The ghost of raids past wrote:I expect the Welsh infection rate to rocket now they have removed restrictions.
In fairness, the restrictions have been eased, rather than removed.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2021/0 ... id-travel/
"Stay at home" has relaxed to "stay local" - and the previous time that applied, it meant that you still couldn't leave your local county area and police were enforcing that on the roads.
Hairdressers are opening, but the rest of non-essential retail still remains closed until March 22nd.
People from two households can meet outside - in their garden.
"Work from home, where possible" still applies. Gyms and hospitality remain shut. All indoor and outdoor events are cancelled and visitor attractions are shut.
Like, it's not a Boris-style "re-open absolutely everything all at once" removal of restrictions, but a genuine slow and steady "relaxation" of the rules over the weeks and months to come. Indeed, non-essential retail re-opens on the same day as in England - April 12th - but Wales is loosening a few things beforehand (which, to be fair, could act as the "canary in the coal mine" - if loosening around hairdressers results in a spike in cases then, okay, pause the plan to re-open all non-essential retail on April 12th).
Don't get me wrong. Personally, as I said with the first lockdown, I'd hold it until I saw some actual zeroes in the data. Keep it in place until we're at least >50% on vaccinations. We all want lockdown to end, but a rushed impatience - as we now know, after three lockdowns, but I was saying this from the first one - only threatens to rush us back into yet another lockdown again.
I stress again that keeping case numbers down is not simply about not overwhelming the NHS, it's because every case out there represents a chance for mutation and the emergence of more variants.
So, no, even if vaccinations end hospitalisations and deaths, then we're not free to let case numbers spike and who gives a shit? Because that's exactly how you "train" a virus into "vaccine escape". And, if that happens, our vaccination efforts are all undone, we're back to lockdown and waiting for the world's scientists to tweak their formulas and re-test it all.
Cloudane wrote:It was mostly about preventing the NHS becoming overwhelmed and as the vaccine prevents hospitalisation by 100% (and in theory anything serious enough to cause long covid)... well. It becomes another cold.
Also, "long Covid" is a misleading name. It suggests "Covid... but for longer". But, really, "long Covid" is its own condition, merely triggered by Covid. And the severity of illness really does not predict long Covid.
Case in point, me. I had mild Covid symptoms initially. This was no predictor that I wouldn't get long Covid, as I did.
This is something I think has definitely gotten mixed up in the reporting. As there is definitely post-hospitalisation "long Covid" in that, after the ordeal of hospitalisation and perhaps being on a ventilator, these survivors still have a long road to recovery. But there's also "long Covid" - such as my own, and which is much more prevalent - which is repeating symptoms for weeks and months, though perfectly mild to never require hospitalisation.
They both get called "long Covid" but they're different things.
I'm afraid I don't believe that this becomes "another cold", even if vaccinations do 100% eliminate hospitalisations and deaths. There is a whole other condition going on with "long Covid". And letting case numbers explode - even without any hospitalisations and deaths - is exactly how you "train" a virus towards "vaccine escape". And if a variant emerges that has "vaccine escape", our vaccination efforts are effectively reset. WE ABSOLUTELY CAN'T AFFORD THAT. It's plunging us all back into lockdowns and waiting for new tweaked vaccines to roll-out all over again.
The danger right now is "vaccine over-confidence". That it perhaps works a little too well, that we don't focus on still keeping case numbers down - to lessen the chances of the mutations of variants, that will all naturally be being selected for "vaccine escape", now that the vaccines are so effective - and there is a potential route there for all the hard work to become undone.
So, as I say, personally - as I said with the first lockdown - is that I'd hold the restrictions in place
beyond what's necessary. Wait for the data to report zeroes, and then wait another three weeks on top of that again. Exercise an abundance of caution.
The thing with exponential growth is that hammering it down low really does matter.
To illustrate that, let's imagine that R goes over one - and we're back into growth again - but at a starting point of 512 cases. Let's say it doubles every week - 1024, 2048, 4096, 8192, 16384, 32768, 65536. So, 7 weeks - almost two months - to 65K. But if our starting point were instead just 2 cases, then that's 4, 8, 16, 32, 64, 128, 256, 512, 1024, 2048, 4096, 8192, 16384, 32768, 65536. So, that's 15 weeks - almost four months - to 65K.
We get way more forewarning that things are getting out of control to do something about it. We can react sooner. Cases going from 16 -> 32 is not too big of a deal, regards worrying about the increased chance for mutation of variants, but 4096 -> 8192 really should start having us worried.
As always, a problem here is that humans naturally think linearly, but this is an exponential phenomenon. Getting 32 cases down to 16 cases is, exponentially, as significant as getting 1000 cases down to 500. Yeah, I know, if you're thinking linearly, not exponentially, then that doesn't jump out at you. Because dropping 500 cases is surely way more significant than dropping only 16 cases. But, no, it's a halving both times. In terms of spread avoidance, you're doing just as well - and, indeed, when the 1000 -> 500 cases gets as low as 32 cases then it'll drop to 16 and it's going just as fast as it ever was. But this is "exponential" for you. When the numbers are lower, the apparent "speed" seems slower. But it actually isn't.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes