Rhythm wrote:So the person earning £18k pays £1k in tax but is entitled to almost £4k in benefits
Which is, of course, a £3K loss to the taxpayer.
Essentially a subsidy to businesses to not pay good wages in the first place.
Creating the absurdity that the taxpayer is making a loss to actually encourage employers to keep folks at that "sweet spot" - in terms of wages and working hours - where they pay the least possible for staff.
And one of those benefits is housing benefit. So the taxpayer is making a loss to pay high rents / mortgages.
I've jokingly referred to these things as "middle-class dole" before. The idea that the taxpayer is not just funding the unemployed to collect dole - and, at least in that case, there's a legitimate reason there, as these people have no other income - but is also dishing out taxpayer money to businesses, that actually encourages them to not pay their staff properly.
If you do the maths with the various rules, then you can see that there are these "sweet spots" where, for example, you make someone work 29 hours, not 30 hours, because then they qualify as "part-time" and a whole bunch of legal responsibilities and costs associated with full-time jobs disappear. And the taxpayer will end up topping up the difference.
Basically, this all makes a mockery of the idea that more jobs is better for the economy. Because, actually, with this stuff existing, that's not always the case. It might actually cost the taxpayer more to have this person in this crappy job, than if they were unemployed.
Not that I'd wish unemployment on anyone but you get the underlying point that the system itself is broken.
Indeed, when I was unemployed myself, coming out of university, back around 2000, I had the weirdest conversation with the folks at the Job Centre (or "Joke Shop" as it's commonly nicknamed). They called me in for an interview and then asked me the most bizarre question ever: "how are you surviving on Jobseeker's Allowance?".
Yes, the people who're paying the Dole were asking me how it was possible that I could live on the benefit that they were offering. And the woman behind the counter explained that this should be impossible, as the amount paid is
BY DESIGN insufficient to comfortably live on. They calculate how much someone needs and then they knock a chunk off that, so it's deliberately not enough. That's actually designed into the system itself, to purposefully not pay enough for someone to live on.
Well, the answer - in case you're wondering - is that, having just finished university and looking for my first "proper job", I was, at that time, still living at home with my parents. Therefore, no rent, shared food costs, etc..
This satisfied them and I was free to go. Because that's the other subtlety to this story. Not just that the woman behind the counter explicitly told me that the Dole is designed to be insufficient to reasonably live on - that's by design, not any accident - but that the underlying reason for the interview was punitive. They were trying to catch me out that I might be secretly doing a job on the sly, or that I'm dealing drugs, or have some other undeclared income. The interview existed to find a reason for not paying me the very payment that this woman openly admitted was designed to not be enough.
Throughout all of this, they provided me exactly zero help in finding a job.
And did you know that 6 in 10 jobs are filled through word of mouth, 2 in 10 jobs by speculative approach, 1 in 10 jobs through Jobcentre Plus and 1 in 10 jobs through newspapers? Those are the government's own numbers, by the way.
Yes, the Jobcentre only fills 1 out of 10 jobs. Because though they like to call it "the Jobcentre", it does not, in fact, really make any great efforts to help people find jobs. It just hands out Dole and then looks for any tiny excuse for not paying it. Folks who just randomly walk into businesses and say "have you got a job?" ("speculative approach") is twice as effective in securing work than the Jobcentre.
It's fucking useless and doesn't do anything. Except trying to find excuses not to pay people Dole - missing the bloody obvious solution, which is helping people to find a job. But, no, that's too obvious and not dysfunctional enough, apparently.
Note that as most jobs are filled by word of mouth, then people are effectively punished for not having a mate who's already in the industry they want to work in, who can put in a good word for them. And this implicitly punishes those who have mental health issues, like anxiety or depression, or folks who just socially don't want to impose themselves on others, to have a network of contacts in the industry already, as their odds of getting a job - by the government numbers above - has just nosedived to 10% at best.
The system is broken. It does not make any sense, even by its own standards and logic.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes