Coronavirus Pandemic
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Giles, theres been reports from Australia where they recently had a resurgence of cases in certain areas that theres been a new wave of panic-buying supplies.
I think I've figured out where the UKs gone wrong with COVID-19. We should have just labelled it an illegal immigrant sent here by faceless EU bureaucrats. What a public response we'd have had then! Nigel Farage would have on the news encouraging people to keep inside to stay safe from the threat of the foreign virus horde and The Sun would have been recruiting an army of Page 3 models in Union Jack bikinis to spray disinfectant on the White Cliffs of Dover...
I think I've figured out where the UKs gone wrong with COVID-19. We should have just labelled it an illegal immigrant sent here by faceless EU bureaucrats. What a public response we'd have had then! Nigel Farage would have on the news encouraging people to keep inside to stay safe from the threat of the foreign virus horde and The Sun would have been recruiting an army of Page 3 models in Union Jack bikinis to spray disinfectant on the White Cliffs of Dover...
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
I am afraid I do not share your optimism that our response to that framing would be so different to that of USAmericans.F-ZeroOne wrote:I think I've figured out where the UKs gone wrong with COVID-19. We should have just labelled it an illegal immigrant sent here by faceless EU bureaucrats. What a public response we'd have had then! Nigel Farage would have on the news encouraging people to keep inside to stay safe from the threat of the foreign virus horde and The Sun would have been recruiting an army of Page 3 models in Union Jack bikinis to spray disinfectant on the White Cliffs of Dover...
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- merman
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10943
- Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: merman1974
- Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
- Location: Skegness, England
- Contact:
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Leicester to be locked down due to a surge in cases.
The R value must surely be close to or above 1 by now in the UK, and that's a week before the pubs & restaurants re-open.
All that time locked down has been wasted.
The R value must surely be close to or above 1 by now in the UK, and that's a week before the pubs & restaurants re-open.
All that time locked down has been wasted.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
The latest ONS figures show that the decline since April - due to lockdown - has paused and has plateaued out.merman wrote:The R value must surely be close to or above 1 by now in the UK, and that's a week before the pubs & restaurants re-open.
This is, by definition, "R = 1.0". Where one person, on average, passes it onto one other person - so what you get is the daily numbers broadly staying the same indefinitely, getting neither better nor worse.
And, of course, those ONS figures were for recent past weeks, before further lockdown easing and those masses crowding the beaches or, as you say, pubs and restaurants soon to re-open. If it's already "R = 1.0" - as the numbers have plateaued and that's what "R = 1.0" looks like (it's the easiest R number to spot, in that regard, because if the numbers ain't getting better nor getting worse then you must be at "R = 1.0") - then, with further lifting and the fact that it still remains the case that we don't see what happens today until about 2 weeks later (there's always a "lag" in the numbers because of how the virus doesn't instantly flare up with symptoms for 5 days up to 2 weeks), it seems inevitable that the UK's "R number" is already above 1 right now.
One of the SAGE scientists - Professor John Edmunds - reckons this is the case and "the tide may already be turning" on the R number:
https://www.channel4.com/news/sage-prof ... en-turning
Indeed. That could well be the case.merman wrote:All that time locked down has been wasted.
I think people forget just how fast - when we were at the "wild" R rate of around 2.7, before going into lockdown - it took for us to go from a handful of deaths to a thousand per day. This is exponential growth that equated to a doubling every 2 to 3 days. That's a quadrupling to 8-fold increase in a week. From a 32-fold to 128-fold increase in a fortnight.
And the problem is the lag. If the R rate was at 2.7 now, then we'd only find out a week to two weeks later. It takes that long for the symptoms to come on and the tests and hospitalisations to happen, for it to filter down into the official numbers. But if it had reached that high of an R rate, then it would already have increased 32-fold to 128-fold. By the time we know, from the numbers, the damage is already done.
That is why I keep mentioning those weeks where Boris fucked around and refused to ban mass gatherings or close schools. In that wasted week, he at least quadrupled the number of cases and deaths. It really is as mathematically simple as that. That week of dither and delay is what made us become the worst affected nation in Europe.
When dealing with exponential increase, you MUST attack it at the earliest possible opportunity.
So, really, the lifting of the lockdown is being rushed too quickly. We should ease one measure. Then wait two weeks. Check the numbers. Then, if all remains well, ease another measure. Then wait two weeks. Check the numbers.
This isn't just to ensure that we're not easing too much too quickly, you understand, it's also so that we can tell which eased measure caused the damage. If we re-open this, that and the other all at the same time, then we can't tell which of those things - or, indeed, which combination of those things - actually made things worse. So the only choice is to re-restrict all of them and go back into a full lockdown (or full local lockdown).
But if you do it one thing at a time - and give it room to settle in and affect the numbers, if it's going to affect the numbers at all - then we can tell exactly which eased measure is not working and just row back on that one, not having to row back on all of it with a full lockdown again.
And, you know, that will have a much, much more devastating effect on the economy - if you have to force all the non-essential shops back into lockdown again, and would be obliged to returning to paying their furloughed workers for yet more weeks and months, if the government still stands by the "no one should be punished for doing the right thing" stance - than a patient and careful easing, that just does one thing at a time, in a more staged manner, which then only has to row back on the bad moves, not the whole progress out of lockdown.
As I say, I'm not at all against the need to re-open the economy. I don't "hate capitalism". But such silly false dichotomies hide the fact that there's good ways to do this and bad ways to do this, and I feel that they are following the bad way of doing this. That they are NOT, in fact, any champions of the economy and getting people back to work, if they are not at all mindful that you've got to do it sustainably, or it won't last - and we're forced back into full lockdowns again, as the numbers turn atrocious once more.
The patient careful approach - where we're double-checking, with each measure eased, that this shit is actually holding before we touch anything else - is the method where you keep verifying that nothing we're doing is making the R rate go above 1 again. Because, indeed, once it does that, the numbers will go back up and that is quite literally "undoing" the progress that lockdown brought us.
That better protects the economy because each "easing" is a permanent measure and we don't lose all progress to "re-open" as we go forward. There are undoubtedly measures we can "ease" perfectly safely - when we went into full lockdown, the point was that that was an "emergency brake" measure. Like, fuck subtlety and nuance, shut the whole bloody lot down at once.
It's the "sledgehammer to crack a nut" approach. And it was necessary initially, because this virus was running wild and, as I've mentioned, a week is a long time with exponential growth. So, yes, you don't try to be clever nor nuanced, you just yank up "the emergency brake" and shutdown everything.
But, from a more controlled position, we can roll the car forward at a steady pace - and just keep our foot hovering over the brake, just in case - and if there is a problem, then we don't have to pull on the emergency brake, but can, in a more controlled manner, just lightly tap on the brake to slow things down, if it really was eased a bit too quickly.
We can keep some economic "forward momentum" going and still safely keep on top of this.
But the government's approach seems to be more "fuck it, push the pedal to the metal" and accelerate as fast as possible. And if shit goes wrong, then we're yanking on that emergency brake to reach a dead stop yet again - and we lose all forward momentum.
It's bad driving. And, yes, I absolutely want you to note the resemblance of this to Aesop's "the Tortoise and the Hare" because this is entirely the moral of that story: "more haste, less speed".
Slow and steady will win this race. Bold, exaggerated melodramatic gestures - political premature ejaculation - will lose the race quite horribly, I'm afraid.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Is page 3 still a thing?.. Moreover do people still buy the sun?F-ZeroOne wrote:..The Sun would have been recruiting an army of Page 3 models in Union Jack bikinis to spray disinfectant on the White Cliffs of Dover...
And to each of those questions I ask: why?
the hairy pies
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Here's a teacher discussing the rather confused message that government wishes to deliver to children:
https://www.lbc.co.uk/radio/presenters/ ... -wont-work
Basically, on the way to school, you must socially distance by 2 metres and, on public transport, always wear a mask. But, once you get to school, ignore the 2 metre thing and don't wear a mask - or we'll never be able to get everyone back into the classroom with all those restrictions. Then, on the way home, remember to keep 2 metres apart and wear a mask again.
It's as I was saying, you can't "bend the facts" like this to suit convenience. Either we should be socially distancing - and that has been judged, by scientific experiment, to be a 2 metre distance - or we shouldn't. It isn't really logical to half-comply to a sort of half-social-distancing, just because it's a bit awkward to do it correctly.
I mean, what next? That everyone should, of course, do regular hand-washing... but if that's taking too long then, you know, only bother washing one of your hands to halve the time taken.
Remember to "catch it, kill it, bin it" when you sneeze. But if that's a bit awkward then, hey, as long as you catch every other sneeze - and only sneeze directly in people's faces half the time - then, well, it's a compromise, I guess.
It's just broken thinking. That's not how reality functions.
https://www.lbc.co.uk/radio/presenters/ ... -wont-work
Basically, on the way to school, you must socially distance by 2 metres and, on public transport, always wear a mask. But, once you get to school, ignore the 2 metre thing and don't wear a mask - or we'll never be able to get everyone back into the classroom with all those restrictions. Then, on the way home, remember to keep 2 metres apart and wear a mask again.
It's as I was saying, you can't "bend the facts" like this to suit convenience. Either we should be socially distancing - and that has been judged, by scientific experiment, to be a 2 metre distance - or we shouldn't. It isn't really logical to half-comply to a sort of half-social-distancing, just because it's a bit awkward to do it correctly.
I mean, what next? That everyone should, of course, do regular hand-washing... but if that's taking too long then, you know, only bother washing one of your hands to halve the time taken.
Remember to "catch it, kill it, bin it" when you sneeze. But if that's a bit awkward then, hey, as long as you catch every other sneeze - and only sneeze directly in people's faces half the time - then, well, it's a compromise, I guess.
It's just broken thinking. That's not how reality functions.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Apparently not, apart from the Sunday Spurt and its sister publications.guythp wrote:Is page 3 still a thing?..
Your second question still holds, though. In fact, with page 3 no longer being a thing, its answer is perhaps even more bewildering.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
I can see the logic, it's just not logic we agree with. It's the same logic that the government has been using throughout: to spread wild herd immunity, prioritising the spread around those who can (for the most part) survive the virus first, while trying to shield the vulnerable just enough that they don't overwhelm the NHS. It's quite deliberate when you look at it that way: let the kids spread it around themselves, but have them socially distance (for now) in public so they're not passing it on to random commuters.KlaxonCow wrote: It's as I was saying, you can't "bend the facts" like this to suit convenience. Either we should be socially distancing - and that has been judged, by scientific experiment, to be a 2 metre distance - or we shouldn't. It isn't really logical to half-comply to a sort of half-social-distancing, just because it's a bit awkward to do it correctly.
The teachers are collateral, of course
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Not peer reviewed yet, but the people who thought they had it earlier than its purported inception MIGHT be correct.
I think it's unlikely, for just one sample in just 1 day to be anything other than contamination or some other false positive, and I'm surprised he's giving it so much credit, but he has infinity% more healthcare related qualifications than me. We'll have to wait and see...
I think it's unlikely, for just one sample in just 1 day to be anything other than contamination or some other false positive, and I'm surprised he's giving it so much credit, but he has infinity% more healthcare related qualifications than me. We'll have to wait and see...
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
He mentions that it could have originated from Chinese workers in Barcelona. It could also be from a group of people who had been to China since Barcelona is such an international city. Would be interesting if other cities, special international ones could do similar studies.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Well, I think it is sort of how reality functions in regard to the statistics of risk. Indulging in risky behaviours only half of the time presumably cuts the risk of those behaviours by 50% (compared with all of the time). And it is a game of balancing numbers, particularly those relating to the risks of SARS-CoV-2 spread and those of other physical, mental, sociological and economic dangers which can also kill and otherwise cause permanent damage to hundreds of thousands of individuals.KlaxonCow wrote:It's as I was saying, you can't "bend the facts" like this to suit convenience. Either we should be socially distancing - and that has been judged, by scientific experiment, to be a 2 metre distance - or we shouldn't. It isn't really logical to half-comply to a sort of half-social-distancing, just because it's a bit awkward to do it correctly.
I mean, what next? That everyone should, of course, do regular hand-washing... but if that's taking too long then, you know, only bother washing one of your hands to halve the time taken.
Remember to "catch it, kill it, bin it" when you sneeze. But if that's a bit awkward then, hey, as long as you catch every other sneeze - and only sneeze directly in people's faces half the time - then, well, it's a compromise, I guess.
It's just broken thinking. That's not how reality functions.
Two metres is not a scientifically determined safe distance; it is safer than one metre and more dangerous than three metres. Different countries use different distances and the safety of any distance varies with environment and time. One metre silently passing people in the street a few dozen times may be far safer than three metres between four people talking and singing in an enclosed room for four hours.
There is no binary Safe/Unsafe here.
The Grauniad wrote:The most recent public Sage document on physical distancing, updated on 2 May, makes clear that multiple streams of evidence are used to advise on safe distancing, including how long people are together, ventilation and room size, and that the 2-metre advice is no more than a ballpark guide for face-to-face meetings.
In a statement, the WHO said it recommends keeping a distance of 1 metre or more.
…
“The findings of this systematic review and meta-analysis support physical distancing of 1 metre or more, which is in line with the existing WHO recommendation that people should physically distance at least 1 metre,” the statement said.
There is also the matter of how much information can be disseminated to the general public that can be effectively understood and implemented, especially when the guidance frequently changes. I personally get lost as to what current guidance is supposed to be. I have mentioned schools having to cope with hundreds of changes and you have mentioned the problem of children being told to apply different rules in different circumstances. How are people supposed to continually apply equations combining distance, environment, number of simultaneous interactions and the timing of those interactions to keep transmission risk below a particular percentage when most of us seem to think that two metres equals four inches?The Grauniad also wrote:Paul Hunter, professor in medicine at the University of East Anglia, said … that the continued focus on distancing irrespective of the length of time spent together was not in line with knowledge about how the virus spreads.
“Staying 2 metres apart for two days while sleeping overnight in the same house is probably more risky than cuddling your grandchild for half an hour,” Hunter said. “There’s certainly some of the nuances that don’t seem to make sense to me when examined in isolation.”
Overall, [Ian Boyd, professor of biology at the University of St Andrews and a contributor to Sage] said, drawing up overarching guidance on how to ease the lockdown would be best described as “an art, not a science”. “It will be informed by an adaptive management method – try something which is approximately sensible based on the evidence and if you find it fails then ditch it and try something different,” he said.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- SuperMappy
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2109
- Joined: Fri Jun 10, 2005 5:30 am 0
- Location: Circleville, OH
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Well the Governor of California has reordered the bars and beaches closed, in parts of the state, due to the resurgence of Covid19 cases.
It's only going to get worse over here before it gets better.
It's only going to get worse over here before it gets better.
Bustin' Naughty Folks since 1983
MAME: Forever Young!
"If you buy a game at launch, you are paying the most amount of money for the worst version of the game" - TotalBiscuit
MAME: Forever Young!
"If you buy a game at launch, you are paying the most amount of money for the worst version of the game" - TotalBiscuit
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
That's actually the one part of his video that I thought was just wrong.PFVA wrote:He mentions that it could have originated from Chinese workers in Barcelona.
We consider the virus to have originated in Wuhan, China because that's where it was first identified, after a significant number of deaths - with similar symptoms - alerted the Chinese to investigate whether we were dealing with a new disease and they discovered a novel coronavirus.
But if the virus was in sewage samples in Barcelona back in March 2019, then this completely throws that "origin story" up in the air.
We think it started in Wuhan, China because that's where it was first identified. But now we have identified it in a completely different country long beforehand - so, if true, Wuhan isn't where this virus started anymore. It could have alternatively originated in Spain and then was taken to China... and all Wuhan represents is where the virus mutated to become much more lethal. Or, indeed, anywhere on Earth, as we don't know that Spain is where it started either, but is just the earliest place where it's been identified to have been so far.
If true, then this is no longer, as Trump insists, "a Chinese virus". Its ultimate origins are unknown - if it was extant elsewhere on the planet, long before things took a horrible turn for the worst - and Wuhan merely becomes the location of where it mutated into its current lethal form, to start killing people in sufficient numbers, that it was investigated and discovered to exist.
And, yes, this means that the narrative of the virus's origins at a "wet market" is very likely not true (as much as we might want it to be true, so that we can pressurise the Chinese authorities to shut those places down - and it'd be an awesome idea to do so, as we all would be better off on a planet where the "surface area" for zoonotic diseases to make the jump to humans was massively reduced - but if it ain't true then it just ain't true, and we have to honestly acknowledge that, even if that's not exactly convenient to various political agendas that people have against China or wet markets).
That bit - still maintaining a Chinese origin narrative, despite evidence of the virus existing somewhere else long beforehand - was where he failed to be sufficiently logical, in the face of new evidence. The origin narrative must logically change, if Wuhan is not the first place where the virus has been found.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
By the way, on that point, this is not without precedent.
The so-called "Spanish Flu" pandemic did not originate in Spain. Indeed, it's believed that it most probably originated in America, in fact, and that the virus entered Spain from France.
But Spain had been neutral during the First World War and, therefore, did not have any wartime censorship on its media - so Spanish journalists openly and honestly reported on the virus and its spread in Spain, which therefore unfairly made it look like it came from there.
But it absolutely didn't. The Spanish were just honest and open enough to admit they had a problem, where other countries - who'd been involved in WWI - were keeping it quiet, to not "damage morale" as these countries emerged from a harsh and bitter war (so, yeah, we can definitely criticise the Chinese for initially trying to keep their outbreak quiet, as that was certainly a wrong move, but they're certainly NOT the only country that's ever done that, unfortunately).
If the virus is demonstrably much older than the Wuhan outbreak, then it's not a Chinese virus. It's just a virus that mutated into something potentially lethal amongst the Wuhan population, when it reached there.
And as I'm one of those who had something in early to mid December that was symptomatically the same as covid-19 - albeit that, that time, I didn't get it "long tail" and only had one resurgence before getting over it - then I'd say that it didn't mutate its main symptoms nor its capability to re-activate in Wuhan. What I've suffered since March feels pretty much like just a much stronger and persistent version of what I suffered in December. In both cases, though the symptoms look externally "flu-like", they don't feel like flu internally - and they both felt different in the same way, and both involved a re-activation.
The most troubling thing, though, is that if I really did have it in both December and in March, that's only 3 months.
So that either means:
1. immunity is very short-lived
2. the Wuhan mutation rendered it "different" to the December strain, as far as my immune system was concerned.
3. I only had it mildly in December and a mild infection does not, in fact, build up sufficient immunity (or, frankly, even much resistance - as I've definitely had it worse the second time around).
And none of these things represents good news for keeping a lid on this virus. 1 could make "herd immunity" impossible to reach. 2 would mean that any "herd immunity" could just disappear 3 months later anyway. And 3 would mean that folks who've had it - symptomatically or asymptomatically - are not necessarily protected from re-infection (and perhaps, as scientists were looking into, the milder your infection, the milder your resistance / immunity).
Though I felt I've had it both times, I was not pushing the thing I had in December as definitely being SARS 2, simply because, with exponential growth, those 3 months should have seen it explode to the point where everyone on Earth had had it. This just didn't seem to add up, so I left it - but this new evidence might just, indeed, confirm that it is actually true (and how the virus didn't exponentially explode back then is another mystery to be solved). But perhaps it was the less infectious / less harmful ancestor of what mutated in Wuhan to become very nasty?
The so-called "Spanish Flu" pandemic did not originate in Spain. Indeed, it's believed that it most probably originated in America, in fact, and that the virus entered Spain from France.
But Spain had been neutral during the First World War and, therefore, did not have any wartime censorship on its media - so Spanish journalists openly and honestly reported on the virus and its spread in Spain, which therefore unfairly made it look like it came from there.
But it absolutely didn't. The Spanish were just honest and open enough to admit they had a problem, where other countries - who'd been involved in WWI - were keeping it quiet, to not "damage morale" as these countries emerged from a harsh and bitter war (so, yeah, we can definitely criticise the Chinese for initially trying to keep their outbreak quiet, as that was certainly a wrong move, but they're certainly NOT the only country that's ever done that, unfortunately).
If the virus is demonstrably much older than the Wuhan outbreak, then it's not a Chinese virus. It's just a virus that mutated into something potentially lethal amongst the Wuhan population, when it reached there.
And as I'm one of those who had something in early to mid December that was symptomatically the same as covid-19 - albeit that, that time, I didn't get it "long tail" and only had one resurgence before getting over it - then I'd say that it didn't mutate its main symptoms nor its capability to re-activate in Wuhan. What I've suffered since March feels pretty much like just a much stronger and persistent version of what I suffered in December. In both cases, though the symptoms look externally "flu-like", they don't feel like flu internally - and they both felt different in the same way, and both involved a re-activation.
The most troubling thing, though, is that if I really did have it in both December and in March, that's only 3 months.
So that either means:
1. immunity is very short-lived
2. the Wuhan mutation rendered it "different" to the December strain, as far as my immune system was concerned.
3. I only had it mildly in December and a mild infection does not, in fact, build up sufficient immunity (or, frankly, even much resistance - as I've definitely had it worse the second time around).
And none of these things represents good news for keeping a lid on this virus. 1 could make "herd immunity" impossible to reach. 2 would mean that any "herd immunity" could just disappear 3 months later anyway. And 3 would mean that folks who've had it - symptomatically or asymptomatically - are not necessarily protected from re-infection (and perhaps, as scientists were looking into, the milder your infection, the milder your resistance / immunity).
Though I felt I've had it both times, I was not pushing the thing I had in December as definitely being SARS 2, simply because, with exponential growth, those 3 months should have seen it explode to the point where everyone on Earth had had it. This just didn't seem to add up, so I left it - but this new evidence might just, indeed, confirm that it is actually true (and how the virus didn't exponentially explode back then is another mystery to be solved). But perhaps it was the less infectious / less harmful ancestor of what mutated in Wuhan to become very nasty?
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
There's also the option that one, other, or both were not covid.KlaxonCow wrote:So that either means:
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"

