gilesgoat wrote:What if .. all this "master plan" has long term unforseen consequences ? ...
I think calling it a "master plan" might be very much over-egging the pudding.
A Machiavellian evil genius Boris is not. So let's just call it "a plan".
Well, the very much foreseen consequences - which I've been saying for months - is that with more cases comes more mutations, and eventually those mutations might add up to yet another new variant.
If this occurs - though mutation is inherently random, so it's literally a dice roll - then, by evolutionary pressure, the new variant
will be tending towards greater transmissibility and it
will chip away at vaccine efficacy.
All the more so to let it rip in a country that actually has one of the best vaccination rates in the world. Because, to gain a foothold, it'll be the mutations that resist - or even escape - the vaccines that'll be selected for (or, to put it another way, any mutation that doesn't resist / escape the vaccine will hit the "brick wall" of the vaccinated and get nowhere. But the mutations that are more resistant / escape the vaccines won't be slowed down / stopped as much by the vaccines, so those are the ones that'll spread far and wide, and multiply. We've seen this with the Delta variant, in that it's become the dominant variant in the UK).
These are, from the virus's point of view, pretty much the ideal conditions for brewing up that "vaccine escape" variant that we all fear.
In Boris's uninformed ignorance, he might think releasing the virus to "let rip" in an environment where many are already double-jabbed is fine, because the vaccines are "magic" and the magic will protect us. This scientifically illiterate perspective is fundamentally wrong. It's not "just fine" at all.
The vaccines and the virus are not independent. Natural selection is adaptation to one's environment. And if you're letting things rip in an environment where the virus's only way to survive is to adapt to the vaccines, you are essentially goading it to escape.
The insane gamble is essentially this.
We do this and the virus doesn't mutate any new "variants of concern". Then we have a highly immune population, a virus that we can keep under control (at the moment) through vaccines. That's the good scenario, where we "win".
The bad scenario is that we do this, the virus mutates a new variant that is, in fact, either highly resistant to the vaccines or it just flat out breeds "vaccine escape" - basically, new variants will chip away at the vaccine efficacy, as that's just natural selection, but the worry is that it might not just be a 2% or 3% loss of efficacy, it could leap to a 30%, 40%, 50% loss of efficacy or even the dreaded "vaccine escape", where vaccine efficacy becomes 0% and it just doesn't work anymore.
Now, this would be atrocious. Because all the immunity that we've accumulated through jabs and natural immunity? Gone. It just vanishes in the puff of smoke. The vaccines now, unfortunately, do nothing (well, nothing with full-blown "vaccine escape" or they could be severely compromised with mere "vaccine resistance").
And, as we all know, eventually these variants always find a way out of the originating country to infect the world. So, to be clear, Boris is not merely gambling with the UK population, this is gambling with the entire human race. Because, equally, the "immunity wall" built up in Israel, in Europe, in the USA and everywhere else on the planet? It'll equally be useless when Boris's "Omega variant" finally breaks into their country.
The hard work of the vaccines undone, we'll have to go back into global lockdown and start again to make new ones. While vast numbers are now suffering Long Covid for the next year or so.
Rather than "Freedom Day", it could end up being the "Send Us All Back to Square One Day" instead.
That's the gamble. That's the dice roll.
Either we nudge the immunity level of the UK population up a few more percent to perhaps, maybe, reach "herd immunity" (but, with Delta, the threshold is already high, so it's entirely possible that this just doesn't work - and the efficacy of the AZ vaccine, mostly used in the UK, isn't as high as the other vaccines anyway), so that - at least while the rest of the world hasn't yet brewed up a new variant that will inevitably come to bother us at some point - we might be able to get back a little bit more economic activity.
Or, alternatively, we end up with a variant of strong "vaccine resistance" or even "vaccine escape" and then everything gets reset. For the whole planet, as this will eventually get out of the UK and around the world, as all the variants have done. We're back in lockdown and the tightest restrictions, as we'll lack the protection of the vaccines again. All the hard work won to build up "herd immunity" is reset.
Another few years of this carrying on? Full of anger and resentment that, for fuck's sake, we were so damned close and Boris threw it away for the sake of rushing it.
That's the dice roll. The basic "risk versus reward" that this idiot man-baby is playing with.
And one has to consider that even if it pays off for Boris, by a fluke roll of that dice, then other countries will then think he's "shown them the way" and they'll all, one by one, take the exact same gamble. So we don't just need the dice to roll good once, but about 200 times. Which is statistically not going to happen.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes