Yes, this is a known problem.gilesgoat wrote:Someone please explain me also "all this testing mania" ... ok "I test TODAY" it takes 2 days ? To get the answer "negative" .. ok .. but I could be infected 1 day after the testing .. 2 weeks later "I am totally sick" ..
In America, leading scientists have criticised boasts on large testing numbers, as not being all that great, after all, because the tests are taking too long to process. Which does introduce the "lag" problems you're alluding to.
But the fundamental problem is that this has been, up to now, the best test we've got.
Even before the sheer logistics of wanting to process tens of thousands or more of these tests a day, the test itself still doesn't escape the inevitable delay of needing to be shipping out to a lab, the process itself isn't particularly fast and then the admin delays of getting the results returned. Work can be done on efficiency of this whole process, of course, but there's a limit to how far, realistically, you can pragmatically reduce these things. Particularly when you're doing so many day-in and day-out again and again.
But, basically, that's the test. That's how it works. It has been, up to this point, all we've had.
Indeed, it's annoyed me throughout that the antigen test has been referred to as if it's "THE test" - it's not qualified. If you "get a test" then it inherently means the lab-based antigen test. I understand why. Because, for many months, it was the only reliable test in town. Eventually, Porton Down perfected a lab-based antibody test to go alongside this, but that one is also slowed by needing to be shipped to a lab - and, as far as I know, they've not scaled up the numbers of labs doing antibody tests, as they eventually did (after taking far too long) with the antigen tests - so antibody testing is being treated as "precious" and used sparingly, as the antigen test initially was.
Which is a crying shame as the antibody test - even if not entirely reliable - could prove an excellent "filter test". When constantly dealing with numbers this large, a fast "filter test" could be super useful, just to cut down on the numbers of tests needing to be processed, by weeding out - with a "filter test" - who needs further investigation and who doesn't. If someone's registering antibodies - in decent number - then their immune system has got a handle on this now.
I mean, as a "long hauler" myself, I'm not suggesting totally ignoring these people, but filter them out and then concentrate on those who really need a test for prevention and protection. Those registering antibodies are already "too late", as it were. Send them to the longer term support of their GP or whatever, but don't waste "frontline" resources on folks who're coming back as having already had this.
In other words, priorities. A "filter test" is essentially triage. You can filter out who does and doesn't need to go onto the "further investigation" of an antigen test.
(And why would the antibody test be the filter? Because it's a blood test - antibodies reside in the blood - and those can potentially be turned into rapid pin-prick tests. I mean, they already have - it's just that these tests aren't reliable enough to be wholly trusted for large-scale deployment. But they have the potential - unlike the complex lab tests - to be turned into a simple and fast "home kit", where a swab test that has to be analysed by a specialist lab ain't ever going to be fast. Because the very fact that you have to physically transport the tests to these labs, who then have to go through them all, is an inevitable delay and bottleneck on the process.)
But, on that front, the government has added this to their website:
https://www.gov.uk/government/news/roll ... -of-winter
As I say, it's known that the delays in getting results from testing is a problem and these new tests attempt to get answers within 90 minutes and don't need a specialist lab to do the processing, as tests are processed by machine (and the machines are to be rolled out to hospitals).
So, yes, the delay in getting results is known to be an issue. But, simply, the only reliable tests were slow and had to be processed in specialist labs. So it was known to be not the greatest, but it was all that we currently had. But scientists have been working on ways to speed things up and they've got two new tests that do it in 90 minutes. I mean, there's still going to be delays processing it all, but hopefully much shorter delays when hospitals don't have to send them off anywhere, but can process them themselves.
It's shaving off a little of the time taken. Improving the throughput. Trying to get results back faster because, yes, having to wait a number of days before knowing what the test found out - that "lag" - does cause potential problems.
Although, the real massive problem with this virus in particular is pre-symptomatic transmission. Folks can have it and be passing it around, without any indications at all that there's a problem in the first place. This is a big problem.
But we are where we are. Hopefully, maybe one of those 15 minute pin-prick tests could actually be perfected to be reliable enough for large scale use. The one thing Boris did get right: If such tests really did work, then that would be "game changing". Unfortunately, they all announced these tests early on, before they'd been checked to actually work reliably, and they were terrible.




