Hi I'm currently considering revamping our home entertainment equipment. Currently we have a 40in TV that we bought in 2011 which is on a TV stand with the bits that plug in (BluRay, HTPC, Virgin Media etc) underneath. Our lounge is smallish so I found it quite appealing to be able to put the TV on the wall and move all the other inputs to the corner of the room and plug into a AV receiver. That way we can get rid of the TV stand. And while I'm at it I might as well get some 5.1 surround speakers
Currently everything is pretty easy to operate. Turn on the BluRay or Chromecast and the tv turns on switched to the correct input and the volume is always controlled by the tv remote. After plugging everything into an AVR though I worry about an increase in complexity and how that will go down with the other members of my household - one of whom is already a bit sceptical about the amount of money all this will cost . For example if we're watching normal tv with the sound going through the AVR changing channels will be done on the tv remote and volume would be done on the AVR remote. Also a high proportion of our TV is watched through the Chromecast and if that is plugged into the AVR I presume there will be extra steps involved in setting the AVR and TV to the right input.
Just wondered if anyone else here has a similar situation and how/if they resolved it.
I found this remote which assigns activities to buttons e.g. Watch movie, listen to radio. It sounds like it would resolve this issue but I wonder how well it would work in practice.
My other half hates tech so thank god my new LG TV just routes EVERYTHING audio wise via eARC to my new Samsung Atoms soundbar.
I have now dumped all my external hardware such as my apple and fire tv and Humax Recorder. We now just use the respective built in LG apps so no pissing about explaining different AV inputs and their requirements to my partner. Gone from 4 remotes to one. He can even use PLEX properly now - IT IS BLISS.
When I had my previous setup with the a yamaha rxv673 I just wrote it all down on an a4 sheet to start with till he got the hang of it but sometimes he would end up in an odd channel or av input or screen and have no clue which remote or system would help him out.
Last edited by Deckard on Mon Sep 07, 2020 11:19 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
I love the Harmony stuff, it really does make life so much easier once it's set up and should be up to your use case. I got mine for exactly the same reason, you need to make it easy for the family. It copes with turning on/off the necessary components and sets the right input etc
Of course, I looked at models like that but talked myself up and I have a Harmony Elite and a Harmony Ultimate and used to have the old Harmony One.
The Elite/Ultimate both come with the home hub which increases flexibility. The Ultimate is the older version of the Elite, essentially the same but the button placement for play/fwd/rew are above the screen and not ideal.
The Elite is currently an eye-watering £250 on Amazon, I think I paid about £120 and can see it was 116 on Amazon in November:
Deckard wrote:My other half hates tech so thank god my new LG TV just routes EVERYTHING audio wise via eARC to my new Samsung Atoms soundbar.
I have now dumped all my external hardware such as my apple and fire tv and Humax Recorder. We now just use the respective built in LG apps so no pissing about explaining different AV inputs and their requirements to my partner. Gone from 4 remotes to one - IT IS BLISS.
Minimising is good, we just do most things through the Apple TV as our TV isn't that smart (if a TV can do all of Apple TV+, Netflix, Amazon Prime, BT Sport, Now TV and Disney+ then I can dump that box).
But for us there is still the Xbox, Virgin box and Blu Ray player that are still needed.
Hubby doesn’t play video games and we don’t have virgin or sky as anything uk tv wise comes from the Uk tv apps although in truth that really for us is iPlayer and C4. All other video media is piped over from my MacPro using PLEX from 50mb to 50gb files
+1 for the Logitech Harmony kit here. We've got two Harmony Ultimate units in the house. They used to be programmed up for the stupid amount of kit we had under the TVs (multiple STBs, amps, HTPCs, consoles, etc.) but as we've simplified to modern smart TVs (LG again, here) and their built-in apps, the Harmony kit is more used a bridge to Alexa and Hue, allowing macros that change lighting when switch the TVs on and off, for example.
Harmony Elite (with the extra Hub) is the best "consumer" remote out there now - they're a dying breed. I've had most of them over the years (endless Philips Prontos, MX Masters etc) - the Elite is good enough but still has some annoying quirks and, as is traditional with these sorts of things, its software veers from vaguely-usable to terrible. All of my kit is inside a cupboard so the IR blasters that come with the hub are very useful.
The Elite kit often comes up on deals e.g. ~£130 around Black Friday (Amazon). If that happens again this year, I might get a second as my current one has an iffy battery and struggles to charge.
If it keeps household harmony its well worth the money ! Plus that can be applied to anything that doesn't hold a value for you - 1000 pounds for a phone ! 3 pounds for a pint of beer ! 300 pounds for golf clubs etc etc
Got everything into a 7.2 (only 5.1 speakers connected at the moment) and that's the only thing the telly connects to. Everything goes through receiver, which switches input when you fire up a new source. Alexa tells the harmony IR flood what pulses to send out, so can just hit remote you want or ask Alexa to turn on Xbone, Blu ray, Set top box (we call it CaTV and you're away. Voice command on volume, but have TV remote and Bluray remote mapped to receiver for volume anyway.
TlDr, a receiver can make things easier if you set things up correctly and the sound is vaaaar nice.
Ugh don't get me started! This is exactly what I've been trying to do these past few days, and this is just my bedroom setup!
I thought a smart TV would probably be perfect for this.
First problem, getting a smart TV that actually fits in my room (6 by 10ft, but effectively 6 by 7 after airing cupboard and doorway, sit on bed) without taking up half the wall, and I don't really want to mount it to an internal wall as I would probably turn that into a DIY Disaster show. Currently I have a 26" Panasonic Viera from 2009 which is dumb and 720p and sometimes locks up my Humax box, but is otherwise superb (it was one of the best on the market at the time) and is a very convenient and comfortable size to look at. So thought maybe I will upgrade, there will be better ones with smaller bezels etc. Turns out there aren't. The manufactures have all but abandoned everything under 43". As "Which?" will tell you, anything below 50" is a second class citizen with missing features, lower quality, poor sound etc, and anything below 43" is trash. Basically, it's all cheap crap (that is not really that cheap, but is "cheap" compared to the eye watering prices for everything that's decent now). I don't want to be looking at a 50" TV from 3ft away, it's ridiculous, which limits me to the crap. Really I'd prefer 32" (which is the new 26" with smaller bezels basically) so that it can sit on the desk I use as a media centre rather than trying to wall mount, which relegates me to the super crap. Lucky for me I'm not TOO fussy and not too sensitive to motion blur.
Second problem, we use Freesat. Freeview is out of the question here, the transmitter is a fair distance with a lot in the way and it's always been really bad. So I thought, get a TV with Freesat built in to simplify the setup. Hah! "What's Freesat?" say 90% of TV manufacturers, especially when you're at the pleb tier (under 50"). Only one available is LG but WebOS was looking pretty good so I bought a 32" LG from Currys for a nice cool £229. To be honest, I thought despite getting a slating in Which, it wasn't a BAD set. Terrible sound, yes, I'd get a soundbar. And the interface is a bit sluggish. All in all considering it's Smart, £229 worth of TV - bit of a downgrade from the Viera in terms of telly, but an upgrade in terms of smarts. Then I started trying to watch BBC HD. And that's when I found a problem they were discussing quite early LAST YEAR affecting 2019 models onwards where if you have a decent signal (100% here, it's satellite and aligned properly so why wouldn't it be), the transponder for BBC HD suffers constant signal gitches and cut-outs. It's something to do with the tuner getting "too much signal". LG have admitted it's a bug and been paying lip service about fixing it ever since. After reading their forum thread, I lost faith and returned it for a refund. I would guess the reason the returns aren't stacking up at Currys is because most people either use Freeview, use Sky with a separate box, or don't know better and just get talked into it being their dish or using a separate box. It was a decent enough TV, though it did "feel a bit cheap", but I wasn't willing to stick with something not fit for the purpose I bought it.
So at this point I've accepted that I'll have to stick with the separate Humax box. Not a good start, but at least if all the smarts work....
Third problem, I like to throw something I've found on a laptop/phone/tablet onto the TV. I have lots of different devices. I don't pledge undying allegiance to Apple or Google. Apple have their own "chuck this at the TV" standard (Airplay) and Google have theirs (Google Cast), and there's the open standard that nothing supports and is more laborious when it does (Miracast), and everyone is "ohhh noooo that's a competitor" and refuses to play nice. A TV that supports both and is part of the Pleb Tier size of TVs, is a unicorn of the highest order. It's hard to even find if some of them support one or both or neither. The LG did neither, but apps like Youtube and Netflix supported the "handoff" thing that uses the same icon as Google Cast. Airplay 2 is on WebOS 4.5, but only people with a Proper Size Telly who have spent £600+ are allowed to have that. So that's a further obstacle in the attempts at simplification.
Alternatives were looking to be a 32" £250 Samsung, which has the bonus of supporting Airplay 2 but everyone says Samsung abandons their smarts very quickly; or staying within a similar budget and trying to accommodate 43" in the form of a Hisense Roku TV (4K and £300, so very tempting). But Roku is a new one to me and there's the old story of "we might be bringing Airplay to it, maybe, rumours might say, rumours said about a year and a half ago"....
In the end, to cut a long story erm... long, I gave up. The Viera still has a superb picture and decent sound and honestly apart from being 720p it seems hard to beat at this size with modern sets. I'm using a Fire TV Stick, and have found the app AirReceiver which enables Airplay (albeit only of the source is DRM-free). "Casting" support is now built into the FireTV (thanks to dropping of feud with Google) but only in the form of the "hand off" from Youtube etc, however AirReceiver has its own Google Cast implementation that adds the screen mirroring and 'custom' casting which can be useful for anything Android/Chrome related. (But it seems to have its own half-working Youtube app, weirdly, so you have to be sure to cast to the FireTV's built-in cast instance, rather than AirReceiver's). At least this means I don't need an Apple TV, and can remove the Chromecast, and basically have all the smarts through the FireTV. But this still means I have a TV remote, a FireTV remote (which is wireless rather than IR) and a Humax remote. Sigh.
It's really hard to just have a simple setup where you can turn on the TV and there's the TV, no separate remote for broadcast, no separate remote for the smart bits, no worrying about "right I'm on an Apple device now, if I want to sling something at the TV I have to do it this way" etc. It's a market ripe for simplification - but unfortunately anyone attempting to simplify it is usually someone like Apple saying "yeah we can simplify it, just use exclusively our stuff!"