Yes. But what I'm getting at is the colloquial difference between "immune" and "resistant". How people interpret the words.Duck Turkin wrote:If you are immune, you are by definition resistant to a specific disease.
For example, if someone has "immunity to prosecution" then they are legally "bullet proof". You can't touch them.
And that's the context most people take the word "immune" to mean - that you're "bullet proof" or untouchable.
But, to quote your words, "If you are immune, you are by definition resistant to a specific disease". Well, how do most people read "resistant"?
If my coat is "water resistant" then, yes, it repels water. But, hmm, that's "water resistant" and not "water proof". "Water proof" says "this thing absolutely cannot be penetrated by water", but "water resistant" typically means "This will repel water... up to a point. Light rain, sure. But if you're dropping your phone or watch into a tub of water and leaving it submerged for the next 6 hours then, yeah, it'll probably not survive".
Colloquially, "immune" is bullets bouncing off Superman's chest. "Resistant" is more like Wolverine - with his healing factor, his body can reject the bullets and rapidly stitch itself back up, but you can rip him to shreds and knock him down with a machine gun of bullets.
This, I feel, is how most people colloquially interpret these English words. That's how - as noted with "immune from prosecution" or "water resistant vs water-proof" - these words get typically used in practice.
But, well, our immune system is called "the immune system". It's not called "the resistance system" - though, really, that's more like what it genuinely is. So when someone has an immune response, that's called "being immune". But, in practice, it's what would colloquially be called "resistance".
You have Wolverine's healing factor from your T cells and antibodies, you don't have Superman's impenetrable and untouchable imperviousness.
Or, in practice, if you have memory T cells but your antibody count have waned to zero, over the course of three or four months, then the T cells and B cells can kick up a whole new batch of antibodies for you. But that is not an instant response. In the meantime, you have the virus, you have symptoms of the virus as the immune system kicks up its response.
That's not quite the same as if you've got the antibodies flowing through your blood stream right now. That one is pretty much an instant response. It's already there. The virus can't gain any foothold at all - what people would generally interpret as "immune" in the Superman sense - because the antibodies are blocking the spikes, to stop infection of cells, and the T cells are actively killing them off.
The difference is the delay.
It's like the difference between having a fire engine parked right in front of your home before it catches fire - so they can immediately rush in to put it out - and having the fire station be 50 miles away. And, sure, they'll rush over with their sirens and flashing lights, as quickly as possible, but your house will be burning, without response, for the time it takes for the fire engine to get there.
Mind you, yes, once the fire brigade have arrived, they'll work just as hard and successfully to put out the fire, as if they'd already been there, parked outside your house. Once the immune system has kicked up those antibodies, then it will block the virus, just as surely as if you already had those antibodies in your blood stream before you caught it.
I feel I have to emphasise the difference because I was a "long hauler". I got it in late March, but the repeats kept coming for 5 months. I'm only fairly recently back to a fully asymptomatic "normal" in the past month or so.
There are degrees and measures of immunity. A spectrum of infectiousness. Things ain't binary and black-and-white.
(For example, I know that, as a long hauler, though I was suffering these repeat symptoms, I was not infectious - or, at least, if potentially infectious, not greatly so - because, simply, there was opportunity for that to happen and it didn't. I did, throughout, do everything I could not to pass it on. But, remember, after the initial bout of symptoms, I felt "back to normal" and, at that point, it was not known that there was a thing called "long haul". I thought I'd had it, gotten over it and now I can carry on with things - and I was less careful that I would have been, if I realised that, no, it wasn't gone and I'm about to carry this for another 5 months.
And that's kind of the lesson I learnt that I'm trying to pass on. This virus is a sneaky bugger. It does things that other viruses don't typically do. I mean, "it's just a flu" that comes and goes for the next 5 months? No, seriously, any notion of "this is just a flu" really needs to be erased out of people's heads - particularly the politicians - as there's been a whole truckload of bad decisions made in response to this virus that stems from misunderstanding it as "only a flu" or "like a flu". And, yes, one of those mistakes was made by me, when I thought that it had gone, after the initial bout of symptoms, before it repeatedly came back with a vengeance.
I initially thought that - because that's how everyone was talking about it - but then spent the next horrible 5 months of "brain fog", thinking I was about to drop dead from circulatory problems (and, by the way, phoning 111 was useless, as they seem to have no clue what "long haul" is or how to deal with it in any way, because I think it's not in their training when, again, politicians continue to peddle the "it's just a flu" / "it's only a flu" falsehood) and a whole carousel of coming-and-going symptoms, like a rash on my hands, dizziness, aches, fatigue, etc.
Sure, I'd like - and initially thought was the case - that it'd just be a week of "flu-like mild symptoms" and then I'm immune and then it's not a problem. But this virus is more complicated than that. It's not just "long haul". It's also the folks that get hospitalised from a more serious infection - they might survive, but it's not instant recovery.
I mean, there are rumours that Boris is considering stepping down as PM, because of coronavirus complications to his longer term health. And, like, he only had a relatively "mild" brush with this - oxygen, sure, but not put into a coma and hooked up to a ventilator. If he does, then King Boris surrendering his crown willingly suggests his after-effects ain't entirely trivial, as he'd never give it up for any reason, ordinarily.
We all want a simplified narrative. Yes or no. Black or white. But reality does not grant us this, unfortunately. It's more complicated than that.





