Nailed it.Foozwah wrote:It really is one of those "only as strong as your weakest link" things, and we unfortunately also had no shortage of "no masker" protests and whatnot, by short sighted folk who somehow couldn't see that they were actually the ones keeping us under lockdown even longer.
This is also true of those who've been pulling the "but won't somebody think about the economy?!?" folks have been essentially doing as well.
"Re-open the pubs! Re-open the shops! Send everyone back to the office!"
Okay, but when the virus cases inevitably start rising exponentially again, then you're back into second lockdown, third lockdown, fourth lockdown... and how does that ultimately help the economy?
We bailed everybody out back in March. Paid most of their wages. We got cases down, with months and months of the first lockdown.
But now we're back to essentially where we were in March - actually, by some metrics, it's worse - and we're facing another lockdown, which will require the chancellor to, again, bail everybody out and pay most of their wages.
So, the horrible blunt question is: What did all those months of lockdown in March buy us? When we paid out all that furlough, what did it buy us?
The amounts of cash that have been spent on this - governments subsidising the entire economy for months on end - are easily the largest amounts of spending that have ever been paid out in all of human history. But, well, if we're yet again "back to square one" and need to keep paying. With the possibility that this second lockdown doesn't prove any more productive in the long term, as calls for "re-open the pubs! re-open the shops!" after this could lead to yet another rise in cases that mandates a third lockdown...
What are we paying this money for? What is it buying us?
I'm sure you know the famous "definition of madness". To repeatedly keep performing the same failed action, yet expecting different results.
For me, the most significant thing is that Australia has stopped everyone - but citizens and permanent residents returning home - entering the country until the end of 2021. Cutting off "imports", kicking things back off again. And the chosen deadline there is time enough to get the domestic cases right down, and have a year-long vaccination programme - for safe and controlled herd immunity - before opening back up to the world.
The real insanity of UK policy is having lockdowns, furlough and all this other stuff, while - by all reports - absolutely nothing at the airports. This is like being in a boat filled with water, using a bucket to bail out the water... but doing absolutely nothing about the hole in the side of the boat that's letting all the water in. "Quick, bail faster". Yeah, but if you've still got the hole letting in water, then you'll be bailing forever.
As I say, in my job, we do work for other local businesses. They were cancelling and postponing jobs weeks before Boris declared lockdown. Those organising "mass gatherings" were cancelling and postponing events, not because Boris told them to, but because events require a lot of up-front costs - hiring the venue, hiring the security, hiring catering, building a stage and installing a sound system, etc. - and if they don't get at least X amount of people through the doors to at least cover those costs, much less make a profit, then they'll be haemorrhaging money. They simply can't operate in an environment where there's serious uncertainty that anyone will actually show up - and people won't show up, if there's a virus running rampage across the country.
When Boris failed to ban mass gatherings - in that wasted week where he unnecessarily made things four times worse by the numbers - then all the major sporting leagues cancelled and postponed the very next day. Now, come on, the Premier League, for example, is a multi-billion pound business and involves all the teams. They didn't just wing their response that morning. The postponement was planned weeks in advance and they were only waiting for Boris to speak first to see if they'd be able to claim on the insurance - if the government bans it, that's an event outside their control that insurance would pay out on. Boris didn't give them that, but yet they still cancelled anyway, even though, in terms of insurance, voluntarily cancelling an event off your own back likely pays out absolutely nothing at all.
I saw it. The economy was nose-diving before lockdown. The virus is what's wrecking the economy, not lockdown (one Monday, we lost tens of thousands of pounds of work in a single morning). Lockdown is the - yes, rather drastic - attempt at killing off the problem, to make the economy viable (and, hey, even with these idiots in charge, not really helping the situation at all, we did still get the Summer months with some small semblance of relative normality - the first lockdown bought us that breathing room).
I predicted it months back. I said that if we don't deal with things, we'll be back in second lockdown - and here it comes - and, indeed, having to pay out tremendous amounts of cash in furlough payments to keep everyone going. And that this would essentially mean that the first lockdown was wasted, as we're right back to where we were, the economy stalled again, paying out silly money all over again. Because we failed to use the first lockdown to fix things - test and trace, hospital capacity, making lockdown sustainable, etc. - so we're right back to where we were.
And it's not me failing to think about the economy, it's the politicians failing to understand how any of this actually works - and, in their impatience, like the "no maskers" stupidly prolonging how long restrictions will last, damaging the economy again and again.
Why did we lockdown? What did we actually buy for all that bail out money?
And the problem is, I see zero sign that any lessons have been learnt. It'll be a month of lockdown and hopefully the R goes below one, then they'll scream "won't somebody think about the economy?!?" and we'll do it all over again.





