tufty wrote:Never ascribe to malice ...
Ordinarily, I'd be amongst the first to make that appeal.
But, well, in the face of an overwhelming preponderance of incompetence, there is a point that's crossed where you begin to suspect they're doing it deliberately.
It's not without cause. When they initially came forward, they were talking "herd immunity" and for businesses to prepare for 20% of their workforce to be off at any one time (and that's a precise number, which suggests this was modelled and planned for, and not just an off-the-cuff remark by Boris). Their failure to prepare, or for Boris not to show up to any Cobra meetings, entirely fits with this, as there is nothing to be planned with "herd immunity", as you're wanting to let it happen.
And how do you not impede the spread of the virus too much - as you want it to spread for "herd immunity" - but not look like you're deliberately letting people die?
Simple. Just delay everything.
Wait an extra week or two before declaring lockdown. Only start ramping up PPE and testing, when shit has already started going horribly wrong, so that we're deliberately always behind the curve. Drop a few covid patients in care homes inside the "ring of protection" to breach it and "seed" the virus there, then pretend care homes don't exist for a few weeks, while it all exponentially goes out of control.
The government has said it's been surprised by how much folks have complied with lockdown, and it's perhaps working too well. Quick, tell vulnerable people who're shielding to go out a bit more. Go on, wander into harm's way a bit more often, as this virus ain't going to spread far enough for "herd immunity" unless people are a bit more reckless with their lives.
Look, when we said "stay at home", we didn't expect you to follow it this strictly. Umm, "stay alert". That's sufficiently meaningless to confuse everyone. Remember, stay at home and also go back to work. Yes, that's contradictory and, hopefully, you'll be confused enough to "follow your instincts" and behave more recklessly. Because, for fuck's sake, we're never going to get to 60+% of the population being infected at this rate, people. Chop, chop. Hurry up. Catch the virus, let "the weak" die and then we can move on with the precious economy again.
You get the gist.
We have the problem of Occam's Razor. My single simple explanation - they're being incompetent and slow deliberately to achieve "herd immunity" and are just lying about it - is increasingly fitting the actual data better than asking us to believe that it's a long string of incompetence after incompetence.
"Oh, oops, I was slow there. Oh, oops, we forgot about that. Oh, oops, we were slow over here too. Oh, oops, it's taking forever to ramp this up. Oh, oops, we forgot to ask private companies to help us. Oh, oops, we dropped the ball over there as well. Oh, oops, everything we're doing is slow and delayed. Oh, oops, our PPE deal has fallen through. Oh, oops, we seem perfectly incapable of doing anything right, on time or ever learning from our previous mistakes at any point."
As I say, the preponderance of failure does eventually reach a crossing point where the simplest and most probable explanation ceases to be incompetence, and you have to begin suspecting malice that's just being hidden behind a veil of incompetence for "plausible deniability".
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes