My little Brony...
Re: My little Brony...
There is definitely that side of it, depending if it's a "general adventures" one or a "coming of age" type (where they're killed off as a sort of 'rite of passage', I guess Lion King is the classic for that but loads of stuff does it)
But the mother in Pokemon is still alive and well, along with possibly the father (I think they revealed him recently, I haven't watched the Pokemon anime for years but heard something). If so the father is basically negligent, running off on his own adventures. The mother just basically encourages him, packs a load of stuff and tells him to change his undies daily :p
But the mother in Pokemon is still alive and well, along with possibly the father (I think they revealed him recently, I haven't watched the Pokemon anime for years but heard something). If so the father is basically negligent, running off on his own adventures. The mother just basically encourages him, packs a load of stuff and tells him to change his undies daily :p
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: My little Brony...
Because there are NO "adventures" and if they are they tend not to end up with "and everyone was living happily ever after" ...Cloudane wrote:There is definitely that side of it, depending if it's a "general adventures" one or a "coming of age" type (where they're killed off as a sort of 'rite of passage', I guess Lion King is the classic for that but loads of stuff does it)
But the mother in Pokemon is still alive and well, along with possibly the father (I think they revealed him recently, I haven't watched the Pokemon anime for years but heard something). If so the father is basically negligent, running off on his own adventures. The mother just basically encourages him, packs a load of stuff and tells him to change his undies daily :p
Well NO adventures "of that kind you see in the movies for sure", nor you'll almost never find anyone doing in real life what they do in the movies, stuff just simply does not go like that except in very exceptional circumstances certainly not "all the time".
Life often turns out something that grinds you up day by day wearing you out rather than something that gives you "a satisfactory fight between good and evil" and in almost all cases no matter what fight you end up with you won't come out as you got in, you'll come out worse.
I think that Pokemon is "particularly odd" with the whole idea of "little monsters fighting" , yeah it's a cartoon, but it's weird, so most of all the cartoons/movies really.
Actually MLP is one with "more ground" at least tries to tell you "to be nice".
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: My little Brony...
Yeah, which is why, as giles rightly notes, Pokemon is just very weird, when you stop to think about it.Cloudane wrote:But the mother in Pokemon is still alive and well
Why that one stands out like a sore thumb, as they haven't followed convention and are actually proposing that, yup, his mother doesn't give a shit and his father's absent. And the "wild adventures" that these kids are going on is basically "global circus freak cock fighting". Which is all kinds of wrong.
Pokemon is strange like that, because it really doesn't remotely care to make any of this make any narrative sense. My guess is because this is a commercial product to make money first, and they've carelessly tacked on a nonsensical backstory, just to make more money with a cartoon and merchandise. That no-one involved actually cares for it to make any sense, or whether it does or doesn't set a good example for the kids, so long as it makes them lots of money.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: My little Brony...
As far as I little know they guy that invented Pokemon in the first place was interested in the VIDEO GAME ( it did start as a video game ) and the idea that "no one would have had the whole thing in the same game" but you HAD to battle with different people in order to collect them all ( not sure the details IIRC but was something like "even if you played all time the video game alone you would have never completed the collection " ).KlaxonCow wrote:Yeah, which is why, as giles rightly notes, Pokemon is just very weird, when you stop to think about it.Cloudane wrote:But the mother in Pokemon is still alive and well
Why that one stands out like a sore thumb, as they haven't followed convention and are actually proposing that, yup, his mother doesn't give a shit and his father's absent. And the "wild adventures" that these kids are going on is basically "global circus freak cock fighting". Which is all kinds of wrong.
Pokemon is strange like that, because it really doesn't remotely care to make any of this make any narrative sense. My guess is because this is a commercial product to make money first, and they've carelessly tacked on a nonsensical backstory, just to make more money with a cartoon and merchandise. That no-one involved actually cares for it to make any sense, or whether it does or doesn't set a good example for the kids, so long as it makes them lots of money.
Story goes nobody was interested in the game he asked/gambled for all his father's money to make it happen luckily it paid off.
I think if I understood correctly his whole idea was "the socialisation aspect" ( you HAD to interact with other players ) and the fact he really wanted to create his Pokemon universe and see all his little critters came to life.
All the rest I think came out as consequence of the tremendous success of a game.
So as a videogame alone "has some little sense" as in "ok, battle to win something and score the max" .. BUT "as a real life story with kids" .. it's LOT more disturbing .. but think about it "as a videogame" Galaga makes some sense .. now try to make a movie/cartoon out of it along the lines of "12 years old kid is teached to shoot, put in a spaceship and sent to mercilessy kill hordes of insectoid aliens shooting them with lasers and bullets in space" ..
I mean it would be SO WRONG IN SO MANY ASPECTS !!!
MLP was aimed a little girls, they needed a NEW product that girls would buy the cartoons were "a proven formula at the time" that "if you had a cartoon attached to a product that would make the product sell widly".
And so on .. "mostly is to sell things and make numbers grow".
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: My little Brony...
I think Billy Shakespeare is more to blame for that example and, as with Pokémon, the mother remained alive (albeit not re-married to the dad-killer in Disney's version).Cloudane wrote:There is definitely that side of it, depending if it's a "general adventures" one or a "coming of age" type (where they're killed off as a sort of 'rite of passage', I guess Lion King is the classic for that but loads of stuff does it)
And it is not even because the protagonist is black!Cloudane wrote:If so the father is basically negligent, running off on his own adventures.
The difference perhaps being that the MLP cartoon creators care a bit more?KlaxonCow wrote:… My guess is because this is a commercial product to make money first, and they've carelessly tacked on a nonsensical backstory, just to make more money with a cartoon and merchandise. That no-one involved actually cares for it to make any sense, or whether it does or doesn't set a good example for the kids, so long as it makes them lots of money.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: My little Brony...
Not as much as THE SPACE STALLIONS !!!Harlequin wrote:I think Billy Shakespeare is more to blame for that example and, as with Pokémon, the mother remained alive (albeit not re-married to the dad-killer in Disney's version).Cloudane wrote:There is definitely that side of it, depending if it's a "general adventures" one or a "coming of age" type (where they're killed off as a sort of 'rite of passage', I guess Lion King is the classic for that but loads of stuff does it)
And it is not even because the protagonist is black!Cloudane wrote:If so the father is basically negligent, running off on his own adventures.
The difference perhaps being that the MLP cartoon creators care a bit more?KlaxonCow wrote:… My guess is because this is a commercial product to make money first, and they've carelessly tacked on a nonsensical backstory, just to make more money with a cartoon and merchandise. That no-one involved actually cares for it to make any sense, or whether it does or doesn't set a good example for the kids, so long as it makes them lots of money.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: My little Brony...
Yes, fully agreed.Harlequin wrote:The difference perhaps being that the MLP cartoon creators care a bit more?
I'm not a brony myself. But I did watch the MLP cartoon movie thing on YouTube, and it was very well produced and, basically, just good story telling. So, I get why it has broad appeal and though not a brony, feel free to consider me an "ally" of the bronies. I felt that I should not pre-judge and see the thing for myself, and I didn't feel I was making myself watch it at any point. It was genuinely enjoyable, and the humour actually funny and the story-telling perfectly well done (complete with shades of "the Hero's Journey" in there and everything).
As I've commented before on Doctor Who, good story-telling is not "for kids" or "for adults" or for anyone in particular. A good story, well told, is for everyone (but, sure, we avoid "adult topics" or swearing for the sake of the kids). Which is why I insisted before that Doctor Who - at its best - is "a family show" (and when writers have "it's for kids" in their head, they write crap that no-one much enjoys).
Many Disney / Pixar movies are much the same - sure, they're "kid appropriate" but they're designed as "for all the family", as a shared experience, where the parents can also enjoy the story and get something out of it, and it's not just "I will suffer this to distract the kids".
I watched one of the MLP cartoons once - to see what all the fuss is about - and would fully agree. The creators actually give a shit. It's proper good story telling. Very well produced, written and acted. Top notch quality.
Mind you, that said, when "My Little Pony" first existed, I think that was just selling toys to girls and not much else going on. But with the cartoon and that "generation" of the product, shits were properly given to actually make something good, on its own merits, regardless of pushing the plastic toys. And it worked, hence the appeal to create "bronies" out of folks for whom those little plastic toys are irrelevant.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: My little Brony...
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: My little Brony...
So question ... AFTER ALL THIS TIME .. still NO WAY to ( legally ) obtain a Season 8/9 "complete DVD/Blue Ray" series anywhere ??
It seems this is as far as it goes ( season 7)
Will we ever be able to buy 8 & 9 ???
It seems this is as far as it goes ( season 7)
Will we ever be able to buy 8 & 9 ???
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: My little Brony...
They've always been terrible for that. Like they don't want your money. yayponies 
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: My little Brony...
No I am SURE IT'S LOT WORSE THAN IT USED TO BE SINCE *STREAMING* EXISTS !! .. I'd bet that "until they can make some pennies out of MLP streaming you will NEVER, EVER see a version on any other media" ..Cloudane wrote:They've always been terrible for that. Like they don't want your money. yayponies
Because also the moment I have it in hands, I can watch and re-watch it and duplicate it "any time I want" easily, I DO NOT NEED their ()*£$()"*$("*$"£) streaming service any more for that !!!
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: My little Brony...
They have it buyable in the States - I think it's more a case of "oh yeah other countries exist?" and perhaps complicated distribution rights
Re: My little Brony...
X-region licensing has gotten better but it's still a flipping nightmare, even when you're buying from digital distribution. I bought Baraka and Samsara on iTunes knowing that when the 4k versions arrive I'll be upgraded for free. News of the 4k HDR remasters hit and... no upgrade. Except copies in the States got upgraded. Looked into it and the licensing in the UK is held by a different company and they don't have rights to the 4k version. Incredibly frustrating stuff.Cloudane wrote:They have it buyable in the States - I think it's more a case of "oh yeah other countries exist?" and perhaps complicated distribution rights
Steam: SteelyDamn
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: My little Brony...
Where ? I can't find a link ?Cloudane wrote:They have it buyable in the States - I think it's more a case of "oh yeah other countries exist?" and perhaps complicated distribution rights
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: My little Brony...
Yeah the whole thing of region locking on the internet is a pet peeve of mine. We have a global online community and still get divided by arbitrary digital borders.
Looks like your only option (besides Malaysian import) is digital purchase for silly money for as long as Amazon allow you to access it, which figures. Such is the modern way https://www.amazon.co.uk/My-Little-Pony ... B08ML24LDY
At least, that's what I kind of assumed based on previous seasons, I'm sure they used to release a DVD in the US and then occasionally gave the rest of the world "compilations of random episodes" that you could pick up at Home Bargains etc. Seemingly this time it's only been released in Malaysia for some reason!gilesgoat wrote:Where ? I can't find a link ?Cloudane wrote:They have it buyable in the States - I think it's more a case of "oh yeah other countries exist?" and perhaps complicated distribution rights
Looks like your only option (besides Malaysian import) is digital purchase for silly money for as long as Amazon allow you to access it, which figures. Such is the modern way https://www.amazon.co.uk/My-Little-Pony ... B08ML24LDY

