Ollie wrote:It's hard to avoid the conclusion that a second wave is deliberate policy.
Particularly because it's not inevitable.
This is perhaps the biggest mistake that thinking that "this is just a flu" has caused.
The notion that it would go away in the hot weather. The idea that it'll come back around in Winter.
Yes, this is what flu does. Because influenza hates heat.
But we have had outbreaks in the Northern Hemisphere - the United States of America and Europe - and near the equator - Singapore, Iran and Saudi Arabia - and in the Southern Hemisphere - Brazil and Australia. Opposite seasons, opposite weather and the Tropics are always hot.
There's nothing in the data to suggest that SARS 2 is particularly heat sensitive (well, any more so than that all living things, of course, have their upper limits - us included).
This virus broke out in Winter for the Northern Hemisphere. It's nearly the ides of July right now, and we've past the Summer Solstice.
Thinking this is "just the flu" has brought in assumptions that it's seasonal. But it clearly isn't.
(Indeed, an interesting pattern in the USA's resurgence - they've hit more than 60K cases a day, and the curve is rising exponentially again there - is that, contrary to the "this is just a flu" seasonal assumptions, it's the hotter states that are amongst those doing the worst right now. So there's even the possibility of the reverse - that the virus actually kind of likes things a bit warmer - although the most probable thing is that it just has a wide "operating temperature" range and isn't bothered too much by the weather.)
I do get it. There's a reason why the body heats up when suffering fever - it's a purposeful reaction from the body to raise the temperature, as germs and viruses usually don't like that too much, so it helps combat them. In the absence of evidence, it's not unreasonable to assume that heat might help. Because it usually does and, ultimately, all living things have an upper temperature limit above which they can't survive - us included.
But we do have some evidence and more data every day. Months of the numbers coming in around the world. And that's kind of the point, the numbers are coming in from everywhere. Both Hemispheres. The Equator. All climates. The virus has not been significantly hindered anywhere on the planet by varying weather conditions.
Thus far, it's been primarily hindered by social distancing, due to the basic indisputable logic that if no-one goes near anyone else at any point, then it can't spread, if we strive to give it absolutely nowhere to go.
(Social distancing is our best weapon for the fact that it definitely works, as the numbers everywhere show, and works regardless of the characteristics of the virus - if the virus can't jump between people, then it can't spread. It's an unassailable barrier for any virus.)
The USA gave up on this - at Trump's insistence - and re-opened too soon. And we can say it's too soon because the "total cases" curve has returned to exponential growth again, which is very bad and a negative example to all countries that if you don't keep on top of the outbreak then it absolutely will 100% kick back into full force again. The nature of the virus's spread ain't changed one bit.
Thinking of this as "like the flu" causes, as I say, these erroneous assumptions about how this virus will behave that's just not borne out by the data and reality. The flu is seasonal, so the assumption is that this is seasonal - even though we've crossed seasons, on both sides of the planet, since December, and that really hasn't seemingly done much of anything to hinder its behaviour.
Now, Winter still poses a problem. Because the seasonal flu does, of course, still exist out there (though, hey, with all this social distancing, we're also beating back other transmissible viruses at the same time here, so colds and 'flus have also not had much chance of spreading this year either) and we have the potential double-whammy of not having gotten this under control by the time the seasonal flu kicks in to add even more stress and strain on our health systems. The seasonal flu strains hospitals every year at the best of times, without an additional - and confusingly symptomatically similar - virus still raging on top of all that too.
But, you know, what makes us think that this virus will rage in Winter? Point to the actual data. Where, in any of the graphs for any country, can we overlay weather data and say "look, it makes a noticeable difference"? It
is Winter in Australia, South Africa, New Zealand, etc. right now.
This is not the flu, and there's nothing in the numbers that indicates this is seasonal in any way. Winter can still be a problem, though, as we don't want this still hanging around in a major way, when the seasonal stuff does eventually make its appearance - we don't need two problems at the same time, though I do fear that it's likely unavoidable, as too many countries let this virus rage - for "herd immunity" or just, with America and Brazil, stupidity from their leadership - that we lost the advantage of this being a novel virus to suppress it towards elimination. It's hard to see how this could not now be endemic for the foreseeable.
This is one of things that most frustrates me in this shambolic response: there was the opportunity, the best chance, to squash this virus towards non-existence by acting swiftly and aggressively to deny it any foothold anywhere, but it's been squandered.
But, yes, the bottom line is that this is not the 'flu, but because that mindset plagued our global response - assuming it's seasonal, assuming only symptomatic cases mattered, etc. - then we've given this thing oxygen, exactly when we should have been smothering it to death.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes