gilesgoat wrote:BTW what's with Bristol ? Justified ? Injustified ?
They're bringing in a bill in Parliament that's giving police more powers to deal with protests - in light of "Black Lives Matter" and pulling down that Colston statue, in Bristol, as he was a slave trader, and throwing it into the water - and many people feel the bill oversteps the mark and basically is trying to stop and ban peaceful protesting.
So I guess the rioters are suggesting, by their actions, "if you're not going to allow peaceful protesting then, fuck you, we're going to protest very non-peacefully from now on". Like, to stress that if you eliminate peaceful protest as an option, then you are kind of only leaving violent and criminal protest remaining, right? Let the politicians know that the alternative is not "no protesting at all", but it's going to be rioting and violent protesting, as "we, the people" refuse to give up our right to "redress of grievance" (if I may borrow the American phrasing).
I mean, I'm an anti-authoritarian - a classical liberal - so, for me, if the government is trying to seriously curtail the right to petition for redress of grievance - that is, the democratic right to peacefully protest against your mistreatment - then I consider that fully justified. And I think, in that case, the violence even serves a direct purpose of making it clear that if you don't allow peaceful protest, then the alternative becomes breaking the law to protest - it does not become "no protesting anymore", it becomes "well, fuck you, if you're going to make protesting illegal, then we will simply just break the law to keep doing it". To remind the politicians that they govern by consent.
Fair play, Bristol's police chief seems to grasp the message being sent, as he warning that this could keep happening and spread around the country, to keep making that point - we are going to protest injustice and if you make that illegal, then we'll just have to break the law to continue doing it. The alternative is not "no protesting", the alternative is that, if it's made illegal, then we will break the law. And the politicians just don't get to decide whether the people can or can't protest. Like, restore the right to peaceful protest, or we're going to keep doing this until you concede.
I also feel it's not justified, in the sense that Jacob Rees-Mogg and his friends are essentially trying to protect statues of slave traders. And, to do so, they're trampling on the Magna Carta, which is the real bit of British history to protect - the best thing this country ever did, to teach the world the concept that "the Law is Supreme" and no-one is above it - and fuck a statue of Colston. He was a racist twat.
(And the other thing with that statue of Colston being pulled down in Bristol is that the people of Bristol had been campaigning peacefully for years and years beforehand to have the statue voluntarily removed. But the local politicians ignored it all. So, with "Black Lives Matter", the straw broke the camel's back and the people pulled it down and threw it in the water. They could have and they should have listened to local concerns that no-one wanted a memorial to a slave trader on prominent display in the city and taken the statue down voluntarily, and moved it to a museum or whatever. This wasn't random and out of nowhere. Campaigns has been waged for years and years beforehand. They should have listened, they should have reacted, when people clearly said they did not want a statue of a racist, who made all the money he splashed on the city of Bristol from the slave trade. We don't want him remembered, we don't want his dirty cash.)
No, we shouldn't "censor" British history and ignore that some really shitty things happened in the name of "Empire". But, equally, we do not need a big fucking statue of a racist - to glorify the dirty cash he made from enslaving and selling human beings - peering down on us in the middle of the fucking city.
As is now going to happen anyway, just move his statue to a museum, where there's all the details of what he did for us to remember - both good and bad - and keep the history alive. But he does not need a special prominent place on a plinth, being glorified for acting like a cunt. That should have happened anyway - it shouldn't have needed protesters to pull down the statue, it should have been reasonably taken down years back.
(And there's plenty of things in Bristol that are named after Colston, or were purchased by his dirty cash. He made a lot of money from selling black people, and splashed it on the city, to curry favour with his home town. He's everywhere. Removing the statue, sadly, does not remotely remove his legacy from Bristol. It's not "censoring" British history, Mr. Rees-Mogg, it's just correctly putting him into the correct "evil cunt" section of a museum, so he's remembered in the correct context of being from that part of British history that was evil and should never be repeated. But I fear we all know the real reason why Rees-Mogg fights for preserving statues to rich evil cunts - because he's a rich evil cunt himself.)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes