Maybe your government wants to train more Portuguese Commandos ?PFVA wrote:I went to Auchan today. The toy section is confined:
Confined Toys
A few other sections such as underwear and socks are also confined.
Coronavirus Pandemic
-
The ghost of raids past
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1682
- Joined: Sat Dec 03, 2005 7:38 pm 0
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Indeed, and note that (on many other news sources as well as the BBC) in the translation from Johnson's statement to headline, "21st June at the earliest" has somehow become "by 21st June," which literally means "21st June at the latest," i.e., the precise opposite of what he said (but the precise message that anyone with half a brain could have predicted many people would take from it).merman wrote:And the BBC website headline minutes after the afternoon announcement was
“Social contract restrictions to end by 21st June”.
Concentrating on the DATE, not the data.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
I refer you to my earlier comment. This was always going to be the case.Ollie wrote: Indeed, and note that (on many other news sources as well as the BBC) in the translation from Johnson's statement to headline, "21st June at the earliest" has somehow become "by 21st June," which literally means "21st June at the latest," i.e., the precise opposite of what he said (but the precise message that anyone with half a brain could have predicted many people would take from it).
Steam: SteelyDamn
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
And it's dumb. Because would it really have been that hard to have specified it by data, instead of dates?
Like "when daily cases have been consistently below 1000 for 2 weeks, that's when 'phase 2' will kick in" or "when daily cases have been consistently below 300 cases for 2 weeks, then 'phase 3' will kick in".
That's "data, not dates".
And then you could go on to say "we estimate that, as things are currently going, this means 'phase 2' is on course to happen no earlier than April 15th" or whatever. So, you can give dates - but these are just estimates, based on how things are going right now, on when the data is likely to reach that point. You can perhaps emphasise this by not giving an actual day, but just "sometime around the week of April 15th - 21st, we're hoping". Specify it as a range and that implicitly makes it clear that you're not declaring "freedom day" at any point here.
And the other thing with specifying it this way is that you don't end up breaking promises. If we haven't reached that point by that date, then you never promised it, so no promises have been broken. But if we really have had less than 300 daily cases for 2 weeks, then that is when you can start relaxing things and it probably won't go catastrophically wrong (as long as variants don't mess things up), that it is safe to relax those restrictions you're relaxing.
Like, it's not just that Boris did this. It's also wondering why he chose to do it the crap way, where it's just asking for things to go wrong and he'll get blamed for "breaking promises", when there was the better way available. Is he a masochist?
"So, Boris, would you like a tasty ice cream or a red hot poker up your arse?"
"Why, being a moron, I'm going to choose the red hot poker up my arse, for no good reason."
It's beyond incompetence. It's wilful stupidity at this point.
Why are you choosing to do it wrong, even after it was you who said "data, not dates"*, so you clearly understood that there was a better option available here?
(Though, as I noted earlier, it was really Plaid Cymru leader Adam Price who said "data, not dates" first in debating the Welsh First Minister's relaxation plans. I guess someone in Westminster saw that, thought "wow, that's a good soundbite" and stole it to sneak it into Boris's speeches so he seemed less of an idiot than he actually is, without, you know, considering actually doing the clever thing that the soundbite was telling you to do. Yes, "data, not dates" is a clever and catchy phrase - and what's most clever about it is that it's right. So actually do it, you morons, don't just say it and then do the polar opposite.)
Like "when daily cases have been consistently below 1000 for 2 weeks, that's when 'phase 2' will kick in" or "when daily cases have been consistently below 300 cases for 2 weeks, then 'phase 3' will kick in".
That's "data, not dates".
And then you could go on to say "we estimate that, as things are currently going, this means 'phase 2' is on course to happen no earlier than April 15th" or whatever. So, you can give dates - but these are just estimates, based on how things are going right now, on when the data is likely to reach that point. You can perhaps emphasise this by not giving an actual day, but just "sometime around the week of April 15th - 21st, we're hoping". Specify it as a range and that implicitly makes it clear that you're not declaring "freedom day" at any point here.
And the other thing with specifying it this way is that you don't end up breaking promises. If we haven't reached that point by that date, then you never promised it, so no promises have been broken. But if we really have had less than 300 daily cases for 2 weeks, then that is when you can start relaxing things and it probably won't go catastrophically wrong (as long as variants don't mess things up), that it is safe to relax those restrictions you're relaxing.
Like, it's not just that Boris did this. It's also wondering why he chose to do it the crap way, where it's just asking for things to go wrong and he'll get blamed for "breaking promises", when there was the better way available. Is he a masochist?
"So, Boris, would you like a tasty ice cream or a red hot poker up your arse?"
"Why, being a moron, I'm going to choose the red hot poker up my arse, for no good reason."
It's beyond incompetence. It's wilful stupidity at this point.
Why are you choosing to do it wrong, even after it was you who said "data, not dates"*, so you clearly understood that there was a better option available here?
(Though, as I noted earlier, it was really Plaid Cymru leader Adam Price who said "data, not dates" first in debating the Welsh First Minister's relaxation plans. I guess someone in Westminster saw that, thought "wow, that's a good soundbite" and stole it to sneak it into Boris's speeches so he seemed less of an idiot than he actually is, without, you know, considering actually doing the clever thing that the soundbite was telling you to do. Yes, "data, not dates" is a clever and catchy phrase - and what's most clever about it is that it's right. So actually do it, you morons, don't just say it and then do the polar opposite.)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Always tempting when delivering a project to say "it'll be done by x". It's not the right answer to give, but it's what the customer wants to hear. And Boris likes saying things that the majority want to hear.
What's more disappointing is seeing media sites run with those dates. Fair play, the Mail and Telegraph would always back Boris, but even places like Joe, who are generally pretty centrist, have started timers proclaiming "only 46 days until you can swig that sweet amber nectar". The whole thing fucking sucks.
What's more disappointing is seeing media sites run with those dates. Fair play, the Mail and Telegraph would always back Boris, but even places like Joe, who are generally pretty centrist, have started timers proclaiming "only 46 days until you can swig that sweet amber nectar". The whole thing fucking sucks.
Steam: SteelyDamn
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
But such conditionals are not useful for planning. I mean, take the vague idea of pubs reopening. Someone's got to brew a few hundred thousand barrels of beer and that takes a couple of weeks. There has to be a date involved.KlaxonCow wrote:And it's dumb. Because would it really have been that hard to have specified it by data, instead of dates?
Like "when daily cases have been consistently below 1000 for 2 weeks, that's when 'phase 2' will kick in" or "when daily cases have been consistently below 300 cases for 2 weeks, then 'phase 3' will kick in".
That's "data, not dates".
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
So: "when <x> data condition has been met, that's when we'll give 2 weeks notice of pubs reopening so they can be ready and stocked up in time."Dio wrote:But such conditionals are not useful for planning. I mean, take the vague idea of pubs reopening. Someone's got to brew a few hundred thousand barrels of beer and that takes a couple of weeks. There has to be a date involved.KlaxonCow wrote:And it's dumb. Because would it really have been that hard to have specified it by data, instead of dates?
Like "when daily cases have been consistently below 1000 for 2 weeks, that's when 'phase 2' will kick in" or "when daily cases have been consistently below 300 cases for 2 weeks, then 'phase 3' will kick in".
That's "data, not dates".
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Even simpler than that.Ollie wrote:So: "when <x> data condition has been met, that's when we'll give 2 weeks notice of pubs reopening so they can be ready and stocked up in time."
Look at the conditional I gave again: "when daily cases have been consistently below 1000 for 2 weeks".
So, if daily cases are, say, 5000 then, clearly, that cannot be part of a 2 week period that's consistently below 1000, right?
But if the daily cases are 923 - less than 1000 - then, okay, that's "day 1". Start counting. If it consistently remains below 1000 - and continues falling - until "day 14", then the next phase kicks in.
My conditional implicitly includes the fortnight's notice in the logic itself. It doesn't need to be added, as it's already there.
Come on, I'm a coder. I know how to write conditionals.
And the more general point is that the data is not fucking random, and then jumps out at you when you least expect it. You can see what the daily numbers are for yourself. You can look at the graphs to see if it's rising or falling - what the trend of the data is.
It's not just the implicit 2 weeks' notice that I put into the conditional itself, but the fact that if you're watching the daily numbers and they're, say, 2000 then 1875 then 1564 then 1200 then 923... you can see that 1000 cases is coming before it happens. And you can also see that the numbers are in decline - the trend is going the right way - so this looks good, if it continues, that the next 2 weeks will be consistently below 1000.
Seriously, this is not rocket science.
And there's innumerable companies out there whose whole business is reacting on-the-fly to consumer demand, prices, fads and fashions, and are perpetually planning on-the-hoof to events as they happen.
And what can I say? This is all reality's going to give us. We have to work with it. You must adapt to the reality that's there, because you can be as sure as shit that reality is never going to adapt to suit you. You might not like this - I don't like this - but, tough shit, that's all we're getting.
Because, just to remind people, there is actually a deadly virus out there. It can't hear your whining complaints. It not only doesn't care, it is fundamentally incapable of caring.
And, in general, for all our understandable impatience, let's remember that you're betting on the accuracy of a politician's futurology - Boris's, no less - 4 months out.
By all means, set yourself up for that inevitable disappointment, if you like. But don't ever say you weren't forewarned.
(Anyway, in the very next paragraph, that Dio clipped out, I went on to say that you could guesstimate dates from the data, if you really want to extrapolate some dates. But the point is that it's the data - the measurement of the actual reality we face - that defines when this is over, and it's safe to relax. Nothing else does that.)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- Deckard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10748
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
- Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Just had my Covid jab invite through.. going on Sunday to get first one and second in May.
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Unfortunately, that isn't true of every coder.KlaxonCow wrote:Ollie wrote:Come on, I'm a coder. I know how to write conditionals.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Well, let's be honest, it's often not true of me either.zip accident wrote:Unfortunately, that isn't true of every coder.
We all make mistakes. Such as, ooh, goading the Gods of Irony by making such bold statements.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
Confinement extended till March 16.
In the meantime yesterday I went thru the business park down the road
It's mostly on telecommute due to confinement
Confinement
And the cafés look like this
Locked Down
In the meantime yesterday I went thru the business park down the road
It's mostly on telecommute due to confinement
Confinement And the cafés look like this
Locked DownRe: Coronavirus Pandemic
Well, Hancock's warning that "it ain't over yet", as the rate of decline has slowed and it's even rising a little in some local areas.
And that's kind of the problem with Boris's dates. If you are trying to predict when cases will be at a certain safe level 4 months ahead of time, then even the tiniest change to our "initial conditions" now is going to amplify - like a butterfly's wings - to being widely different than your prediction, by the time June 21st rolls around.
It's like weather forecasting. When the weather lady on the telly is telling you that it's going to rain in the next hour, that's pretty much going to be dead accurate. But her predictions for 4 hours' time? For tomorrow? For next week? For 4 months' time?
You get the gist. The further out into the future the prediction, the more likely it is for it to become completely fucking wrong.
Weather forecasters would never even touch trying to predict "chance of rain" on June 21st from the end of February. They might try a very broad prediction - that this year's Summer is going to be wetter or warmer than last year - but actually giving you an accurate "chance of rain" for a particular day 4 months away? No chance.
Because, basically, there's no point even trying. The amount of chaotic "noise" that accumulates over 4 months just utterly drowns out any "signal" that you're trying to pick up and extrapolate from.
Or, you know, predicting next year's tech is just incrementing what we've got today by a notch or two. But predicting what tech will exist in 100 years' time?
In fact, this is what Chaos Theory tells us. Chaos is intrinsically impossible to predict. It cannot be done.
So the March date is fine, as we can guess fairly well where things are in about a week's time. But the further dates, the further out they are, the more and more unlikely it is that the government's predictions on the data will be accurate and, therefore, that the dates will be right.
March 8th will hold, because we can politically force that one to happen - be it a good idea or not to send all the kids back to school simultaneously (and pretty much every expert agrees, it is a bad idea). But the dates after that will start sliding around.
Essentially because, when we relax the school restrictions, that will inevitably put a "spike" back into the data. How big a spike? Well, depends on many things. The behaviour of the kids, the teachers and their parents. Whether the UK or South African or Brazilian or New York variant - yes, America's adding its variants to the pool and if we're not controlling the airports and borders properly, that one can appear over here - gets into our schools. Because those buggers are more infectious, so if they take hold then your predictions, based on the original virus / UK variant mix we have right now, are going to go wrong quickly.
This is the thing. This is why this is an inherently chaotic pursuit. Because our actions - the relaxation of restrictions - affects the data that we're trying to predict, upon which we base future actions, that further affects the data, upon which we base further future actions and... well, that's iterative. And that means you've got Chaos.
And the lesson of Chaos Theory is that this is intrinsically impossible to predict - even if every element here was simple and 100% deterministic (which it isn't, as human behaviour is involved, so throw any notions of "deterministic" right out the window) - and it gets worse and worse, ever more impossible to guess at, the more and more we iterate the chaos again and again.
The March dates, okay. But the June 21st date? Boris might as well be pulling it out of his arse and almost certainly is.
I mean, come on, June 21st is, of course, the Summer Solstice.
What's the odds that the scientists just so happened to predict, from the data, that everything would be safe and fine enough for "freedom day" to be on the day that is also, coincidentally, the Summer Solstice this year?
Versus what's the odds that Boris picked that date, with no regard whatsoever to the data, just because it's Mid-Summer - the longest day of the year - and that's all very symbolic, but not remotely accurate nor pragmatic in the slightest?
Hence, sure, Boris has given us some dates - even when he explicitly said he'd do otherwise, with his stolen "data, note dates", so he's contradicting himself already - but the actual value of those dates to any useful planning?
I would say it's of extremely minimal value and very low reliability (and my real fear is that he'll do something ridiculous like stick by his "irreversible" dates - as if set in stone, and not "no earlier than..." - even if it all goes tits up, and some variant takes over that brings about a "third wave", that he'll be all stubborn-like to re-open regardless).
Thing is, if folks were saying that having a date provides hope - some semblance of a glint of light at the end of the tunnel, a salve to our rocky mental health at the moment - and there's some psychological value to that, even if, in practical terms, these dates are completely bloody useless, in truth, and are very unlikely to actually pan out to that exact day, then I'd have sympathy with that.
I'd still object. As let's not provide false hope - that's, yet again, dashed - as that's actually worse for our collective psychology than just accepting that we've got a bit more "more of the same" to tolerate for a while.
But let's call a spade "a spade". Boris's dates are an eternally insecure man offering some kind of feeble comfort and hope to a beaten down populace, who're sick to their hind teeth at all this, unfortunately necessary, "stay at home" bollocks. In his standard "please love me" fashion.
It's not reliable. You definitely should not be planning things 4 months in advance to some random June 21st date - that he plucked from his arse, because that's just the Summer Solstice and the longest day of Summer, not any careful and clever analysis of the data - and thinking that, dead on the stroke of midnight, we'll all magically be free of Covid forever and you can go on your hols to Greece.
Because, for fuck's sake, in our heart of hearts, we all know that's not how this'll go down at all. We'll still be doing masks and social distancing - and I know I'm not going to be running instantly back to the pub, the second it opens, as I do not volunteer to be Boris's "canary in the coalmine" - for a good long while to come. And there will be outbreaks and local lockdowns and then going back to get our latest booster shots for years to come.
Because we missed that early opportunity to consign this virus to the historical dustbin, and it's now endemic and it'll keep - per natural selection - fighting back, and sometimes winning in some places for a short while.
Expectation management. There will be no magical "freedom day" when this all vanishes. It'll gradually, over time, move into being a "background problem", like our other old enemies, and you might think dates are useful. But, actually, these dates will not prove useful, really, as they won't prove reliable enough to be useful. And "the end of all this" is not a point - a single date - but a slow and steady "today is slightly better than yesterday" progression, until this problem joins the rest of our eternal "background problems" that we can never completely solve.
It sounds good. And we all want it to be right, because that fills us with hope and that feels good.
But, you know, reality check. That's all I'm saying.
And that's kind of the problem with Boris's dates. If you are trying to predict when cases will be at a certain safe level 4 months ahead of time, then even the tiniest change to our "initial conditions" now is going to amplify - like a butterfly's wings - to being widely different than your prediction, by the time June 21st rolls around.
It's like weather forecasting. When the weather lady on the telly is telling you that it's going to rain in the next hour, that's pretty much going to be dead accurate. But her predictions for 4 hours' time? For tomorrow? For next week? For 4 months' time?
You get the gist. The further out into the future the prediction, the more likely it is for it to become completely fucking wrong.
Weather forecasters would never even touch trying to predict "chance of rain" on June 21st from the end of February. They might try a very broad prediction - that this year's Summer is going to be wetter or warmer than last year - but actually giving you an accurate "chance of rain" for a particular day 4 months away? No chance.
Because, basically, there's no point even trying. The amount of chaotic "noise" that accumulates over 4 months just utterly drowns out any "signal" that you're trying to pick up and extrapolate from.
Or, you know, predicting next year's tech is just incrementing what we've got today by a notch or two. But predicting what tech will exist in 100 years' time?
In fact, this is what Chaos Theory tells us. Chaos is intrinsically impossible to predict. It cannot be done.
So the March date is fine, as we can guess fairly well where things are in about a week's time. But the further dates, the further out they are, the more and more unlikely it is that the government's predictions on the data will be accurate and, therefore, that the dates will be right.
March 8th will hold, because we can politically force that one to happen - be it a good idea or not to send all the kids back to school simultaneously (and pretty much every expert agrees, it is a bad idea). But the dates after that will start sliding around.
Essentially because, when we relax the school restrictions, that will inevitably put a "spike" back into the data. How big a spike? Well, depends on many things. The behaviour of the kids, the teachers and their parents. Whether the UK or South African or Brazilian or New York variant - yes, America's adding its variants to the pool and if we're not controlling the airports and borders properly, that one can appear over here - gets into our schools. Because those buggers are more infectious, so if they take hold then your predictions, based on the original virus / UK variant mix we have right now, are going to go wrong quickly.
This is the thing. This is why this is an inherently chaotic pursuit. Because our actions - the relaxation of restrictions - affects the data that we're trying to predict, upon which we base future actions, that further affects the data, upon which we base further future actions and... well, that's iterative. And that means you've got Chaos.
And the lesson of Chaos Theory is that this is intrinsically impossible to predict - even if every element here was simple and 100% deterministic (which it isn't, as human behaviour is involved, so throw any notions of "deterministic" right out the window) - and it gets worse and worse, ever more impossible to guess at, the more and more we iterate the chaos again and again.
The March dates, okay. But the June 21st date? Boris might as well be pulling it out of his arse and almost certainly is.
I mean, come on, June 21st is, of course, the Summer Solstice.
What's the odds that the scientists just so happened to predict, from the data, that everything would be safe and fine enough for "freedom day" to be on the day that is also, coincidentally, the Summer Solstice this year?
Versus what's the odds that Boris picked that date, with no regard whatsoever to the data, just because it's Mid-Summer - the longest day of the year - and that's all very symbolic, but not remotely accurate nor pragmatic in the slightest?
Hence, sure, Boris has given us some dates - even when he explicitly said he'd do otherwise, with his stolen "data, note dates", so he's contradicting himself already - but the actual value of those dates to any useful planning?
I would say it's of extremely minimal value and very low reliability (and my real fear is that he'll do something ridiculous like stick by his "irreversible" dates - as if set in stone, and not "no earlier than..." - even if it all goes tits up, and some variant takes over that brings about a "third wave", that he'll be all stubborn-like to re-open regardless).
Thing is, if folks were saying that having a date provides hope - some semblance of a glint of light at the end of the tunnel, a salve to our rocky mental health at the moment - and there's some psychological value to that, even if, in practical terms, these dates are completely bloody useless, in truth, and are very unlikely to actually pan out to that exact day, then I'd have sympathy with that.
I'd still object. As let's not provide false hope - that's, yet again, dashed - as that's actually worse for our collective psychology than just accepting that we've got a bit more "more of the same" to tolerate for a while.
But let's call a spade "a spade". Boris's dates are an eternally insecure man offering some kind of feeble comfort and hope to a beaten down populace, who're sick to their hind teeth at all this, unfortunately necessary, "stay at home" bollocks. In his standard "please love me" fashion.
It's not reliable. You definitely should not be planning things 4 months in advance to some random June 21st date - that he plucked from his arse, because that's just the Summer Solstice and the longest day of Summer, not any careful and clever analysis of the data - and thinking that, dead on the stroke of midnight, we'll all magically be free of Covid forever and you can go on your hols to Greece.
Because, for fuck's sake, in our heart of hearts, we all know that's not how this'll go down at all. We'll still be doing masks and social distancing - and I know I'm not going to be running instantly back to the pub, the second it opens, as I do not volunteer to be Boris's "canary in the coalmine" - for a good long while to come. And there will be outbreaks and local lockdowns and then going back to get our latest booster shots for years to come.
Because we missed that early opportunity to consign this virus to the historical dustbin, and it's now endemic and it'll keep - per natural selection - fighting back, and sometimes winning in some places for a short while.
Expectation management. There will be no magical "freedom day" when this all vanishes. It'll gradually, over time, move into being a "background problem", like our other old enemies, and you might think dates are useful. But, actually, these dates will not prove useful, really, as they won't prove reliable enough to be useful. And "the end of all this" is not a point - a single date - but a slow and steady "today is slightly better than yesterday" progression, until this problem joins the rest of our eternal "background problems" that we can never completely solve.
It sounds good. And we all want it to be right, because that fills us with hope and that feels good.
But, you know, reality check. That's all I'm saying.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
We still don't have many people that been vaccinated, some, but not too many.KlaxonCow wrote:*SNIP*
But, you know, reality check. That's all I'm saying.
I don't know how many, if any got a SECOND dose ...
It's still a lot "in the air" ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
-
The ghost of raids past
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1682
- Joined: Sat Dec 03, 2005 7:38 pm 0
Re: Coronavirus Pandemic
gilesgoat wrote:We still don't have many people that been vaccinated, some, but not too many.KlaxonCow wrote:*SNIP*
But, you know, reality check. That's all I'm saying.
I don't know how many, if any got a SECOND dose ...
It's still a lot "in the air" ...
we know exactly
https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/vaccinations



