Dio wrote:Harlequin wrote:I am not sure what the difference is supposed to be between people in Newcastle being ruled by unelected persons and bodies in London and their being ruled by unelected persons and bodies in Brussels.
Yeah, that's my 'granularity' point.
Sure, but you can also look at it from the angle that the UK's own internal "granularity" doesn't remotely work, so, like, maybe we should be worrying about getting our own house in order first.
How does the Bible phrase it? Something like "don't worry about the mote in your brother's eye, while there's a plank in your own eye".
That "running gag" irony that as Westminster complains about EU rules and demands independence from the European Union, it dismisses Hollyrood complaints about Westminster rules and Scottish demands for independence from the UK Union.
It's basically exactly the same thing, just happening at a different level in the hierarchy.
And, yes, I'm sure that if, say, the Orkney Islands wanted to secede from Scotland and demand Orkney independence, then we'd see the same thing, with the Scottish government acting just like the Westminster government, dismissing it out of hand with a patronising "don't be silly".
As every level of this hierarchy does, indeed, want to consolidate centralised power to itself - so rejects being controlled by the next level above it, while dismissing the levels below it from, well, doing exactly the same thing to it.
And, therefore, to get more philosophical about this, I don't believe there is a solution to the granularity problem. It's inherently a "line in the sand" thing, with no actual objective "right answer". From a true global "Wild West" anarchy, where everyone is individually self-governing - that would be shit - to some tyrannical "One World Government" - that would also be shit - there's no definitive place where you can draw the line in the sand that's "correct".
Although, I have advocated for a more "federal" UK, where Scotland, England, Wales and Northern Ireland all have regional Parliaments and are equal partners in the Union, where Westminster is the Parliament of the Union.
Because I think that any "top down" solution is going to fail on this, so I'd prefer a "bottom up" solution.
For example, instead of my taxes going to Westminster, and then for the regions and local authorities to have to beg for that money from the central power, I'd have it work in the other direction. I pay my taxes to my local authority.
Then my local authority hands money up the chain for shared concerns. For instance, a motorway runs through my local authority area and through neighbouring ones too - so they all collectively have an interest in its maintenance, and get together to work together to do that. All the Scottish local authorities then hand tax money up to the Scottish government, who deals with the Scotland-wide things. Then, at the highest level, the regional governments hand money up to Westminster, whose job is to deal with the UK-wide stuff - such as defence, border policy, international relations, etc..
And this reversal of the power structure - bottom up, instead of top down - implicitly puts a check on the consolidation of power. Because the purse strings - where the real power resides - is actually at the bottom rung, closest to the people, and money is sent up to the higher levels, where we share mutual interest.
This essentially forces what Thomas Jefferson had that governments rule by the consent of the governed. Westminster doesn't take all my taxes, and then the lower local levels have to beg for some of that money back. My taxes all go to my local authority. Then it's Westminster that has to persuade and beg for the money to be sent up to it.
I don't think you can solve the granularity problem by just moving the line in the sand, as wherever you place those lines, that's the level where you'll find a rejection of the levels above, and a dismissal of the levels below, as that level looks out for itself and tries to consolidate power unto itself.
But if the higher levels are dependent on the lower levels, then they can't dismiss them. And as the pyramid is numerous at the bottom, then to gain more political power - more reach - then you have to work together with your peers to create a new higher level in the hierarchy.
Such a structure is designed so that you have to cooperate. And the directionality of power is reversed, so you can't dismiss the local level and the people. Because that's where all the money comes from, so you've got to persuade us that we should, for all our mutual interest, send some of that money upwards.
You've got to compromise, you've got to negotiate, you've got to cooperate, as the system is designed that way.
I don't think there is a solution to the granularity problem, not until you first fix "the direction of travel" of political decisions.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes