Cloudane wrote:- Man-made vaccines could possibly last longer? If not, the vulnerable could get shots every 3 months while the rest of us get on with our lives
This is a possibility.
Indeed, I do believe that some of the vaccine efforts are putting SARS 2 RNA / DNA into other types of harmless virus - to carry it - and, thus, if you choose a harmless virus carrier that's one of the ones that the immune system tends not to forget, maybe we could train up an immune system to produce Covid-killing antibodies that won't die off quite so quickly.
But that's much more complication added on top and that means, if it's at all possible, then it'll take longer to get there.
Although, yes, there is the fact that there's 200 vaccine projects going on around the world, so it was always likely that we'd possibly "upgrade" the vaccine as we went along - that the first vaccine is "good enough" but one of the other efforts is proven to work even better, so we all move to that one instead. With 200 shots at it, one of them might, indeed, encourage different antibodies - that still do the same job - that have a better longevity to them.
Cloudane wrote:- T cells and memory cells, while they don't stop it spreading, should help those who've been infected with it before
That's something that I've been seeing regards "long haulers", as a possible explanation for why that happens.
That, with some people, the antibody response is strongest. But that, for others, it's the other immune mechanisms that actually come to the fore to clear out the virus - because it's been noted that "long haulers" also seem to have far less antibodies than other "survivors" of the virus, and this might be the difference. Their - or should I say "our"? - recovery is not primarily antibody based.
So, yeah, the human immune system does have other mechanisms. But, well, they generally ain't as good, in terms of still suffering some symptoms and how long that goes on for.
Cloudane wrote:- Treatments are getting better, there's dexamethasone and soon we could be looking at anticoagulant drugs to stop the scary aspect of blood clots etc
Indeed, in my first draft of the above post, I suggested treatments could potentially make this non-fatal, and that's another alternative - people still get it, but if we can then cure them up with treatments, that can work too.
Prevention is better than cure, but cure will do if prevention ain't possible.
(I deleted it, as there's much to be said on that, and I started saying it - totally digressing from the main point - then removed it to be more focused on the actual point of posting.)
Cloudane wrote:- As always, the possibility that getting too strict will cause more deaths (economic and lack of "non emergency" healthcare) than the virus itself
Yes, I have said before that it's social distancing and such that does the job (and it doesn't actually matter where you're doing your social distancing, as long as it's being done), and that such measures have to be made sustainable, if they are to be maintained in the long term.
That is, this doesn't necessarily mean "eternal lockdown". In truth, lockdown was the "emergency brake". The unsubtle way to put a halt to the exponential growth, sharpish.
As the Pandemic meme would have it, "the President Madagascar approach" (though, in reality, Madagascar didn't actually do this) of "SHUT DOWN EVERYTHING!".
With more manageable numbers, measures in place, local lockdowns if necessary, ramped up testing and tracing and so forth, there are less drastic ways to keep things safe, without caging absolutely everyone in their homes for the rest of history.
And, on the "sustainability" angle, then we'll have to work out exactly how to do that - to make the measures tolerable enough that people actually keep to them. On that score, I was actually in favour of opening non-essential businesses, in a socially distanced way, before even Boris et al were touting it. Like, if you're asking people to stay at home, then you need to let the hardware / DIY stores open, as people will need to fix shit that's broken in their homes. If you want people to stay at home more, then you've got to make that feasible to allow them to do it.
Cloudane wrote:- Possibility of it mutating to be less harmful because killing your hosts isn't a great viral strategy
Unfortunately, though, in those terms, the virus isn't - as a percentage of overall cases - killing off that many people. The majority of hosts are just fine - 80% asymptomatic - and a majority who're symptomatic also come through this okay too.
There's just not enough evolutionary pressure to push thing too rapidly in that direction.
(Evolution is a "good enough" process. It's not aiming for optimal, just "functional". If you survive and pass on your genes, then you survive and pass on your genes - and it's not really relevant if you only just barely managed to do so, or easily walked it. Once you reach "survival", then all evolutionary pressure just drops away. Fat, stupid and ugly people have kids too. Their genes are passed on. What happens to them after that is, evolutionarily speaking, irrelevant.)
Cloudane wrote:- If either it becomes cultural (doubtful) or Boris grows a set of balls and makes masks mandatory in all shops not just public transport, this could considerably reduce spread while still allowing people to act fairly normally in other settings.
Yes. And he absolutely needs to grow those balls and do it now.
There are also other things - like increased ventilation, UV lights at doorways and in air conditioning units, more self-service contactless payments, more stuff done outside, etc. - that can do big things to reduce spread, whilst not requiring us to be locked up in cages forever.
To be clear, I absolutely don't want an eternal lockdown. Not at all. I'm just trying to be pragmatic about what is most safe for us all.
Social distancing definitely works - the whole world has proved that and it's just logical that if there's zero opportunities for spread given, then spread just can't happen. We have to work out ways to do that and still be able to carry on. Like having masks, one way systems, limits on numbers indoors and all the other stuff that supermarkets and other shops have been doing. Keeping social distance but not getting too much in the way of being able to do what needs to be done.
Is it awkward and a right pain in the arse? Undoubtedly. But it is a way through this that doesn't ask us all to stay locked up like Rapunzel in a tower forever more, without being recklessly unsafe that we'll never see the end to this, if we can't keep the numbers right down.
Because there is another "endgame" here. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland - unfortunately, not England yet, but it's getting there - have had days registering zero deaths. If we can start to get to zero daily cases too, then zero is a special number.
One person with the virus can explode into an outbreak. But zero people with the virus doesn't go anywhere.
We can suppress things down to "mostly zeroes" - and enter "the green zone" - then instigate strict quarantine to stop "imports" then we can keep it at bay that way, and it'd be safe - if there's truly no-one in the country with the virus - to then lift all measures. If no-one has it, then no-one can spread it.
I mean, we do have, for instance, very strict rules about pets and such to keep the UK rabies free. There are rules about not bringing invasive plant species into various countries. We do attempt to restrict "imports" of other things and, yes, doing this to human beings with long quarantines would be the strictest we ever got.
But in the battle between the airlines remaining rich and folks having foreign holidays versus being able to keep the virus at zero and lift all internal restrictions then, sorry, fuck Richard Branson and folks wanting to sun themselves in Spain. Tough shit, frankly. Reach zero and then maintain zero, and we could actually safely get things back to normal - and I mean real normal, not "new normal".
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes