Let me explain myself better.bcass wrote:There's more soul in the earlier works. I don't think it's a "necessity is the father of invention" kind of situation either, as he had access to most of the best equipment for Oxygene and Equinoxe.
What I mean by the "analogue vs. digital" distinction is that with analogue instruments - including the electronic variety, as well as the traditional "taught strings against a wooden board" and "taught skin over a wooden cylinder", known as "guitar and drums" - you've got to find your sounds.
Phasing, flange, wah-wah pedal, exploiting the limitations of valves inside amplifiers, fingering techniques (vibrato / pitch bend on strings), filters, etc. - and note that all the ones I mentioned there are typical of electric guitar, just to point out that I'm not just talking about synths here - is this whole process, guided by ear (and by soul), towards that perfect sound.
It's an acoustic adventure. "This is a journey into sound".
And this is the "necessity is the mother of invention" that I speak of. It's got absolutely bugger all to do with how expensive your equipment was, or what equipment you had access to. It's to do with everyone, in the analogue world, being stuck in the same boat that you were limited by the fact that you had to literally construct the sounds.
There's only a few "presets" on an electric guitar. Twiddling the tone knob or switching that lever that changes which of the pickups gets emphasis. Everything else comes from effect pedals and amps and just the sheer brilliance of the fingering technique (how you play) and musicianship (what you play).
For a masterclass on the last two, I defer to Dave Gilmour's solo for "Comfortably Numb":
And how, in this live and more improvised version, you can see him playing the same refrains multiple times in a row and note how it's absolutely identical each time. What makes this solo work so well, on a technical level, is that he's not just bending the strings. He's bending to very exact places in very exact timings - and is "riding" the music, teasing it out, feeling out exactly how far to bend on a vibrato and fast to do it and so forth. These are not just notes on a stave. The Devil is in the details of how he's bending the strings and travelling his fingers around that fretboard. Oh, in composing this, it's all so neurotic and pedantic to the millimetre precision (but I feel, in the process, he lets himself be entirely guided by feeling, at it contains too much soul to come from anywhere else).
But, again, it's chasing that exact sound. That analogue journey of finding those sounds - which you feel are out there somewhere - and constructing them and teasing them out and taking one sound and morphing it into something else with a pedal or an amp or whatever.
And, yes, in case you've not worked it out yet, there's a reason that I'm actually giving my example via the medium of electric guitar rather than synthesizer - as the point I'm making is that the analogue world of music and the digital world of music just work in a fundamentally different way, and the different way of working, I feel, fundamentally changes the end result.
Because, to move onto digital, what you've got is a buffer of bytes. A series of numbers that define where the speaker cone ought to be.
The sample. An actual recorded waveform - a long pre-recorded sequence of numbers to drop into that buffer of bytes - that you just playback at a faster or slower rate to obtain that same sound at different pitches.
You have to understand that, underneath this criticism, I'm a digital musician myself. And it was the Fairlight - that inflexion point of an instrument - that underlies so much of the music that I grew up on. Yes, Jarre from "Zoolook" onward. But also the Art of Noise, who were basically nothing but a Fairlight. Which Trevor Horn took over to stuff like Frankie Goes To Hollywood - to transform a plain old rock band into a series of number ones and, along the way, effectively invented "dance music".
So the story goes, Trevor Horn had to save ZTT - his record label - and, thus, it was not acceptable for "Relax" to fail. Could not happen. It had to be a hit. So he locked himself in the studio and just kept reworking it over and over again. Again and again. And, yes, though Frankie is a real band and it was genuinely their composition, Trevor Horn so reworked it and gutted it out and redid it, that one could argue that the only thing that remains of the original band is Holly Johnson's vocals.
This produced two things that fed into the coming "dance music" scene. The first was the remix. In reworking it so many times to get the single "just right", he produced a bunch of alternative mixes that, though they weren't the "perfect mix" he was after, they were quite good. So a few of these "remixes" were bundled on the 12" and released. A glimpse into some of the many different ways he went about mixing the same track in his quest to get it exactly right.
And the other thing that fed into "dance music" was that the final "perfect mix" that he settled on sets out the basis of all dance music to come. Bass drum on the beat and hi-hat on the off-beat. The monotonous "On, off, on, off, on, off, on, off" beat. The rhythmical formula of all dance music to follow, which a friend of mine nicely summed up how it works so well - basically, whilst dancing, you can stick your arm or your leg out at any point, and you'll hit a beat or an off-beat. You can dance any way you like, and it'll fit the music. Because the rhythm is totally relentless - which also works to hype folks up on the adrenaline.
You know, the "boots and cats" thing:
(Okay, okay, you could argue that New Order's "Blue Monday" got there first with the "boots and cats". Because, yes, it really did get there first. But "Relax" is what made it stick around and catapulted it all to producing a brand new genre of music, complete with the Relax-like remixing culture. Or, if you like, with these two classics banging the same (bass) drum, this ensured the "boots and cats" was here to stay - and it still hasn't stopped from that point forth.)
These two are amongst my all-time favourite songs. So understand that my criticisms here are not remotely any wanky "it was much better in the old days" old man pining for guitar bands again.
But I'm just trying to more precisely chart - and understand - where things started to go slightly wrong with the digital era.
Let us call it "Delia's Lament".
Theoretically, that digital buffer of bytes can potentially - to the resolution of the digital quanta - represent absolutely any and every possible sound. All of them. The entire audio spectrum is unlocked. The speaker cone can be placed anywhere to produce any conceivable pattern of pressure waves.
So I do find it so ironically interesting that, in practice, it's generally had the reverse effect on music.
And I believe the root cause is the digital way of working. Everyone uses the same DAWS - Logic, Cubase, etc. - and then uses the same or similar VST plugins, and lays down the "boots and cats". The analogue "sound construction" has given way to the use of "presets" and post-production "sound deconstruction" - as you say, the producing things to within an inch of their life.
And the simple question to ask at this point is where does the soul come from in this process? Where is its entry point?
Modern music does have soul. Sometimes. But it's all generally coming from the un-neutered instrument in all this - the vocals of the singer - which sits atop what's usually a very sterile musical line (and "boots and cats" has proved so successful, no-one dares stray from it too far anymore).
Personally, I give zero shits as to how a musician produces the sound. And I have zero prejudice towards digital, as it's entirely 100% what I do myself and so much of my favourite music has a Fairlight - or modern equivalent - at its core.
But the way people go about producing those sounds - their method - does have a distinct effect on the end result. Logically enough.
The "necessity" of analogue was actually that you had to construct the sounds yourself. There wasn't a "preset" for you to select from a vast catalogue of sounds. You built it up and experimented to find your sounds. This "sound construction" process was implicit and you had to do it, because that's how analogue instruments work. They produce one basic sound and then you have to twist it and shape it and mangle it into whatever you needed.
Digital is selecting someone else's "preset" from a menu. And instead of pre-production "sound construction", you've got post-production "sound deconstruction". In analogue, you're building up to the sound. In digital, you're tearing down that sound - which is already there in the "preset" - to produce it within an inch of its life, after-the-fact.
Does that remotely clarify what I was getting at? Or have I just confused this all further?




