Harlequin wrote:Cloudane wrote:Per Campbell's latest video, % required to be infected for herd immunity is proportional to R0. We seem to think that's about 2.5 for SARS-CoV-2 but of course the number varies based on social distancing/mixing.
A July study based on the Wuhan/China data "
calculated a median R0 value of 5.7 (95% CI 3.8–8.9)".
Yes, and I was about to point out that another study had revised March's "wild R" to around 3.5 too.
Although, of course, that's entirely the point that's being made here - that the "in the moment" R value can vary, depending on our behaviour. Which is why we have tighter restrictions, in an attempt to lower the R value again.
But there is the notion of a "wild R" value, which would be the R value "in the wild", if we carried on as normal and did nothing whatsoever to protect ourselves, unmodified by any behavioural changes. This, though, is necessarily an estimate - one hopes - as you wouldn't actually stand around, doing nothing, just to take a measurement of R.
Anyway, what's really significant about R values of 2.5, 3.5 or 5.7 is that these are extremely high numbers for R. In comparison, the "in hindsight" R value for the Spanish Flu pandemic was 1.8, and your average seasonal flu has an R of 1.26.
So, you know, even the most conservative R estimates here make this thing incredibly infectious - which is why we really should have been suspecting airborne transmission really early on (and some scientists exactly were suspecting this, as there were notable "super-spreader events" with choirs and people singing), as it seems deeply unlikely that you're going to get an R of 2.5 - 5.7 from something that's "contact transmission only".
But, unfortunately, the conservative advice - which, as I say, seemed based on the assumption this was like a flu, solely because a flu was what everyone based their pandemic response strategies on, as it was the most likely type of virus to become a pandemic - kept with "wash your hands" and even actively discouraged "wear your face mask" for too long in the early days.
This is a natural human thing, unfortunately, though. Like, if the first thing you heard was "it's really important to wash your hands and don't worry so much about face masks" then people internalise the advice, and it becomes harder to then alter it later. People stick by what they think they know - rightly so, because if you think you've got the right answer, then you should stick by it somewhat immovably to remain doing the right thing. But the problem is when the initial advice wasn't actually right, and you really need people to drop that and start doing something else, pronto, as there will be this initial resistance to it.
Or, put another way, ideas can also be said to possess inertia and momentum. When "at rest", it's hard to get it moving, and then once "in motion", it's hard to slow it down to bring it to rest in the right place. That's just how ideas are inside human heads, unfortunately. As mentioned, in a general abstract sense, it's only right that ideas possess inertia, because we really shouldn't be too fickle to keep changing our ideas every 2 seconds - because if you have got it right, then you should stick by it rather stubbornly. But, equally, one should avoid being too stubborn and "stuck in the mud" because it's entirely possible, especially with something new and unknown like this, that our initial ideas weren't actually correct - or not quite correct enough, even if in the right "ballpark".
Indeed, as has been correctly emphasised since, from the evidence, even though we should be paying more attention to airborne transmission of this thing - and wearing our face masks - this doesn't actually mean that contact transmission can't happen - so you should still be washing your hands - but the evidence, as it's come in, has suggested that contact transmission seems low, and it's the airborne transmission we should have always been worrying about.
But, yeah, the % required for "wild herd immunity" does depend on how naturally infectious this thing is. And, indeed, on how many people have already been infected too. And on our behaviour.
As the point is that what "wild herd immunity" is about is the natural "blocking" effect of those who've already had it - their antibodies / memory T cells blocking re-infection (and, in fairness, on that one, we seem mercifully lucky there, as there seem to be very few reports of proven re-infection with this virus, in comparison to, you know, that over 40 million people have been confirmed as having this worldwide) - to stop further spread.
And it should be noted that herd immunity - whether obtained by wild transmission, or safely controlled through vaccination - is never 100%. Though reports of confirmed re-infection are very low - considering the overall numbers - they're not zero.
And, of course, there's very much a statistical "on average" thing about this. You might have 70% of the overall population with immunity, but the virus could still gain a foothold here and there, where it just naturally finds pockets of people who've never had it.
We might have, say, 70% "herd immunity" overall but that's an "on average" thing. In practice, it might be, say, only 50% in the Midlands, 90% in London, etc. - and it just all averages out to 70% overall. And the virus might find its way to a small town somewhere, where immunity is only 30%, say, and then it could gain a foothold there.
And no vaccine ever developed has been 100% effective. Indeed, it's considered a very big win, if a vaccine proves to be 75% effective.
It's the old mathematical rule of thumb. When dealing with the real world, you need to think statistically and in a "Bayesian" manner. Nothing in the real world is ever a perfect zero or a perfect 100%. Growth curves are ogives, natural distributions are almost always bell curves. You should always think in terms of ranges, not precise values. Always build in a "margin of error" into everything. And expect that values in the real world always fluctuate up and down chaotically.
This is just, in practice, how maths actually works in the real world:
Well, I did attempt to "manage expectations" on a vaccine earlier in the thread. To emphasise that we should not expect "bullet-proof immunity", but rather just improved "resistance". That "herd immunity" refers to how much immunity there might be within "the herd", not that the entire herd is 100% immune.
You get the gist, if you read that article. Manage our expectations. Vaccines will certainly help immeasurably - but the virus will not just instantly disappear in a puff of smoke overnight. Nothing can do that. It's, unfortunately, more of a hard slog of us getting better and better at resisting it - through natural immunity, through vaccines, through restrictions, through new drugs and treatments - to push it further and further back.
We're wading through mud.
This was kind of what I was getting at when I suggested that we needed to work on making lockdown sustainable, so that we could sustain it in the long-term. Work out how we can live and work and keep the economy going with restrictions in place - because, realistically, we're going to have to keep this going for a while, so we need to make it possible - and least inconvenient - for all of us to do so. And I said that months back, in lockdown, as there was enthusiastic talk of lifting restrictions.
Not to pull a "I told you so", but we are where we are and maybe you can begin to see why I was saying these things earlier. Managing expectations for what we now currently face, and what we will rather inevitably face going forward.
There will be no "light switch" moment, where everything's instantly back to normal again. It'll rather be this hard slog - wading through mud - where we've got to keep on going, and it'll eventually get easier and the ground'll get firmer. And we should really prepare our mindset for that, because there's still an awful lot of mud left for us to push our way through yet. It's a dimmer switch back to normality, not a flick of a light switch and everything's fine again.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes