snaff wrote:Why wait for decades-long research when it's something you can do at home in a few days?
Because it's not demonstrable that it does even does anything useful.
You could also play that game of "Pascal's Wager" with anything and everything else, though, couldn't you?
Maybe "healing crystals" work. Why aren't you trying that out? Just in case.
Noel Edmonds sells these yoga mats, which he says cures cancer (he also thinks death doesn't exist and is an illusion, by the way). Maybe that works. Who knows?
Religious people will advocate for the power of prayer. If Allah really is the one true God, as claimed, maybe you should be praying 5 times a day. Just in case. Because you wouldn't want to be only praying once a day to find out that it was Allah all along, who demands it 5 times a day. You might piss him off and then he gives you Covid to teach you a lesson. Indeed, a grand problem with the praying thing is that there's so many gods, so the odds you've got the right one is very low and they might be "a jealous god" that freaks out when you kneel before the wrong graven images and all that.
And, basically, by this logic, I would have to do everything - a million different things - on the off-chance that one of them is correct. So, even if it did turn out that one of these things really did cure Covid, then I'd have no bloody clue which one it was, and would have to keep doing everything. Just in case.
In essence, you're asking me why I'm not superstitious and don't believe in "magical thinking", basically.
Mainly because it demonstrably doesn't bloody work, and it's a waste of time dodging cracks in the pavement and throwing salt over my shoulder all day long, which is a distraction from, you know, real stuff like visiting my GP, eating healthily, taking appropriate medicines, getting regular exercise and other stuff that we do know, for a proven fact, actually does something physiologically useful to address the problem.
Mind you, in this particular case, as the essence of it is "eat healthily, get regular exercise and look after yourself" then, actually, you should probably do that stuff anyway. Not because it's any proven "cure" for Long Covid, but it's just a thing everyone ought to be doing anyway for their overall general health. And, yes, being in better health - having a strengthened immune system - is going to be useful for Covid and Long Covid anyway.
(Indeed, part of my scepticism relates to the problem of how do you tell the difference between this just being that people in generally better health, who look after themselves, will fare better with any illness, including Covid... and that you really have found a true link between obesity and Long Covid specifically? That's really not an easy problem to address. Not at all. That's, unfortunately, why you need the decades-long studies. Because teasing that difference, to full and proper scientific levels of scrutiny, is NOT easy at all.)
But, yeah, seeing as the message is just "eat more healthily, do more regular exercise and look after yourself better" then I'm not going to shit on that advice itself, as it's generally good advice for everyone regardless. But I've no reason to advocate for it for the reasons you've given from what I've seen so far.
(By the way, though "the plural of anecdote is not data" and I tend to avoid personal witness, as I don't believe it's good evidence of anything, I used to run 5K every day for a few years. Getting a new job slightly screwed with my schedule for actively running every day, but I still insisted on walking to and from work - which is a 10K round-trip - every work day. So, granted, it's slacked off a little - and the pandemic and having Long Covid have nixed it for the last couple of years - but my BMI was right down at the bottom edge of "healthy" and, in fact, I had to purposefully eat a bit more or I risked being unhealthily below the BMI for my age and height, and I had to put my scales on "athletic mode" to get any decent numbers out of it. So, you know, though my new job did screw my running schedule before the pandemic hit, I was definitely NOT in the category you're talking about... before ending up suffering from Long Covid anyway. So, you know, another big reason why I can't swallow this is that my own experience flatly contradicts it. So I'd have to be given a good explanation for that first, before I could even begin entertaining the idea. I'm sure you can understand that reasoning, yes?)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes