I prefer my guns to be wearing frocks, personally.Harlequin wrote:Are we reviving the old "Guns versus Frocks" arguments?
The Dr Who thread
Re: The Dr Who thread
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: The Dr Who thread
Can't wait for it to have that kind of personality again! Even if it's not what we wanted exactly, at least it'll have something to it and not just be kind of... "just there"... like gruel...
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
I never thought I would be nostalgic for arguments about nonsensical plots and "deus ex machina" endings.Cloudane wrote:Can't wait for it to have that kind of personality again! Even if it's not what we wanted exactly, at least it'll have something to it and not just be kind of... "just there"... like gruel...
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Just read an interesting thing in YouTube comments.
It's not just that RTD is coming back. So is Julie Gardner too, apparently.
As the show is now - for the first time ever - not actually going to be produced in-house by the BBC. Rather it's now outsourced to RTD's Bad Wolf production company (and there's also some stuff about HBO throwing in some money to have exclusivity until season 15 or something - therefore, it might actually have a decent budget behind it too).
But, anyway, the theory doing the rounds is that the BBC were just going to cancel it - again - after Chibnall left.
And so RTD has stepped in, and for the first time, it's not going to be an in-house BBC production, as that's the deal to stop it being cancelled. RTD saying "look, give it to me and I'll turn things around" (and note that because it's not in-house, then Bad Wolf can do things like get funding from HBO or others, keep rights to the DVDs and Blurays, and make some cash from merchandise, maybe - a private production company is not limited, as the BBC in-house is, in where it can field its funding from).
The logic being "look, if you're just going to cancel it anyway, then you might as well outsource the IP to me to give it a shot at turning things around, and our production company takes the brunt of the funding risk here". After all, what's the alternative? You just leave one of the biggest IPs the BBC has to sit there doing nothing. Might as well loan the IP to Bad Wolf to give it a go, as they do with Big Finish for audio adventures (and those do alright, as audiobooks go).
No idea the veracity of this. But it does kind of make sense. Why RTD is coming back. Why it's now going to be outsourced to Bad Wolf to produce it.
The Beeb were possibly toying with the idea of simply cancelling it. And when RTD heard that, he rushed in to save it from possible cancellation. And struck up this "look, my production company can make it and we can field funding from elsewhere, so it'll cost you less, while I might be able to save this major IP you've got and return it to popularity again", which the Beeb agreed to in a "might as well" way. Because, if cancelled, it just becomes a dead IP doing nothing.
Being outsourced, it's Bad Wolf who actually take on the production costs and then the Beeb just buy it from them to show it (and, in America, sounds like HBO are throwing money to be the ones screening it there, and it's stuff like that - syndication rights to other countries, future DVD / Bluray sales, etc. - where Bad Wolf can scrape up the cash, in the way a private production company can that the BBC themselves can't necessarily do in-house "because of the unique way it's paid for", to hopefully make this shit work again).
This theory could be all bollocks. But it does kind of make sense of things. The Beeb were pondering just cancelling it and, hearing that, RTD rushed in with a plausible plan to save it.
We'll have to see, but there's also the possibility that being outsourced, instead of in-house, that this could up the budget and quality too. Not subject to the internal politics of the BBC - Bad Wolf are making it, the Beeb is just paying to show the episodes (and is, of course, the IP owner, licensing RTD to do this). You get the gist.
The change to its production seems significant. It's never happened before. It's not just RTD returning that could be shaking things up here.
It's not just that RTD is coming back. So is Julie Gardner too, apparently.
As the show is now - for the first time ever - not actually going to be produced in-house by the BBC. Rather it's now outsourced to RTD's Bad Wolf production company (and there's also some stuff about HBO throwing in some money to have exclusivity until season 15 or something - therefore, it might actually have a decent budget behind it too).
But, anyway, the theory doing the rounds is that the BBC were just going to cancel it - again - after Chibnall left.
And so RTD has stepped in, and for the first time, it's not going to be an in-house BBC production, as that's the deal to stop it being cancelled. RTD saying "look, give it to me and I'll turn things around" (and note that because it's not in-house, then Bad Wolf can do things like get funding from HBO or others, keep rights to the DVDs and Blurays, and make some cash from merchandise, maybe - a private production company is not limited, as the BBC in-house is, in where it can field its funding from).
The logic being "look, if you're just going to cancel it anyway, then you might as well outsource the IP to me to give it a shot at turning things around, and our production company takes the brunt of the funding risk here". After all, what's the alternative? You just leave one of the biggest IPs the BBC has to sit there doing nothing. Might as well loan the IP to Bad Wolf to give it a go, as they do with Big Finish for audio adventures (and those do alright, as audiobooks go).
No idea the veracity of this. But it does kind of make sense. Why RTD is coming back. Why it's now going to be outsourced to Bad Wolf to produce it.
The Beeb were possibly toying with the idea of simply cancelling it. And when RTD heard that, he rushed in to save it from possible cancellation. And struck up this "look, my production company can make it and we can field funding from elsewhere, so it'll cost you less, while I might be able to save this major IP you've got and return it to popularity again", which the Beeb agreed to in a "might as well" way. Because, if cancelled, it just becomes a dead IP doing nothing.
Being outsourced, it's Bad Wolf who actually take on the production costs and then the Beeb just buy it from them to show it (and, in America, sounds like HBO are throwing money to be the ones screening it there, and it's stuff like that - syndication rights to other countries, future DVD / Bluray sales, etc. - where Bad Wolf can scrape up the cash, in the way a private production company can that the BBC themselves can't necessarily do in-house "because of the unique way it's paid for", to hopefully make this shit work again).
This theory could be all bollocks. But it does kind of make sense of things. The Beeb were pondering just cancelling it and, hearing that, RTD rushed in with a plausible plan to save it.
We'll have to see, but there's also the possibility that being outsourced, instead of in-house, that this could up the budget and quality too. Not subject to the internal politics of the BBC - Bad Wolf are making it, the Beeb is just paying to show the episodes (and is, of course, the IP owner, licensing RTD to do this). You get the gist.
The change to its production seems significant. It's never happened before. It's not just RTD returning that could be shaking things up here.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
I think the involvement of Bad Wolf directly implies both her and Jane Trantor (for as long as they still own the company, at least. Broadcast reported a month ago that BW is close to being sold).KlaxonCow wrote:It's not just that RTD is coming back. So is Julie Gardner too, apparently.
HBO has previously co-produced with BW for shows like His Dark Materials. HBO and Sky also appear to be minority (10%) stakeholders in BW.KlaxonCow wrote:… there's also some stuff about HBO throwing in some money to have exclusivity until season 15 or something …
I could understand that. Beyond RTD and Moffatt, it is difficult to think of any excellent writers with showrunning experience who are also fans of the series and could handle the unique stresses of DW (within the Head Writer/Script Editor/Executive Producer/Showrunner model that RTD introduced, anyway). Mark Gatiss and Michaela Coel might partially fit but the former is not a great writer (albeit arguably far better than Chibnall) and the latter might not be deeply familiar with the show.KlaxonCow wrote:But, anyway, the theory doing the rounds is that the BBC were just going to cancel it - again - after Chibnall left.
Audioplays, sir! Labelling them "books" is akin to calling a West End play a "book reading"[*][/size].KlaxonCow wrote:… Might as well loan the IP to Bad Wolf to give it a go, as they do with Big Finish for audio adventures (and those do alright, as audiobooks go).
Perhaps surprisingly, RTD does not appear to have any ownership or directorship connection to the Bad Wolf production company. I do not recall him even working for the company before (although Billie Piper is now starring in one of their series).KlaxonCow wrote:… And when RTD heard that, he rushed in to save it from possible cancellation. And struck up this "look, my production company can make it …"
BBC Studios Productions also appears to be co-producing.KlaxonCow wrote:… the Beeb is just paying to show the episodes …
Agreed. This might even suggest a way to save the show if the Beeb is ever destroyed by Government mandate.KlaxonCow wrote:The change to its production seems significant. It's never happened before. It's not just RTD returning that could be shaking things up here.
[*] Protests this actor.[/size]
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: The Dr Who thread
It's what Big Finish themselves use.Harlequin wrote:Audioplays, sir! Labelling them "books" is akin to calling a West End play a "book reading"[*][/size].KlaxonCow wrote:… Might as well loan the IP to Bad Wolf to give it a go, as they do with Big Finish for audio adventures (and those do alright, as audiobooks go).
To make sure that I was remembering their name correctly, I did a Google search on "Big Finish".
Their home page is titled "Audiobooks from Big Finish" and if you go to that website, the menu heading is titled "Audiobooks" under which you find all the DW stuff.
So, you know, make your protests to Big Finish themselves. I was merely following the convention to use the name that which the thing being named itself uses.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: The Dr Who thread
I don't know to what extent this gives them any say over the direction the series goes in (e.g., casting of the next Doctor).Harlequin wrote:BBC Studios Productions also appears to be co-producing.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
I may very well do so! Some of their cast and/or crew members should have complained, IMO!KlaxonCow wrote:It's what Big Finish themselves use.Harlequin wrote:Audioplays, sir! Labelling them "books" is akin to calling a West End play a "book reading"[*][/size].KlaxonCow wrote:… Might as well loan the IP to Bad Wolf to give it a go, as they do with Big Finish for audio adventures (and those do alright, as audiobooks go).
…
So, you know, make your protests to Big Finish themselves. I was merely following the convention to use the name that which the thing being named itself uses.
Nor I. Such decisions are usually left to executive producers but can be overridden by broadcasters and production companies (much as higher-ups at the Beeb back in the day were able to insist that Colin Baker be replaced). It would seem, though, that BBC Studios are directly funding the production, in part, rather than simply renting the IP then purchasing the product.Ollie wrote:I don't know to what extent this gives them any say over the direction the series goes in (e.g., casting of the next Doctor).Harlequin wrote:BBC Studios Productions also appears to be co-producing.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Solid theory. As it was under Chibnall, it was Old Yeller, really needing to be taken out back and put out of its misery. But RTD revived it before and can probably revive it again, with the BBC content to not pour loads more gambling money into it.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Well, yeah, as I said, I have no confirmation on this or anything. Could be complete bollocks, for all I know.Cloudane wrote:Solid theory.
Just something I read in comments elsewhere and thought "actually, that makes sense of all this". It seems consistent with the known facts. Also made me think "hmm, solid theory".
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
The final Thirteenth Doctor season, a six part story titled Flux, will start on Halloween evening. There will then be some specials next year before RTD returns.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Unfortunately, Chibnall's gone for the cheap device of "mystery".
Who's that? What's going on? How are they involved? Who's this other person? Why? How? What? Who?
Granted, it's the first part of six, so we were not going to get major conclusions and mysteries should be laid. But it's a bit of a mess of a million loose threads, I fear, to have sixteen hundred questions... and then "to be continued".
Am I meant to keep track of all these three dozen threads? They were all quickly recapped at the end, so I fear that, yes, Chibnall's going to be giving us an exam to test how well we remembered everything. I think a cuddly toy and "his and hers" matching suitcases were involved somewhere.
And more "tell, don't show" exposition by just inexplicably having "visions" appear in the Doctor's mind.
The music was also totally drowning out the dialogue at the end too.
Chibnall needs to go on a beginner's "creative writing" course, I reckon. Sorry, but he's really just not a good writer.
I reckon the BBC ought to have a competition, on Blue Peter or something, for kids to write their own Doctor Who scripts and then they could film those, as they'd be better than anything Chibnall's ever written, I'm sure.
I did, in the past, take a pop at some silly bits of RTD's writing. But, in hindsight, come back. All is forgiven.
Who's that? What's going on? How are they involved? Who's this other person? Why? How? What? Who?
Granted, it's the first part of six, so we were not going to get major conclusions and mysteries should be laid. But it's a bit of a mess of a million loose threads, I fear, to have sixteen hundred questions... and then "to be continued".
Am I meant to keep track of all these three dozen threads? They were all quickly recapped at the end, so I fear that, yes, Chibnall's going to be giving us an exam to test how well we remembered everything. I think a cuddly toy and "his and hers" matching suitcases were involved somewhere.
And more "tell, don't show" exposition by just inexplicably having "visions" appear in the Doctor's mind.
The music was also totally drowning out the dialogue at the end too.
Chibnall needs to go on a beginner's "creative writing" course, I reckon. Sorry, but he's really just not a good writer.
I reckon the BBC ought to have a competition, on Blue Peter or something, for kids to write their own Doctor Who scripts and then they could film those, as they'd be better than anything Chibnall's ever written, I'm sure.
I did, in the past, take a pop at some silly bits of RTD's writing. But, in hindsight, come back. All is forgiven.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: The Dr Who thread
Chibnall seems to have gone for the "dump everything in a big pile on the floor in episode 1, sort it all out later" method. I counted at least three strands (the Sontarans, the Weeping Angel, and the bloke with his tunnels) that will doubtless go somewhere in future episodes, but didn't lead to anything in this one and could easily have been left out and introduced as needed throughout the series.
Re: The Dr Who thread
At least it remained entertaining, had some much needed sense of humour (so much of this era has just felt dry), gave Yaz a purpose and personality etc. So in some ways it's a step up. But yeah, it's very incohorent so far, and you're just thinking "where does Crystal Voldemort fit in, what's with the Yorkshire Terrier / Wookie, who's this random future-woman who just turned up and says she'll be important later, why are there angels, what's going on"

