powerups were easily distinguishable, in T4K I don't even know that a powerup has spawned, and I frequently can't see it until it's past me off the web. It doesn't help that from the very first levels, there is some sort of flower petal effect that looks like a slowly moving enemy shot or something, but doesn't appear to interact with the player at all. It's just... stuff that doesn't matter, but looks like stuff that does. This is unfamiliar to me in a Tempest game, as normally things on the playfield serve a purpose.

While on the subject of powerups: the fact that the first powerup is a "useless" point bonus (combined with the very low fire rate of the base weapon) feels like cheap difficulty. It's like I don't get to start playing Tempest until the second powerup. While playing, I felt like that change combined with the removal of "leaning" from lane-to-lane (from TxK) made the difficulty spike seem really obnoxious. I won't claim to be a record-holding scorer, but I've cleared T2K on beastly mode, I've cleared TxK, I've cleared Gridrunner Revolution... I have some passing familiarity with Llamasoft shooters. And this just felt cheap.

That is, until I found out that leaning is in the game; you can hold LT to lean. Which brings me to my next point:

The documentation/UI is this game is unacceptable. It's terrible. There is no mention anywhere that leaning exists. To compare apples-to-apples, the How To Play screen in TxK is several pages long, explaining many facets of the gameplay and how the game works. The How To Play screen in T4K is one tersely-worded page listing controls... which isn't even accurate if you're playing the PC version with the default keyboard option. (And does not list the lean button, even for an Xbox controller.) If you want to know what the keyboard controls are, you have to drill down through the SteamApps folder and find a readme.txt like it's 1994. There, you'll find a list of the keyboard controls... that, again, does not list the lean button. (Does it even exist on keyboard? Who knows?)

Now, I understand the decision to only support XINPUT/Xbox controls, and I can even (somewhat) understand the decision not to allow remapping. But if you're going to support keyboard controls out of the box, you have to AT LEAST tell the players IN GAME what the keyboard controls are. I spent about 10 minutes trying get three powerups and then go through every key on the keyboard trying to figure out which one of them is Jump (without dying or finishing the level) before I gave up and decided to hope there was a readme. (The Jump key is S. Superzapper is F. To exit the game, you push P. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ )

I realize this review comes off as harsh. I've bought every (non-tablet/mobile) Llamasoft release since T2K. I'm a fan. There were some games, like T3K and Space Giraffe, that I just didn't feel were for me. And that's OK! Not every game will be for everyone. But this is the first Llamasoft game I've played that just felt... careless*. Incomplete. And looking at the difference between TxK (which I loved in every way!) and T4K, it seems like whatever the difference was - Atari's requirements, the demands of a multi-platform release, etc. - it doesn't seem to have been worth it. TxK was a far more polished game in nearly every respect.

Ultimately, I'm really disappointed that the existence of this game means we'll never get a proper PC/console release of TxK, or a TxK VR. To be honest, if Atari continues to be a bunch of copyright trolls about future tube shooters, I'd rather Tempest ride off into the sunset, and see Llamasoft make sequels to Space Giraffe for future tube shooters. (Or Space Ox I guess, because as we all know, Space Giraffe Is Not Tempest.)

*To be clear: I know that Llamasoft cared very much about this game, and that there are several factors that were out of their control.
User avatar
Spider-Dan
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 29
Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2003 11:32 am 0

Re: My T4K review

Post by Spider-Dan »

I just wanted to point out one more thing:

If TxK did not exist, I think I would be generally satisfied with T4K. It's definitely a step up from T3K (in my book), and T3K also had a lot of recycled T2K tunes behind a few new tracks, so that wouldn't really be a change (provided that the "new" TxK tracks were fronted instead of the old T2K tracks). So I guess if you set aside the PC specific issues, as a Tempest game T4K is fine and good.

It's mostly that TxK seems... far superior as a retail product. Expectations, I suppose.
User avatar
tenshi_alpha
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 192
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2014 6:00 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: tenshi alpha
PSN: tenshi_alpha
Location: Sheffield

Re: My T4K review

Post by tenshi_alpha »

What is leaning for? Now I've got it, I'm like... ok, how is this useful?
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: My T4K review

Post by gilesgoat »

Spider-Dan wrote:I just wanted to point out one more thing:

If TxK did not exist, I think I would be generally satisfied with T4K. It's definitely a step up from T3K (in my book), and T3K also had a lot of recycled T2K tunes behind a few new tracks, so that wouldn't really be a change (provided that the "new" TxK tracks were fronted instead of the old T2K tracks). So I guess if you set aside the PC specific issues, as a Tempest game T4K is fine and good.

It's mostly that TxK seems... far superior as a retail product. Expectations, I suppose.
I am sorry Atari/Simon "but I have to say this" .. IF we would have ditched that story of "Localization" that I continue to think "it's pointless" ALL THAT DAMNED TIME spent sorting out strings and translations and "manette gauche" "knop" "taste" "boton" "atras" make this fit in that , no the menu goes out a char and such, the accent, the line .. there could have more time to deal with this kind of stuff.

"Whatever next game is going to be" will have only ONE menu "Press ANY button to play". STOP, NOTHING ELSE :lol:

To my knowledge/opinion, "little ui/glitches apart of the PC version", T4K is a superior product than TxK because I know there's much more to it, also TxK had "100% of its time to it" while T4K had "33% of time split in 3 versions" ( PC, XBox, PS4 ) and also having to deal with "be sure it's the same in all of them".

Which seems trivial, it is NOT, no matter how, takes time to cross check this and that.

Also it's been "a completely different working experience", TxK was done "all by LS with LS methods" and was created ONLY for Vita with the "maybe one day somewhere else but not now", T4K is been done "with other goals in mind" having to deal with more people/requirements/way of working/versions/etc.

I mentioned somewhere I really can't count the various THOUSANDS of emails I send there and there discussing this and that , sorting out this and that, etc.

It makes a HECK of a difference doing a project for ONE machine alone with NO immediate plans for "ports" or immediately start with "N versions", plus working with other companies/people/etc.

It's a bit like the difference having to cook a meal for your close friends at home and doing something "equally fantastic and nice" for 200 people with a strict time and budged limit and with 200 people out there shouting out "is it ready yet ?" all time.

Honestly "in the space and time and all" that we had "that's the best at least for the moment that could have been done" and I'll repeat "seriously or I was going to end up in a hospital" or out somewhere running around screaming never to be seen again ..

However yeah, I am already working a bit on some stuff to be honest "better now the game is out" than while "on a deadline to make it go out getting progressively insane" :mrgreen:

Oh "other places" can have N coders ( or at least 1 ) whose 24/24 7/7 job is ONLY sorting out those things like "video modes" or "remap controls" and do absolutely nothing else, and trust me it's also "that type of job that nobody is happy to do" :mrgreen:

I had to do all this sort of stuff and more all my own .. ah yes don't forget WIN7, that was another "4th version" to check and make it sure it works.

Anyway I am looking into those kind of things .. TIME MAN TIME, everything takes time :!:

And understanding .. you think it's easy to understand wtf Window does with all that "crap" of video modes .. listing .. device .. enumerations .. shit .. virtualization .. DPI awarness ..

"WTF you talkin' about Willis ?" :lol: :lol:
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: My T4K review

Post by gilesgoat »

tenshi_alpha wrote:What is leaning for? Now I've got it, I'm like... ok, how is this useful?
LEANING :?: :?: :!: :!:

.. is there some bit of code I never seen :?: :!:

Reminds me of a bug once someone found by pressing can't remember what button in a certain place .. and it's like "I've been playing this game for N months I never pressed that button because I know that buttons SHOULD do NOTHING" ..

( it was a debug thing left in completely forgotten )

Anyway in this case we did have quite some testing so "there's no such button" ...

.. leaning .. ? .. ? ..
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Junosix
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1959
Joined: Sun Jul 14, 2002 4:12 pm 0
Location: Plymouth

Re: My T4K review

Post by Junosix »

The leaning thing like in TxK when you hold the left shoulder button and you can kind of creep into a neighbouring lane on the web and get some sneaky shots in.

You can switch between the T2K CD, T2K MOD and some of the TxK tracks by pressing the triangle button (on the PS4 anyway), but I found that out by chance, didn't actually see any mention of it in the instructions...
wicked skills
User avatar
Misfit
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10454
Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
Location: Nottingham UK
Contact:

Re: My T4K review

Post by Misfit »

I really hate to say it, but I'm kinda with Dan and I rank the Llamasoft Tempest games as my favourites of all time (despite being useless at them compared to others on here).

I just can't get into it like I can TxK and I can't quite put my finger on why. I'm wondering if after the immersion I got from having TxK right there in your face and being inside Polybius that this just being on a large TV is enough anymore!

A couple of annoyances:

-As mentioned by Dan, the first powerup being useless hurts quite a lot. I'm certainly doing significantly poorer staying with the standard firepower for longer.

-Also mentioned, noticing the powerups is much harder than in previous iterations and I don't like the fact that we have things coming out the background that look like they could be shots, but turn out not to be (I'm thinking pink torpedo like things didn't help me once I got to around level 9).

-The shooting sound effects are annoying too and way too loud on the Xbox by default. Yes, I know you can turn them down and have, but this also quietens other potentially useful sounds.

-And why is the pause on the left shoulder button? Never seen that before!

Saying that it I quickly lost 2 hours to it last night and will be back for more as soon as I can. I just won't be selling my Vita anytime soon.
User avatar
Deckard
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10748
Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK

Re: My T4K review

Post by Deckard »

I did say somewhere else on this forum all they do is moan, moan, moan about this game ;) shame I don’t have a PS4 or Xbox to join in with these blessings especially as I am the reigning TxK champ. I will wait for the Switch version.....
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !
ThatSpaceShooterGame
Posts: 4
Joined: Mon Jul 16, 2018 2:45 pm 0

Re: My T4K review

Post by ThatSpaceShooterGame »

I have Tempest 4000 for the PS4. I'm loving the game so far, but my biggest issue has been with having to use the tilt sensor on the controller to get through the rings in-between levels and the warp stages. Also, having the directions inverted is confusing. The X-Box version only uses the analog stick for the bonus stages, correct?

Also, I liked the "Ready Player One" reference that shows up sometimes when starting the game. :)
User avatar
Spider-Dan
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 29
Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2003 11:32 am 0

Re: My T4K review

Post by Spider-Dan »

Let me clarify what I mean by "leaning":

When you hold LT and push left or right, your claw is pinned to one lane, but the tip that your shots come out of moves to one side (the direction you push) and stretches a bit into the next lane.

In pre-TxK Tempest games, this would have been nice but not incredibly important; when you die, the level starts over and anything on the rim is cleared. In TxK (and T4K), when you die you resume the level in progress, and there are bunch of enemies on the rim. So you need to either kill them all at once as you are landing (difficult if you still have an incredibly slow base weapon because the first powerup doesn't do anything), or get near them and lean into the next lane so you can kill them without getting snatched.
User avatar
rowan
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7965
Joined: Tue Nov 25, 2003 11:53 pm 0
Location: Notts.

Re: My T4K review

Post by rowan »

I always used "leaning" [or "brake" as I called it] a lot on the Vita

* if you are moving fast, you can halt quickly if danger is ahead
* if things are on the rim coming at you from both sides, you can stay where you are & easily control which hoof emits shots
* when the rim would get very busy, I often hold hard left or right, and just release the brake for a moment before clamping it back on, to slowly advance one way or the other, as I clear the rim of foes

And yes, I was surprised this control is not mentioned anywhere.

But I still want my d-pad control back...
I am not finding it easy to be precise with the higher speed and overly sensitive analogue stick.

Also the higher speed seems to mean that even with maximum bullets, holding fire and zooming along the lanes means that some lanes don't get a bullet in them.
I feel certain in TxK you'd get a bullet in each lane.

Anyways, it's early days in terms of getting acclimatised & I do quite like the "slightly wilder" difficulty. Feels somehow more coin-oppy.
User avatar
korruptor
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4291
Joined: Sun Sep 22, 2002 10:35 am 0
Location: Under The Northern Lights
Contact:

Re: My T4K review

Post by korruptor »

Junosix wrote:The leaning thing like in TxK when you hold the left shoulder button and you can kind of creep into a neighbouring lane on the web and get some sneaky shots in.

You can switch between the T2K CD, T2K MOD and some of the TxK tracks by pressing the triangle button (on the PS4 anyway), but I found that out by chance, didn't actually see any mention of it in the instructions...
Wtf? Lol, I was wondering if the other soundtracks were in there :D
"Don't go into a trance boys..." :: DJ Mixes
User avatar
WiteWulf
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10125
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 11:20 am 0
PSN: WiteWulf
Location: Loughborough(ish)

Re: My T4K review

Post by WiteWulf »

Judging from twitter, even Jeff's not sure how to change soundtrack :lol:
:::G:::

PSN: WiteWulf
Switch: SW-3941-2878-7584
Steam: WITEWULF66
ascully
Posts: 5
Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2018 10:45 pm 0

Re: My T4K review

Post by ascully »

Pressing Triangle or Y seems to change the soundtrack, three choices available.
User avatar
bcass
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1932
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 7:54 pm 0
Location: Island of Dots
Contact:

Re: My T4K review

Post by bcass »

I've noticed that sometimes the first powerup is the droid. Not sure what causes that to happen, maybe random? BTW stuck on lvl30.
Post Reply