Coronavirus Pandemic
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
But nobody is being forced to do anything. However, people can't live without the government handouts so they have to tow the line and do as told?
As I said above. If I go to work tomorrow and the lad who is living with an 'infected' comes in, I'm off.
I've already told them, "I can always get another job, but I can't get another life". Balls in their court.
As I said above. If I go to work tomorrow and the lad who is living with an 'infected' comes in, I'm off.
I've already told them, "I can always get another job, but I can't get another life". Balls in their court.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
At the start of all this one of the local teachers died from it. It may be safe for the kids, but what about the teachers being bombarded with it (we still don't seem to know if "viral load" is a thing, but it seems like it?)
- Dvorak
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4560
- Joined: Wed May 08, 2002 7:37 am 0
- Yahoo Messenger: d3dxquaternion
- Location: Germany
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Yeah, I know that Giles.gilesgoat wrote:[edit] - I AM NOT having it "about you" in particularBut I am "taking advantage" of this post to state a thing.
I think, in Germany the general perception of this damn thing is a bit different to that in the UK by now, since it's fading (wouldn't say fading out but fading nevertheless):

And these 50% capacity reopenings are quite tentative and will be taken back in those local areas where they do not work.
Currently it's not like we're back to normal - far from it. There's much hassle around each restaurant visit (masks, distancing, leaving your contact details etc.), so they're not really overrun. May suffice to flatten the curve further. We'll see.
>take off sunglasses
Seamen and fishermen alike swear to have heard voices in the rising tide. Inhuman screams, some of them say.
Seamen and fishermen alike swear to have heard voices in the rising tide. Inhuman screams, some of them say.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Fading?Dvorak wrote:I think, in Germany the general perception of this damn thing is a bit different to that in the UK by now, since it's fading (wouldn't say fading out but fading nevertheless):
Perhaps.. time will tell.
Here are some Spanish Flu graphs. I've marked first wave in this one :

Some regional graphs ;



Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
This is completely unscientific but lets say we superimpose the graph you posted @dvorak...

Edit : just did that visually, but the time axis seems to align with the original graph covering approx 3 months.

Edit : just did that visually, but the time axis seems to align with the original graph covering approx 3 months.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
- Dvorak
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4560
- Joined: Wed May 08, 2002 7:37 am 0
- Yahoo Messenger: d3dxquaternion
- Location: Germany
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
You may be totally right, (o)(o), yes.
A Second Wave may has formed already (given the incubation latency).
In which case my cannelloni (filled with mozzarella and baked ham btw) were my last dish at a restaurant now for a long time.
I don't know it. Neither does the data.
A Second Wave may has formed already (given the incubation latency).
In which case my cannelloni (filled with mozzarella and baked ham btw) were my last dish at a restaurant now for a long time.
I don't know it. Neither does the data.
>take off sunglasses
Seamen and fishermen alike swear to have heard voices in the rising tide. Inhuman screams, some of them say.
Seamen and fishermen alike swear to have heard voices in the rising tide. Inhuman screams, some of them say.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Meanwhile "in background" it seems "the supershit Brexit stuff" continues .. and NOT in a good way 
Despite being "almost totally eclipsed by Covid" the trend seems to go in the direction of the No Deal .. quite fast ...
It seems "they are still not reaching any sort of agreement" and there isn't much will, just again they are pushing for a new immigration law/scheme and of course end of freedom of movement.
Now they say "that the people they considered like scum before" MAYBE turns out they actually need them .. .. maybe .. ( nurses and other sort of workers ) .
Despite being "almost totally eclipsed by Covid" the trend seems to go in the direction of the No Deal .. quite fast ...
It seems "they are still not reaching any sort of agreement" and there isn't much will, just again they are pushing for a new immigration law/scheme and of course end of freedom of movement.
Now they say "that the people they considered like scum before" MAYBE turns out they actually need them .. .. maybe .. ( nurses and other sort of workers ) .
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
- Kelloggs
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1859
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2005 11:38 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: TheAntiKelloggs
- Location: Widnes or Altrincham. Take your pick.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Couple of thoughts to play with:
Your graph, (o)(o), just as it runs out of orange, coincides with the winter flu season. I'd expect the 1918 figures to have risen at that point. We aren't seeing what we might think of as seasonal variations, so I wouldn't expect ours to rise like that, but the 1918 figures also don't speak of a relaxed lockdown (although there may have been - I just don't know) so I think it could go either way, but would think it would stay low.
Mutations: China looks to have had an "easier" time with the initial strain (but backflow [returning foreign travellers] may put paid to that - their second wave, possibly?) and Europe has had a worse showing. There are two things we really care about with this thing: how transmissible is it, and how serious? Any mutation which reduced transmissibility (and, they're random - could go either way) would be an evolutionary dead end for that variant. In other words we would only really notice mutations that got worse - staying the same isn't something we'd really notice, either. A mutation which made it more dangerous may neatly explain Europe's experiences, and also the US cases if the transmission route was through Europe.
Your graph, (o)(o), just as it runs out of orange, coincides with the winter flu season. I'd expect the 1918 figures to have risen at that point. We aren't seeing what we might think of as seasonal variations, so I wouldn't expect ours to rise like that, but the 1918 figures also don't speak of a relaxed lockdown (although there may have been - I just don't know) so I think it could go either way, but would think it would stay low.
Mutations: China looks to have had an "easier" time with the initial strain (but backflow [returning foreign travellers] may put paid to that - their second wave, possibly?) and Europe has had a worse showing. There are two things we really care about with this thing: how transmissible is it, and how serious? Any mutation which reduced transmissibility (and, they're random - could go either way) would be an evolutionary dead end for that variant. In other words we would only really notice mutations that got worse - staying the same isn't something we'd really notice, either. A mutation which made it more dangerous may neatly explain Europe's experiences, and also the US cases if the transmission route was through Europe.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Yes, as I mentioned, the latest scientific analysis is suggesting that China wasn't faking its numbers, as Trump might imply, but that the virus was initially less transmissible at the beginning, when it emerged in Wuhan. That it has "learnt" to be more transmissible since spreading out of China. And, yes, if China gets "imported" cases coming back in, the that changes as it's getting the more transmissible version returning.Kelloggs wrote:Mutations: China looks to have had an "easier" time with the initial strain (but backflow [returning foreign travellers] may put paid to that - their second wave, possibly?) and Europe has had a worse showing. There are two things we really care about with this thing: how transmissible is it, and how serious? Any mutation which reduced transmissibility (and, they're random - could go either way) would be an evolutionary dead end for that variant. In other words we would only really notice mutations that got worse - staying the same isn't something we'd really notice, either. A mutation which made it more dangerous may neatly explain Europe's experiences, and also the US cases if the transmission route was through Europe.
And, indeed, natural selection. Mutations that make it less transmissible will die off faster than mutations that make it more transmissible. So those will eventually win out and, as they're more problematic, those are, yes, the ones we'll notice.
Again, this is a problem with wild "herd immunity". You're just surrendering and letting that sort of shit happen, and it's totally a dice roll what mutation throws up. And mutation itself undermines "herd immunity", in that if the virus mutates into a completely new strain, then any previous "herd immunity" you've built up is now "out of date" and might not remotely help.
You need 60+% of the population to have immunity simultaneously to the exact same strain and then it's only good for that strain.
Notice just how many "known unknowns" and caveats that statement contains. Is immunity even a thing? Does it last long enough to allow you to practically reach 60+% simultaneously? And the herd immunity thus developed - which, remember, will sacrifice lives to achieve - is only good for the current strain, and if the virus mutates too much, it might become something sufficiently different that we find ourselves no longer immune (if, as mentioned, it is even possible to have immunity to this - something that's not been factually confirmed yet).
Whereas, lockdown and "test, trace, isolate" can be compared to artificial selection - such as dog breeding, pigeon fancying or farmers selecting the best crops - where we are stepping in and forcing the selection we want (namely, that no instance of this virus should survive).
This is why, when the government says that it's following the scientific advice, I absolutely 100% don't remotely believe them in the slightest. It's total bullshit and / or their scientific advisers are idiots. Probably both.
I've compared both approaches and explained how wild "herd immunity" depends on things we don't even yet know is true, and has multiple ways in which it can fail miserably and / or prove completely unachievable - and is one massive dice roll, basically.
Whereas, the other approach has already proved itself to work and, logically, cannot fail - if no-one meets anyone else, then spread is physically impossible. It also keeps the numbers down, so that nasty mutation is less likely (it's random, so there's no way to eliminate the possibility completely, but if kept to a "dull roar" then you're greatly improving the odds). This is the only plan that has an "end game" - if we can push those numbers right down to zero everywhere in the world, then eradication is theoretically possible (likely at the moment? Yeah, not so much. But it is possible through suppression and, you know, the original SARS was pushed to extinction, so it can be done as it was done with its closest cousin before it).
And, for me, the big one is this. If "herd immunity" fails, then there is no "plan B". You've let 60+% of your population get this thing, and it's running wild. If you go down this path, then we will simply never get on top of this thing ever again. We will be allowing it to become endemic - deliberately - and so, if we head down that route, there is no going back. No "plan B". If we attempt this and it doesn't work, then the cat will not go back into the bag, the worms will not go back into the can.
Whereas, if you go for suppression - lockdown, "test, trace, isolate" - then there is a natural "plan B". Which is that natural wild "herd immunity" will eventually happen if you can't get on top of it. The "plan B" for suppression is wild herd immunity. You give it a shot. You try to keep it as suppressed as possible. If you can't, then things will naturally go the way of "wild herd immunity" anyway - that's inevitable and can't be prevented.
So, suppression has a "plan B" and that backup plan is, in fact, wild herd immunity anyway. Going straight to wild herd immunity means you're starting with "plan B" and there is no "plan C".
Suppression has an "end game". Two, in fact. There's the possibility of crushing the numbers down until you push it to total eradication (or, even if you don't get there, then we might at least push it into "small pockets of resistance" around the world that can be kept on top of, and be constantly hammered towards eradication eventually). And then there's the other "end game" which is keeping this down long enough for a vaccine - one might be coming from Oxford in September, if all goes well - and then we can safely inject "herd immunity" into everyone (and this is why I've always been careful to say "wild herd immunity" to distinguish it from a vaccine that also provides herd immunity too, but safely without rolling the dice on who lives and who dies to get it).
Seriously, maybe it's just me, but when I look at these two options side-by-side like this, then suppression - the approach recommended by the WHO throughout - is a "no brainer" on being the superior option.
And "health vs. the economy" is a false dichotomy. We can't get the economy healthy again, while the people are all sick. It won't work. People will, rightly, not jeopardise their lives, if they have any alternative options (I like that quote: "I can get another job, but I can't get another life" - sums it up perfectly). Businesses will not "open up" when they depend on ticket sales, bums on seats, people spending money, tourist showing up, etc. and that's just not happening on the ground, as people all stay away.
Indeed, running a business costs money - the idea is to make enough of an income to cover those costs and then go into profit. If you can't generate enough income, then your business will be haemorrhaging money. It'll be loss making and "re-opening", when the custom / trade simply isn't there, could actually accelerate and guarantee the death of many businesses.
Plus, as I mentioned before, there are "support industries" to consider. If you re-open your cinemas right now - fuck social distancing, we're just forcing them all open tomorrow, regardless - then, simply, what fucking movies are they going to show? Well, not any of the big blockbusters. Hollywood has postponed them all. Indeed, during lockdown, no movies have been filmed, so there's going to be a draught of material. It's going to be thin on the ground. And let's be frank, cinemas were already on the ropes in normal times anyway.
If you force them all to re-open right now, then you're pretty much guaranteeing that they all die. All the costs of running a cinema, but no income. As no-one's showing up because, one, there's still a global plague going around, so no-one wants to be cooped up with tons of strangers indoors right now and, two, there are no new fucking movies to watch anyway. What would these cinemas show?
If you are going to re-open the economy, from a standing start, then you've also got to do it in the right order. Support industries have to come online, to support the businesses to be able to do what they do in the first place.
You can send the brick layers back to the construction sites, but if the brick factories are not already back up and running, then when the brick layers run out of bricks, they won't be able to get any more and will be necessarily forced to stop working again. You can't build brick walls when you have no bricks.
An economy is an interdependent thing. Businesses have their suppliers. Those suppliers also often have their own suppliers.
The brick layers need bricks from the brick factory. But the brick factory itself needs raw materials from the mines / quarries to make the bricks out of.
No business is an island.
And if this goes wrong, and R rises above one, and the number of cases and death starts exponentially growing again, then we'll be forced back into lockdown again. The economy put on hold again - and the bailouts that governments need to pay to keep that going will be paid out once more. This puts economies out of action again.
We do need to make things sustainable, so it can be sustained. But it needs very careful targeted "opening up", a plan that brings part of the economy back up in a safe and "socially distanced" manner - as there are plenty of businesses that can operate that way already, or could operate that way with some modifications - and I can see a sensible staged way of keeping things going, while largely maintaining lockdown and suppression.
What it does not involve is Boris just saying "go to work" and that's it. Or Trump declaring that the economy will be forced fully open by July, like it or not.
That's not careful, that's not staged, that's not planned. That's just a temper tantrum. "Wah!! No fair!! Rich people are not getting richer!! Waah!!".
No, fuck you and your impatience. Not least because, genuinely, I don't do the politics of envy. This really is NOT the approach you want to follow, if you really are wanting to get back into "business as usual" and profits once more. I am thinking of the rich bastards too. This is not the approach you're looking for, even if you erroneously think it is.
Doing this wrong will not just kill people, it'll kill businesses. If you re-open without customers / clients / trade, then it's all costs and not enough income. A recipe for bankruptcy.
Go on, re-open the airports and the airlines. Where exactly would they fly to right now? Running an airline ain't cheap, that's for sure. So how do you intend to pay for everything, if only 5 people actually book tickets on your plane?
I know many businesses preemptively shut down and / or slowed down and / or cut costs in anticipation of lockdown (as I say, our business does jobs for other businesses - we're B2B in the jargon - so we see a lot of what goes on in the overall economy and these people tell us their stories when they visit the office). They get it. If the business is not out there to generate the income, then staying open is just haemorrhaging costs. Wages, rents, materials, advertising, etc. all have to be paid out. If none of that actually brings in enough income, then your cashflow goes negative.
You can't just instantly turn the machine back on. It has a "boot sequence" that needs to be followed.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
While there do seem to have been many mutations, there is apparently no evidence that one type of SARS-CoV-2 is worse than another (the study suggesting there was having been ripped apart by a group at the MRC-University of Glasgow Centre for Virus Research (CVR))Kelloggs wrote:Mutations: China looks to have had an "easier" time with the initial strain (but backflow [returning foreign travellers] may put paid to that - their second wave, possibly?) and Europe has had a worse showing. There are two things we really care about with this thing: how transmissible is it, and how serious? Any mutation which reduced transmissibility (and, they're random - could go either way) would be an evolutionary dead end for that variant. In other words we would only really notice mutations that got worse - staying the same isn't something we'd really notice, either. A mutation which made it more dangerous may neatly explain Europe's experiences, and also the US cases if the transmission route was through Europe.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- Kelloggs
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1859
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2005 11:38 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: TheAntiKelloggs
- Location: Widnes or Altrincham. Take your pick.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Good... and, bad. In a manner of speaking. (Just skimmed through that paper - reading it more thoroughtly wouldn't help me, as I ain't an 'ologist)
Good: If there's only one type to worry about, one antibody will deal with it. Easy. (ish)
Bad: If China had the same type, their figures look odd. There's a lot of people living 'round Wuhan, and even more in the rest of the country, and knowledge of its transmissibility has taken a few months to percolate - at least that we know of.
I find it nice, however, that the paper refers to many sequencings having taken place of the virus. I was reading some comments earlier today on Youtube (a particular video which is diametrically at odds with what I understand to be the case, but I watched it anyway, because that way lies broken echo-chambers) which said along the lines of "it's all made up - after three months, we still don't have any samples or sequences" and I thought, that's very odd, because I've seen bits of what I was told was its genome. People, it appears, are strange.
Further thought - an individual mutation is actually unlikely to affect the function of this thing, statistically. It would need to specifically hit a protein which did something (to us), and there's loads that don't. Single substitutions in its RNA won't change much (and there's redundancy in there anyway) and these are the sort that occur in the wild - larger changes tend to need a lab...
Good: If there's only one type to worry about, one antibody will deal with it. Easy. (ish)
Bad: If China had the same type, their figures look odd. There's a lot of people living 'round Wuhan, and even more in the rest of the country, and knowledge of its transmissibility has taken a few months to percolate - at least that we know of.
I find it nice, however, that the paper refers to many sequencings having taken place of the virus. I was reading some comments earlier today on Youtube (a particular video which is diametrically at odds with what I understand to be the case, but I watched it anyway, because that way lies broken echo-chambers) which said along the lines of "it's all made up - after three months, we still don't have any samples or sequences" and I thought, that's very odd, because I've seen bits of what I was told was its genome. People, it appears, are strange.
Further thought - an individual mutation is actually unlikely to affect the function of this thing, statistically. It would need to specifically hit a protein which did something (to us), and there's loads that don't. Single substitutions in its RNA won't change much (and there's redundancy in there anyway) and these are the sort that occur in the wild - larger changes tend to need a lab...
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Today I got to have my coffee sitted under the trees at a 'esplanada'.
After 2 Months
After 2 Months
The cafés and restaurants re-opened today with rules of distance between tables. I didn't see anyone on the inside portion of the cafés but there was a few people on the outside.
And the beach looked like this:
This Afternoon
They are not opened, they are still closed till the 6th of June but on a warm day like today (28ºC) they don't intervene unless there is crowds on top of each other. In this case there wasn't many people actually because the presential classes for the high-schoolers started today too.
After 2 Months
After 2 MonthsThe cafés and restaurants re-opened today with rules of distance between tables. I didn't see anyone on the inside portion of the cafés but there was a few people on the outside.
And the beach looked like this:
This Afternoon They are not opened, they are still closed till the 6th of June but on a warm day like today (28ºC) they don't intervene unless there is crowds on top of each other. In this case there wasn't many people actually because the presential classes for the high-schoolers started today too.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Indeed. Did you know, for example, that there are not really any large land masses between Europe/Africa and Asia? What we see of "America" all takes place on a set of sound stages in Vatican City (they still control the world and the Empire Never Ended).Kelloggs wrote:I find it nice, however, that the paper refers to many sequencings having taken place of the virus. I was reading some comments earlier today on Youtube (a particular video which is diametrically at odds with what I understand to be the case, but I watched it anyway, because that way lies broken echo-chambers) which said along the lines of "it's all made up - after three months, we still don't have any samples or sequences" and I thought, that's very odd, because I've seen bits of what I was told was its genome. People, it appears, are strange.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Well I live in a country that apparently doesn't exist, so...Harlequin wrote:Indeed. Did you know, for example, that there are not really any large land masses between Europe/Africa and Asia? What we see of "America" all takes place on a set of sound stages in Vatican City (they still control the world and the Empire Never Ended).Kelloggs wrote:People, it appears, are strange.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Of course your country exists. Where do you think they have secretly filmed all those those westerns and wilderness movies? Some old Star Trek scenes were obviously shot near Ayers Rock.Foozwah wrote:Well I live in a country that apparently doesn't exist, so...Harlequin wrote:Indeed. Did you know, for example, that there are not really any large land masses between Europe/Africa and Asia? What we see of "America" all takes place on a set of sound stages in Vatican City (they still control the world and the Empire Never Ended).Kelloggs wrote:People, it appears, are strange.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.

