"Entirely" is wrong.PFVA wrote:According to what I heard on our news here this morning Brexit is entirely Putin's fault.
But, yes, Russian manipulation was part of the big mix of shit that contributed to it all.
As has been mentioned, it was a perfect storm of bullshit - to which I'd add to the list already given, that there was also indecisiveness and lack of confidence on the Remain side.
Cameron, leading the Remain campaign, was all caveats and conditions. The case he made was along the lines of: "well, the EU's got problems, but we should remain as part of a reformed EU". And he said that constantly: "a reformed EU". So he was basically saying "don't vote to remain in the current EU, as it's a bit shit, but vote to stay in the EU, so we can perhaps gradually convince the other members to slowly change it to something maybe a little better. Perhaps".
Like, it was all in that kind of tone of voice and he always said "reformed EU", never just "EU". So his whole salespitch - as leader of the Remain campaign - was "yeah, the EU as it stands is not very good, but vote to remain in it and maybe we can fix that, perhaps?".
But, in the post-analysis, the polling numbers suggest that what really did it was essentially this:
Remain lead the polls in the weeks coming up to the referendum and it lead the polls in the weeks after, but the vote landed exactly when the EU was suffering a refugee crisis - from Syria - and the Leave vote fully exploited the racist vote.
By the polling, it was bad timing. A week earlier or a week later, Remain would have won. But it landed exactly in the week when there was a refugee crisis and the news was talking about the EU struggling with immigrants fleeing Syria... and folks like Farage exploited every last inch of xenophobia they could find, to just barely get Leave over the line on polling day.
That's what the numbers and expert analysis shows. Bad timing. Holding a vote about staying in the EU, just as shit was hitting the fan with a migration crisis.
I mean, anyone who actually stopped to think for a second would spot a gigantic problem with Farage's poster. How can you have a photo of a "flood" of migrants, before this predicted "flood" had happened? Farage does not possess a "future camera" that can photograph things yet to come.
The photo was taken in Slovenia in 2015 and it's deceptive. These migrants - who crossed from Croatia into Slovenia - were being marched to a new location. So it's not what it looks like. The refugees had crossed the border at one point and the Slovenians wanted to process them elsewhere, so guards gathered up all the refugees and moved them all, en masse, to somewhere else.
It's not a queue. It's a march. Lead by Slovenian guards, taking all the refugees to a new location.
Context matters.
But Putin certainly was meddling as well. Yet, yeah, because Leave won, Cameron resigned, and Boris Johnson - who lead the Leave campaign - become Prime Minister. So absolutely no investigation into whether his campaign and his Brexit government only won and came to power because of Russian meddling was, unsurprisingly, never looked into. Though, as with Trump's election, it was definitely known - and talked about - that Russia was fuelling the fires from afar.
But the victors write the history books. So, once Leave won, this was never properly looked into at all.
Remember, Leave barely crossed the line - indeed, if the referendum had been sensibly conducted, then it wouldn't have been a simple majority (>50%) but would have stipulated a victory margin and that enough votes were cast and so forth. And by the polling numbers, it only managed to cross the line in the very week that the vote was conducted - because a migrant crisis was on the TV news every night - and it would have lost a week earlier or a week later. Shit timing, basically.






