I covered this earlier, in mentioning Tony Blair was advocating this idea (and it seems Boris agreed with him, as they pretty much immediately adopted the policy).
It's not really a scientific question.
(Well, I mean, ultimately, everything is a scientific question - as science means knowledge, after all - and one could argue that there are pros and cons that one could logically and arithmetically evaluate. There are two paths and, logically, each path produces a different result and one will be better than another.
But, to reverse the quote, science tells us how the Heavens go, it doesn't tell us how to reach Heaven.
This is not a binary "right / wrong answer" thing, but a statistical thing. We're attempting to forecast the future.)
The essence of the question is, is it better to vaccinate 2 million people with partial protection, or is it better to vaccinate 1 million people with full protection?
Should we go breadth-first or depth-first?
A big factor in answering that question is supply. It's worth noting that we should have had 4 million doses of the Oxford vaccine - that was the promise - but, though enough of it has been made, apparently, only about 500K has been properly bottled up and prepared for use.
So, you know, if we had all 100 million doses already ready to go then, without question, you go "depth first" - two jabs - as you know you've got the second dose ready to go.
But if it is going to dribble out more slowly in batches of 500K then I can see the thinking behind going "breadth first" - one jab to as many people as possible - to get the widest possible range of protection. Albeit only partial protection.
Another factor to consider in this is that the majority of people, in all age groups, does avoid severe illness and death. So, even partial protection, widely held across the population, could make a massive difference much sooner.
That is, we are against the clock here. If you take time to do two jabs, then it'll take longer to get around to giving some people any protection at all. If you give one jab, then you can reach more people sooner, albeit with partial protection - but if the supply issues are resolved over time (12 weeks?) then you can go back and turn that into full protection.
I'm not a fan of the government and have criticised their policies throughout this. But this one is a bit more subtle. It's not a simple "government = bad" thing.
It's a judgement call. And I'm not sure that they aren't, in fact, calling it right, in the grand scheme of things.
It's not clear cut. I've been happy to call out the government for straying from the science, but this time it's not really that kind of question. It's a logistics question. An implementation thing. An engineering question.
Ultimately, a maths question. And I'm not entirely sure that the numbers don't actually back up that "breadth first" approach - particularly if the government knows it's going to have initial supply problems.
Certainly, with the Pfizer vaccine, our initial order will run out by the end of January, at current rates. We don't have another order until March. Pfizer does have other orders with pretty much the rest of the world that it also has to fulfil. Without the Oxford vaccine, we'd have a gap in February.
Thing is, we were told that the Oxford vaccine had 4 million doses prepared. Apparently, when it got approved, that's "prepared" in the sense of manufactured, but not "prepared" in the sense of bottled up, packaged and ready to go. They only, in fact, delivered 500K. Like, an eighth of what was expected.
I think the government sees that the supply isn't coming as quickly as promised, so it's going "breadth first" to get as many single doses out there as possible, hoping that the supply problems resolve in the intervening 12 weeks.
I do hope that involves the government saying "do you need another factory? Here, have another one on us". For a country's treasury, the cost of another factory is basically nothing, and we need this now. Plus, I mean, though I was against Brexit, now that we've got it then let's take advantage of where it can be handy - we can explicitly do "state aid" now. Our government can just give AstraZenica direct financial assistance to speed this along.
It's a tricky call and I'm not confident to say that this is necessarily the wrong thing to do. Arithmetically, if there really are supply problems, then it might actually be the right call. Can't totally tell for sure, as I don't have the numbers on supply, or details of what exactly is wrong, nor is there sufficient transparency on how the whole vaccination programme is going.
Basically, this is the trolley problem:
Pull the switch and you kill one person. But don't pull the switch and five die instead. Do you pull the switch or not? Neither option is good, but one is clearly "the lesser of two evils".
And maybe pulling the switch is, indeed, "the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few". But it is a tough call, as I'm very much Kant-ian in my moral philosophy, so Spock's purely Utilitarian argument doesn't wholly convince me. But if there is no possible way to stop the trolley and someone has to get run over, pulling the switch saves 5 for the loss of 1. The Utilitarian argument might have to win, if there are no other options for avoidance of the problem in the first place.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes