Harlequin wrote:KlaxonCow wrote:Only trouble is that they still believe it - and America interferes in the wider world as an extension of "Manifest Destiny", to bring "freedom" and capitalism to all the faithless savages of the world.…
This is one thing that the Dump seems to have moved away from. At least compared to other recent U.S. Presidents including Obama.
Yes, true enough.
But then, as I've already stated, I'm convinced that Trump is no true Christian believer. He says whatever you need to say to get elected. I detect no sincerity nor passion there whatsoever - not an ounce of it. He's just bare-faced lying.
Though I don't believe any of this crap myself, I do meet those that do. And I can tell the difference between someone who really believes it, with all their heart, and someone who's just going along with it all, as they reckon it's what should said to get what they want out of other people.
Well, if gay people have "gaydar", then consider it "atheist-dar". There are "tells" that you can pick up, that perhaps others don't look for and so never see.
Trump is very special. There's a complete dearth of passion and belief behind any religious statement I've heard him make. The whole thing is a facade. A cardboard cut out. I detect no substance behind any of it whatsoever.
No, true enough.
But I guess we're entering the weeds of "the implementation details" here. When we say "religion", what do we actually mean?
What Milgram was testing for was obedience to authority.
Indeed, he was explicit, at points, that his motivation for the experiments was trying to understand or explain how so many people happily went along with the Nazi genocides. Otherwise "good people" being willing to engage in one of the most heinous evils there's ever been.
In a sense, he was putting the Nuremberg Defence on scientific trial. "I was just following orders" is, of course, the Nuremberg Defence. I was just submitting to a higher power, a superior authority, than my own. An abdication of personal responsibility to the whims of a higher authority or power.
Why did you commit this evil? "I was demonstrating my loyalty and faithfulness to a power / authority greater than my own".
And, yes, if you want to get real specific, then
that is what we're talking about.
That is why "good people" commit evil.
They are convinced to abdicate responsibility for their own actions, unto some "greater good" or "higher purpose" or "superior authority".
That is the general problem. Religion, in particular, is one specific instance of it, but it is not, granted, solely limited to that.
But, well, we get into the weeds of argument over whether someone with total unwavering unquestioning commitment to a political ideology - Nazism, Communism, "free market capitalism" or whatever else - could be described as "being religious". They are zealous, for sure. Perhaps lacking supernatural claims, it should not strictly be called "a religion" but we all know that, in terms of on-the-ground words and actions, there's often almost no true difference otherwise. The nationalist suicide bomber has, at least metaphorically, made "the nation" into their god or at least an idol of unquestioning worship.
Be it an imaginary entity, a thing, a concept or whatever, it is that subjugation of "self" to the transcendent, as the transcendent's wishes are deemed superior to our own - and that causes a potential abdication of personal responsibility for one's own actions. This makes committing an evil now seemingly a good - a greater good, a test of faith, a trial of one's loyalty.
Yeah, if I was to edit the quotation, then it perhaps should not say "religion" but rather "unquestioning loyalty to a higher power / authority / concept, which that person feels transcends their own person - but this unfortunately opens the door to their abdication of personal responsibility".
Religion is not the entirety of everyone who makes that mistake, granted. But it absolutely does fit the description, and it is a specific instance of the wider problem of subjugation of "self" to some transcendent concept - a god, an ideology or whatever - that then seems to justify, in their demonstration of loyalty to it, an abdication of responsibility.
Why did you just do that evil thing? "I was just following orders" = Hitler wanted it / God wanted it / Communism demands it / social pressure insist on it. And you are being "sub" to this transcendent "dom", to demonstrate loyalty / trust / "love" to this transcendent thing, as you will suffer its abuse to prove your unwavering fealty and commitment to it, come Hades or high water.
If we're digging down, then that's the common mechanism here.
It goes beyond religion, I'll entirely grant you, which is only a specific instance of this unfortunately innate human psychological problem, so the quotation is, yes, guilty of implying a specific instance is the whole, when it isn't. But it is a specific instance of it, without doubt. I mean, we're only a handful of days after September the 11th here, after all.
It is similar to how almost all war propaganda focuses on de-humanising the enemy. Because our natural instincts are not to harm our own. But if they can be made "other" or "savage" or "animal" or "lesser" then, well, we kill animals to eat all the time. It creates the exception that allows us to break our natural moral compass. Our enemies are "satanic". They are demons. Now, no longer being people, we've by-passed our mental moral lock against harming others.
And be very careful not to remind anyone that even these "demons" have, of course, mothers and fathers. Families. Ambitions and dreams. Make jokes. Smile. Have fun. Show compassion to their less well off. No, no, no. They can't be humanised at all, or you'll hesitate to pull the trigger, if it dawns on you that the other guy really isn't any different to you, save being on the other team here.
(I'm reminded of when I saw Geoff Hoon on Question Time, trying to justify the invasion of Iraq and one of the things he said floored me. He was talking about how we, the UK, were sending experts to teach the poor "mud hut" Iraqis how to do irrigation. Yeah, he crossed a line there and broke my immersion in his little fictitious narrative. Because, wait, teaching the Iraqis - who've lived in a desert since the dawn of civilisation and built cities rivalling any of ours, in these most hostile conditions - how to irrigate? What else are we doing, Mr. Hoon? Teaching the Phoenicians how to write? Giving the secret of gunpowder to the Chinese? Instructing the Ancient Greeks on geometry? The very last people on Earth who need instruction on how to do irrigation, are the descendents of Bablyon and the children of those that created the Hanging Gardens, slap bang in the middle of a desert. But you can see what he was trying to do, war-propaganda-wise - painting the Iraqis as idiot barbarians living in mud huts, unsophisticated and primitive, that we're only "bringing civilisation to the savages". Why, it's a noble goal to incidentally help kill a million of them, in pursuit of oil. These poor "dumb monkey people" need our sophisticated white privileged help to even exist. We're doing them a favour by dropping a war on their heads. You could even say it's "for the Greater Good".)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes