gilesgoat wrote:Again this is a case "yes the economy but .. " .. BUT NOW you see WTF happens in not listening too much to science warning !
Unfortunately, yes.
And the thing is, scientists understand numbers better than economists do (economists are generally poor mathematicians - they assume things like "infinite growth", which is fundamentally impossible, and believe nonsense things like they can predict and control a chaotic system - which, again, is a mathematically impossible thing - so, when it comes to numbers, I'll believe the doctors over the economists).
This start / stop / start / stop of lockdown / release / lockdown / release will end up costing more over the long-term, than was ever won back for the economy in that small "window" of a few months where businesses could slowly limp along - as it was only limping, because you can't go back to full-blown "the old normal" consumerism, while this "sword of Damocles" hands above us all.
"Easing" of lockdown should have been true to that word. Easing is not "All shops can now open! Everyone can now go on holidays! All schools shall return! Open all the pubs!", but is a gradual phased approach, where you release restrictions one-by-one in small measured ways - monitoring, for a few weeks, that they aren't making things worse each time - and then you can "feel out" what's safe to leave open and what needs to, unfortunately, remain under restrictions. Reversing course, if necessary, should any release of restrictions fail to work (but only that last "easing" needs to be rolled back, as the previous "easings" will have proven themselves safe for many weeks and months already).
What I've found remarkable, so far, is the lack of consideration put towards making lockdown sustainable, so that we can sustain it in the long term - as we've already done this for most of the year, thus far, and face many more months ahead. Such as government grants to help businesses get online, investment and support for delivery firms, priority and assistance for the vulnerable and elderly in being able to do this (sorting out Internet for everyone), and that kind of thing. Ways to make lockdown itself work, rather than trying to find ways out of it or around it.
E.g. get the military to help in distributing food and essential items to those shielding, not just relying on them asking neighbours and friends to help out (not every elderly person, unfortunately, has many friends left nor knows their neighbours), and that the supermarkets will handle this all on their own (particularly when, at the start of the pandemic, when government told everyone to use home delivery, the supermarkets got together to say "sorry, that's just not possible, as we don't have anywhere near the capacity to handle that". They immediately got together to say "this is not possible, as home delivery was only 4% of our total business, you know - 'online' really hasn't taken over to anywhere near the extent that many people assume it has").
I guess, underlying that, is that no-one wants to accept, so baldly, that we honestly need to start doing things differently in lockdown, to make it work and make it less costly while we're in it, and everyone dreams - in "wishful thinking" mode - of the virus and lockdown just magically going away tomorrow.
And governments bow to landlords in trying to restore "the old normal" for them, while it very clearly can't hold. I know landlords are not used to their business ever being disrupted by anything - they're very much like funeral directors, who never see a dip in their trade - but now's the time that they have to learn what every other industry suffers all the time, that their business can be disrupted, and learn to live with it.
This impatience - and failure of imagination to believe anything but "the old normal" could ever exist and function - will, regrettably, cost lives.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes