Ollie wrote:I'm wondering if they might be seeing some advantage in pretending things are worse than they are, so that at some opportune time in the future they can pretend they've achieved some massive turn-around?
If that is the plan, then that's a really dumb plan.
To be honest, the Occam's Razor here is incompetence. As the saying goes, "never attribute to malice that which can be more than adequately explained by sheer incompetence".
They thought it was "just the flu". Trump explicitly said so.
But we can note the UK government's initial "herd immunity" proposal, how they did talk of "pushing it back to the Summer when it'll retreat, and there may be a resurgence next Winter" (which describes how the flu behaves, as it's heat sensitive, but there's no particular reason to think this of this coronavirus - reason to think otherwise, as it has infected every climate on Earth, with no apparent "retreat". Perhaps heat and humidity helps a little, but as I've been saying "this is NOT the flu, this is SARS 2"), Boris proudly boasting of shaking hands with coronavirus patients (!), being hesitant to close schools and ban mass gatherings initially, the fact that they initially always spoke of "mild flu-like symptoms" but the "flu-like" bit has been dropped more recently, etc.
As I like to say, ignore words. People can lie with words. Rather, look at actions. Actions don't lie.
They thought that this was just a new type of flu. That, basically, we were going to have a bit of an "extended flu season" this year. That's all. No big deal.
(Trump, lacking enough intelligence to have any guile, pretty much literally said exactly that early on.)
Underestimating what this was, they squandered two months - because the WHO issued a worldwide public health alert on January 9th, followed by a declaration of a public health emergency on the 20th - which should have been used to ramp up production / purchases of ventilators, PPE, testing kits, etc. in preparation for what was coming soon.
I mean, that's what Germany and South Korea did on the testing, for sure, so they were able to jump on their outbreaks early - and squash them right down - and their numbers speak for themselves. So, I mean, there's some accusations flying around that China spread "misinformation" - to dump blame on China for this initial "misinterpretation" of the situation - but, hey, Germany and South Korea worked it out, and actually reacted to those WHO warnings by massively ramping up their testing regimes, and they're the countries who've best quashed their outbreaks. So the signs were definitely there - I saw them and have been saying "this is NOT the flu" throughout, and the WHO's declarations of a worldwide emergency is on public record - and could have been reacted to.
But many Western countries read it wrongly. Badly wrong.
"It's just the flu. Bit of a longer flu season this year. No sense "damaging the economy" by shutting things down or halting international flights. It'll retreat in Summer. No big deal. How do we usually deal with the flu? Well, it's endemic and seasonal, so we really can't do much but carry on regardless. Once enough people get this new type of flu, we'll have some 'herd immunity' going on. Not a problem."
This was how they were talking, behaving and acting initially. Until - in the UK government's case - when a group of scientists (lead by Oxford University, to give it clout that it'd be listened to) gave them a realistic picture from their data modelling. 200,000 deaths. And that was the "oh shit" moment, where they rapidly U-turned to bring in the lockdown, and set up "Nightingale" hospitals and so on and so forth. To start promising to ramp up testing to 10,000 then 25,000 and now 100,000 a day.
The problem is, we should have been ramping these things up in the two months beforehand. If we had, then we could have been at 100,000 tests a day, straight out of the gate (we know this was possible, as Germany pretty much did exactly that). We'd not be rapidly building hospitals now, but would already have them in place.
Look at their actions, not their words. They're clearly chasing behind the curve here. They're trying to ramp things up - and make arrangements with manufacturers to produce ventilators and arrangements with countries to purchase stuff - while the virus is out there in the wild.
But, hey, the WHO issued those warnings on the 9th and 20th of January. They famously said, explicitly, "testing, testing, testing" to ram that message home. Germany and South Korea heeded those warnings and got their testing regimes prepared, so proof positive that, when a country did start ramping up in preparation, it very much has squashed their outbreaks right down.
There was the time and the prior warning to have done that. Other countries managed to do it.
But they horribly misread this. They thought "it's just the flu". Therefore, the initial plans were just plain wrong and months of preparation time was squandered doing sod all. And now that they realise what they've actually got on their hands, they're scrambling to do all those things - increase testing, increase NHS capacity, etc. - that should have been done in preparation for this, with a couple of months to get it all up to speed, but are doing them whilst the infection is out there in the wild, chasing after the curve, instead of being ahead of it. And that's beyond dispute, really, as we can see them doing that right now in real-time.
And being politicians, they won't admit "we initially read this totally wrong" but, as I say, ignore words and rather look at actions. They won't confess it, but that's clearly what really happened.
It's not malice nor clever strategy. They just fucked up big time in reading the situation before it was already upon us, and are now scrambling like headless chickens to try to mitigate that.
"Never attribute to malice, that which can be more than adequately explained by sheer incompetence".
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes