Coronavirus Pandemic
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Dr John with results from the Sweden approach.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Some time ago I listened to a vaccine researcher talk on the radio. She said people and media should talk more about COVID drugs and less about vaccines, because in the short term effective drugs are much more likely than effective vaccines. It takes a long time to make sure a vaccine is both effective and safe enough to give it to the whole population.Barney wrote:That's about the size of it, yes. If we don't get an effective vaccine, we have no other option really.gilesgoat wrote: So what now ?
Hope that someway it will fade out by itself ?
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Was that ever actually a plan? It might be feasible that the real plan was just to do as little as possible. Compared to the hit on the economy (which itself costs lives), the huge rise in poverty, the massive damage to mental health due not least to both isolation and being locked into cabin pressure cooker environments (causing family breakdowns and a terrible rise in domestic violence), the disruptions to education, long-term projects and even the functioning of Parliament and many other problems caused by extended lockdown, it could have been thought prudent to just ensure that hospitals were not overwhelmed then to do just the bare minimum to make it look like the Government was doing its job. After all, a reduction in population by a small fraction of a percent due to the virus could be considered the lesser of available evils, especially if most of those dying were the old, poor, already sick and/or of ethnic minorities.KlaxonCow wrote:As I've covered, the "herd immunity" non-plan is dumb …
I am an inveterate cynic, though.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
I'm afraid Dr John is misinformed about Sweden.snaff wrote:Dr John with results from the Sweden approach.
Gatherings of more than 50 people is banned, not discouraged.
Higher education is done remotely. Children have been in school the whole time.
That was two facts he got wrong in the first two minutes. I stopped watching after that.
This is my update on Sweden:
The number of people who test positive is increasing in Sweden right now because testing has been scaled up a lot in the last few weeks. The number of deaths/day and the number people in intensive care have been slowly decreasing since the peak in the middle of April. At the peak we had over 100 deaths/day. The average is now below 40/day. Today 48 people were reported dead in COVID (but that does not mean they died today). The military field hospitals that were on stand-by have been dismantled. They were never needed. According to John Hopkins University, Denmark has 103 dead/million people so far, Sweden has 480 and UK has 629.
Sweden's strategy looks bad compared to many other countries right now, but that may change depending on what happens when Europe opens up again. Personally, I try hard to not have an opinion. I am not an expert.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
I tend to agree we won't know if Sweden's approach was better or worse till this is over.
In the meantime around here:
This is the 'Beach Traffic Light' as it is known. The sensor counts the people going in and out, and turns the lights on, green for plenty of space, yellow for approaching limit, red for maximum capacity reached, in this case 1000 people. The information also goes to an app so people leaving home can know if the beaches are full or not before deciding where they should go.
Beach Traffic Sign
I still think that the most effective control was the decision of closing the parking lots by the beach.
Lisbon's region number of cases continues to increase and the government continues saying there is no reason for alarm for as long as we follow the rules. And speaking of those, there is a new focus, this time in Lagos, Algarve. A teenager had his birthday about a week ago and his parents decided to rent a space in a club for a small party of about 15-20 people as per Covid rules. Somehow several dozen people, in fact about a 100 showed up, coming fm diifferent municipalities. It included people of different nationalities most residents here but there was some visitors too. Result, so far, 16 people infected, 2 of them are in the hospital due to a more serious condition, one in his late 20s, the other in his 30s. There is also 2 children infected and they are asking that everybody who has been at said party to please go to the hospital to be tested.
In the meantime around here:
This is the 'Beach Traffic Light' as it is known. The sensor counts the people going in and out, and turns the lights on, green for plenty of space, yellow for approaching limit, red for maximum capacity reached, in this case 1000 people. The information also goes to an app so people leaving home can know if the beaches are full or not before deciding where they should go.
Beach Traffic SignI still think that the most effective control was the decision of closing the parking lots by the beach.
Lisbon's region number of cases continues to increase and the government continues saying there is no reason for alarm for as long as we follow the rules. And speaking of those, there is a new focus, this time in Lagos, Algarve. A teenager had his birthday about a week ago and his parents decided to rent a space in a club for a small party of about 15-20 people as per Covid rules. Somehow several dozen people, in fact about a 100 showed up, coming fm diifferent municipalities. It included people of different nationalities most residents here but there was some visitors too. Result, so far, 16 people infected, 2 of them are in the hospital due to a more serious condition, one in his late 20s, the other in his 30s. There is also 2 children infected and they are asking that everybody who has been at said party to please go to the hospital to be tested.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Dr John is normally pretty good with his references etc (much better job than all the guesswork that goes on in internet forums and tabloids) but I guess no one is perfect.
The treatment is good news but the way the media (the beeb at least) is hyping it up like an amazing breakthrough... it's nice to at least have something to be optimistic about but it doesn't seem THAT amazing? It cuts your chance of death by a third if you end up on a ventilator. That's it. If you end up on a ventilator there's still a VERY uncomfortable chance you won't make it plus there's the permanent damage to your lungs, the possible permanent damage to sense of smell and taste that some are reporting etc. I worry that the tone of reporting will make people go "ah cool it's cured"
I'm more interested about the alleged "promising vaccines" that are going through fast track trials. Though if my downer isn't enough to bring optimism down a peg or two I'm sure someone will be along shortly with an essay on why the vaccines aren't as promising as reported
If all else fails we have a more dangerous world and more people dying. Humanity won't die out that easily.
The treatment is good news but the way the media (the beeb at least) is hyping it up like an amazing breakthrough... it's nice to at least have something to be optimistic about but it doesn't seem THAT amazing? It cuts your chance of death by a third if you end up on a ventilator. That's it. If you end up on a ventilator there's still a VERY uncomfortable chance you won't make it plus there's the permanent damage to your lungs, the possible permanent damage to sense of smell and taste that some are reporting etc. I worry that the tone of reporting will make people go "ah cool it's cured"
I'm more interested about the alleged "promising vaccines" that are going through fast track trials. Though if my downer isn't enough to bring optimism down a peg or two I'm sure someone will be along shortly with an essay on why the vaccines aren't as promising as reported
If all else fails we have a more dangerous world and more people dying. Humanity won't die out that easily.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
You'll notice that I consistently refer to it as a "non-plan".Harlequin wrote:Was that ever actually a plan?KlaxonCow wrote:As I've covered, the "herd immunity" non-plan is dumb …
Yes, that's partly just a healthy dose of deserved mockery and derision, but satirically so - as it is a perfectly accurate description too.
Because when you call it "herd immunity" then it sounds like you've got a plan - a strategy to pursue - because it's got itself a fancy name. But it does, indeed, translate into the plain English of "let's do as little as possible, and cross our fingers that our immune systems, collectively, can eventually get a handle on things for us".
Indeed. Sweden's position is forever mischaracterised.Daniel wrote:I'm afraid Dr John is misinformed about Sweden.
Here's Sweden's Deputy Prime Minister addressing the "myth" that Sweden has not taken serious steps:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-eur ... ious-steps
People see that Sweden has not had an official lockdown and are then assuming this means that there's no restrictions nor behavioural changes at all, and everyone's gleefully wandering about coughing on each other and having "coronavirus parties" or something.
But, you know, just because the government hasn't officially declared a lockdown and brought in laws to enforce it, doesn't mean that the Swedes ain't doing anything at all.
You don't have to be officially told by your government that working from home, where possible, is probably a good idea right now. To avoid crowded public transport, if you can. Mass gatherings are, in fact, banned - but even if they weren't, then would you be in any hurry to cram yourself in with thousands of other strangers right now?
(I point again to that week where Boris wouldn't ban mass gatherings or close schools - the very next day, every major sporting league banned themselves anyway. That whole week of government inaction was filled with pretty nearly all events and mass gatherings postponing or cancelling themselves, without any legal prompt to do so. By the time Boris actually banned mass gatherings, there simply weren't any left for him to ban anyway. You don't need the government to officially declare it to be so, if it effectively is so anyhow.)
As should be obvious by now, I don't subscribe to "the Swedish strategy" but I also don't subscribe to erroneously mischaracterising it either.
Put another way, there was another country that had no official lockdown either: South Korea. They chose to alternatively go ham on "test, trace and isolate" aggressively to bring their outbreak under control.
There's more than one way to skin a cat.
Oh, that one's easy.Cloudane wrote:Though if my downer isn't enough to bring optimism down a peg or two I'm sure someone will be along shortly with an essay on why the vaccines aren't as promising as reported
We have a vaccine for influenza. Or, more correctly, we have an annual attempt at predicting what vaccine we'll need for whatever predominant strain of the 'flu is active this Winter.
You'll have noticed, I hope, that I'm fairly careful in differentiating wild herd immunity from controlled herd immunity. A vaccine is also herd immunity, but it's a controlled - and, hopefully, harmlessly derived - herd immunity.
A vaccine is not a cure. It's a prevention - and it ultimately works by obtaining herd immunity harmlessly and deliberately through a jab.
But as it's a form of herd immunity, it is just as vulnerable to all the things I've mentioned about wild herd immunity.
With influenza, we have to keep having annual jabs for it. Because it falls foul of the "wrong mutation" problem (point number one of the four points I made previously). The 'flu mutates far too often, so our collective immunity becomes out-of-date in fairly short order.
Also, a vaccine can fall foul of point two as well. We can have a jab that "trains" our immune systems to produce antibodies for the virus. But if those antibodies are naturally fairly short-lived, then we might have to have annual jabs to build the immunity back up again.
Basically, you get the gist. All of the four points I made earlier also applies to a vaccine, because a vaccine is also herd immunity too - it's just controlled herd immunity, hopefully harmlessly derived, rather than just letting it happen in a totally wild and dangerous fashion.
In this sense, an effective drug treatment might actually prove more useful. If we can find something that stops the virus being fatal or leaving long term damage, then if we could take away the unacceptable consequences of the virus completely, then the virus becomes more like an annoying common cold and we could contemplate suffering it - it would require immediate treatment, if someone gets it, but that treatment can neutralise its worst consequences and stop people dying of it.
Indeed, an effective drug treatment can largely avoid my previous list of points. It would be vulnerable to "wrong mutation", though depending on how it targets the virus, it might still prove effective beyond the immune system's method of targeting the virus (and could potentially be modified, as needed, to meet any mutations). But the "short-lived immunity", "weak immunity" and "Typhoid Mary" points just don't apply. Drug treatments don't rely on immunity - they directly target the virus - so they're not vulnerable to those points.
The thing is, though, that getting effective drug treatments is not that much easier than getting an effective vaccine.
Currently, you'll notice that drug trials are focusing on going through our current arsenal of drugs one-by-one to see if any of them coincidentally work. Because the same principle with vaccines - that you need to ensure it's safe - applies to drugs too. So they're going through the "approved drug list" right now, as if one of them coincidentally does a good job then we don't have to worry about safety trials to ensure that it's safe for use in humans - as all the drugs on the approved list have already undergone all those safety trials already.
But, well, what's the odds that, for example, a malaria drug just so happens to also work on this virus? It's relying on coincidence. We might be lucky and just such a coincidence exists. But, equally, it's entirely possible that nothing on our current "approved drug list" does anything particularly useful for this virus.
And if it's not on the approved drug lists then - just like the vaccine - it'll have to go through all the safety trials to ensure that you haven't got a cure that's worse than the disease.
So an effective drug treatment - that directly targets the virus - could prove actually way more useful than a vaccine. But finding that drug - if one even exists - can be just as difficult a task as creating a vaccine, and is subject to all the same safety checks and trials.
Hopefully, something on "the approved drug list" might actually be useful here, as that skips safety trials and can go immediately into actual use. But, realistically, that relies on coincidence - that something we already have in our bag of tricks just so happens to work effectively on this new virus - so we also have to grudgingly accept that it very likely won't throw up any "miracle cures" here. And a more targeted drug, specifically for this virus, might be possible, but that requires just as much work and all the safety trials that a vaccine needs too.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Called it
Basically it’s not going away and you can’t guarantee to track and trace every possible case in 66m / 8bn people. So what are we supposed to do if an effective treatment isn’t forthcoming (I don’t class a reduction in death chance to 30% on a ventilator as all that effective). Just all stay locked down for the rest of our lives?
Might suit some of the internets biggest shut-ins but at some point when civilisation collapses from perpetual lockdown we won’t have an internet to be talking about it on...
Basically it’s not going away and you can’t guarantee to track and trace every possible case in 66m / 8bn people. So what are we supposed to do if an effective treatment isn’t forthcoming (I don’t class a reduction in death chance to 30% on a ventilator as all that effective). Just all stay locked down for the rest of our lives?
Might suit some of the internets biggest shut-ins but at some point when civilisation collapses from perpetual lockdown we won’t have an internet to be talking about it on...
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
In fairness, you implicitly asked for it, so I felt duty-bound to oblige.Cloudane wrote:Called it
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
KlaxonCow wrote:In fairness, you implicitly asked for it, so I felt duty-bound to oblige.Cloudane wrote:Called it
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4598
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
After a good run of no new cases, NZ gave two travelers compassionate leave from quarantine and testing procedures for a funeral.
They had covid-19.
They had covid-19.
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Sorry about that.Little stoned kiwi wrote:After a good run of no new cases, NZ gave two travelers compassionate leave from quarantine and testing procedures for a funeral.
They had covid-19.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4598
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
It's back again. A hotel employee, coincidentally in the city I live in, has tested positive. Contact tracing is being done other people related to that case isolated, but I don't have confidence in that.
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Apparently Lisbon's region has now one of the highest concentration of Covid cases in Europe just comparable to some areas of Sweden, such as Stockholm. The official explanation however is that we're actively seeking cases by testing lots and lots of people.
The party in Lagos on the 7th of the month seems to be very effective though in spreading the epidemic. The people who got it there have passed it to relatives and friends. There is now 36 cases linked to it spread out in several municipalities, and there is still test results to be received. For just one bithday is not a bad achievement.
In the meantime life goes on and Lisbon has been chosen to host the finals of UEFA's Championship League. Eight teams will be here to play the games in the middle of August. The support staff of the teams, plus the UEFA's people, plus the sports media should be enough to fill up a few hotels, and help other related businesses. I just hope they come in Covid free and/or don't get it here.
The party in Lagos on the 7th of the month seems to be very effective though in spreading the epidemic. The people who got it there have passed it to relatives and friends. There is now 36 cases linked to it spread out in several municipalities, and there is still test results to be received. For just one bithday is not a bad achievement.
In the meantime life goes on and Lisbon has been chosen to host the finals of UEFA's Championship League. Eight teams will be here to play the games in the middle of August. The support staff of the teams, plus the UEFA's people, plus the sports media should be enough to fill up a few hotels, and help other related businesses. I just hope they come in Covid free and/or don't get it here.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Also back with a vengeance in Beijing it seems. Time will tell if these resurgences get squashed or turn into full blown second waves (ugh, hope not)
Same in our area which statistically is the worst (Barrow-in-Furness) but you look at the second which is Lancaster (a 45 minute drive away) and both are run by the Morecambe Bay hospital trust so it seems crediblePFVA wrote:Apparently Lisbon's region has now one of the highest concentration of Covid cases in Europe just comparable to some areas of Sweden, such as Stockholm. The official explanation however is that we're actively seeking cases by testing lots and lots of people.



