Well, Roddenberry was an idealist. Quite unashamedly so.Cloudane wrote:Of course, Trek also has its more "actually we do have scarcity and capitalism kinda" moments especially later on
Like, he actually had a rule - for TNG - that there should be no arguments nor conflicts between crew. As his "vision" was that, by this time in the future, humans would be above all that kind of thing.
This famously infuriated script writers and actors. Because he was basically mandating that there should be no interpersonal drama nor emotion in the shows at all.
Like, sure, maybe in the future humans really do rise above it all. But, in the here and now, I've got a show to write and you're severely restricting my ability to not make it really fucking boring. Sometimes, Trek can be almost "sterile"... and that's Roddenberry's "vision" creeping in.
So, yeah, when Roddenberry died, you can definitely see - particularly with Deep Space Nine - more cynicism, drama and darkness creeping in. Because - at last! - they could write more realistically, without Roddenberry telling them off.
Yeah, it's a weird thing because Roddenberry's "vision" is often hailed as what makes Star Trek work, but it's also equally despised - because, come on, let's have some "capitalist" Ferengis meeting some "racist" aliens, as that would make for a more interesting show that can tell different stories.
Like, you want to include racists, because then you can show why being a racist is a bad idea. But if you ban all racism from your show, then you're actually, arguably, giving it a free pass, escaping all criticism. This is often what the "woke brigade" fail to appreciate - stories should have arseholes in them to act as the "negative example" of why you shouldn't ever be like that. Cain and Abel, in the Bible, is not endorsing murdering your brother - quite the opposite - but you've got to include a murder to narratively demonstrate why murder might be a poor decision to make.
Actors universally love playing the bad guy. It's the more interesting part, trying to breathe enough "Human Condition" into your character to actually explain why he's a complete arsehole. The emotional range you can play with. Any interview with an actor and they all universally say the same thing: they much prefer playing the bad guy who's an arsehole. And, truth is, we the audience most often prefer the bad guy too, even if we disapprove of them.



