gilesgoat wrote:But yes I think "it's not just Covid" there are many shit out there that "you get it and you could never be 100% the same as before" or it could take very long time to be really ok.
Yes, certainly. To clarify, I'm not saying SARS2 is the only virus with long-term health consequences. Obviously not - for example, HIV.
What I'm specifically referring to is this "re-activation" trait.
To explain, when I say I get "repeats", these are very distinct episodes. It's not that I'm continuously suffering from symptoms all the way through. In fact, the overwhelming majority of the time, I'm feeling entirely fine and dandy. Back to normal. Not a squeak nor hint of any symptom. Somewhat cruelly, it feels like it's gone away completely and maybe, just maybe, it won't be back - until it is.
It's like catching it over and over again. These are distinct episodes - that I can number, as "the first time", "the second time", "the third time", etc. - where, in-between, I'm feeling a-okay and am perfectly symptom-less.
That is what I'm claiming is an unusual trait for a virus - or any disease, for that matter - because, typically, either you get a long-term chronic condition that persists, or your immune system handles it and you get better. What's unusual and rare with "long tail covid" is that you get ill, you get better, you get ill, you get better, you get ill, you get better... repeatedly.
I'm up this early because, earlier, I had another bout of symptoms for a few hours - the 7th episode so far - and went to sleep early. Thing was, at the start of the day, I was feeling just fine and now that I've slept it off and woken up, I'm feeling back to normal again.
But, for a few hours, my stomach was in knots. Neurologically, I felt a bit like I was in "third person mode" - feeling light, not entirely present, lacking the "weight" of presence, as if I wasn't entirely inside my head but was observing it remotely, a "one step back" feeling - and I got a little alarmed at a fleeting symptom of pins and needles in my right hand when I sat down for dinner. I flexed my fingers and moved my hand around - get the circulation going - and it passed in about 20 to 30 seconds. But, well, shit, you know the list of the more extreme symptoms that have been reported - so, as I say, any hint of circulation issues was a bit panic-inducing for that half minute or so.
I am noticing that, each time, I'm recovering from the symptoms faster. These episodes are shorter, as the first time was nearly a week, then it was days, then it was a morning, now it's a few hours.
I would guess this could be that my immune system is getting better at clearing this stuff out of my system whenever it flares up? Though, again, no-one really knows anything. It kind of feels and behaves that way, but goodness knows what's really going on at the cellular level - because, at the same time, if my immune system has now got a handle on this, then why does it keep popping back up periodically like this?
This is why I've been running with the speculation that maybe this virus "hides away" inside cells - lies dormant and just replicates, for the incubation period, without the immune system picking it up as a threat - and then it "activates", bursts out of a cell and the immune system now picks it up and goes on the attack. But if some of the virus gets past the defences to infect another cell, then it goes back into dormant "stealth mode" there for another week or two, before erupting once more... and so the cycle repeats. But, as I say, I recover faster and the symptoms (though this last one had its alarming moment, as mentioned) are generally weakening each time. Which I interpret as the immune system gradually whittling down the numbers over time.
In that sense, I want to differentiate between "long tail covid" - which has this "re-activation" thing - and those who're suffering long-term chronic conditions from covid (where, basically, the virus has left lasting damage that they continue to suffer after it's gone). What I'm talking about - what I'm suffering - is an inability to shake it off in the first place.
Also, something else I'm wondering - yet another mystery of this virus - is whether these "re-activations" are, you know, repeatedly topping up the antibodies too. That is, if we assume that antibody immunity is good for a year, is that a year from when I first got it or a year from when I last suffered symptoms? I don't think anyone has a useful answer to that. And it seems contradictory - on the one hand, with my immune system repeatedly fighting it off, could this actually be strengthening my antibody response? On the other hand, if it was that strong, then why would it keep coming back anyway?
Seriously, I mentioned it before, but as we continue with this, it has to be recognised that the value of antibody testing increases. The problem is that it's taken the government this long to ramp up antigen testing to where it should have been all along and the obsession is getting those "(antigen) testing capacity" numbers up. But, well, by the time they've finally done that, the natural need has moved on to more antibody testing too. Because, you know, it's just the nature of time - those who've got it become those who've had it.
And there are the currently unanswered questions on immunity. I understand that you can't just drop people in harm's way to test out their immunity directly - not with a potentially fatal virus - but this is the value of antibody testing. There are now surely plenty of people who've had it.
Indeed, the ONS random study of the population was registering that 7 out of 10 people were coming up positive for antibodies, even though they were totally asymptomatic. So the amount of people out there who've had it - including even larger numbers of those who don't even realise this is the case, as they never got symptoms - is surely much larger than the official numbers even suggest (and the official numbers are a large sample size already).
With antibody testing, we can identify these people and then track them. Is anyone - who's known to have antibodies from testing - coming back with reports of getting it again? If not, then that indicates some immunity. Through antibody testing, we can start getting a metric on whether immunity is there, how strong immunity might be, how long it lasts, and so forth.
By monitoring the presumably immune and confirming that, yeah, they actually do seem to be immune. And, if not, by how much. And are the symptomatic sufferers better off, immunity-wise, than the asymptomatic cases?
And the thing is, though I'm no fan of the "herd immunity" bollocks, antibody testing is really the only way to get a metric on whether we might be anywhere near obtaining it (if it is, as I've covered, attainable at all). And if we can confirm that, yes, immunity does exist then we can begin answering the question of whether "immunity passports" could actually be a safe and sensible thing or not?
Currently, the WHO says "don't do immunity passports, because we don't know that there's good immunity". But there is a "catch-22" in that, in that we'll never find out, unless we're monitoring folks who've had it - confirmed with antibody testing - and keeping track of whether a statistically significant number of them are or aren't getting it again. And because we can't ethically just deliberately infect those with antibodies to double-check if they work, when this is potentially fatal, then it really does have to be done by antibody testing and mass monitoring, and then working it out statistically. You don't place anyone in harm's way, but we are all naturally in harm's way, as we live our lives, so keep an eye on those with antibodies - in a large statistically useful sample size - and track if anyone in that group is catching this thing again.
If reports are rare to non-existent, then immunity seems good. If reports aren't much better in this group than other groups then, bollocks, immunity ain't a thing.
Basically, if we can't deliberately infect people to directly ascertain the whys and whats of immunity, then we have to use a little "Bayesian statistics" to work it out instead:
This is the mathematics of "the known unknown". When you can't get precise and exact answers, this doesn't mean you can't still get useful statistical answers.
(Also, Dr. Hannah Fry. A mathematical redhead. Swoon. Plus, you've got to love that mathematician's joke: "What's the chances of you finding me here?" / "As this is the first time I've ever found you here, then I don't know". Ba-doom-tish!)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes