Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
User avatar
snaff
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1038
Joined: Sat Mar 15, 2003 1:11 pm 0

Re: Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Post by snaff »

A useful piece of the puzzle is the Flirc infra-red receiver: https://flirc.tv/more/flirc-usb

It's a USB infra-red receiver that can learn any remote. It appears to the system as a keyboard - you link remote buttons to keypresses. I use it with things like Kodi and triggerhappy.

They don't seem to advertise it for some reason but it can also send infra-red.
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Post by Cloudane »

Got a higher spec LG. One of the 43" 4K models has a central stand so sits on my desk. Great decision. I knew the satellite was a risk and figured that if I have to use an external box I've lost nothing but so far it's pretty stable. Most of the apps are there, iPlayer is present now after a licensing hiccup on 2020 models, ITV catchup thing is coming soon. Both Google Assistant AND Alexa are built in. Much faster and better sound than the 32". 1080p games scale better to 4K than I expected. Really happy with it so far. LG smart TVs so far go back in my recommendations! Just make sure you get one of the 4K models (43" upwards) and expect to pay £400+. Airplay works great. I just unplugged countless HDMI things.
User avatar
Misfit
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10448
Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
Location: Nottingham UK
Contact:

Re: Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Post by Misfit »

Cloudane wrote:Got a higher spec LG. One of the 43" 4K models has a central stand so sits on my desk. Great decision. I knew the satellite was a risk and figured that if I have to use an external box I've lost nothing but so far it's pretty stable. Most of the apps are there, iPlayer is present now after a licensing hiccup on 2020 models, ITV catchup thing is coming soon. Both Google Assistant AND Alexa are built in. Much faster and better sound than the 32". 1080p games scale better to 4K than I expected. Really happy with it so far. LG smart TVs so far go back in my recommendations! Just make sure you get one of the 4K models (43" upwards) and expect to pay £400+. Airplay works great. I just unplugged countless HDMI things.
Great news, glad you got it sorted.

You could have saved yourself some time on yesterday's rant! :)
User avatar
xav
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2455
Joined: Thu Jun 06, 2002 5:32 pm 0
Location: Bucks, UK
Contact:

Re: Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Post by xav »

I got the Harmony Elite when it was on offer at Amazon three years ago. I hate it.

I've got a pretty complex setup: an older plasma TV with things plugged into every orifice (some older consoles and such, for example). The 'main' HDMI is connected to a surround sound box that switches between a further eight inputs. So a 'smart' remote that can have macros created is definitely what I need, and have previously used a series of Philips Pronto devices with much success. The Harmony? Not so much.

I'll spare you all the gory details, as this post would be far too long, but here are the headlines:
  • It doesn't like my older TV, which only has direct IR codes for some of the inputs, not all of them.
  • According to their database my TV only has one HDMI input (it has 3). But you can't override their database when setting up a device. I ended up having to send their support department photos of the back of my TV before they would believe me, but still they didn't correct the database.
  • I ended up having to lie about my TV by making up a model that wasn't in the database, then learning every single button on the original remote.
  • After 18 months the pointlessly touch-sensitive buttons for switching between activities and devices stopped working. But as I only ever used the activities screen, that wasn't too bad.
  • About 6 months ago the whole touchscreen started misbehaving. Sometimes it doesn't respond at all. Sometimes it gets stuck in an endless loop switching between the activities and devices views (and buzzing as it does so).
  • A power cycle fixes it - sometimes for 10 mins, sometimes for 2 weeks. But powering the remote off also turns off the TV and other devices, so can't always be done trivially.
  • Using the app to control things when the remote is playing up is hit-and-miss. Usually it works fine. But sometimes it has trouble connecting to the hub - or just loses the connection for no good reason. Sometimes it queues up button presses, appearing to do nothing, then sends them all at once.
I'm seriously considering going back to my last Pronto, if I can find the time to program it up again. When I finally get fed up enough with the Harmony I'm also thinking about using Flirc with a Raspberry Pi to effectively roll my own system. It won't be as pretty, or have as friendly a UI, but at least I'll be able to make it do exactly what I want.
Co-creator of The Greys, Monsters, Inked & Elvie webcomics
• Web Site • Twitter • Patreon •
User avatar
rowan
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7964
Joined: Tue Nov 25, 2003 11:53 pm 0
Location: Notts.

Re: Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Post by rowan »

Not meaning to hijack or piss on this thread but good goat, it makes me more glad than ever I don't have a telly.

A friend who always insisted on hooking up his NICAM stereo to go through his hifi 20+ years ago was enough to make me avoid it like the plague with all the remotes consuming the space of a person on the settee. If I went near it, there's no way I'd be getting sound the same day unless I unplugged it all to use the TV speaker.

But the level of madness here? You can keep it.. I'll stick to my monthly correspondence from the TVLA. :lol:
User avatar
Daniel
Baaaa!
Baaaa!
Posts: 563
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 12:09 pm 0
Location: Sweden.
Contact:

Re: Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Post by Daniel »

xav wrote:I got the Harmony Elite when it was on offer at Amazon three years ago. I hate it.
Nice to see that I am not alone. Had a Harmony once. I *really* tried to get it to work with my setup. But I found that the principle of controlling multiple devices using a sequence of transmit-only commands is very sensitive to transmission errors when the functions are toggled on/off with the same command. It did not help that the only way to program the thing was using a super-slow, super-buggy, web service.
In the end I throwed it in the bin.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Post by gilesgoat »

rowan wrote:Not meaning to hijack or piss on this thread but good goat, it makes me more glad than ever I don't have a telly.

A friend who always insisted on hooking up his NICAM stereo to go through his hifi 20+ years ago was enough to make me avoid it like the plague with all the remotes consuming the space of a person on the settee. If I went near it, there's no way I'd be getting sound the same day unless I unplugged it all to use the TV speaker.

But the level of madness here? You can keep it.. I'll stick to my monthly correspondence from the TVLA. :lol:
All we have is the PS4 connected to a TV and a "now super old" Sony 5.1 "decoder" with speakers .. and for some extra one "el cheapo" mechanical switch 3 to 1 HDMI box .. which works .. for when we want to OCCASIONALLY put the Switch/Chromecast on the main screen.

ONE single remote for volume , one TV remote, the PS4 controller .. end ..
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Post by Cloudane »

Misfit wrote: Great news, glad you got it sorted.

You could have saved yourself some time on yesterday's rant! :)
But it's fun! :lol:

Great stuff and YAY down to 1 controller and 0 addon devices (other than the consoles) and being able to say something like "Alexa, put the latest soandso youtube video on the TV" and have it turn on and do just that is quite something.

But if I have one thing to whinge about, it's how being 3ft from a 43" TV makes 4K suddenly "kind of necessary", making you realise how little 4K content there really is. 1080i/1080p looks fine as long as you tone down the sharpening (as it's designed to be viewed from a tad further away). SD looks like absolute potato camera dogshit though, and I wish it was possible to turn the upscaling off and simulate an old telly using big black borders. Some old Doctor Who episode really doesn't need to (vertically) fill the screen. But yeah first world problems of the higest order :mrgreen:
User avatar
xav
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2455
Joined: Thu Jun 06, 2002 5:32 pm 0
Location: Bucks, UK
Contact:

Re: Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Post by xav »

Daniel wrote:I found that the principle of controlling multiple devices using a sequence of transmit-only commands is very sensitive to transmission errors when the functions are toggled on/off with the same command.
It's worth expanding on this, in case anyone is tempted to buy one of these.

The primary design principal seems to be to make the remote 'smart' by having it maintain an internal record of the state it thinks all your devices are in. So if your device is turned on/off with a single command (rather than having separate on and off IR commands), it keeps an internal record of whether it thinks the device is currently on, or currently off.

Even if you do have separate commands, the Harmony still maintains an internal record. So if you push the 'off' button and someone walks in front of the TV as it's transmitting, blocking the signal, you're out of luck. You can't try pressing the off button again because the Harmony thinks it's already off, and won't let you do it.

It also likes to turn things off for you. A lot. It kind of makes sense: by turning things off you get them back to a common base, and the internal record is effectively re-synced with the state of the device. So whenever you switch to another device (e.g. Blu-ray player to Fire Stick) it turns one off and the other one on. On the whole it works okay, but can be a right pain when you just want to temporarily switch inputs. Ever paused a film to quickly catch the news headlines or see what the weather forecast is? Not with a Harmony, as your film-playing device will get switched off - and not everything resumes from where it was when powered back on again.

As for the Bluetooth capabilities. It's a nice idea in theory - make it act as a Bluetooth keyboard or game controller so that the Harmony remote can also operate your Fire Stick or power up your Wii U. Except that the pairing seems to get dropped with every firmware update, change of wind direction, or if you look at it the wrong way.

When I bought mine, I assumed I would be able to just program whatever series of commands I wanted, just as with the Pronto. But that's not the case. Certain combinations just aren't allowed (presumably because it interferes with its internal record). So don't buy one if you think it will give you geek-level control over command macros.

I know a lot of people rave about them, and are, presumably, very happy with the way they work. Perhaps my experience is worse than most. Perhaps it's just the combination of new and old gear I've got. But caveat emptor.
Co-creator of The Greys, Monsters, Inked & Elvie webcomics
• Web Site • Twitter • Patreon •
User avatar
Misfit
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10448
Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
Location: Nottingham UK
Contact:

Re: Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Post by Misfit »

xav wrote:
Daniel wrote:I found that the principle of controlling multiple devices using a sequence of transmit-only commands is very sensitive to transmission errors when the functions are toggled on/off with the same command.
It's worth expanding on this, in case anyone is tempted to buy one of these.

The primary design principal seems to be to make the remote 'smart' by having it maintain an internal record of the state it thinks all your devices are in. So if your device is turned on/off with a single command (rather than having separate on and off IR commands), it keeps an internal record of whether it thinks the device is currently on, or currently off.

Even if you do have separate commands, the Harmony still maintains an internal record. So if you push the 'off' button and someone walks in front of the TV as it's transmitting, blocking the signal, you're out of luck. You can't try pressing the off button again because the Harmony thinks it's already off, and won't let you do it.

It also likes to turn things off for you. A lot. It kind of makes sense: by turning things off you get them back to a common base, and the internal record is effectively re-synced with the state of the device. So whenever you switch to another device (e.g. Blu-ray player to Fire Stick) it turns one off and the other one on. On the whole it works okay, but can be a right pain when you just want to temporarily switch inputs. Ever paused a film to quickly catch the news headlines or see what the weather forecast is? Not with a Harmony, as your film-playing device will get switched off - and not everything resumes from where it was when powered back on again.

As for the Bluetooth capabilities. It's a nice idea in theory - make it act as a Bluetooth keyboard or game controller so that the Harmony remote can also operate your Fire Stick or power up your Wii U. Except that the pairing seems to get dropped with every firmware update, change of wind direction, or if you look at it the wrong way.

When I bought mine, I assumed I would be able to just program whatever series of commands I wanted, just as with the Pronto. But that's not the case. Certain combinations just aren't allowed (presumably because it interferes with its internal record). So don't buy one if you think it will give you geek-level control over command macros.

I know a lot of people rave about them, and are, presumably, very happy with the way they work. Perhaps my experience is worse than most. Perhaps it's just the combination of new and old gear I've got. But caveat emptor.
You used to be able to program what you want, but they do seem to have simplified things in the last few years to the detriment of the more competant power users.

And back in the early days I had far more issues with the state of devices you mention than I do now. I have practically none.

One thing you have to do is put away other remotes. They mess up the state!

But if the state does get out of sync, you press help and it runs through asking is this device off? is it now? does that fix it? A few taps and all is back together.

I'm certainly not saying your problems aren't real, but I have the family coping with kit that they just wouldn't turn on normally now.
User avatar
xav
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2455
Joined: Thu Jun 06, 2002 5:32 pm 0
Location: Bucks, UK
Contact:

Re: Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Post by xav »

Misfit wrote:One thing you have to do is put away other remotes. They mess up the state!
First thing I did. And removed the batteries. But now they've started coming back out again so that we can still adjust the volume when the Harmony remote goes into an endless cycle and the app doesn't work. But yes, it goes without saying that anything else that interferes with the one-true-source of IR data - whether that's another remote, or someone blocking the IR sensor - will cause it to get out of sync.
Misfit wrote:But if the state does get out of sync, you press help and it runs through asking is this device off? is it now? does that fix it? A few taps and all is back together.
That works maybe 70% of the time for me. Usually just powering everything off is quicker and easier.

It's also not such a good solution for anything that doesn't have a direct IR code. On my TV, for example, some inputs can be selected directly, but others need a sequence of steps (e.g. bring up the input menu, then arrow down three times, then OK). if that gets out of sync then the help function is largely useless, as 'arrow down three times' can mean something very different if it's already reacted to part of the sequence.

But to be clear, my previous post was intended more as a description for anyone who thinks it does nothing more than run a macro, blindly sending a sequence of events (as the Prontos do). The take-away was that it tries to track the state of your devices, and can easily be misled. That in itself is not a reason to dislike it, it's just the way it operates - but it's not something that is necessarily obvious to a potential buyer.


My own issues with it were primarily on trying to get the thing set up in the first place: I was basically accused of lying to them until I sent a photo of the back of my TV; then I ended up having to fake a non-existent device in order to hack my way round their broken database entry. More recently the combination of a flakey remote touchscreen with an app that isn't particularly reliable as an alternative has made it hit-or-miss as to whether we can even turn the TV on! One or two problems might be overlooked or explained, but for me the whole experience with this 'premium' product has been one of frustration and annoyance from start to finish.
Co-creator of The Greys, Monsters, Inked & Elvie webcomics
• Web Site • Twitter • Patreon •
The ghost of raids past
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1682
Joined: Sat Dec 03, 2005 7:38 pm 0

Re: Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Post by The ghost of raids past »

I backed this a couple of weeks ago. I hope it will reduce the number of remotes

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/15 ... =user_menu
User avatar
xav
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2455
Joined: Thu Jun 06, 2002 5:32 pm 0
Location: Bucks, UK
Contact:

Re: Home Theatre Remote Complexity

Post by xav »

More information and moaning about my Harmony Elite.

The physical remote now misbehaves so much (touchscreen stops working from time to time) that it's been retired completely, and we just use the app to control the hub.

The stability of the hub is now a lot better than when I last posted. I finally got fed up enough to investigate more thoroughly, and found some suggestions that it doesn't like its IP changing. So I gave it a fixed IP via the DHCP server on my router, and it's been a lot more stable since. It still craps out every month or two, which requires a reboot of my wifi access point before it settles down again. Note that nothing else on my network ever requires me to reboot the AP, and everything else manages to automatically pick up the same IP from DHCP when the leases renew, without the need for me to fix the addresses. I don't know what's special about the Harmony hub that it requires such fine tuning of my network, but at least we can go for a few weeks at a time without it failing to respond.


Last weekend, however, the hub managed to reach a new low, as it tried to kill me. I was adjusting a cable near the PSU, which caused the lead to move slightly - not much, and not with any significant force. Nevertheless, it was enough for the top of the PSU to pop off entirely. On closer inspection, the plastic weld around the PSU had given way under the pressure of the spring-loaded pins on the US-UK adaptor plate that clips onto it. Unfortunately it had popped off the PSU part, but left the adaptor plate in place - complete with its sprung metal pins sticking up into the air, and still connected directly into the mains socket! The bastard thing tried to electrocute me!!!

The one good thing about the hub is that the power connection is just a micro USB socket, so it's now temporarily running off an old phone charger.


It looks like Logitech has given up on the Harmony line: https://www.engadget.com/harmony-remote ... 10167.html

Hopefully this might mean another manufacturer steps into the gap to make a better "smart" IR remote. I doubt the market's big enough to support a large manufacturer (after all, if both Philips and Logitech have given up...), but perhaps there's an opportunity for a smaller company, or a good crowdsourced project.
Co-creator of The Greys, Monsters, Inked & Elvie webcomics
• Web Site • Twitter • Patreon •
Post Reply