Well, it's like I said earlier, when I posted the "cheese and wine" photo, that the real problem is that if "it's a work event" excuses all this shit away then the rules for workplaces are clearly not good enough.
If it's the wrong thing to do at home, then it should equally be the wrong thing to do at work as well. Because, like, it's not as if the virus is going to come along and think "oh, they're officially at work, then I'd best leave them alone".
The point of having slightly different rules and regulations for workplaces was not because they're magically immune to the virus, but because we're trying to balance competing priorities - we do still need "key workers" to go about their business, to stop everything from collapsing, and it'd be nice to have some economic activity going on, as we do need the economy to keep going too.
It's a necessary compromise. In an ideal world, the rules would be 100% universal - work or home - but then everything would have ground to a halt. And we do still need things - key infrastructure, a basic economy of some kind - to function. So we've got to accept some degree of risk - and spread - will have to exist, as the world does still need to keep turning.
So, as I said, if the excuse is "it was a work event" then all this is really telling me is that the workplace rules simply weren't good enough. If such "super spreader" behaviour was technically legal, then the laws simply weren't good enough. Because it shouldn't have been acceptable.
The virus doesn't care if we're following the rules or not. So the point should be that the rules focus on reducing / preventing spread of the virus - be that at work or at home. And if such dangerous behaviour was allowed by the law - as "it's a work event" - then the laws simply weren't good enough.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
Well, the interesting thing is that Omicron is doing the same thing it did in South Africa. Being a "flash in the pan" of a massive surge, but then, equally, falling off fairly rapidly too.
Even the world stats seem to hinting at that too (though there's not enough data to conclude that at a global level yet, it is tracing out that pattern thus far).
And, again, a double-edged sword. Because if it's too "flash in the pan" then it's not going to stick around long enough to get us to "herd immunity".
I mean, I have my doubts about that strategy in the first place. As it seems to ignore that the virus is a moving target. We can have an excellent "immunity wall" to the current strain - and then a new variant just happily smashes that down. Omicron itself did that. As we had built up the immunity wall from double jabs, but then Omicron ruined that and we all had to get a third jab.
So, you know, even if we did get to "herd immunity" with variants up to Omicron - but, no, we're a long way off that, as even the third jab doesn't get us better than about 70% protection - then a new variant can come along and ruin that.
I guess the point there is to make clear that "herd immunity" is not just hard to reach, but it's not permanent either. So even if we did just about hit the "herd immunity" level, then the virus can mutate and we lose it again.
Again, it has to be pointed out that there are plenty of viruses - 'flu or the common cold - where we can never reach "herd immunity". The prevalence is too high and they mutate far too often. So that's always cracks in the "immunity wall" by which it survives and keeps going.
We're not going to hit "herd immunity" by some concerted effort and then it's "job done". Rather, it's going to be that, over time, we're going to have a collective immunity that hopefully keeps this at a "just another 'flu" level and then we learn to live with it.
That's going to take a long time. It is, indeed, the result of repeated exposure to different variants, until - collectively - our immune system generally learns how to deal with Covid. And not in a "you can't catch it" way, but just in a "break the link to hospitalisations and deaths" way. It'll still be around, folks will still catch it and get sick, but eventually we'll have an overall level of basic immunity that it hopefully stops killing people, and we just have to suffer it. Like we do with influenza or the common cold.
That is, eventually it'll fade into the background as another piece of "disease furniture" that's always there.
But this is kind of why I cautioned against these "more haste, less speed" solutions to try to race to a conclusion. Won't work. We might get to "herd immunity"... but then lose it again. It's not a static target, you see, but a level that goes up and down depending on the variant, our behaviour and the current state of our collective immunity.
The inevitable good news is that, eventually, an equilibrium has to be found (there are only three options - either the virus wipes us out, we wipe out the virus or we eventually find an equilibrium in the middle somewhere. The first two are unlikely, as humans have only ever wiped out a single virus in all of our history and the traits of this virus, even at its worst, has never been anywhere near the level where we have to worry about being wiped out by it, as an overwhelming majority of people survive it).
But, as much as we all want that, it's an un-rush-able state of affairs. We can't race to that conclusion. It just eventually happens. It's always a whimper, never a bang.
We will get there. But it's a marathon, not a sprint, unfortunately. As has already been happening, things will gradually get better, restrictions can be released and it'll slowly fade into the background.
I know, I know. We all want to just press a button and end it tomorrow. But it's a "fade away" kind of thing. So this is why I've been cautioning against any "more haste, less speed" rushing... because we won't get there any faster from this, and rash actions might actually just serve to make shit worse and prolong this.
E.g. "eat out to help out" was, as the jokes have had it, helping out the virus to spread. And the problem there is that if the virus surges, then the restaurants have to shut up shop again. So you really haven't speeded anything up at all, in fact.
It has to be measured and sensible, not a mad rush "back to normal" and, well, we've now seen exactly why. "Herd immunity" can be too easily ruined in a heartbeat - Omicron comes along with sufficient "vaccine escape" that we all had to get jabbed again. A rush to "open up" can just fuel a surge (and, in the background, encourage another variant to brew up) that means we've got to force everyone to shut up shop again.
Basically, I've been advising us to have this gradual phased movement back towards normality, as the "boom and bust" cycle really isn't very helpful to anyone. While shops might celebrate opening up, it's not helpful - to have certainty - when they could be made to shut up shop all over again. Better a constant gradual trickle, that's always improving over time, than boom, bust, boom, bust, boom, bust for however long it takes for this virus to eventually become part of the furniture.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
A legal chap was commenting on this on 6 Music news last night. His view was that as it was plainly not just a work thing, it was in breach. Working with others was only permitted if absolutely necessary. It being a "BYOB" deal changes it from solely being a work event
A legal chap was commenting on this on 6 Music news last night. His view was that as it was plainly not just a work thing, it was in breach. Working with others was only permitted if absolutely necessary. It being a "BYOB" deal changes it from solely being a work event
Because as we know the infection spreads in the public places but NOT in the work places where lot of people are all together .. absolutely not .. "all you have to do to be safe from Covid is to be at your work place" ...
gilesgoat wrote:
Because as we know the infection spreads in the public places but NOT in the work places where lot of people are all together .. absolutely not .. "all you have to do to be safe from Covid is to be at your work place" ...
The point he was making was that this "meeting" happened at a time when every worker in the UK was being told to WFH if possible. There were absolutely cases where people needed to show up in person but this party in the garden was not one of those cases
gilesgoat wrote:
Because as we know the infection spreads in the public places but NOT in the work places where lot of people are all together .. absolutely not .. "all you have to do to be safe from Covid is to be at your work place" ...
The point he was making was that this "meeting" happened at a time when every worker in the UK was being told to WFH if possible. There were absolutely cases where people needed to show up in person but this party in the garden was not one of those cases
It does not take a genius to realize that "when everyone is told to do some things" it's NOT "the best time" to make a garden party no ?
Basically "they fucked up", and now they are trying to dig all excuses to say "no they did not".
[edit] - also "LS policy", we don't think alchool/do parties during working hours/days
The regulations changed on the 1st June 2020 to extend the restrictions on gatherings to private as well as public places. So the party on the 20th May might not have been in breach, but it seems there were certainly later parties that were.
What people were being told was not necessarily what the law stated.
While people might be rightfully disgusted that these parties were going on while far less hazardous gatherings of vastly greater personal value were in fact legally prohibited, can anyone point to any paragraph of the actual law of the time that the party on non-public work premises was in breach of?
Rhythm wrote:The point he was making was that this "meeting" happened at a time when every worker in the UK was being told to WFH if possible. There were absolutely cases where people needed to show up in person but this party in the garden was not one of those cases
IANAL but the law stated people could leave their living places to go to work "where it is not reasonably possible for that person to work … from the place where they are living". I see nothing about what people should or should not have done while taking breaks from that work or after working. I do presume it would have been an offence to go to Downing Street specifically to attend a party when one's presence was not also required for work on that day.
Ollie wrote:The regulations changed on the 1st June 2020 to extend the restrictions on gatherings to private as well as public places. So the party on the 20th May might not have been in breach, but it seems there were certainly later parties that were.
Indeed.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Harlequin wrote:What people were being told was not necessarily what the law stated.
While people might be rightfully disgusted that these parties were going on while far less hazardous gatherings of vastly greater personal value were in fact legally prohibited, can anyone point to any paragraph of the actual law of the time that the party on non-public work premises was in breach of?
Restrictions on gatherings
7. During the emergency period, no person may participate in a gathering in a public place of more than two people except—
(a)where all the persons in the gathering are members of the same household,
(b)where the gathering is essential for work purposes,
(c)to attend a funeral,
(d)where reasonably necessary—
(i)to facilitate a house move,
(ii)to provide care or assistance to a vulnerable person, including relevant personal care within the meaning of paragraph 7(3B) of Schedule 4 to the Safeguarding of Vulnerable Groups Act 2006,
(iii)to provide emergency assistance, or
(iv)to participate in legal proceedings or fulfil a legal obligation.
Hmmm... I was not properly considering the F1 ("or be outside of") insertion. That may indeed complicate interpretations although it does not seem inarguably clear to me.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Dio wrote:What's the definition of 'public place' here?
And this is the loophole they will now rely on after the Sue Gray “inquiry” reports.
Number 10 is not a normal house or office, by definition. There are multiple caveats and bylaws that make it either exempt or excluded from regulations that affect other buildings.
But...
It doesn’t matter.
Johnson is fatally damaged.
Either he continues to give in to the backbenchers and becomes a pitiful wreck, unable to pass legislation. He can try to hang on to the next General Election but he won’t last beyond summer 2023.
Or he fights to save his own skin and the moderates / Red Wall / 2019 intake make a move before the May local elections.
I tend to agree on both the expected strategy and the overall outcome.
But many want him to limp on until at least the summer, so they can do the leadership contest at a quieter time and have the run up from party conference to putative election next year. The nerves are how much council carnage it's going to cause in the meantime, but there's an argument that a leadership contest between that shower could be as bad for them as Johnson is.
The allegations of ministers “threatening and blackmailing” the rebels are worse.
A Minister threatening to take funds away from a constituency breaks the Ministerial Code.