That one, to be honest, was never adequately explained.WiteWulf wrote:Why was The Doctor in prison?
It might be related to being a Fugitive of the Judoon. That is, Jo Martin's version of the Doctor was on the run, wanted by the Judoon, on behalf of the Timelords. But, really, that makes little sense, as the Judoon have not tried to arrest and imprison any earlier incarnation of the Doctor - and Jo Martin's one pre-dates Hartnell, right? - and they captured Jodie Doctor extremely easily, with a teleport, so could have presumably done that at any time?
No, it doesn't seem to be that. Doesn't make sense. And what was interesting was the other prisoners. I mean, I can't imagine that one particular Silence was worse than all the rest of them to deserve imprisonment, while leaving the rest of them alone. Particularly because, of course, no-one ever remembers that the Silence exists (perhaps the only half decent joke in the episode, with Jodie saying "Oh, yeah, I forgot you were also here"), which is a species-wide defence mechanism.
I'm thinking that maybe the fugitive thing might be a distraction - to make you think that - but, actually, that "prison" seemed more like a zoo. A collection of interesting specimens.
Then again, this is Chibnall. I'm probably over-thinking it to a level that Chibnall himself can't do, and it was just the Judoon finally capturing their fugitive, and we're just supposed to overlook that this makes no sense when earlier incarnations met the Judoon with zero problems, so the Doctor's "wanted" status was presumably over by then. The Timelords are time travellers, but the Judoon aren't. So Jo Martin was a fugitive, but then Hartnell, Troughton, Pertwee, Baker, Davison, Baker, McCoy, McGann, Eccleston, Tennant, Smith, Hurt, Capaldi weren't. Only for Jodie to become a fugitive again? I hope that really isn't it, because it makes no fucking sense.
As it was never properly addressed, maybe it's something that we later find out more about?
Thing is, though we and Jodie might not know what the fuck was going on there, Jack does. Because, when springing her out of jail, he says that he spent the last 19 years getting himself placed in a nearby cell, in order to break the Doctor out (by hiding a magic "walk through walls" ball and a time bracelet up his arse). So, like, if Jack did that, then he does know where that place is, who's rounding people up and so forth.
Mind you, again, probably over-thinking it beyond Chibnall's own capacity to write plots. I mean, if Jack possesses a "walk through walls" ball then why did he spend 19 years getting into a nearby cell to break the Doctor out? Like, just walk through the walls using the magic ball into her cell with your time bracelet and jump out. If you can walk through the walls to get out, then you could walk through the walls to get in, right?
If this is ever addressed ever again, there's a lot of explaining to do, frankly.
Gallifrey.WiteWulf wrote:Where did the "spare" TARDIS come from?
They all jumped through that portal thing and ended up on Gallifrey. The Master was there, had murdered everyone (somehow) and then all that "Timeless Child" stuff.
Anyway, they'd gotten there without the TARDIS, so to get off Gallifrey and go home - and get back to the Doctor's TARDIS - they "borrowed" another TARDIS from Gallifrey. This TARDIS, though, has a functioning Chameleon Circuit, so it disguised itself as a house when they landed in Sheffield.
(Although, this throws up the idea that there's a vast array of TARDISes on Gallifrey, with no-one guarding them, as all the Timelords are dead now. Can any old idiot just stroll in and nick one now? And why did we have to kill off the Timelords anyway? It deflates the "Timeless Child" revelation - "Doctor, you're not really a Timelord. But, don't worry, as all the Timelords are dead anyway, so none of that matters anymore". Like, finding out and coming into conflict with the Timelords - interesting. But finding out when all the Timelords are dead anyway - who cares?)
As mentioned, Jack says that he spent 19 years getting himself into a nearby cell to spring her out of there.WiteWulf wrote:Where did Captain Jack magically appear from?
So the logic is, I believe, that, being immortal, he gives no fucks for wasting 19 years of his life being in prison to somehow arrange for him to be placed next to the Doctor to launch his escape plan. Like Capaldi doing his billion year Shawshank thing of digging himself out with a spoon or whatever. Chibnall borrowing Moffat-style brain-melting time stuff but, as usual, not really knowing what the fuck he's doing.
I'm with Cloudane on this. If you think of the individual elements in these shows, they have the potential to be excellent. The individual ingredients are there. But Chibnall's just too crap as a showrunner and writer to pull it off.
I'd be okay with the Cartmel Masterplan stuff, if it was done well. But, like, the "revelation" was given to us in "tell, don't show" with a long boring Master monologue thing. Jo Martin was excellent - and only demonstrated that the problem is not with the Doctor being female, but with the choice of actor (Michelle Gomez could also have perfectly pulled it off, I reckon, had she not got the Master gig first). I like shit that "subverts expectations" - that's my gig - so I'm fine with all that.
I just think Chibnall is really, really shit. He can't write it well enough. His dialogue, on occasion, has been distinctly "George Lucas writing Star Wars". The jokes aren't funny. And the choice of Jodie - it's not that she's a woman, or that, in other roles, she doesn't act perfectly well. She just isn't, for me, a convincing Doctor. It doesn't feel, as with all the others, like a different person playing the same character, but actually a different character.
But, the thing is, as radically different as Jo Martin's version was, she managed to pull that off, for me, within seconds in just one episode. Now, that felt like the Doctor. Can we use the TARDIS to go back in time and get her cast as the first female - and black - Doctor instead of Jodie, please?




