Coronavirus Pandemic
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Fuck's sake, the whole scientific community has got the thing's full genetic code. No-one, of any relevant qualification, thinks this is man-made.
Also, if you're going to engineer some deadly virus then why the shit would you release it on your own doorstep first? How does that work?
"Ha! We shall teach these Americans. We shall create a deadly virus and then infect our own people with it... then hope that it'll get out, despite our strict lockdowns and quarantines, to eventually perhaps make it over to America, where our cunning plan depends on Trump being an idiot to not order testing and PPE and lockdowns fast enough... then we shall succeed! In, umm, killing all those people who buy tons of shit off us and make us rich?!? Wait, why were we doing this again?"
Also, if you're going to engineer some deadly virus then why the shit would you release it on your own doorstep first? How does that work?
"Ha! We shall teach these Americans. We shall create a deadly virus and then infect our own people with it... then hope that it'll get out, despite our strict lockdowns and quarantines, to eventually perhaps make it over to America, where our cunning plan depends on Trump being an idiot to not order testing and PPE and lockdowns fast enough... then we shall succeed! In, umm, killing all those people who buy tons of shit off us and make us rich?!? Wait, why were we doing this again?"
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Accidental release?KlaxonCow wrote:Fuck's sake, the whole scientific community has got the thing's full genetic code. No-one, of any relevant qualification, thinks this is man-made.
Also, if you're going to engineer some deadly virus then why the shit would you release it on your own doorstep first? How does that work?
No qualified person may believe with any certainty that it is man-made but quite a few, it would seem, have yet to rule out the (remote) possibility.
To ruin his re-election prospects and put Biden in the White House, apparently.KlaxonCow wrote:"Ha! We shall teach these Americans. We shall create a deadly virus and then infect our own people with it... then hope that it'll get out, despite our strict lockdowns and quarantines, to eventually perhaps make it over to America, where our cunning plan depends on Trump being an idiot to not order testing and PPE and lockdowns fast enough... then we shall succeed! In, umm, killing all those people who buy tons of shit off us and make us rich?!? Wait, why were we doing this again?"
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- merman
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10943
- Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: merman1974
- Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
- Location: Skegness, England
- Contact:
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Nothing subtle about it.gravy wrote:It will flare up and the government knows it. There's been a v subtle change of their position on a second surge from "we need to ensure that it doesn't happen" to "we need to ensure that it doesn't overwhelm the NHS.Cloudane wrote:Not an epidemiologist so.. I don't understand how it's possible to get us out of lockdown without it flaring up again. I'd have thought as soon as you have people back in contact with each other, it'll spread just like it did before? That is unless we have indeed achieved this miraculous "herd immunity" thing and most of us have had it without knowing.
Newspapers were publishing "Boris's dilemma about easing the lockdown" stories last weekend before he took up the reins again. It was all about forcing him to ease it because of the economy.
As soon as he's back in Downing Street? Oh look, he announces a strategy to ease the lockdown will be published. Of course it's totally inadequate and unsafe and the TUC have called him on it.
But the papers and big business have achieved what they wanted. They get big subsidies and get to re-open quicker. Screw the vulnerable, elderly and key workers.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
I think this 'blame China' is just Trump campaigning for re-election. I don't even pay attention to it anymore.
The gradual de-confining started today. The President gave the example by going to shop in a bookstore. And one of the ministers was up North using a bus and wearing a mask. There was very few people going to the stores though. Beaches yesterday it was another story. Temperature reached 30ºC and all over the country police spend the day chasing people out of the beaches.
I had my Dr's appointment by phone today. I have the OK to go regularly to the boardwalk for as long as i practice social distancing and wear mask in the bus and if there is a crowd there.
The gradual de-confining started today. The President gave the example by going to shop in a bookstore. And one of the ministers was up North using a bus and wearing a mask. There was very few people going to the stores though. Beaches yesterday it was another story. Temperature reached 30ºC and all over the country police spend the day chasing people out of the beaches.
I had my Dr's appointment by phone today. I have the OK to go regularly to the boardwalk for as long as i practice social distancing and wear mask in the bus and if there is a crowd there.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
As opposed to "screw the five million unemployed and the education of our kids"?merman wrote:Screw the vulnerable, elderly and key workers.
This is not an easy or obvious decision either way, whatever your political position, especially when currently the science says that a genuine 'solution' to the problem is at best 18 months away and there is a distinctly non-zero, maybe even likely possibility that there is no solution to the problem even in the long term.
The world is obviously not going to stay locked down forever, and not for 18 months either.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
I do appreciate your point of view - that there is no "right answer" here, as harm will be caused either way.Dio wrote:As opposed to "screw the five million unemployed and the education of our kids"?merman wrote:Screw the vulnerable, elderly and key workers.
But from a utilitarian perspective, the population of "the vulnerable, elderly and key workers" is larger than the five million unemployed. So if we're going by "the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few", then it's a no brainer.
And even from a Kantian perspective, the quality of "screw the vulnerable, elderly and key workers" is that of death. Their abandonment is to oblivion. The quality of harm done to the dead can be characterised as being infinite - there is no redress of grievance for death.
Whereas, one can weather unemployment and poor education. The poor have to do so perpetually under our already far-from-perfect system.
This is, of course, not without harm, but it's a temporary harm that can be later redressed - as the economy returns, then job opportunities will return (well, to the degree that automation - that this pandemic will only increase - allows, as that's the true long-term enemy of the unemployed, as I've mentioned). And, with concerted effort, education can be recouped - years redone, additional training given and a recognition that the years affected by this can be given some grace in expectations.
You're correct. There is no "right answer" here, as harm is caused either way.
But then the next step is to consider the degree and nature of the harm caused. To mitigate, to limit damage, to choose the lesser of two evils.
And both Utilitarianism and Kantian morality equally favour the vulnerable. There's more of them. Their harm is greatest. Their harm is permanent. And, regarding key workers, to let them come to harm is shooting oneself in the foot - those five million unemployed and all those kids will require doctors and nurses for medical treatment, they will get old eventually and become the new vulnerable and elderly. Allowing the first group to come to harm indirectly harms the second group too.
(Plus, those five million unemployed and those kids are not non-zero from dying of covid themselves, unfortunately. It's not mutually exclusive and getting on top of the health issue benefits ALL groups simultaneously. You wouldn't exactly be helping those five million unemployed or those kids if you sent them back to unsafe workplaces and schools, where they developed covid and some of them died or suffered permanent crippling injuries - because covid can also do that too, knocking holes in people's lungs, even when it doesn't kill.)
Yes, there is no right answer. But what, by all the moral calculus available, is the closest we can get to a right answer?
To temporarily screw the five million unemployed and the education of our kids, for the sake of the vulnerable, elderly and key workers - then do our utmost to redress those costs, when we have an economy back again. We can and are mitigating for their harm - furlough schemes, ensuring kids get their qualifications even without exams, etc. - but you simply can't ever do that for death. There is no mitigation nor compensation for that one.
There is no right answer. But that doesn't mean we're excused from making a decision.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
It's hard to make a case that there's going to be much more harm to kids education if they're brought back after that summer holidays rather than before.Dio wrote:As opposed to "screw the five million unemployed and the education of our kids"?merman wrote:Screw the vulnerable, elderly and key workers.
This is not an easy or obvious decision either way, whatever your political position, especially when currently the science says that a genuine 'solution' to the problem is at best 18 months away and there is a distinctly non-zero, maybe even likely possibility that there is no solution to the problem even in the long term.
You can make an argument that there'll be a greater health risk if they allow childcare that usually covers the summer holiday to open. Which I think is likely.
You're right but the timing will be because of political pressures irrespective of whether it was the right thing to do.Dio wrote:The world is obviously not going to stay locked down forever, and not for 18 months either.
Saying people may die unnecessarily to serve political expediency isn't tinfoil hat territory. It's worth banging on about because public pressure will feed into that decision making process as much as scientific advice does.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Utilitarianism could (and I'm pretty sure did) make a strong argument for herd immunity because it's a system of through incredibly sensitive to presuppositions of what constitutes utility across a populationKlaxonCow wrote:I do appreciate your point of view - that there is no "right answer" here, as harm will be caused either way.Dio wrote:As opposed to "screw the five million unemployed and the education of our kids"?merman wrote:Screw the vulnerable, elderly and key workers.
But from a utilitarian perspective, the population of "the vulnerable, elderly and key workers" is larger than the five million unemployed. So if we're going by "the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few", then it's a no brainer.
And even from a Kantian perspective, the quality of "screw the vulnerable, elderly and key workers" is that of death. Their abandonment is to oblivion. The quality of harm done to the dead can be characterised as being infinite - there is no redress of grievance for death.
I don't know much about Kant except it's supposed to be hard to scale his ethical approach to a society without a lot of fiddling about. Something like Rawls Theory of Justice, which I learned a little about here
http://philosophizethis.org/theory-of-justice/
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
The political, as in sociological, aspects should probably not be disregarded in favour of the purely scientific ones. As the lockdown period stretches on, people are increasingly beginning to disregard the restrictions. As with systems of political philosophy put into in practice, the actual behaviour of real people is a problem.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Well, yes, I guess - across the whole population, not merely measuring "five million unemployed versus all the vulnerable, old folk and key workers" - would lean towards herd immunity.gravy wrote:Utilitarianism could (and I'm pretty sure did) make a strong argument for herd immunity because it's a system of through incredibly sensitive to presuppositions of what constitutes utility across a population.
But let's remember that a vaccine is also "herd immunity" too. So what we're actually comparing is "wild herd immunity" - the "do nothing" plan - versus not letting a novel virus - emphasis on "novel" - become endemic and, thus, we'll never be rid of it ever again.
And the latter is certainly a possibility because that was the fate of the original SARS. It was beaten back until it no longer existed in humans (unfortunately, it carried on existing in bats and other animals - and it seems to have become the "SARS 2" we now face). This version is more difficult, as it has that horrible "viral latency" to it.
But here's the logic. We attempt to crush this down. If we fail in doing so, then wild herd immunity will inevitably result anyway. It's the unavoidable default position here.
As a WHO representative put it: "let herd immunity take care of itself". We should aim to control the outbreak and, to the degree that we can't, wild herd immunity will naturally happen anyway. You can't prevent that, nor do you ever need to aim for it either. It's like natural selection or gravity - you don't have to do anything to make it happen, it will happen anyway.
(The mention of gravity reminded me of a brilliant analogy someone posted online. Lifting the lockdown is like jumping out of a plane with a parachute and then, as you fall, thinking "okay, the parachute has slowed me down enough now, so I don't need it anymore" and losing the parachute.)
And the other point is that if we can push it right down and the Oxford vaccine efforts do emerge in September, then we can have controlled herd immunity through the vaccine. Everyone can be given the antibodies, via the vaccine, without playing dice with death.
Indeed, there's a big issue with immunity here.
If immunity is not long-lasting nor strong, then wild herd immunity might seem prove pragmatically impossible. You've got to have 60+% of the population with antibodies against this thing SIMULTANEOUSLY. Because, yeah, when folks talk about "herd immunity", they often forget that crucial simultaneous requirement. It really doesn't work if, as some gain immunity, then others are losing it. This might make wild herd immunity fundamentally impossible to achieve.
I mean, there are other coronaviruses out there - four of them cause the common cold - so, you know, tell me, where's our wild "herd immunity" for the common cold, then? Where's our wild "herd immunity" for the influenza virus?
The biggest problem for this wild "herd immunity" plan - besides the deaths it demands - is that there's every likelihood that it is, in fact, impossible to achieve.
We might sacrifice all the vulnerable and old and key workers - and there's no mutual exclusion here, so we'll also lose many of those five million unemployed and some of those children who need their education, as this fucking thing gives zero fucks who you are - and then discover that, actually, wild immunity from this thing is too short and too weak, and it's fundamentally impossible to reach 60+% of the population having simultaneous immunity (and even if we do manage those levels - how long does it last? Will this thing come back next year and the year after that?).
So we could sacrifice so many lives to discover that we're absolutely nowhere. That it doesn't work.
And this has to be considered a feasible possibility. As mentioned, there are 7 known coronaviruses. Four cause the common cold - no such thing as "wild herd immunity" for those - and the other three are MERS, SARS and now SARS 2. The four that are endemic - the common cold - have no achievable "herd immunity".
Indeed, alongside "world peace" and "an end to world hunger", the goal of "a cure for the common cold" is usually also found on the same "wouldn't it be lovely?" list of impossible things that'll never happen.
It's very much a definitely feasible possibility here that wild "herd immunity" could prove completely impossible to achieve. We could let people die and then find that absolutely nothing has been improved by our sacrifice. Not a single thing. That we're all just as vulnerable next March as we were this March.
Aiming to control it and crush it down makes logical sense, because if we succeed - which is very much possible, because look at China and South Korea and Australia, who've done it and are now just fighting "imports" from other countries bringing it back - then we might relegate this thing to insignificance.
If we can beat it back for long enough - and Oxford's vaccine comes in September or shortly afterwards - then we'll have the means for a controlled and harmless "herd immunity". One that we can give ourselves every year - with possible modifications, should it mutate - to keep this bastard at bay.
And note that vaccine "herd immunity" can be better than wild "herd immunity" in terms of how long-lasting it is. It depends on the technique, but if utilising the idea of putting SARS 2 genes into some other harmless virus and introducing that, then the immune system could develop stronger immunity to it than the wild article. We can select the "harmless virus" that we inject into to being one that the immune system is not keen on "forgetting". Plus, if it is genuinely harmless, then we can give the immune system a big dose of it.
Also, SARS 2 appears to have "viral latency" to it. It goes quiet - in "stealth mode" - inside cells for up to two weeks. Whilst not active, there's nothing for the immune system to respond to. This is part of what makes this virus the massive bugger that it is. But our "harmless virus + SARS 2 genes" won't do that, so it's out and about for the immune system to see.
And when we have a vaccine, we have some control over this. We can refine it. There are many vaccine efforts. Perhaps Oxford gets there first, but another team tries a different method and finds a much better, longer-lasting vaccine for this. And then we can, for the longer term, switch to the best vaccine available.
Wild herd immunity might well prove impossible. That's entirely true of the common cold, who are "close cousins" to this thing. It's betting the bank entirely on something that, right now, we don't know is even achievable.
But we do know that lockdowns work. We do know that the countries that went ham on contact tracing are the ones that have fared best, and some of them now have zero domestic cases and it's a case of fighting the thing being re-imported (and, logically, if the whole world can reach that stage at the same time, then the virus would, in fact, be extinct, by definition). With more time, we will get drug treatments - that could reduce the lethality of this, which could then make wild herd immunity less of an insane plan, if you have a means to stop people who get it from dying of it - and we'll get a vaccine.
And if absolutely none of that works and we fail, then all that happens is that we "default" to wild herd immunity anyway. You don't have to aim for it, it'll inevitably happen anyway. Aim for something far better and where we fail, our immune systems will do what they can.
Indeed, unlike most people, I've not been critical of Matt Hancock's "moonshot" of 100,000 tests a day. Because that's kind of what I'm getting at here - aim for 100K and if you fail to achieve it then, hey, you're still managing 50K or 75K or whatever instead. Don't let perfection be the enemy of the good. 75K tests a day might not be 100K tests a day, but it's still vastly better than struggling to even reach 20K a day.
I'm fine with "moonshots". Let's aim for the total eradication of this virus. Yeah, probably won't manage it. But it's new and not yet endemic - so that's in our favour - and this was achieved with SARS 1, so why not try it with SARS 2 as well, and the idea is that even if we fail total eradication, we might still get it down to, say, Polio levels (which does still exist, but is barely clinging onto existence - and, most importantly, though it still exists, it's not a serious issue for 99.9% of the human population to give a shit about in their daily lives).
Attack, attack, attack. There's no benefit to surrender. This thing is not alive, it has no mercy upon which to appeal. Wild "herd immunity" is - in a very feasible manner, judging by its "closest cousins" - potentially completely impossible. If the immunity only lasts, say, a year or two, then we're fucked for 2022 onwards.
That's true enough.gravy wrote:I don't know much about Kant except it's supposed to be hard to scale his ethical approach to a society without a lot of fiddling about.
Kant's revision is the idea that some actions are morally unacceptable - intrinsically so - regardless of their utility.
For example, slavery. Because slavery can be of extreme utility - great fortunes were made on the backs of slaves working the cotton fields and sugar plantations. And you could do the utilitarian mathematics that, hey, if 90% of the population massively benefit from the enslavement of 10% of the people then that ticks all the utilitarian boxes, right?
But the Kantian argument against that would be how ol' Uncle Abe put it: "As I would not be a slave, so I shall not be master". That slavery violates "the Golden Rule" - you would not suffer slavery, so it is morally unacceptable for you to engage in enslaving others, regardless of its utility.
Or, with the old moral example of the runaway train that is about to crash into a bunch of railway workers and kill them all, but you're stood on a railway bridge above it all and you could perhaps push that fat bloke standing too close to the edge of the bridge in the way of the train to impede it and save the railway workers, the Kantian argument is that pushing the fat man is cold-blooded murder. And the quality of the act of murder is intrinsically morally unacceptable, whatever the arithmetic of "sacrifice this one bloke, in order to save 10 others".
(And the typical measure of how to judge the moral "quality" of an act is just to reverse it. You're the fat bloke on the bridge. Would you be fine with someone pushing you off to your death, if it saved many others lives? This is an interesting measure because you could then ask "but what if the fat bloke voluntarily jumped off the bridge of his own accord?" - that would actually pass the test. Which is worth noting regarding the vaccine and drug treatments for this thing - it's considered ethically unacceptable to deliberately infect trial patients with the real virus, because if the vaccine / drug treatment doesn't work, you're potentially killing them. But if they volunteer to take those risks, then is that then ethically acceptable to speed up trials?)
Basically, Kant adds that extra bit of morals - that, in practice, we do all actually obey, having principles that we won't violate, no matter how good the reward for doing so - that goes beyond the cold numbers of utility alone. Like I say, being against slavery is Kantian - because, from a purely Utilitarian perspective, why not enslave a handful of people to the greater benefit of the overall population? Kant would say "no", because if you wouldn't suffer it, then you cannot morally enact it on others - because, in the moral calculus, there is no difference between you and them, so you cannot morally resolve it.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Holier than thou
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
This is what "the Elite tought", but in reverse, it's about "what if 10% of the population massively benefits from the other 90%" ? And they found out "hey it works pretty well !".For example, slavery. Because slavery can be of extreme utility - great fortunes were made on the backs of slaves working the cotton fields and sugar plantations. And you could do the utilitarian mathematics that, hey, if 90% of the population massively benefit from the enslavement of 10% of the people then that ticks all the utilitarian boxes, right?
Yes .. "I think most boils down to what you define as 'supreme concepts' " or such, the "mathematical reasoning" of "if <y> Maximizes the outuput of F(X) then that is the best ( or at least the max possible ) " it's .. mathematics .. it may be "technically functional" but you have to put it in comparisions/context with your 'supreme concepts'.
In the case of "Slavery" for example if we decide "it's completely wrong in ANY context/use" then "whatever would involve it has to be totally rejected no matter what the outcome of the function" is just simply "NOT appliable in ANY case".
The idea of "killing some ( or let them die ) to save many" .. because in short boils down to that .. BIG question .. if you just use "pure math" you could say "go on, it works, end of the story" .. put in your "supreme concepts" and they'd probably say "can not be done".
Then again "who can decide if it's wrong or not ?" .. again "the mayority ?" but wait a minute "that is recursive !" we are coming back to "is using math alone right again ?".
In these situations "history seems to prove over and over" that "ultimately the last decision is in the hands of who has the power to enforce it" and by "power" could really mean "the weapons and the means to make it happen" regardless of what the mayority or minority of people would think about it.
In essence "let's hope we don't get to that", "let's hope NOT to be among those that will die", I'd dare to say "whoever will fight to avoid to be in those who will have to die has the total right to do so regardless of whatever 'some else power' decided and cannot be blamed for" .. and ultimately "any choice of that sort that will be done in that way will ALWAYS have some wrong".
If we get to that sort of choices, there will be a guilt that could never be fully forgiven we'll always have to live with.
But you know "all this vaguely" sounds like something already heard .. as long as they will not call "herd immunity" as "the final solution"
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
That's pretty much exactly my point. There is no black and white here, only shades of grey. The government has, so far, roughly reflected the will of the people. Which was to regard it as a problem that wouldn't hit here hard until Italy went to shit, and now to keep our heads down. It's the same conversation I had with tufty before - the government ends up not being able to substantially lead or lag the population here, whatever we might think the 'right' idea is. When the public mood changes, the policy will change with it.gravy wrote:You're right but the timing will be because of political pressures irrespective of whether it was the right thing to do.Dio wrote:The world is obviously not going to stay locked down forever, and not for 18 months either.
Saying people may die unnecessarily to serve political expediency isn't tinfoil hat territory. It's worth banging on about because public pressure will feed into that decision making process as much as scientific advice does.
If you split the population into three groups, hard lockdown, soft lockdown and mostly reopen, currently hard lockdown is still the majority. Following the current trajectory, that will cease to be true probably over the next four weeks and the mood will tend to open. So I expect us to shift to soft lockdown over the course of June.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Polio's been a concerted effort over 50 years, right?KlaxonCow wrote:I'm fine with "moonshots". Let's aim for the total eradication of this virus. Yeah, probably won't manage it. But it's new and not yet endemic - so that's in our favour - and this was achieved with SARS 1, so why not try it with SARS 2 as well, and the idea is that even if we fail total eradication, we might still get it down to, say, Polio levels (which does still exist, but is barely clinging onto existence - and, most importantly, though it still exists, it's not a serious issue for 99.9% of the human population to give a shit about in their daily lives).
Attack, attack, attack. There's no benefit to surrender. This thing is not alive, it has no mercy upon which to appeal. Wild "herd immunity" is - in a very feasible manner, judging by its "closest cousins" - potentially completely impossible. If the immunity only lasts, say, a year or two, then we're fucked for 2022 onwards.
Vaccines do not move on political timescales, and you need a shitload of time to develop the kind of safety data you need to hit the kind of five-nines safety profile that you need on anything you're planning to give to five billion people.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
You don't need five-nines to do better than the "herd immunity" option.Dio wrote:you need a shitload of time to develop the kind of safety data you need to hit the kind of five-nines safety profile that you need on anything you're planning to give to five billion people.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
