Coronavirus Pandemic

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by KlaxonCow »

F-ZeroOne wrote:I've joked with family that I want to know who is really running the UKs vaccination programme, because I'm having difficulty based on their track record believing its the current government.
Ah, that's because the UK government called in the military to handle the logistics, and the NHS, of course, does the actual vaccinations.

I saw an interview with the Welsh minister in charge of the vaccine roll-out in Wales and, in the background, were a bunch of people in military camouflage gear on their laptops, coordinating things.

Yes, without doubt, that was a photo op. The choice of background for a political interview is never accidental.

But the point they were making - that the military has been drafted in, as they are the logistics experts - is a point that perhaps Westminster could also do with making, by doing their interviews in front of some soldiers coordinating the programme, in the same way.

The military know what they're doing. The NHS know what they're doing. The pharmaceutical industry knows what it's doing.

The real reason that the UK's programme's going well so far? Because the politicians got out of the fucking way.

The NHS has always known how to do vaccinations. Simply, the UK has the biggest take-up of annual flu jabs anywhere in the world.

Doing things at this scale is, of course, unprecedented, but the army were called in to handle the logistics. And those guys know what they're doing - because, simply, they have to. They have to do mad shit like drop massive engineering projects in the middle of war zones, and actually somehow get away with doing that. And, like the NHS, it's all immensely pragmatic, not theory or ideology. If they don't do it right, then the enemy murders them all. So the military are very good - the foremost experts - in pulling off on-the-fly logistics, often of immense scale, and getting it exactly right on their first go. Because if they don't learn how to do that well then, bluntly, they all end up dead and we lose whatever war they're involved in.

Meanwhile, for the EU, it's "bureaucracy, bureaucracy, bureaucracy". National politicians sticking their oar in, to not look completely useless. Having to agree every step at 27 ways, before you can move forward.

The politicians lead, so they end up doing silly political things, like pissing about with Article 16 to mess around, in a paranoid fashion, with international politics. When they should be being purely pragmatic, to get as many jabs in arms as possible.

What's the saying? "When all you've got is a hammer, everything looks like a nail".

When you've got politicians in charge, everything looks like a legal negotiation. It's all laws this, and treaties that, and export controls the other. Because that's what politicians do - that is their hammer - so they're trying to bang everything they see down with their ideological nails.

The reason why the UK government is looking good with this vaccine roll-out programme? Because they, for once, had the sense to have very little to do with it. Handed it off to the experts. Let the military do it, instead of palming it off on some private company owned by their ill-qualified mates, to essentially embezzle taxpayer money. You know, what they normally do.

Quite why, in this instance, they actually uncharacteristically made the right decision to not insert themselves into things and fuck it all up, is a mystery.

My guess is that, of course, it's not that they've grown a brain at any point. I'm thinking it's more a conscience / legal liability thing. They've fucked things up too many times in a row - which, you know, is definitely going to result in public inquiries and lawsuits and everything against them - and they're trying to minimise their legal and, thus, financial liability for this rolling catastrophe. Sometimes, selfishness can result in people doing the right thing, ironically enough.

Why is this going well? Because the UK government has, in fact, very little to nothing to do with it. That's basically why.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
merman
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10943
Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: merman1974
Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
Location: Skegness, England
Contact:

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by merman »

Boris is talking about “data not dates” today, trying to give the impression he is actually following the science this time.

One thing to note - myself and those shielding have now been told to keep shielding until March 31st. An additional 1.7 million people will be told to shield, based on risk and health conditions. So if the schools are going back on the 8th of March, it shows that someone was paying attention to the scientists who stressed that lifting restrictions in one area (schools) would mean restrictions elsewhere (continued shielding for the most vulnerable until vaccination is more widespread).


What does worry me that people are already talking again about “living with COVID”, affecting annual outbreaks in winter that would kill a few thousand every year. Is that really and morally acceptable?
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by gilesgoat »

merman wrote:*SNIP*

What does worry me that people are already talking again about “living with COVID”, affecting annual outbreaks in winter that would kill a few thousand every year. Is that really and morally acceptable?
Hard to say but if that really would be "a few thousands every year" with everything else "more or less looking normal" isn't this what already happens with common flu and such ?

"In an absolute scheme of things" there's that "every life is sacred" so you could say that "even ONE death per year cause that is NOT good enough".

Overall I think in a way "the best medium term outcome" would be MAYBE/really (?) if Covid could turn out one day "like a common flu" where "you get some pills/stuff, you'll be fine in a week" with .. "the same number of deaths due to common flu per year" .. which could be those "a few thousands" every year.

I said "medium term outcome" in the sense "if we could manage to arrive at the point it to make par as dangerous as common flu".

Total eradication .. who knows .. could take longer than a few lifetimes I suppose, I am guessing nor me nor you we'll see that in our lifetime ?

But the other question is .. "if a few thousands every year" bothers you .. for covid .. think at the amounts of other people dying like that we don't really know precise numbers per year .. or maybe even every day .. not for Covid or such but for the wealth "of the Civilized Western World" ...

iPhones, iPads, big tech, Facebook, Google and all the rest ...

And that apparently is "very socially acceptable" already .. .. :?
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by KlaxonCow »

merman wrote:Boris is talking about “data not dates” today, trying to give the impression he is actually following the science this time.
Actually, that one is just a straight theft from Plaid Cymru leader Adam Price:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-politics-56070009
The Welsh Government's lockdown easing roadmap has to be "built around data not dates", said the Plaid Cymru leader Adam Price.

"That's absolutely critical, so you can't set an arbitrary date", he said, adding there should be a "phased step by step approach rather than all at once".
I saw him say this days ago on TV.

I guess it polled well with the focus groups, and so the PR firm advised that Boris should just steal it. Perhaps exactly because I think his ridiculous use of the word "irreversible" for lockdown easing landed so badly.

The Welsh health minister certainly didn't feel it was remotely sensible to be promising things that you fundamentally cannot guarantee:
[Boris Johnson] added: "So we have got to be very prudent and what we want to see is progress that is cautious but irreversible. I think that is what the public, people up and down the country, want to see."

At Monday's press conference, Mr Gething warned there was a "danger" of setting out "absolutes" by talking about whether lockdown lifting was "irreversible".

"If we make cautious steps outwards, then it will still very much feel like a form of lockdown for most people, because we're not going to be returning straight away to what we thought of as our normal lives just over a year ago.

"So yes we don't want to see a return to having to introduce more restrictions, but I wouldn't say we can give a cast iron guarantee that would never happen."
So, basically, Boris blurted out silly nonsense on the Monday. To which everyone rightly reacted with some horror at the "irreversible" declaration, as that's just patently ridicoulous.

Like, if he'd said "we hope and are aiming for it to be irreversible, but that cannot be guaranteed" then fair enough. Or if he suggested "we're aiming to get kids back into school by March - that's our hope - but, obviously, the exact timing depends on how well we're keeping on top of the virus".

Basically, what "data not dates" snappily captures. Not "blindly open schools by March 15th, no matter what the fuck is going on in the world", but rather "once we've seen cases consistently below 300 for a week, it'll be safe to re-open schools - at current rates, with things not getting any worse, that looks like it might happen around mid-March".

We can only hope that Boris decides to actually steal the policy, and not just the words, from the grown ups in the room. Because Adam Price is entirely on the money that this should be governed by "data, not dates".
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by KlaxonCow »

Not a "told you so" I'm happy to report.

But, yeah, I did say that I was deeply worried about the US brewing up variants of the virus, as their numbers were astronomical compared to everywhere else and, under Trump, there simply was no coordinated federal genomics programme to monitor it all.

Well, with Trump gone, this shit can now be properly monitored and reported on. But the news ain't great.

"7 Virus Variants Found in U.S. Carrying the Same Mutation":

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/14/heal ... ution.html

Seven. Seven variants from the US alone.

This shit is not being appreciated by the politicians, but keeping case numbers down - flattening the curve - was not just about reducing cases and deaths, it's about reducing the risks of mutation. And, eventually, at some point, the virus will mutate its way around our defences, if we give it enough rope to hang us. This is an inevitability - because it's simply natural selection at work.

I still hope we're in time. The vaccines remain effective for now - though, yeah, with every mutant variant that the politicians just allow to breed out there, it gets less effective and it will eventually escape - but the world's leaders have brought us so horribly close to the brink, where we are rushing vaccination against the backdrop of getting it all done in time, before the variants actually end up winning this battle. This should not have been such a neck-and-neck race here.

I'm not psychic, of course. I just looked at the numbers and this made it rather inevitable that America must be breeding variants, and they were just not tracking them properly under Trump, as we all know his "don't look and then you can pretend there is no problem" policy.

Like, mathematically, this shit is easy cheese to predict. But our leaders still, clearly having no fucking clue what's going on, act shocked and surprised that - wow! - it turns out that natural selection is actually a real thing. They still don't understand what the word "exponential" means, and why, when you do understand its meaning, that you act as immediately as possible. Not fuck about for a few weeks, and then announce that a new restriction's coming on Monday, so don't forget to all crowd the pubs and really get this virus spreading over the weekend!

But, yeah, 7 variants. I didn't see that coming. That's kind of disastrous and totally Trump's fault.

And, to add insult to the injury, they also think they've found one of these US variants merging with the UK variant. This is rather terrifying. If the variants are "sharing notes" like this - because, simply, we're not keeping a tight enough lid on this - then they will find "vaccine escape" even faster.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by zip accident »

KlaxonCow wrote:
merman wrote:Boris is talking about “data not dates” today, trying to give the impression he is actually following the science this time.
Actually, that one is just a straight theft from Plaid Cymru leader Adam Price:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-politics-56070009
The Welsh Government's lockdown easing roadmap has to be "built around data not dates", said the Plaid Cymru leader Adam Price.

"That's absolutely critical, so you can't set an arbitrary date", he said, adding there should be a "phased step by step approach rather than all at once".
I saw him say this days ago on TV.

I guess it polled well with the focus groups, and so the PR firm advised that Boris should just steal it. Perhaps exactly because I think his ridiculous use of the word "irreversible" for lockdown easing landed so badly.

The Welsh health minister certainly didn't feel it was remotely sensible to be promising things that you fundamentally cannot guarantee:
[Boris Johnson] added: "So we have got to be very prudent and what we want to see is progress that is cautious but irreversible. I think that is what the public, people up and down the country, want to see."

At Monday's press conference, Mr Gething warned there was a "danger" of setting out "absolutes" by talking about whether lockdown lifting was "irreversible".

"If we make cautious steps outwards, then it will still very much feel like a form of lockdown for most people, because we're not going to be returning straight away to what we thought of as our normal lives just over a year ago.

"So yes we don't want to see a return to having to introduce more restrictions, but I wouldn't say we can give a cast iron guarantee that would never happen."
So, basically, Boris blurted out silly nonsense on the Monday. To which everyone rightly reacted with some horror at the "irreversible" declaration, as that's just patently ridicoulous.

Like, if he'd said "we hope and are aiming for it to be irreversible, but that cannot be guaranteed" then fair enough. Or if he suggested "we're aiming to get kids back into school by March - that's our hope - but, obviously, the exact timing depends on how well we're keeping on top of the virus".

Basically, what "data not dates" snappily captures. Not "blindly open schools by March 15th, no matter what the fuck is going on in the world", but rather "once we've seen cases consistently below 300 for a week, it'll be safe to re-open schools - at current rates, with things not getting any worse, that looks like it might happen around mid-March".

We can only hope that Boris decides to actually steal the policy, and not just the words, from the grown ups in the room. Because Adam Price is entirely on the money that this should be governed by "data, not dates".
I think Boris is one of the "literally really means figuratively" people, and he takes the same view of all words, they don't mean anything to him, so long as they sound good that's okay, and forget the meaning of them.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
F-ZeroOne
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8213
Joined: Wed Sep 29, 2004 8:27 pm 0

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by F-ZeroOne »

KlaxonCow, yes, a family member also suggested to me that the military and NHS were organising things for the large part. There must be some political involvement because investment on the scale needed would almost certainly require it, but the "practical" aspect of it... for some reason, military involvement hasn't turned up an awful lot in the news sources I use. Call me cynical for suspecting its because the politicians want to claim the credit later... :)

(I have an interest in military history so I'm familiar with how important logistics are to any military campaign).
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by Cloudane »

gilesgoat wrote:
merman wrote:*SNIP*

What does worry me that people are already talking again about “living with COVID”, affecting annual outbreaks in winter that would kill a few thousand every year. Is that really and morally acceptable?
Hard to say but if that really would be "a few thousands every year" with everything else "more or less looking normal" isn't this what already happens with common flu and such ?

"In an absolute scheme of things" there's that "every life is sacred" so you could say that "even ONE death per year cause that is NOT good enough".
This... I think also once it's down to flu levels of danger thanks to vaccines and treatments it definitely has to be weighed up against other risks - if you want to lock down every winter to try and save "those few thousand" (probably flu as well if we get to that point) then you need to really closely examine the risks in terms of mental health, economy, late cancer diagnosis and missed treatments due to keeping everyone indoors and terrified of catching winter bugs and so on. Because then things like cancer deaths and suicides could end up exceeding it, or more subtly, overall shortened lifespans due to increased seasonal stress, depression and anxiety. Plus if everyone is "losing" x amount of their life every year, does this justify "the maybe 1 year or so extra you gave a small number of frail and elderly who would've been pushed over the edge by the virus" (I know this sounds really cruel and callous but these are the difficult questions the government have to answer, and I know it affects a wide range of people NOW but we're talking about when vaccines and treatments bring it down to flu levels of danger and it's genuinely mostly popping off 96 year olds a year early like the flu and other pneumonia triggers)

We should definitely take the opportunity to make reasonable adjustments to our culture - keep everyone confident of vaccines and keep them up to date, design shops and supermarkets for good ventilation, encourage mask wearing when symptomatic with something, do everything possible to ban the SHEER STUPIDITY of the "office hero" who likes to drag themselves into work with the flu to signal how important and hardworking they are, make hand washing a regular healthy habit we all get used to, ensure public places have good surface sanitising routines etc. But as it's looking vanishingly unlikely that "zero Covid" is feasible (it's endemic and constantly mutating and you can't get the whole world to remain in lockdown indefinitely even if you could somehow convince the UK citizens to) I think otherwise yeah to some extent we're going to have to live with it. Once it's no longer flooding the hospitals and morgues.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by KlaxonCow »

I mean, realistically, we are going to have to live with it.

Early on, I suggested - as it's a novel coronavirus - that we had a golden window of opportunity to eradicate it.

Because, on the bad side, "novel" means that no-one's got natural immunity to it but, on the good side, it hadn't gained the global foothold yet, so a bit of "extreme prejudice" against it could have seen it off, before it got going.

But, yeah, with Trump and Boris and Bolsonaro, the world totally fucked that one. Way too late. It's now endemic, and we have variants - so multiple moving targets - and it's reached, essentially, every country on planet Earth.

Absolutely no chance now, I'm afraid.

But what's irks me about the "living with Covid" stuff from the politicians - and this might be what merman is getting at - is that, like "wild herd immunity", they seem horribly keen to just give up.

That we're saying "regrettably, it looks like we're going to have to live with some level of this in the long term", as a bitter regret, while these Tory tossers are saying it in tones more akin to "Wahey!! This'll bump off all those old, disabled and poor people who we despise. I can't wait for us to be living with this virus forever!! Woohoo!! It's my eugenics wet dream come true!! Quick, let's give up fighting against this instantly. Oh, damn, the lockdown is doing too well. Quick, tell them to 'eat out to help out', so we keep the virus going a bit longer. Phew! We almost accidentally did the right thing there".


(Like this stupid cow, who suggested a pandemic would be "quite useful" in killing off bed blockers:

https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/5 ... -blockers/

Yeah, because Covid has really, really helped the NHS hospitals to function so much better, hasn't it? It's not just that she's an inhuman cow, she's an INCORRECT inhuman cow. The pandemic has done the polar bloody opposite of help hospitals to run more efficiently. She'd have been all for "wild herd immunity" - and we would have watched the NHS burn to the ground. They're barely hanging on. Can you just imagine what would have happened - remember, exponential growth - if Boris had dithered and delayed for another week or two? Or not called a lockdown at all? It was this atrociously bad, and that was with us taking action and locking down.)


Like, seriously, their first response - their natural instinct - was to go immediately to "wild herd immunity" and if it bumped off the pensioners then, well, that helps solve NHS bed blocking and the pensions crisis, yeah?

They're just way, way, way too keen to throw their hands up and let the poor people die.

"Won't anybody think of the economy?!?", they cry.

Except, of course, as New Zealand nicely proves, dealing with this properly and early from the beginning has allowed them to re-open their domestic economy just fine and dandy right now. Cafes, pubs and nightclubs are open - have been since May 2020, when they started their cautious re-opening - and there's been normal New Year's celebrations and concerts with tens of thousands of people in attendance. The Kiwis are living very close to a "normal life", like the Before Times, right now.

And it's because they got strict fast and early. Then shut down the borders for re-importation.

What about the economy? Well, they have one. We don't.

I can understand how this might seem counter-intuitive to folks who've never thought anything through in their lives before, but lockdown - done properly - can save the economy. Delaying, half-arsing lockdown, throwing all the doors open simultaneously in Summer and using taxpayer money to "eat out to help out the virus spreading", etc. is the thing that's brought us to repeated on / off lockdowns that's been truly killing the economy.

(And, come on, from the twats that brought us Brexit at the exact same time as all this? Who gave us ten years of "austerity" for, basically, no fucking good reason whatsoever? They have all the economic sense of a dead ferret. They keep damaging the economy, and telling us it's totally awesome. This is like some kind of perverse domestic abuse going on here, and they're gas-lighting us to believe we "deserve" to be beaten to a pulp by them repeatedly.)
Last edited by KlaxonCow on Wed Feb 17, 2021 10:57 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
PFVA
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14996
Joined: Fri May 24, 2002 1:40 am 0
Location: Paralel 38

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by PFVA »

Here, officially 4 community cases of the South African variant and none of the Manaus (Brazil) one.

That South African one worries me because the vaccines seem to be less effective with it. It also seems to spread without problems during their dry summers and their climate is very similar to ours.

In the meantime I learned today the code to ask for an espresso during lockdown. People go to the café working in takeaway mode and ask to use the restroom. They say wait just a minute, then let the person in, the espresso is ready, person drinks it, and gets out saying thank you for letting me use the restroom.

As I smuggle mine with the take away lunch I wasn't aware of that option. A couple of weeks ago I had seen someone doing it, I mean asking to use the restroom and I wondered since I knew the person lived about 50m from the place why would he be asking that at the café but I just assumed he had plumbing problems.
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by Cloudane »

Oh absolutely, I'd assumed everyone with a heart was already on the same page about the dickheads who use "live with the virus" to mean "even after all this time, fuck it just abandon all hope and let it rip" (e.g. far right Tories grumbling from a back bench or a fascist called Katy - I assumed it was Hopkins but it was another one - spewing bile for a newspaper opinion column)

I was reading it as "to live with it to any degree at all" (the more sensible person's "live with it", upon facing the fact it's endemic and we can't "stop the world brutally enough" to wipe it out now) being inhumane and I totally get that argument as on the surface it seems so - when you get into discussions like I touched on where you have to bring up the notion of "acceptable deaths", it's horrible to think of any death as "acceptable". If it was my loved ones I'd certainly not consider it acceptable, so I get it. But under the surface you have all those other complications that sort of force "acceptable deaths" to be a thing.

Society currently considers seasonal flu deaths to be acceptable. Maybe there's a conversation to be had there (it does stress the NHS), to be fair, and covid is the catalyst for that conversation and can probably soon be considered in the same category as seasonal flu (I know it's not yet, but soon will be). I and probably most of society don't consider going in and out of lockdowns indefinitely to be an answer - any extremism like that, like most extremism that is rife these days, is likely to shut down conversations and cause polarised shit slinging instead - but more and better vaccinations, 'free' vitamin D (whether by fortification or pills on the NHS), better hygiene, flexibility to work from home or have paid sick leave if one has a bad cold/flu etc. Sensible things we don't do enough of but CAN do without disrupting our delicate economy, risking jobs or messing with anyone's mental health.
User avatar
VNVObit
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4072
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
PSN: VNV_Obit
Location: London

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by VNVObit »

more interesting news on AZ contract with UK

https://edition.cnn.com/2021/02/17/euro ... index.html
But the UK's official contract is actually dated August 28, one day after the EU's contract.
seems to be a more tangled web than first presented by AZ
does cover comparison of the 2 contracts

(still no excuses for mucking around with the NI Protocol)
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford

My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single

"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by KlaxonCow »

Cloudane wrote:Society currently considers seasonal flu deaths to be acceptable.
I don't think it does. Or, at least, I hope it doesn't.

I don't see any deaths as "acceptable". The point with seasonal flu deaths is that we can't really do much more than we're doing.

We've got annual flu jabs on offer - and the UK has the biggest vaccination take-up of these jabs in the world. We do try to keep up with this virus. But the thing with the flu is that it mutates all the bloody time.

I would not phrase this in terms of "acceptable" and "unacceptable" - that, to me, stinks of the sort of language that our right-wing eugenicists are trying to steer the narrative towards - but rather that this is the best we could ever hope to do, with an endemic ever-mutating virus.

Now that we've all actually watched a vaccine go through development and trials and approval - how long and complicated the whole process is (and, remember, with the Covid vaccines, this stuff was all fast-tracked and the more standard procedure is even longer and more laboured than even this!) - then we can perhaps appreciate just how much constant effort is placed into making those annual flu jabs.

Until the pandemic, we never looked at this. But it focused our eyes on seeing what vaccine development involves. Now, consider that this - in fact, an even more complicated and laboured process, as Covid got special "fast track" treatment here - has been happening every year, over and over, for the annual flu jabs.

Indeed, because trials and approval take so long, the annual flu jab requires a bit of guessing. They track the current strains of flu doing the rounds and try to predict which ones will be dominant by the time that the jab is done and approved. They don't necessarily always get those guesses exactly right, unfortunately, and a different strain might gain dominance or a new strain pop up in the meantime.

But, again, you have to 100% ensure that a jab is safe before you start jabbing people with it, so what else can ever be done?

I don't see it as society thinking flu deaths are "acceptable". I think it's more that the nature of the influenza virus means that we can't ever get ahead of it. This is, regrettably, the best we can do. And a heck of a lot of effort is continuously put into keeping up with the 'flu virus. We might not have noticed before, but what we've seen with the Covid vaccines, is continuously happening with the annual 'flu jab. All the time. No rest. Once they've got this year's flu jab sorted, they immediately start predicting what next year's one will need to look like.

And another thing about the influenza virus is that its hatred of heat - that it does largely disappear in Summer, and then kicks off seasonally in Winter - gives us the opportunity to do this at all. Because it is seasonal - every Winter - then we've got that time in-between to rush efforts to get a new jab done and approved in time.

It's not "acceptable". I don't see it that way. This is, regrettably, simply the best we can do with this virus. We do offer vulnerable groups a jab every year (and we are a free country, so if you don't want to take up the jab offer, then you will not be physically forced to do so).

I think phrasing it in terms of "acceptability" is wrong. This is the best we can do - at least, not unless you want to start making jabs compulsory.

We don't lockdown for the 'flu, because the nature of the virus - constantly mutating - means that lockdowns would only be of limited utility. I mean, we have been under lockdown - on and off - for over a year now. It was for Covid, but it's also implicitly locking down for 'flu and the common cold too. But the 'flu still exists and the problem is that it throws up new "variants" so often, that if one case survives through lockdown, then it re-emerges, as everyone's previous immunity - or annual jab - no longer works for next year's strains.

We can't lockdown the 'flu out of existence. It's rapidly changing nature defies that particular tactic (not totally, but we'll never eradicate it that way, only temporarily knock it back). And, for the 'flu, by its nature, our best protection is to offer annual jabs for the vulnerable and to allow those who're very unlikely to die from it - young and healthy - to get it for "herd immunity" purposes, which does help protect the more vulnerable.

I mean, we can't lockdown Covid out of existence either (not anymore, once it became endemic, that possibility was lost). The point of lockdown was and is to "flatten the curve" - keep healthcare systems working, keep "variant" mutations as low as possible, etc. - until we had the vaccine and treatments and such to actually fight back. Which is what's going on now. Hopefully, vaccination will work and though Covid won't, unfortunately, disappear that easily, it can be consigned, hopefully, to being "small pockets" of outbreak here and there, and we fight those fires as they happen (but now actually armed with some weapons to do so).

I think that if a doctor said - and it was proved true - that they could actually totally eradicate the 'flu once and for all, with it never coming back, but it would require going into lockdown for a year, then I think society would - or, at least, ought to - take that. It's a bargain at the price to make influenza permanently extinct forever more.

I'm suspicious that whoever's lead the charge to paint 'flu deaths in the language of "acceptable" or "unacceptable" is someone with a "living with it" agenda that's trying to paint things in their terms, to have people accept the idea that "acceptable death" is a thing. It really isn't. There are no "acceptable deaths", but this is the best we can do against an enemy like the 'flu.

Because it's thoroughly endemic, lockdowns alone cannot eradicate (and the same is now true, unfortunately, for Covid). But the point of a lockdown is to buy time. Stop the NHS overloading, stop "variants" springing up alarmingly fast that we can't keep up with them, and buy time for the scientists to create the vaccines and the treatments.

Lockdown cannot be permanent. That's not how this can or should work.

The point is that it's bought us time to now have the vaccines, roll them out and build up some "herd immunity" in the population - in a safe way, that doesn't result in suffering and death - but, ultimately, "herd immunity" is our protection. Lockdown is what we do when we haven't got that, to buy the time for the vaccines to come online to give it to us. To keep "variants" at bay - yeah, that part of the plan was missed by certain politicians - so that our vaccines remain good by the time they are rolled out.

I wouldn't ever go near the phraseology of "acceptable" and "unacceptable". I see it more as "possible" and "impossible". We don't accept these deaths, we just can't do any better than that. And herd immunity has to be our long-term protection - we locked down to buy the time for the vaccines to give it to us, and for treatments to come along that can hopefully reduce fatality rates.


p.s. to provide something more positive, the Covid vaccines have proved that the new "mRNA" technique works (and, indeed, works bloody well, if it honestly is producing efficacies as high as 90% or 95%, as that kind of level was previously unheard of, and we thought 60-70% was awesome with previous techniques). And this technique is faster to modify - to keep up - and some scientists have been talking about the possibility that, mastering this technique, they could develop more generic vaccines. One that targets common elements of ALL coronaviruses, for example. So it's not going for the spike protein, but aiming for something that all coronaviruses - all Covid variants, all common cold variants - share and makes a more generic attack against the whole class of viruses in one go.

Obviously, all minds are focused on Covid right now, but the new technique - applied to old enemies, like the 'flu - might offer more effective annual jabs, and the prospect of more generic vaccines (but still potentially having that high 90+% efficacy too) could mean that we start hitting these bastards back even more widely, even more effectively and being able to "keep up" way faster than before. The "emergency" of Covid unlocked funds, research and development of new techniques that could well prove massively more effective - against everything - going forward.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by gilesgoat »


Cloudane wrote:

Society currently considers seasonal flu deaths to be acceptable.

I don't think it does. Or, at least, I hope it doesn't.

I don't see any deaths as "acceptable". The point with seasonal flu deaths is that we can't really do much more than we're doing.
For once I have to see things "a bit different as well" .. in fairness, for EVERYONE, even if it sounds sad "I really think it does".

"It does" in the sense that "if NOTHING else can be done" nothing else that would create even more problems.

It's a balancing act, of course THE MOST IMPORTANT THING is that the research and efforts and studies to reduce/eliminate all those deaths CONTINUE and are ALWAYS GOING.

The real problem would come if someone decide "there's nothing we can do, leave things as they are move on" without supporting and continuing to research better ways to deal with.

As I said "in an absolute sense" EVERY life is sacred, should be saved.

And OF COURSE EVERY ONE OF US COULD BE THAT PERSON ILL WITH COVID THAT IS ABOUT TO DIE ! EVERYONE .. maybe not now, maybe not in 10 years time but maybe in 20 ...

And "no date is a good date to die" there's NO such thing "you lived enough" or such, it's bullshit.

BUT .. "there's only so much you can keep the world in certain ways" .. without much progress .. without the risk of "a tremendous collapse".

A collapse that could take really hundreds of years to recover .. and who knows what else shit could be in the middle.

So yeah maybe "a progressive step-by-step solution" is needed .. it's very hard to find out "correct answers".

Also "how much is dedicated to research/development/implementation of new medicine/stuff" .. "how much politician deadlocks" there are in the middle of all this .. how many "people we don't want to take any risks/responsibilities" are that hamper down maybe new solutions "because they want 1000 reassurances first ?" .. how many times there's been people dying "negated an experimental treatment that MAYBE could have worked" ?

Is that "socially acceptable" ?

And yet for many it is !

So don't know .. "I can't see it that much worse" than MANY other things "so socially acceptable" that already we have in place and many people don't even stop thinking about they just look the other way and move on.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Ollie
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4446
Joined: Mon May 03, 2004 7:04 pm 0
Location: London
Contact:

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by Ollie »

Saw some Tory MP on something the other day talking about needing to decide how many deaths we're comfortable with, which seems a rather large step beyond "acceptable deaths" on the callousness scale.
Post Reply