Oh dear.
Drakeford was doing well with this "fire break" idea. But, then, all of a sudden - barely giving shops time to react - he's banning the sale of "non-essential items" in the essential supermarkets and shops staying open. They have to literally cordon off aisles and stop their sale, if it ain't strictly food and medicine (although, yes, the shops themselves are annoyed not only at the fact that this was sprung on them 24 hours before they were expected to do it, but that there's been no explicit clarity on what counts as "essential" here. Like presumably cleaning products count - as we need those for fighting the virus directly - but what about, say, a Glade plugin air freshener, which is typically in the same aisle? Do the shops have to re-order their shelves to be able to keep "essential" away from "non-essential", so they can cover the "non-essential" stuff and forbid their purchase?).
Like Drakeford was looking like the leader who was most taking the virus and the science seriously, but then he's gone all Boris and is insisting on confusing shit because he wants to "ensure a level playing field".
Right, a level playing field with shops that are closed. How does that really help anyone?
Bearing in mind that Amazon do have one of their massive "mothership" fulfilment centres just outside Swansea. So, you know, if folks need any such items, then they're being forced by the Welsh government to not shop locally, but to order it all from Amazon instead.
Seriously, if I were, say, a local DIY store that's been forced to close as "non-essential" - though I would dispute that classification in the first place, when if you're asking people to "stay at home", then you've got to allow those people to maintain their homes, right? - then I'd rather they were buying, say, their drill bits or whatever DIY hardware it is they need from my local rival Tesco store, than for all of us to lose when this sends all our customers to Amazon, with the prospect that they'll never come back to their local town centre ever again.
He's not thought this through properly.
(And this also speaks to what I've been saying all along about "making lockdown sustainable". Truth is, governments should have been doing more to assist businesses in this pandemic with, you know, grants for setting up online sales. Assistance to help make home deliveries more practicable for all businesses. And, yes, I know - governments giving businesses taxpayer money to help them "go digital"? You wouldn't ordinarily do that, sure. But
this is a pandemic, it's needed.
I think that's my frustration with governments and politicians generally - local ones included - that they've not changed their mindsets to meet the challenge. Initially, they had to lockdown - though, yeah, we can go into how, if they'd reacted sooner and got test and trace up and running before this hit, then South Korea and others show it is possible to have avoided even that - but then it was all about how to get back to normal again.
They used the phrase "the new normal", but they didn't really do anything towards that. Boris just declared all non-essential shops re-opened. And you can go on holidays again. And all schools will re-open. And everyone should go back to the office - heck, even if things are working out fine with "work from home", he was seemingly overriding the employee-employer relationship to tell employees to go back, even if their employers didn't yet want that.
I feel some sympathy to even the "Cov-idiots" here, in that if you've shut absolutely everything down for lock down, then you re-open absolutely everything simultaneously and
tell people to go back to normal, then you are implicitly saying "okay, it's all over now. Go back to how you were".
I mean, I pay attention to the politics and the science and stuff, so I could see that this was disastrously wrong - as I've been saying in this thread - but I do get it that, for others, who're trying to get on with their lives and don't follow this stuff, but just listen for "leadership" from our great leaders, then this totally binary approach to virus management does implicitly say "okay, it's all over now" and I don't entirely blame people for starting to behave in that way.
This was totally the message that the UK government was broadcasting. Literally. As Boris came on TV, with the same seriousness and "this is an important national address" background of his Downing Street office behind him - that "Churchillean look" - to say "everyone should now go back to the office, schools will now fully re-open, we have an 'air bridge' with Spain so go on your hols, and it'll be totally over by Christmas".
We'd had that before - bookending the beginning of lockdown - and now he was doing it again - apparently bookending the end of lockdown, right? - so, if you were not obsessively following the science on the virus and the politics (which, you know, there is an argument that folks like me who do actually do that should find a better hobby that's more conducive to one's mental health - although I know not to do that, simply because our politicians are fucking idiots, so you simply can't reasonably do that or they will, as they have done, happily lead us off a cliff edge of disaster, while singing "Rule Britannia!"), then that was totally 100% the image all this was sending out: "It's over. Go back to normal. Everything's fine and it'll be all over by Christmas".
They should have been actively assisting in making "the new normal" a thing.
Deckard wrote:Somewhere like Bristol where I used to live - cover the entire town centre so everyone can drink/eat outside all year round and do it with any other big towns too. Make them all far more people friendly as they and not cars will save the town centre businesses....if this is ongoing then a lot of "old" ideas need to be jettisoned fast.
Now, this is exactly what I mean by "making lockdown sustainable".
I've been to those "food courts" that are popular in Asian countries, and those actually work like that.
Well, sort of. I'm thinking of one I visited in Thailand that had no need for cover because, you know, it never rains there (and should it rain, the temperatures mean that it's all bone dry 5 minutes later anyway). But there was a big area next to a shopping centre with tables and chairs. Then, around that area, there were stalls selling food and drink. So I got my chicken and rice, and some Tiger beer from the stalls around the edge and then you find a place to sit in the communal eating area. And there were entertainments - music being played and such - for the whole area, so you could enjoy that while you munched or knocked back a few... well, I was going to say "pints" but that's not actually the metric used outside the Anglo-Saxon countries. But you know what I mean.
We could, indeed, create an impromptu version of this. Cover over the town square - or other suitable large available area - to protect from the rain and then lay out a bunch of "socially distanced" tables and chairs for everyone. You go to the food shops and pubs - who're acting in a "take-away" capacity here, so that's within the rules - to order your food and a drink, then find somewhere to sit in this make-shift outdoor "food court".
I'm sure the local businesses - if it allows them to trade and make money - would lay on a bit of a "table service" for this too, if you wanted to ensure it's even more "covid secure".
This is the kind of thing I'm getting at with "making lockdown sustainable". The way we usually do things doesn't work with a pandemic, so let's innovate new ways to do what we need to do that's "pandemic friendly" (to coin a rather horrible term there). Assist businesses to do this sort of thing - the local council can sort out covering the town square (as that area would be publicly owned, so it's their responsibility) and the tables and chairs, then the local businesses would work with them to maintain that area and make sure that it really is being operated in a "covid secure" way.
Assist businesses with online orders, home deliveries and maybe "apps" that helps make trading in a pandemic easier. Provide grants, information to businesses about how to do this, partner businesses up so that those who make websites and apps are introduced to those who need them right now.
An acceptance that this is not going away tomorrow. I'm sorry, but it just isn't. I'd love to say otherwise, but that's just not how the facts here stack up.
So we've got to work out how best to allow as much as possible to carry on, in a "covid secure" way, and then directly help businesses and consumers and everyone to do that.
Drakeford cutting off "non-essential items" doesn't really help consumers nor businesses. The "level playing field" he's trying to create is one with closed businesses that can't trade. Well, that's dumb. You're just stopping things dead, rather than assisting for things to carry on in a "covid safe" way instead. It's not going to work as he thinks, because Amazon exists. What these local businesses could actually do with is assistance to be able to compete with Amazon.
It's a fucking mess and that's because they've all done it wrong. As they've been trying to maintain the old order - and where that can't happen, they've just shut down civilisation completely - rather than adapted, and helped others adapt, to what now needs to be done.
That's why I vented about Boris bowing to the commercial landlords with his "go back to the office" - I'm sorry, but it's your employer who tells you to return to the office and it's not the government's business to tell businesses how they should operate - because his rich mates need their "money for nothing" incomes back. Our latter day "feudal system" needs the serfs back on the Lord's properties, paying their rents and tithes to prop up the inequalities of a broken hierarchy.
Things must change. And things will change.
Jefferson's "sufferable evil":
Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly all experience hath shewn, that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed. But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security
Tyrants never get this. They are
never getting away with it. Not even once, not even an inch. But we, the people, will, indeed, be "more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed".
We ain't forgiving nor forgetting a single bit of it. I mean, when their cock-ups have killed off our parents or grandparents in care homes, or their policies now mean we're on the Dole, or we're all living in anxiety that we're not 100% sure that e can pay our rents to our Lords and our tithes to government by the end of the month, it's hardly possible for any of us to actually forget that. Even if we wanted to, which we absolutely don't.
But life is shit and unfair, so you suffer its evils - as you must - while evils are sufferable.
But these idiots need to be wary that this "get out of jail free" card doesn't last forever nor forgive everything. It has limited uses. You're not really getting away with - not one bit - but it all just adds to the pressure cooker boiling underneath.
Because, simply, we're not, indeed, going to start riots and civil disobedience "for light and transient causes". That shit fucks us up, as much as it does you. You don't do it lightly. But when we, the people, end up forced to act like this - when the lid of the pressure cooker blows - then you will reap the whirlwind of their wrath.
And you really, really don't want to be doing that.
Because, you know, in the French Revolution, that involved guillotines separating people's heads from their bodies. Or it might involve pitchforks and stringing people up from the nearest tree. To be clear, I absolutely 100% do not endorse such behaviour - the whole point here is trying to get through to our "Lords and Masters" that they need to stop being idiots, as I exactly don't want to see the need for any of this to ever happen. As it doesn't have to happen, if they just behave themselves and throw a few "bread and circuses" to the masses sometimes. Seriously, if you're supplying the cake then, actually, "let them eat cake" - you'll get away with that, as people like cakes.
The more our elected idiots run the established systems into the ground, then the faster those systems will necessarily have to die. And that's totally
their fault. Things can only be suffered, while they're sufferable. Evil included. You don't want to be going beyond "sufferable" at any point, as we, the people, always outnumber you twats by a very gargantuan ratio, and don't you ever forget it.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes