Coronavirus Pandemic

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
PFVA
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14996
Joined: Fri May 24, 2002 1:40 am 0
Location: Paralel 38

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by PFVA »

Hmm... I don't think that having over 10K people inside Faro's airport (Algarve) today trying to go back to the UK is the best way to fight a pandemic. It looked crowded all day in there. Maybe it was a bad idea to open for tourism no matter how important it was for the travel industry.

But I keep having a feeling there is something more now that the UK and the Portuguese governments know, and China too, and they are not sharing with us. But it is in the capital. Yesterday they admitted that the cases of the Indian variation are start to increase fast in this region even though the dominant is still the British. They are not mentioning the Nepal mutation though and have said earlier that Nepal and India are basically the same variant. In the meantime they went from having some events for St Anthonny's to nothing is allowed not even street lights and decorations because those can attract people to the streets.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by KlaxonCow »

Oh dear. This has all gone pear-shaped.

There is no "goal". No intent, no purpose, no destination.

After all, think of it this way, when does natural selection stop?

I mean, when you've reached a goal, when you've arrived at a destination, when your intent is fulfilled... then you can stop, yes? If your destination, on a train, is London then once the train arrives at London, then you can get off the train and stop riding it. If you "choose the Moon" and then succeed in getting there, then the goal is achieved... now what? Well, as was the case, absolutely nothing. When your only goal - as defined by JFK - was just to get to the Moon and you've got to the Moon, then you've succeeded. You've won. Job done. And then no-one's fucked to go back to the Moon for the next 50 years at least.

This is why I'm not a sports fan. And, watching this David Mitchell sketch, I fear he has - being a student of history - the same underlying fundamental philosophical problem with it all that I also have:



The football lasts forever. These same teams will, eventually, play each other an indefinite number of times. It's endless, by definition. Therefore, there cannot be any final state to the football. There can be no winners. No goal, no destination, and ultimately no purpose to it all.

Infinite things have no "end state". By definition. For obvious reasons.

So you can't logically claim that natural selection has a "goal" because, if it did, then it could never fucking reach it. Or, more precisely, if any temporary "goal" is set and then met - that's nice - but you've got the rest of forever to keep going... so, umm, what now? I guess I, umm, just keep going somehow...

Okay, football is not really infinite. Nothing is. Eventually, the human race will die out or evolve into some other species - or go "transhuman" with cyborg parts, until eventually replacing all our organic parts with a digital "hive mind" or something - or, eventually, people might just stop giving a shit about football to be bothered to watch it anymore.

But you get the point. Football is infinite by design, indefinite by nature. There can be no overall "goal" or purpose or destination to the never-ending act of football. It will end eventually, as nothing lasts forever, but with a whimper of no-one being remotely interested in it anymore - or the human race being wiped out by an asteroid or something - not with a bang of anyone ever finally winning the football. No-one can ever win the football. They'll keep trying to end it forever, until the universe itself ends the possibility of anyone ever playing football ever again - and, the thing is, that's likely the end of the human race too, so there will be no-one left to celebrate the final winners of the whole football adventure, that's already been going for centuries with, pending natural disaster or the evolution of the human race into something no longer willing nor able to play football anymore, it's got centuries, thousands of years, even millions of years left to go.

Infinite things have no "end goal", as they have no end. There can be no "final state", if the state change happens forever.

This is not just natural selection, this is not just the overall philosophical meaningless of football, this is the whole entire universe.

Because we all know Douglas Adams' gag. Aliens build a big computer - "Deep Thought" - to work out the meaning of life, the universe and everything. Finally, it works it out and, well, you're not going to like it. The answer to the meaning of life, the universe and everything is... 42.

Yes, it's comedy. But it's also philosophical satire. Apparently, Adams went through all the numbers one-by-one until he found the one that seemed most meaningless.

But here's the thing. What answer could "Deep Thought" have given that would be meaningful? Come with me on a thought experiment.

So, let's say that Deep Thought declares "the answer to the meaning of life, the universe and everything is... to reproduce".

Okay, but then what about people who can't have children? What about gay people (well, I mean, gays can still have children through surrogacy or insemination or whatever, but you get the general point - they cross over into the people who can't have children in a different way)?

What's the purpose of a mountain or a river? Why bother with the colour purple? What's the point of Pluto? What's the point of, well, 99.9999% of the universe that's not got anything whatsoever to do with reproduction or furthering the goal of reproduction?

What I'm getting at is that the greatest destroyer of meaning is, in fact, to define that there's some grand singular universal meaning to the universe.

Seriously, substitute anything you like for "42". The answer to the meaning of life, the universe and everything is X.

But whatever "X" is, what's the point of all the "not X" out there in the universe? What's the point of all the other stuff - for example, eating, shitting, sleeping, football, etc - that's got nothing to do with X, and does not in any way help further the cause of X either?

Whatever "X" you choose as the singular universal meaning of life, the universe and everything, it'll instantly render 99.9999% of the rest of the universe - which is "not X" or doesn't help in the pursuit of "X" - meaningless.

Let's say that the meaning of life is to worship God, as some religious folks believe. Okay, but then what's the point in making the universe so gargantuan? What are those X-ray bursts from distant galaxies all about? What's the meaning in a cockroach? Why does the element "protactinium" exist? Why is 99.99999999...% of the universe completely inhospitable to life? Why bother with quantum entanglement?

Let's say that the meaning of life is to make as much money as possible. Again, what's the colour purple about? Why do men have to shave? Why are there only three dimensions of space? Why have the speed of light be finite, and what's the purpose of time dilation?

Whatever you choose - any "X" at all - you are, in fact, engaging in the most destructive act to meaning possible, as you are rendering the 99.99999% of the rest of the universe that's "not X" or doesn't aid in the pursuit of "X" or really have anything whatsoever to do with "X" intrinsically meaningless.

Indeed, if the "ultimate meaning" was to worship God or make money or reproduce then, damn, all of this here is a complete waste of time. If the only meaning and purpose is to worship God or make money or whatever, then why the fuck am I wasting time doing anything else besides that? Including sleeping or taking a shit. If the only purpose is "X", then any nanosecond I spend not doing "X" or being in pursuit of "X" is absolutely a 100% meaningless waste of time. Pointless. There's no reason for its existence at all, apparently.

To put any singular universal "meaning" or "purpose" on life or the universe, is the most destructive act against meaning that you could possibly commit.

You're NOT solving the problem, you're making it quite literally infinitely worse. You're not putting meaning into the universe but are, in fact, draining out any meaning and purpose to the overwhelming 99.99999% majority of everything that does and could possibly exist.

The most meaningless universe of them all is the one where Deep Thought comes back with any answer, other than "well, it's what you make of it, innit".

Because, before we all get too nihilistically depressed at a universe that, in fact, has absolutely no universal meaning whatsoever, then understand that I'm not in any way excluding personal meaning in any way. Indeed, personal meaning very much does exist. I've experienced it myself many times. It is most definitely a thing that's real and exists.

So, the alternative way to look at it is that, for Joe Bloggs over there, the meaning in life for him is his stamp collection. And that's just fine - because as there is, in fact, no grand universal meaning, then that personal meaning, for him, is no more valid nor invalid than any other personal meaning someone might take. For Doris over there, her meaning is her children. Caring for them. And that's awesome. For John over there, it's his life-long devotion to coming up with the cure for cancer. Good on you, John. For Gordon over there, it's all about being super rich and famous. For Eleanor, it's about going to church to worship her god.

And all of these personal meanings are completely valid. All of them. In a universe with no singular "universal meaning", there's nothing to judge any of them more or less valid than any other meaning someone might take from this chaotic mess we all find ourselves in.

This is the universe that has the most meaning of them all. Because it has, at the current count, some 7 billion active meanings going on right now - at least for humans, I can't number all the aliens out there and what personal meanings they might (or might not) be taking from all this, and I can't judge at what point "meaning" becomes a thing for the vast, vast arrays of animals and plants there are on this planet with us. I don't know. Does an amoeba have "personal meaning"? What about a dog? Or, closer to home, do chimpanzees roughly see things kind of like we do, as we're not that much biologically different to them? I don't know, and maybe we'll never know.

Arguably, viruses aren't even alive (and I'm in the "not alive" camp myself in that debate). They have no intent nor purpose nor meaning.

I mean, if they did, then where would this be happening? Where's the physical location of the part of them that holds this abstract concept of "intent" (I was about to type "in their heads"... but, well, that's my point, they don't have heads and brains, so where would any such intent or purpose be coming from exactly?).

It's not an unfair question, because if you asked the same of human beings then I'd happily have an answer for you. It's in your mind. The functioning of your brain. With an MRI scan, we could be even more precise in pin-pointing its physical location within that grey matter, if you like.

And natural selection is not even a thing. I mean, it is an abstract thing, but it's not a physical thing. It's a process. A "strange attractor" in a chaotic system. A general tendency of things tumbling about to find a stable configuration.

It's not a person, who's sitting down over there, making it all happen. It's not, like, some magic black box that's sending out "natural selection rays".

There can be no intent nor purpose here. Because, well, where would it reside? How would it get its influence from wherever it resides to all life on Earth to make its intent happen? Like, as I say, is there some kind of box or rock or something somewhere inside the Earth that's radiating out "natural selection rays"?

Basically, what's the mechanism? Because there must be a physical mechanism that causes it to happen.

So, like, even if you tell me that there's a supernatural god "outside the universe" (whatever that means) who's making it all happen, to fulfil her own personal "intent", then how does she do it? Even if it is of supernatural cause, it's interacting with natural physical things. There must be an interface between the two at some point. The "magic" is changing physical atoms. Even if you can't measure the magic, you should be able to measure the interface, where the magic "touches" the physical and natural.

Like, if I throw a ball and then God intervenes to move the ball then, well, it's now clearly disobeying Newton's laws. The "magic" is perturbing its natural course - so is it somehow adding in extra momentum from nowhere, or is it stopping what momentum is there from actually following physical law. Even if I can't measure the magic, it must be possible to measure the physical bits of this system and directly witness them breaking the rules?

But, you know, I do get it.

I'm a coder and I've used computers all my life. And there have been occasions where I've superstitiously not moved a joystick while a tape was loading, "just in case". There's moments where I've wanted to get violent at its intransigence, and punch the screen or smash the keyboard. I've pleaded with my C64, ST and PCs to "please, please, save the file". I have, at a particularly desperate moment, even tried some bargaining. "Look, if you do this for me, then I'll not ask anything more of you". Bribery even - "if you do this, then I'll give you a RAM upgrade".

And, indeed, we can all regularly witness giles swearing at the Android SDK over in the programming forums.

But, here's the thing, both me and giles code the machine. We know how compilers work, how it all boils down to CPU instructions, we know about logic gates and can see how simple mechanical operations can, indeed, build up to the programs we write. And those programs, from hours of debugging, we know are only ever deterministically doing what they're told... unfortunately, to a fault.

I know for a solid fact that there is absolutely NO "ghost in the machine". I can - and have - traced code in operation, and manually confirmed that its always following the instructions perfectly (well, save perhaps the Pentium "IDIV" bug but you know what I mean) and, every single time, the error was mine (or Microsoft's, which is why I generally hate them).

I know, for a solid indisputable fact, as the thing I've devoted most of my life in the pursuit thereof, that there is absolutely nothing there.

There is no ghost in the machine. No "entity" there with intent. It's just a very, very elaborate set of cogs and wheels. An exceedingly complex machine. But just a machine, operating purely mechanically.

I know that there's bugger all point threatening it, getting violent, pleading with it, trying to persuade it, trying to make a bargain or offer a bribe, or anything else. THERE IS NOTHING THERE TO RESPOND.

Mind you, this shit does, of course, often work on fellow human beings. Beg for mercy, make a deal, bung a bribe, threaten to kick their head in... these methods work on other thinking agents like myself. Hey, including with dogs, as a stern voice and a bag of dog treats works wonders - so I don't only limit this to humans alone.

And what I'm getting at is that this sense of "agency" is so strong, so "built-in" to us human beings, that we'll still imagine it, still respond to it, still modify our behaviour according to it... even when we absolutely 100% know for a solid indisputable fact that the computer cannot be threatened or bribed or persuaded. Indeed, without plugging in a microphone, it can't even hear me. And I know it doesn't speak English anyway, even if it could.

I KNOW I'm talking to a brick wall. And, yet, I still feel compelled - instinctively - to do so.

To ascribe "intent" and "purpose" and "meaning" where there simply isn't any. It's a very powerful feeling, though, I understand this, as I'm also human and I feel it too, and I have totally sworn blue murder at a computer screen on occasion. Who am I talking to? Truthfully, just myself. But I guess it's part of the whole "theory of mind" thing that I pretend like the computer can hear me.

We all, unfortunately, have this sense of "false agency". It seems to be a vestigial bit of "caveman" programming still stuck in our brain circuits back there.

Because, you see, the one thing about natural selection that most people seem to fail to understand is that it's only ever a "good enough" process. Man, it's littered with vestigial and redundant bollocks, bad design everywhere. Like, perhaps amongst the best evidence that there really are no gods is that, well, if there were, they've done an atrociously poor job of things. Like, I'm a puny human and I can spot tons of "bugs" in this program. Really stupid design.

I do so love this tirade by Neil deGrasse Tyson, as a quick blitzkrief over why none of this shit makes any sense:

"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by Cloudane »

Harlequin wrote:
Cloudane wrote:The goal for anything is replication, it's an expanding universe.
That is certainly not my goal, nor that of many people I know. Do we not count as anything in this universe? I do not think my mug of tea wants to replicate, either. The general cruft of papers, magazines, boxes and the like in my home does give the illusion of following your rule, though. As does the dust.
Well, that's taking my comment deliberately over-literally, but living organisms generally. We're a bit of an exception with our complex minds but most things have an innate "design" of reproducing. This is the basics of nature.
Selected by whom?
Natural selection. Some would say a guy called Darwin, but he just popularised the theory that makes up basic biology in the present day.
Read some biology books
You're the one who just asked me who does natural selection XD
Humans could probably replicate even more if we still gave birth to large litters as most other mammals do, but we seem to have evolved in the opposite direction. Does that mean that we have "failed"? Should non-heterosexuality be considered an unnatural evil? Is keeping people alive decades after fertility some kind of crime against our species?
Humans are not exactly a basic microorganism though and not a virus (even if misanthropists enjoy calling us one). Viruses don't think. They just mutate, and the ones that mutate to be easier to spread become dominant because, well, that's how the universe works?! Things come into existence. It's not like things are going backwards. Normally, less harmful mutations would be selected - this is nothing to do with anyone making a decision, it's just logic, viruses don't thrive if they kill their hosts.

This one is interesting as that's not applying - I guess because we have good healthcare systems so they can carry on replicating as long as they're not killing the host in particularly big numbers, but this does put a burden on said healthcare systems, which a virus is incapable of caring about.
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by Cloudane »

Perhaps "goal" was an incorrect word to use, but does no one read the intended meaning of what's being said? Do we need all this effort singling out one word and picking it apart?
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by zip accident »

Cloudane wrote:Perhaps "goal" was an incorrect word to use, but does no one read the intended meaning of what's being said? Do we need all this effort singling out one word and picking it apart?
Words are all we have. Thoughts may be bigger and/or wiser, but to get ideas from one head to another, all we have is language and gestures (including sharp sticks to the eyeball). Language is inadequate, but it's pretty much all we have (counting maths and logic as languages, or aspects of languages).
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by Cloudane »

Yeah, but surely it's possible to grasp the context of what someone is trying to say even if they use one incorrect word. It's needlessly pedantic. But "you win I will shut up and stop trying to say things"
User avatar
Ollie
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4446
Joined: Mon May 03, 2004 7:04 pm 0
Location: London
Contact:

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by Ollie »

Cloudane wrote:
Harlequin wrote:
Cloudane wrote:The goal for anything is replication, it's an expanding universe.
That is certainly not my goal, nor that of many people I know. Do we not count as anything in this universe? I do not think my mug of tea wants to replicate, either. The general cruft of papers, magazines, boxes and the like in my home does give the illusion of following your rule, though. As does the dust.
Well, that's taking my comment deliberately over-literally, but living organisms generally. We're a bit of an exception with our complex minds but most things have an innate "design" of reproducing. This is the basics of nature.
It's not a "design," nor a "goal." The fact that most things in nature reproduce is simply an inevitable consequence of the fact that things which don't reproduce tend to die out.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by zip accident »

KlaxonCow wrote:Oh dear. This has all gone pear-shaped.

There is no "goal". No intent, no purpose, no destination.

After all, think of it this way, when does natural selection stop?
I suspect natural selection is a function of entropy. Entropy stops when the universe reaches heat death, when energy is uniformly distributed through space, and if black holes exist, that may be never.
Arguably, viruses aren't even alive (and I'm in the "not alive" camp myself in that debate). They have no intent nor purpose nor meaning.

I mean, if they did, then where would this be happening? Where's the physical location of the part of them that holds this abstract concept of "intent" (I was about to type "in their heads"... but, well, that's my point, they don't have heads and brains, so where would any such intent or purpose be coming from exactly?).
Viruses evolve, and replicate. I take the view that the current definition of "life", by which they are not alive, is faulty. It's a techicality, and not an important one. Prions are proteins, why the presence of one thats folded wrong makes one that's folded correctly fold wrong I don't know, maybe somebody does, but it doesn't sound to me as if they are alive, the replication is in the cells, if it changed the folding might not happen? I believe that life doesn't imply intent, amoebae have activity but they almost certainly don't have intent, it's all just reactions to stimuli, which viruses must also have.
It's not an unfair question, because if you asked the same of human beings then I'd happily have an answer for you. It's in your mind. The functioning of your brain. With an MRI scan, we could be even more precise in pin-pointing its physical location within that grey matter, if you like.
Where do you stop? do Cats have intention? Chimpanzees? Earthworms? Hydra? Wasps? Wasp Nests? I deeply regret that I do not remember what the species was that had (about?) 2,000 neurons that could be mapped exactly, I think it was a worm? anyway, that seems small enough that you could say it was probably all stimulus and response.
And natural selection is not even a thing. I mean, it is an abstract thing, but it's not a physical thing. It's a process. A "strange attractor" in a chaotic system. A general tendency of things tumbling about to find a stable configuration.
This is wonderful. It's all correct, but it's direction seems to be off. Would you say the same about entropy? it's all about selection by anti-selecting the things that fail. Prime numbers are selected by eliminating the numbers that are not prime, are prime numbers not a thing?
Basically, what's the mechanism? Because there must be a physical mechanism that causes it to happen.
The mechanism is the death of those who fail, with prime numbers there is the Sieve of Eratosthenes (I presume he was greek).
So, like, even if you tell me that there's a supernatural god "outside the universe" (whatever that means) who's making it all happen, to fulfil her own personal "intent", then how does she do it? Even if it is of supernatural cause, it's interacting with natural physical things. There must be an interface between the two at some point. The "magic" is changing physical atoms. Even if you can't measure the magic, you should be able to measure the interface, where the magic "touches" the physical and natural.
I very much hope there isn't, because that would be a Devil.
Because, you see, the one thing about natural selection that most people seem to fail to understand is that it's only ever a "good enough" process. Man, it's littered with vestigial and redundant bollocks, bad design everywhere. Like, perhaps amongst the best evidence that there really are no gods is that, well, if there were, they've done an atrociously poor job of things. Like, I'm a puny human and I can spot tons of "bugs" in this program. Really stupid design.
The process is one step at a time, and if you can't get there without missing a step, then you can't get there. The mark one billion eyeball is a pretty amazing thing.
Cloudane wrote:Yeah, but surely it's possible to grasp the context of what someone is trying to say even if they use one incorrect word. It's needlessly pedantic. But "you win I will shut up and stop trying to say things"
It is very difficult to grasp the context of what someone is trying to say. Sometimes it's one word, sometimes it's a dozen. It's generally meant to clarify what intentions are, not to score points, though those people exist and should generally be avoided if malice is absolutely confirmed to be present.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by KlaxonCow »

I don't know why they don't teach natural selection the way Darwin himself explained it in "Origin of Species".

Because, honestly, the dude spent 20 years pondering its explanation and I think he nails it.

He spends the introductory chapters discussing artificial breeding. You know, dog breeding, pigeon fancying, domesticated crops and animals. That sort of thing.

(And Darwin actually became a pigeon fancier himself. Though it took him 20 years to reveal his theories, he didn't sit on his arse. He did various experiments to confirm and expand his ideas. One of which was that he took up pigeon fancying. Kept some pigeons and bred them.

Another experiment involved him pissing on some of the plants in his conservatory. Yeah, that one sounds a bit mad, but what he did successfully work out is that plants love nitrogen. There's nitrogen in piss, you see, and the plants he pissed on thrived better than his "control" plants that he didn't piss on. It's an odd experiment to be sure, but nitrogen-based fertilisers - based on the Haber process - helps grow much of the world's food. So pissing on his plants was a crucial first step in a series that eventually lead to even being possible to feed billions of people around the globe.)

Anyway, yeah, Darwin discusses the perfectly uncontroversial subject of breeding.

We all know the gist of it. The dog breeder selects breeding pairs, according to their beneficial traits (and also lack of negative traits). So, if you want a bigger dog, then you choose the biggest dogs as your breeding pair. Because, as we all know, children take after their parents. So, if you breed off the biggest dogs then, chances are, they'll have big children. And then, next generation, you can repeat the process and, slowly, you steer the very morphology of these dogs through your breeding pair selections.

And this is, simply, selection. I have a large pack of dogs and I'm selecting which dogs should breed. If I want a more agreeable breed, then I choose the most passive and friendly dogs. Chances are, their children will take after them. Then, from those children, we select the most passive and friendly dogs. Until, eventually, we're steered the process towards a new passive and friendly breed of dog.

There's no controversy here, right? Children take after their parents. Dog breeders - and pigeon fanciers, and farmers with domestic crops - have been doing this for a very long time (indeed, dogs are, in fact, the descendants of wolves but humans seemingly bred them into a whole different species altogether), and everyone knows this is the case. No controversy there.

But then Darwin performs his magic trick. He yanks the tablecloth from under the plates and cutlery on the table.

What happens if there's no human breeder there to select the breeding pairs?

Well, the dogs would, of course, select themselves. I can't personally vouch for what bitches find attractive, but let's say they like a big male dog as a partner - a bruiser, who can see off threats to their would-be children - then the female dog is doing the selection, and she's choosing the bigger "alpha" dog.

So, chances are, same as with the earlier artificial selection from a human breeder, if successive female dogs are choosing bigger male dogs as their sexual partners, then their offspring will, again, take after their parents.

And now you understand why Darwin called this "natural selection". As he was comparing it to the artificial selection - or just "selection" - of dog breeders or pigeon fanciers.

But was posing the idea of, if you take the human breeder out of the equation, the dogs are still being selected for and the process remains essentially the same - with children taking after their parents, who're both on the look out for beneficial traits in their sexual partners - but now the selection is "natural selection". The selection that just inherently takes place between dogs.

So, to answer the question of who does the selection? The dogs do. Natural selection is self-selection. Inherent selection, as dogs feel sexual attraction to each other.

If one removes the external selection - the artificial selection - of a breeder, then these dogs and pigeons and crops and cows would, of course, select themselves. They'd naturally pair off, as suits their fancy.

And this is "natural selection", in opposition to the "artificial selection" of a human breeder.

But this does only, as yet, cover "sexual selection" - which is a form of natural selection that rarely gets mentioned, even though it is the most direct form of selection and has a big influence on things - the further realisation of Darwin is that, of course, the circumstances and environment of the animals further affects the choice.

Most simply and bluntly, the female dog can't choose a dead male dog as its sexual partner. It's dead. It can't engage in sexual reproduction. Also, being dead, it's not much company on a cold Winter night either, it must be said.

Therefore, in addition to sexual selection, there's also the "natural selection" from environmental factors that limit the choices available.

Another obvious one on that score is geography - as Darwin famously examined through his finches that lived on a series of islands, which showed that, as logic would dictate, if a sexual partner is geographically isolated, then that further limits the choice - in that you're more likely to meet your future wife in the local area, than from Russia or the Philippines (well, unless you've been using one of those "mail order bride" websites lately), simply because those are your more readily available choices.

As I say, you have to read Darwin in the original. He explains it so simply and perfectly, in my opinion. There was nothing particularly hard or complicated or controversial in any of that, was there?

And it gives you the correct answer to the "who does the selection?" question. It's self-selection, within the confines of what the environment allows.

It's the "natural selection" that all of us sexual species do. Of quite fancying the girl next door. Of swiping left and right on your dating app. Of being set up on a blind date by a work colleague who can't understand that, honestly, you're not miserable being single and you really don't need to keep doing this.

It's a natural selection, as opposed to the artificial imposed selection of a breeder, choosing breeding pairs. If the breeder ain't there, then who's choosing the breeding pairs? Well, the animals (or plants) themselves. And that "choice" - if it is a choice, as plants throw out pollen to the winds and where it lands is where it lands - is inherent, intrinsic and, well, "natural". Ergo, "natural selection". The selection which, in the absence of an external "breeder" forcing the selection, is just what happens naturally.

And then you ask yourself what factors guide and limit those choices. As noted, being dead tends to throw a major "Debbie Downer" on the whole proceedings. You can't have sex with a corpse - or, at least, if you're a bit sick and weird, then you can, but it will not result in any pregnancy and offspring.

And that one's a bit of a brick wall in the "available selection" stakes. And, as we're discussing here, it's often the big brick wall that forces the reproduction down an inevitable path.

When vaccines work well, then immune systems get good at seeing off viruses. So vaccines create this "brick wall" and steer things in a hopefully good direction for us - this is us reaching in and applying a bit of "artificial selection" back into the mix to regain some control over where this is going.

It's a beautifully simple explanation, I feel. I have no idea why Darwin is not taught by the very same way Darwin himself explained it. Because he did a bloody job of it.


And fuck Herbert Spencer's "survival of the fittest" crap. Because, yes, Darwin did not come up with that phrase. It was Herbert Spencer, as he was rather dubiously comparing natural selection to "dog eat dog" economic theory. The original inventor of "Economic Darwinism". Only one step less horridly wrong than "Social Darwinism". Neither of these two, by the way, should carry Darwin's name, as it is demonstrably bollocks pseudo-science that just isn't correct.

Darwin, desperate for a catchy phrase to capture natural selection for the layperson - as he was keen for all to understand the revelation that had struck him - made the horrible choice of endorsing this phrase and "borrowing" it for later editions of "Origin of Species". That was a mistake, in my opinion.

At best, "survival of the fittest" is horridly misleading. More directly, as people will commonly interpret it, it's just plain wrong.

To explain that, let's say we've got three subjects - A, B and C. Now, subject A is "the fittest" - that is, they easily survive to pass on their genes. Then Subject B is "moderately fit" - that is, they do manage, barely, to pass on their genes. And subject C is "unfit" - that is, an illness kills them off as a child and they never get the chance to pass on their genes.

Now, the naive interpretation of "survival of the fittest" is substitution. Subject A is "the fittest". Therefore, by substitution, "survival of the fittest" means "survival of subject A", right?

Wrong. This shitty phrase has mislead you to the completely wrong conclusion.

In fact, both subjects A and B survive. Only subject C does not, as they are "unfit", in the sense that they never got the chance to pass on their genes.

If you're being kind, then you could say that "survival of the fittest" makes sense if you understand "the fittest" to be a plural, not a singular. We don't mean "the fittest" as in literally the individual that's most fit - subject A - but in a broader plural sense of "all those who are fit".

But, yes, this is bollocks. Because who naturally reads a sentence with a superlative like "fittest" in it, and then thinks "ah, right, that clearly means all those who're fit as one big plural class".

Now, if it was "survival of the fit" then you might actually start thinking that way. But if I say "who's the fastest 100m runner?" then, odds on, you're going to name an individual like "Usain Bolt". You're not going to list all the competitors of the last Olympics 100m race, are you?

The superlative is just wrong. Or, at least, so deeply misleading, it's as good as wrong.

Fuck Herbert Spencer. He was just one of the first of the breed of "greed is good" economists who're trying to half-inch Darwinism as if them being arseholes is "only natural" and being the first - of a long line of cunts - to commit the naturalistic fallacy, in pursuit of their own fucked up aims, pretending it's only right and proper.

In this case, the naturalistic fallacy I speak of is the one where you (sometimes deliberately) confuse an "is" for an "ought". Natural selection "is", for sure, but there's nothing about that which logically leads to it being an "ought".

For a nicer example of the naturalistic fallacy at work then, hey, disease is perfectly natural. Therefore, as it's the way things are, then it should be the way things should be. Confusing the "is" for an "ought". So, by this reckoning, close all the hospitals, stop all medical science, get rid of doctors... all they do is try to prevent what is perfectly "natural" in people getting diseases, and becoming ill and dying.

(And gay people will know about this naturalistic fallacy from the homophobes who're all about how being gay isn't "natural". Even though, you know, it is demonstrably entirely naturally occurring - not just in humans, but it's been seen across innumerable animal species too.

Which leads to the other "line in the sand" problem with the naturalistic fallacy. How are you defining "natural" exactly? I mean, I'm a human being and human beings came about through the entirely natural process of evolution. Ergo, if humans are natural, then you could argue that anything we do is also "natural" by extension. Humans are a product of nature, human intelligence to eventually invent plastics came about naturally, therefore plastics are "natural" and so, confusing an "is" for an "ought", we should leave the oceans to fill up with plastic because, hey, you could argue that this - and, frankly, anything at all - is "natural" by extension. Where do you draw the line? How do you actually define "natural"?

Yeah, it's a known logical fallacy. It does not hold. To go from "is" to "ought" is a logical non-sequitur. You're doing it wrong.)

There is no intent. None whatsoever. Natural selection is the blind watchmaker - no intent, no foresight, no plan, no goal.

Indeed, let us further refine Spencer to get the emphasis right. It's "non-survival of the unfit". Where "unfit" literally means failing to reproduce.

It's not that natural selection is, at any point, selecting the best. Please remove that superlative "fittest" from your mind, as it's quite wrong. Rather, it's culling the worst.

Whether you have the looks of Brad Pitt, the intelligence of Einstein and the fitness of an Olympic athlete, or you're, like, a bit fat, a bit ugly, and sit on your arse all day, once you've sown your seed and passed on your genes to the next generation, that's it. You are "fit".

Like, "survival of the fittest" - being an egotistical bit of self-flattery from an economist thinking he's all that for being richer than most - would imply some silly nonsense, if you think about it. What does not happen is that, every generation, everyone but, say, Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie (being my exemplar "fittest" people for illustration) drop dead. But the Spencer misinterpretation implies this. Who's the fittest? Well, this is the most fit bloke and the most fit bird. Okay, survival of those two... and everyone else drops dead, failing to pass on their genes to the next generation?

Well, no, that's not how it fucking works at all. We all know this. With our own two eyes. Indeed, possibly by the fact that you've already got kids. There you go. Already passed the test. I can be run over by a bus tomorrow, but my genes live on through little "Apple" and "X Æ A-12". Hey, don't you criticise my kids' names!

Anyway, stop using the phrase "survival of the fittest" - well, unless, like me, you're trying to point out how wrong and misleading it actually is - because it's honestly bollocks, and will mislead you to the completely wrong conclusion.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by gilesgoat »

<metaphysics>

"The ultimate goal of the soul is to attain liberation, liberation from Samsara, the otherwise eternal cycle of death, rebirth, suffering, pleasure, creation, destruction, etc. Only when you attain Nirvana ( or Moksha ) you reached your ultimate goal" ...

Anything else generates Karma and is subjected to it, or the bindings of causes/effects leading to the cycle of Samsara, the more you are attached to Karma the further away you go from Nirvana.

Owing to the absence of the cause of bondage and with the functioning of the dissociation of karmas the annihilation of all karmas is liberation.
Having achieved the ultimate goal, knowing everything that needs to be known, and enjoying eternal and supreme bliss, the Omniscient, Effulgent Soul, rests permanently in the Highest State (of liberation).
</metaphysics>

Or, in essence, anything else that is NOT going in the path to obtain liberation is "just going into another cycle" and this goes on at infinity until you finally reach liberation.

Also note "liberation" is NOT "heaven" in the "standard religion form" nor has anything to do with the concept of "God" ( but let's not go there for the moment ) it's "a state" ( also for some thinkers still an individual state different from being to being that reached it , for others not, depending on who you follow ) and it's not even something "purerly theorectical" as there are "recipes and procedures" to reach it .. they are just .. not easy .. and not fast ..

And with that, I can go bed :roll: :mrgreen:
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by gilesgoat »

KlaxonCow wrote:*SNIP*
BTW do you know that in USA is ILLEGAL to teach evolutionist theories in schools ? :mrgreen:
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by Harlequin »

Cloudane wrote:
Read some biology books
You're the one who just asked me who does natural selection XD
Umm... Who were you quoting and responding to there?
Cloudane wrote:… it's just logic, viruses don't thrive if they kill their hosts.
Please convince the deadliest Marburg and Ebola viruses (very much thriving in large areas of the world) of that.

Rabies still thrives and apparently had a 100% death rate (at least among humans) before we developed treatments for it. Much the same could be said for HIV.
Cloudane wrote:Yeah, but surely it's possible to grasp the context of what someone is trying to say even if they use one incorrect word. It's needlessly pedantic. But "you win I will shut up and stop trying to say things"
In my own case, aside from seeming to be genetically pedantic, I am suspected of being autistic (pending a diagnostic panel, for which I've been waiting for over a year). Whatever the case, I appear to be in the habit of assuming literal meaning unless there are fairly immediate and (to me) obvious contextual cues from which to derive a different definitive meaning. I think this tendency becomes more severe in non-humorous discussions of philosophical nature, including science, religion and politics.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by KlaxonCow »

zip accident wrote:I suspect natural selection is a function of entropy.
That sounds profound. But I honestly have no idea what you could be talking about, sorry.
zip accident wrote:Viruses evolve, and replicate. I take the view that the current definition of "life", by which they are not alive, is faulty.
I don't agree, but I'm not going to argue with you over this.

Because, well, in the end, it's just a word. And, as the Bard had it, "what's in a name?".

I'm with Feynmann on this. It's not what things are called, it's what they actually are and the names of things doesn't not, unto itself, constitute knowledge:



So, I'm fine with the "not alive" category myself. Because I think if something doesn't have the capacity to independently metabolise or reproduce, then that's not alive, because it cannot independently function or exist. At the very least, you have to consider it "symbiotic". And, well, there's just a problem in declaring what's basically a string of raw RNA to be "alive", because does that mean that, within each of our cells, we're carrying an independent lifeform in the form of our DNA?

Personally, though, I think it doesn't matter. Per Feynmann, it's what a thing is, not what it's called. And, like memes, things do not need to be alive in order to undergo reproduction and natural selection. Being alive is not a requirement for evolution by natural selection. So, for me, the designation doesn't really matter, but I do side with the "not alive" category by my own tastes and prejudices.
zip accident wrote:It's a techicality, and not an important one.
Yes, certainly, we can 100% agree on it not being important.
zip accident wrote:Where do you stop? do Cats have intention? Chimpanzees? Earthworms? Hydra? Wasps? Wasp Nests? I deeply regret that I do not remember what the species was that had (about?) 2,000 neurons that could be mapped exactly, I think it was a worm? anyway, that seems small enough that you could say it was probably all stimulus and response.
I think this might well be like the classification for "alive" and "not alive".

There isn't really a neat definitive line in the sand. You can say, on one extreme, that something is "not alive" or "has no intent" - such as a single carbon atom - and then you can say, on the other extreme - a human being - that, yeah, they're definitely "alive" and "have intent".

But I don't think there's an obvious neat dividing line there. It's all "line in the sand" stuff. That there's probably degrees and measures of both "being alive" and "having intent". Like, our human intents are quite complicated things. But maybe a cat does have intent, but it's a more primitive form - just "want food", "want warmth", "feel the urge to hunt", etc. - so it's not our form of "intent", but it is its own simpler form of "having intent". And there just probably is no neat dividing line there at all. There's just degrees of "intent" - a spectrum of capability to have some kind of intent - and different animals are in different places on the scale.

And like with "being alive", where do you want to draw the line in the sand to say, "okay, at this point, we consider these primitive mechanisms to constitute a form of 'intent'"? And that there probably is no objective "right answer" to this.

And, as I was also saying, even if there was, then how do we even measure this? We're heading into Descartesean territory here - how do I even know, for certain, that you are real and have intent? I can't enter your brain to verify it. I just trust, from your responses, that you're very much behaving as if that's true. But I can't really ever know it for certain.
zip accident wrote:Would you say the same about entropy?
What exactly? That it's "a general tendency of things tumbling about to find a stable configuration"?

I guess, in the sense that I think everything ultimately amounts to that.

Unstable things are unstable. Obviously. Tautologically.

But the point I'm making there is that instability cannot be a final state. It's not sustainable, you "tumble" from one instability to another. And this only ends when you find a stable configuration. Stable things are stable. That can be a final state. A thing tumbles until it comes to rest, and then it just stays there (unless an external force comes along and makes it unstable again).

In a sense, that's like a generic version of Newton's First Law: "an object in motion stays in motion and an object at rest stays at rest, unless an external force acts upon them". But while he's talking about physical things, I think this "stable / unstable" principle can be more universally applied.

Not sure if it applies to entropy, as I've never thought about it. But, like, I can see it working for diffusion, gravity and motion (per Newton's laws), electric charge / magnetism (which is always seeking a stable "balance"), etc.

It's like a more generic "higher" law that everything is seemingly always seeking out a stable balance, as instability is unsustainable. So instability keeps changing, stays in motion, until it finds a stable "resting place" and then, barring nothing coming along to disturb that balance, the stable configuration can, in theory, last forever.
zip accident wrote:The process is one step at a time, and if you can't get there without missing a step, then you can't get there.
Well, what I was specifically getting at, by calling natural selection a "good enough" process actually stems from working with genetic algorithms.

It's quite literally a "good enough" process by the usual definitions of that term. Like, there's evolutionary pressure and while the pressure is on, it'll evolve. But if there's a stable configuration that's "good enough" and crosses the bar - the evolutionary pressure is now off - then it honestly won't bother doing anything more.

So, like, that statement isn't theory, but just empirical from actual practice. It is a "good enough" process, in that if it can find a stable configuration that meets the bar of evolutionary pressure, then it will not intrinsically seek a more optimal solution.

If it gets stuck in a local minima - a ditch in the graph - then it'll just stay there. It will not seek - not without some external "nudging" - to find a more optimal solution. What it's found is "good enough", so it gives up right there, at the first available opportunity.

And I think that aspect of natural selection is rarely mentioned. I get the impression that people think it's some perfect process that always finds the optimal solutions. But, nah, honestly, you can mess about with Genetic Algorithms to get a feel for it. It simply just doesn't actually do that. It doesn't care. As long as a solution works to cross the bar, then that'll do. It's good enough. There will be no intrinsic "urge" to keep looking for a more optimal answer - not unless something comes along and gives it a good kick out of its complacency. That's literally how, if you play with these things, it actually behaves in practice.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by gilesgoat »

Obligatory ....



I prefer him in Pulp Fiction ..
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: Coronavirus Pandemic

Post by Cloudane »

Just going to stay out of it.

I don't get it, don't know who to believe (the "we're on our way out of it because vaccines work" crowd, or the "vaccines won't save us, we're all fucked" crowd) and can't try to assess any particular position without everyone getting pissed off.
Post Reply