gilesgoat wrote:/me is remembered he should not mess with police horses while in London ....
Yeah, that's different and I don't have problems with laws that say "you cannot physically interfere with a police officer doing their duty".
But, like, if, while the police officer is arresting you, you want to call them out and say "I believe this is wrongful action, and you are abusing your position to bully people" or something like that, then that should never be illegal.
Because, simply, what if you're right? There should never be a law that prevents simply speaking the truth, or at least having the ability to challenge what that truth might actually be.
As the public official might well be wrong. As I say, if a crowd of people have all decided to start calling some public official, doing their duty, "a cunt" openly in public, then there's probably extremely good cause for that. It's more likely than not, probably actually true.
Well, I've said this before, but it bears repeating, as I think people miss that this is really the moral of "the Emperor's New Clothes".
You all undoubtedly know the story, so I don't have to recap that, but I'll just ask this simple question: "Who benefits most from the kid shouting 'the Emperor is naked!'?".
Well, it's not the kid. They're stating that which they already knew. There is no new information there for the kid. And, perhaps very naively - and that's why the story makes it a child, as children do just naively blurt things out, as they don't yet understand what's really going on - the kid is actually asking for a whole heap of shit to land on him. The Emperor might execute him. The crowd might turn on him, for blowing the whistle (as, undoubtedly, most of the crowd very likely already knew that the Emperor was naked, but were just going along with it, as they knew that you don't piss off the Emperor, or he might send you to the chopping block). The Emperor's advisers are not going to be happy that their lack of care for the Emperor is now exposed. And, of course, most of all, the tailor who is conning the Emperor here is definitely not going to be pleased with the kid at all for blowing the lid on his scam.
Nope, the kid's not really benefiting from saying this at all. Indeed, that's why the story makes it a kid. Because a kid will naively blurt things out without realising the consequences. If the kid did understand the consequences, then he'd have been 100% like the rest of the crowd. Say nothing. Pretend everything is fine. Enjoy the spectacle of this arsehole Emperor making a twat of himself, then go home to laugh at him behind closed doors.
The crowd's not benefiting. It's making it all rather obvious that, like, at least some of them must have known but said fuck all. It's making it all very, very clear to the Emperor that "his people" do not like him at all, and actually fear him and his power. Because they've chosen to say nothing for their own benefit - not being sent to the chopping block for "insulting" the Emperor - and fuck the Emperor. Indeed, they're all standing there and enjoying watching the Emperor make a twat of himself in public.
The Emperor's advisers aren't benefiting. This has exposed that they're just "yes men" who want to keep their jobs - the money and the power afforded to them by their position - and couldn't give a rat's arse for the Emperor. Let him behave like a twat. Don't like him anyway, so it's kind of funny. But keep quiet, because while he's happy, we keep our jobs and wages.
The tailor who's conning the Emperor benefits least of all. Because if the whole crowd and all the Emperor's advisers are keeping quiet, then that's most likely because the Emperor rules by fear, sends people to the chopping block and is an unpleasant tyrannical twat. They know to keep quiet to avoid having the Emperor send them to the executioner.
Therefore, this con artists tailor is fucked. The Emperor's going to hang him by the neck for this, guaranteed. He definitely is not benefiting.
So, who's actually benefiting here? Actually, it's the Emperor.
Because now the Emperor knows that there are no "invisible clothes". He knows he's been conned. He now realises that his advisers are untrustworthy self-serving cunts. He now knows that "his people" don't love him at all, and they went along with it, as they're scared of him. He might begin to realise that "rule by fear" isn't actually that clever - if these people will happily let him just parade around naked, then they'll equally do nothing if the Emperor was about to walk off the edge of a cliff or eat poisoned food. Indeed, they'd probably be internally cheering it on, as that's the easy way to get rid of this twat.
Who "wins" from the kid having that "freedom of speech" to say "the Emperor is naked!"? The Emperor himself.
And, for me, that's the true "moral of the story" here. Never shut down anyone's ability - their "freedom of speech" - to tell you that you've got it wrong. Because, you know, they might well be telling you the bald truth - "the Emperor is naked!" - and the person who most benefits from that free exchange is, in fact, you.
Sure, we're all human. So you won't like being insulted or publicly exposed for being wrong in the moment. The ego will be bruised. But, ultimately, you now know what you got wrong, and can endeavour to never get it wrong ever again.
Being told you got it wrong - when you have, indeed, genuinely got it wrong - is a win for you. Otherwise, you'll carry on being wrong. Getting it wrong. Doing it wrong. Failing to get respect from others, as they can see you've got it wrong and won't accept that - or even hear it - so, well, how can anyone respect someone that bone-headed and stubborn? What a twat.
Your "mental model" not in accord with actual reality, you'll find that you won't be getting the results you expect. If you delude yourself into thinking "everyone loves and respect me" - when, in fact, they think you're a twat who's got it all wrong and they can't stand you for that - then your life is going to be a series of "rude awakenings" where you think people would want to help you out - but they don't - that they'd want to enjoy your company - but they absolutely don't - and so forth. You're going to throw a party... and no-one shows up. "Forever alone".
But, like, if you knew the truth - that they all think you're a corrupt arsehole who's only out for himself and who's done nothing for anyone else - then you now know. You can correct it. And maybe, when you've reformed and become an awesome public servant that everyone likes, they'll all show up to your next party.
It's that understanding that, despite how horrible it internally feels to be called out or insulted, it is logically the best thing for you.
(Presuming that, of course, it's true. But, like, we can't know in advance whether someone calling you out is right to do so, until they've done it. We don't know what's going to be said until it's been said. Like, "freedom of speech" doesn't in any way guarantee that the truth is spoken - the kid could have shouted "the Emperor is fully clothed in fine clothing!" and kept the lie going - but you have to allow it, or the truth won't ever come out. As the old joke has it: "everyone's entitled to their own opinion... but that doesn't mean I have to accept it".)
This, to my mind, is what that story's all about. Its underlying moral message. It's showing us a very dysfunctional society - where everyone's too scared to speak a simple truth - and that the Emperor is, in fact, fucking himself over by acting as a "rule by fear" tyrant. No-one's coming to his aid. Truth is, if he got ran over by a bus tomorrow and died, they'd be throwing street parties in happiness that the twat has finally gone. They don't love nor respect you, they're just shit scared of your substantial power being used against them. That's all.
Boris is a clown. If he doesn't want people to say that anymore, then all he has to do is stop behaving like a clown. But while he is a clown, it's nothing more than stating a bald truth - "the Emperor is naked" - and there should never, ever be any laws preventing truth from being spoken. Because we all benefit from knowing what the reality is. To accord our behaviour to that reality, to actually get the real world results we expect.
The last person you should ever shut down is your second biggest critic. They're your "sanity check" on the world.
(And why do I say "second biggest critic" and not "first biggest critic"? Because, of course, the biggest critic of you should ALWAYS be yourself. You are your own worst enemy and don't ever forget it.)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes