Well, if the reports of Russia hacking into the vaccine efforts around the world is correct then, for all we know, this is the Oxford vaccine, that they've just half-inched and replicated it for themselves.Cloudane wrote:Is it though? Aren't we about to do the same thing with Oxford?KlaxonCow wrote:There's a worry - as this has only undergone 2 months of testing - that Russia's cutting corners here, and is rushing a vaccine that's not really had sufficient safety testing.
This is why I earlier put forth the idea of "challenge testing", which the campaign 1 Day Sooner have been advocating for, and have even been collecting names for volunteers who're willing to consent to the risks of a challenge trial.Cloudane wrote:Which leads to "is a testing period counted in months rather than decades enough?"... the scientists seem to think so (phase 2 for safety testing already passed, phase 3 to see if it's effective), the, lets use a diplomatic term as there are a few here too, "vaccine skeptics" - seem to think otherwise.
You can compress down the time taken - dramatically so - with challenge trials, where - with full consent, of course - you actually deliberately infect the vaccinated person to the virus, rather than vaccinate them and then wait around to see if they get infected. With no real way to tell the difference between whether the vaccine did protect them, or whether they just, you know, avoided catching this virus - and, because of that, we do statistically require many more months to be entirely sure that, on the balance of probabilities, it's the vaccine and not just luck that's kept them safe so far.
(And that gets even more complicated to demonstrate statistically - remembering that statistics never gives you a "yes / no" answer, but rather a "we have 60% confidence that it's probably a 'yes', maybe" - if the vaccine doesn't provide "bullet-proof" immunity, where you just can't get it at all, but rather "herd resistance", as I've been calling it, where you can still catch it, but as your immune system is now prepared for it, the severity - and, thus, fatality rate - is drastically reduced. Which, realistically, is probably what we're looking at, as antibodies don't naturally stick around for this, but it's more about ensuring everyone's got the "memory T cells" that can produce more antibodies should you get the virus. So you can still catch it and even become symptomatic, but the vaccine's trained the immune system's response ahead of time, so it can immediately get to work on getting on top of it and clearing it out. From the evidence so far, that's most probably what we're looking at. As the WHO put it, it's not "a silver bullet" that makes the virus go away, but training everyone's immune responses to be there immediately fighting it, so symptoms are reduced, severity is reduced, fatalities are drastically cut (hopefully, even eliminated, as the percentage chance is already very low, so an extra nudge will get it ever so closer to zero), recoveries are faster and so forth. It's not a "magic shield" spell, but a "health regeneration" spell - you still take some hit point damage, but hopefully you're back up to full hit points faster. And, to be honest, it'd be nice if scientists and governments were more up front in the "expectation management" department there.)
You can reasonably compress the trial period, if you're using challenge testing. Because then it's not statistical - you know this person has the vaccine and you know they've been given the virus, so it's all about monitoring how well the vaccine works. No waiting around for someone to get naturally unlucky and catching it in the normal course of events.
And, of course, the volunteers give 100% consent to this, aware of the greater risks. And we can keep the viral load down, when deliberately infecting them. And we only use young, healthy volunteers who're already deeply unlikely to die from this - and if the vaccine works, then that fate hopefully becomes non-existent.
But, yes, usually the ethical rules say that you simply cannot deliberately infect someone with a potentially fatal virus - for which we currently have no effective treatments - because you could well end up killing them. I feel, though, that if the risks are understood and folks volunteer willingly, this clears the moral bar.
Because, on the other end of the moral scale here, how many people could get infected and die, while we wait around for results? The morals are not clear cut here. Delay causes much misery and death. Even by Kantian moral philosophy - and I am a Kantian, not a Utilitarian, in my morals - then we can still call on "the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few", where people choose willingly to take a personal risk as a volunteer to help. If the fat man on the bridge doesn't need to be pushed, because they choose to jump down on the tracks to try and save everyone from the trolley car, that is an acceptable moral solution to the trolley problem - even if, tragically, they lose their life in the effort. I mean, we accept such risk for firefighters, for instance.
(Well, acceptable to me, as I'm not plagued by religious ideas of suicide threatening someone's immortal soul. I'm very, very wary of being 100% sure that someone who wants to visit Dignitas in Switzerland to bring a dignified end to their life is absolutely 100% not being pressured into it for any reason. To make sure that we haven't got any instances of "murder in disguise". But, if that moral bar is cleared, I'm okay with that choice. And, indeed, similar to challenge trials, if someone voluntarily wants to do that and you're stopping them, then there's the argument that you're being immoral to deny them an end to their pain for your own selfish reasons. It's not a clear cut "this is moral and this isn't", but more "degrees and measures" as to which is the most moral option from a bunch of bad solutions.)
It is possible to compress trials down to a very short period. But I don't see how you can acceptably do so, without explicitly going for challenge trials on the vaccine.
With a challenge trial, you are legitimately cutting down on the time to get the data. Years can be validly reduced to months. But if you're not doing challenge trials, then reducing the time is just collecting less data. It's just proceeding with less confidence that it actually works.
(And, hey, Putin's Russia is, unfortunately, the sort of place where they might well have sped this up by exactly taking on the risk of challenge trials - there are places in the world which don't share our Western moral perspectives, and it is reported that Putin's said his own family has had the vaccine already - but they're just not explicitly admitting to this. As we all know, Putin is not a squeamish sort of person. Former KGB. I wouldn't put it past him. I wouldn't put it past him that he's not as concerned as I am to ensure everyone's giving full consent beforehand.)
Yes, indeed.Cloudane wrote:But I'd have thought it'd apply equally to whatever country, short of the "Russia = bad" stuff.
To be clear, I was just reporting the worries expressed by others there. I don't necessarily share them.
And, as a humanist, I definitely don't subscribe to any notions that one nationality is intrinsically superior to any other. So my comments above are not "Russia = bad", but just "Putin = arsehole".
Indeed, I have previously noted that D-Day would never have worked without great Russian sacrifice keeping Hitler busy on the Eastern Front. That Russia did win all of the space firsts - first satellite, first orbit, first man in space, etc. - except for "first people on the Moon". And I have defended Russian tech, when an ignorant idiot suggested that a Russian-built camera would be inferior - are you kidding, mate? We might not have ideologically agreed with the Soviets, but you're just being silly if you're suggesting, from that, that the Russians don't know what they're doing or produce inferior technologies.
On the contrary, running my cluster of servers at work, the attacks that worry me are those that come from Russian IP addresses. Because those ones are always "probing" for vulnerabilities, and their intent is clearly to get "root" on my servers. Whereas, from other countries, they're all just trying to brute force email passwords to get a "relay" for spam - and I generally don't give a shit about that, as their statistical odds of success are low - and if they did get in and start spamming, then I can just shut them down by disabling that account. But the Russians are those I fear, as their intent is more malicious and, realistically, these folks know more than I do about vulnerabilities. I have a perfectly grudging respect for my enemy there.
(Oh, and that last one is why I'm not really going by "Russia = bad", but just direct personal experience that they ain't lying that Russians are forever trying to hack into things. Now, as to whether this is or isn't "state-sponsored", I can't tell from my server logs. But there are definitely ceaseless assaults coming from Russian IP addresses all the bloody time - and the nature of what they're going after, in terms of vulnerabilities, their goal is getting root access, not just trying to get an email relay for their spamming efforts. Russian IPs show much more malicious intent. My email logs will be full of mostly Asian IPs, trying to brute force passwords. But Russian IPs show up trying to hack into Wordpress - when a known vulnerability has just been patched, so they're chancing their arms that I've not updated properly - or in the SSH logs. They don't fuck about, they're going for full-blown server take-over. They're the ones to be worried about.)


