Cloudane wrote:"Acceptable" is probably the wrong word to use. I was hoping folks would understand what I'm getting at, but forget that there's a tendency to assume I'm an evil heartless monster who wants people to die and argues in favour of the Katy's and Adolfs of the world.
Eh? What are you on about?
The thought would never cross my mind for a second. We've talked back and forth for years now, and your name would definitely never feature on my "evil heartless monster" list at all, and I'd hope you'd also mutually feel the same way. Don't be daft, Cloudane.
No, what I was getting at is that people with agendas put these words and phrases out there to twist the narrative. I don't think you'd ever say "acceptable deaths" - I mean, your post was exactly saying otherwise.
My point was more that... well, to give you an example, lots of people use the phrase "nothing to hide, nothing to fear". Ask yourself where that actually comes from. Because, I mean, it's a meme. People who use that phrase didn't personally come up with it, they're reciting a meme they heard.
You can tell that this is the case because, actually, while the phrase superficially sounds catchy and clever, it actually makes no fucking sense whatsoever. Like, none.
For example, I've not committed a crime - nothing to hide - therefore I am somehow now magically immune from having any crime committed against me - nothing to fear?
Wait, what? That doesn't remotely make any kind of sense. Because I have never stolen money from anyone - nothing to hide - then I should have nothing to fear in someone else trying to scam me over the phone, or try to break into my house, or mug me in the street?
No, that's not how it works at all. "Nothing to hide, nothing to fear"?
Okay, here's my bank PIN number, my burglar alarm code, my credit card details, all my passwords. There, I'm now hiding nothing. Therefore, I'm now magically protected from being a victim of crime at any point. Phew! That was close.
Wait, what? No. It's the polar opposite. Having something to hide - your PIN, your password, your card number, your bank details, etc. - is what's preventing you from being a victim of theft. You should definitely, in fact, hide that stuff... and then you have nothing to fear.
It sounds catchy and clever, but a moment's thought reveals that, actually, "nothing to hide, nothing to fear" is complete meaningless bollocks. It's not true. The opposite is true. Privacy protects you from criminal abuse (and this ain't remotely altered by the fact that the criminal abuse might come from the government - no, that makes shit, like, a hundred times worse, not remotely any better, if your abuser actually wields a genuine position of power - as your recourse in that situation is
only through secrets and privacy, when you're dealing with a criminal agent who already has way, way too much information and power over you to begin with, let alone voluntarily making it worse).
It's bullshit. But you can see why it's catchy. Why folks grab that meme when they hear it and recycle it thoughtlessly. It's got a nice little pattern to it "nothing to... nothing to...". Repetition. It's almost like poetry rolling off the tongue.
This is, indeed, exactly of the same calibre of phrase as "Big Brother is watching you". If you swallow that bit of propaganda, then you might read it as nice and comforting. Ah, "Big Brother" is taking care of us. But, of course, from the external perspective, we can exactly see what Orwell's phrase really is. It's a threat. To those of a rebellious mind, don't even think about it, we're monitoring everything.
What "nothing to hide, nothing to fear" really is, is a similar threat. Reverse it. If you try to hide something from me, then I'm going to give you something to fear. "Something to hide? (Then you'll have) Something to fear!".
Another little propaganda meme that floats around our collective consciousness is "there are no jobs for life". Again, a little thought and that one is equally meaningless.
I mean, let's say I trained as a plumber. Well, folks still have plumbing in their houses, and therefore they're going to always need someone who knows how to fix plumbing to fix their plumbing. As long as people want such services and I'm happy to keep providing such services, then why should that ever need to end at any point?
Nah, it's an agenda-pushing meme. It's preparing people to accept, in their minds, that their job is transient, not permanent, and is there to encourage the workforce to keep churning around between jobs. Because if people are perpetually "new recruits", you can pay them less. Lacking experience and standing in the company, they can't ask for that pay rise. Those better working conditions. Indeed, if you're only ever in any job for six months to a year then it's not worth bothering to join the union, right?
This is "de-skilling" - essentially keeping everyone in a permanent state of "apprenticeship", as it were, so you can pay them the lesser "new boy" wage and they carry no sway and they're always just barely qualified, so have no leg to stand on to ask for a pay rise and better conditions.
The meme is meaningless bollocks. If you have a skill and that skill will remain in demand for the rest of your life, then there's no logical reason why you couldn't continue to offer that skill as a job for the rest of your life. You're a plumber. People have plumbing at their house. They'll always need someone to come fix problems for them - and why can't it be you doing that for the rest of your career?
No, the phrase is a meme that's put out there, by corporations, to kind of "prime" people into thinking that it's perfectly normal to keep changing jobs as often as your underwear, so they won't question the workforce being forever churned around by these policies of "de-skilling" every possible job, to keep wages down and profits up.
So, no, I don't think that you think that these are "acceptable deaths". I mean, you explicitly were telling us how you're not comfortable with that language at all. And what I was saying is that people with an agenda put these "memes" out there for us to absorb and repeat. They're trying to set the tone and language of the conversation into their preferred way of looking at it.
They put out the phrases "acceptable deaths" or, indeed, start pushing their luck with ideas like "how many deaths are we comfortable with", to switch the tone of the public conversation. So now you've tricked people into essentially going along with your underlying eugenics agenda, and have them start thinking in terms of "it's acceptable for tens of thousands of people to unnecessarily die". Then it edges a little further, as they ask how many deaths would you be comfortable with? "Are you okay with us letting tens of thousands of people die? Please give us the number of deaths that you're okay with".
Step-by-step, trying to sneak the tone of the public conversation in their direction. Hoping that once we all accept and are comfortable with X amount of deaths by disease, then they can move onto how many deaths by poverty are you willing to take? Go on, give me a number. How many people are you comfortable with dying off from simply being poor or ill (which too often go together)?
This, indeed, is really a way to sneak a logical fallacy past people without them noticing it makes no sense.
It's like that infamous question: "So, have you stopped beating your wife?". They've forced an assumption into the question and you're now screwed whether you answer "yes" - because then it seems like you're admitting to having previously beaten your wife before you stopped - or "no" - as then you're saying that you still beat your wife. And then your inquisitor can interrupt and just keep pushing this - "come on, this is a simple 'yes' or 'no' question. Just answer the question" - if you try to correctly re-frame your response: "well, I couldn't have stopped doing that which I have never started because...". "Ah, stop dodging the question. Have you stopped beating your wife?". "But I...". "Look, stop avoiding this simple question. Have you stopped beating your wife?".
I mean, you've seen someone like Paxman or Piers Morgan interviewing folks. You can pull the "look this is a simple 'yes' or 'no' question" interruption, the second your interviewee isn't saying "yes" or "no" to your loaded question, and keep trying to force them to fall into your trap. And if they continually refuse to get drawn into the trap, then you've successfully made them look suspicious. As everyone at home, watching this on TV, is thinking "well, why is he refusing to say whether he's stopped beating his wife? He's hiding something. I don't trust him. I bet he is beating his wife and is just trying to hide it".
What I'm cautioning against is that there definitely are these little "memes" that float around that are planted by those with an agenda to try to twist the public conversation.
I don't think that you think this. On the contrary, I know that you don't. Hence the "woah, watch out for that, they're trying to trick us all into talking in their language of what's 'acceptable' and what we're 'comfortable with', when this is not the tone of this conversation at all".
And it's very simple why they want us to talk in those terms, because it's loading the question with an assumption, just like "when did you stop beating your wife?".
So, like, "what number of people would you accept dying? What number are you comfortable with?". Because if you answer any non-zero value, you're now implicitly saying you're okay with them bumping off that many people. If it is "acceptable" then you accept it. They're asking you, implicitly, to accept a level of unnecessary death.
And then, indeed, there's a subtle switch of language to "how many deaths are you comfortable with?". So now they're asking you to be comfortable with unnecessary deaths.
You can see where this is going. If they succeed, then the next question might be "so, how many deaths by poverty and homelessness are you fine with the government imposing on us?". Very slowly trying to bring everyone round to talking in their language of eugenics, basically.
Essentially, this:
Watch out for this trick. They keep trying to pull it on us all the time. And I say that because I
know you're not "comfortable with" nor "accepting" of this at all. So, just be careful of letting others supply the language and tone of the conversation. Certain people will always try to swing it their way, with loaded questions, and fallacious assumptions.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes