gilesgoat wrote:"Fuck the shit of everything and just survive you are all by your own" .. ..
No, no. That's entirely the attitude that got us into this shit in the first place and continues to make it ever worse.
I explained this before.
Money is debt (or, well, the token system we use to measure it anyway).
So the more we retract from trading with one another - reducing our economic activity - the more fucked the economy gets.
Okay, imagine five people in a circle. Person #1 buys something from Person #2 for a fiver, so they hand a £5 note to them. Person #2 buys something from Person #3 and hand over that £5 note to them. And so forth, until Person #5 - possessing the fiver - buys something from Person #1 and the £5 note has, in fact, made a circuit.
First of all, that same £5 note has actually represented £25's worth of trade around the circle - and if it goes around again, then it's £50 of economic activity that it's furnishing. It's important to note this constant re-use, I feel, to understand that a single £5 note can keep representing a multitude of different debts, again and again.
But, second, imagine if we had a hypothetical "speed dial" and we could speed up how quickly that £5 note goes around the circle. And we dial it up, faster and faster, until it's so fast that it's just a blur... and it would appear as if everyone had the £5 note simultaneously.
It's like multitasking on a PC. Our single core CPU can only actually perform one task at a time (it's an older CPU - just one core, no multithreading tricks). But if we have that CPU switch rapidly between tasks - task #1, task #2, task #3, task #1, task #2, task #3 - then, switching quickly enough, it can give the illusion of all of the tasks running simultaneously. Even though, no, only strictly one task at a time.
So there's this notion that we could create a similar illusion - "phantom money" - by engaging in more and more trade.
Money is debt. So it only has value in the exchange. Debts are transferable - so the same note can represent a multitude of different debts, far greater than its face value, in constant trade. And there's a sense in which, the more trade that goes on, the faster the £5 note comes back, and we have this virtual "phantom money" as if people are actually richer than they strictly are.
Wealth, unto itself, is pointless. Trade is what matters.
After all, why do you want money? So that you can trade it for food, clothes, energy, rent / mortgage, etc. - and it's in that exchange that it has value and worth.
Like, we crash land in a plane on a desert island in the middle of nowhere. No-one's coming to rescue us. We've got a suitcase with a million pounds in it. But we have no shops to spend it in, we have no other people on this island whose labour we can hire, etc.. In this situation, where there is no capacity to trade it for anything, the money is useless.
I would say that all it's good for is burning to make a fire to keep you warm... but, well, the notes are made of plastic now, so it probably doesn't burn that well and would make a horrid smell, as it goes melts rather than goes up in flames. So, yeah, money's not even good for burning or wiping your arse with anymore.
Our instinct in tough times is to retract. To horde. To become selfish. But, actually, this is logically the polar opposite of what you should be doing.
(Indeed, truth is, recessions and depressions eventually end, because folks get used to it, when it's gone on for years, and they slowly start getting back into creating new businesses and trading again... and eventually get "back to normal". But while everyone's on the defensive, the economic shit will actually keep getting worse.)
This is the thing about the Banking Crisis. Yes, there were subprime mortgages which would never be paid and, suddenly, the world economy realised that it didn't have enough actual money to honour everyone's debts. So if you were the last person to get your money out of the bank / cash in your debts, then it could be you who'd be told "sorry, there is no more money left" and you just lose it all.
So we get runs on the bank. We get businesses calling in their debts with each other. And then it became hard to get loans from anyone.
Everyone was on the defensive, and were contracting - moving from trade, which matters, to hording wealth, which doesn't - and that's what causes the economic damage.
Truth is, let's be honest. Do any of us honestly believe that the amount of money out there - in notes and coins, in bank accounts, in mortgage contracts, etc. - actually adds up to exactly the value of all the resources on the entire planet?
Bollocks. Even when times are good and we're in a "boom", if everyone called everything in, so we could tally it up then we'd still have folks being told "sorry, there's just not enough money".
I mean, we know for a fact that there's the criminal black market. That fraud happens. That theft and fencing stolen goods happens. And none of that could possibly be accounted for properly in our money systems. Indeed, it's estimated that the criminal black markets, collectively, are the largest industry on the planet.
So, you know, what we could have done when the Banking Crisis happened is just say "ah, well, there probably was never actually enough money in the system anyway - it's never been an accurate measure at any point in history... so, fuck it, let's carry on and pretend like it never happened". And there would have been no contraction, no economic recessions or depressions, no hardship and no austerity. And absolutely nothing untoward would have happened.
But, as Roosevelt had it, "the only thing to fear is fear itself".
It was like everyone scrambling for the toilet roll in the pandemic. There was plenty of toilet roll. There was nothing wrong with the supply at all. As toilet roll is a bulky item, where you only make pennies profit per roll, then it doesn't make economic sense to import it. And, therefore, almost all toilet roll manufacture is done locally, in reality. So it's actually one of the safest products out there. The least likely to cause any problems, even if all the international borders were all shut for the pandemic.
There were no supply problems with toilet roll at any point... well, except that because people were panic buying 50 rolls each then, yes, they were emptying out the shelves far faster than they could ever be filled. But the second everyone stopped panicking, you'll note the toilet roll shelves were back to capacity immediately.
There was no actual problem. But people, in their panic and fear, created a problem out of nothing. If people hadn't reacted with panic buying, then absolutely nothing untoward would have happened.
But, sure, it's a self-fulfilling prophecy. In that, even though I know this and am telling it to you now, did I also grab too many toilet rolls when I had the chance? Well, yeah, because you had to. As I had no idea when I'd get another chance to buy any... so I'll grab some extra "just in case".
And, in the same way, if there was an actual run on the bank, then I'd have to rush down there and get my money out. Not because anything would happen if absolutely no-one panicked, but that, once people start panicking, they create the problem... and that problem they create is quite real. The last person to pull out their money would be the one told "sorry, there's no more money" and find all their savings had just vanished.
(But, as I say, I reckon that if there was a run on the banks, even in good and prosperous times, then the same thing would actually happen as well. This only becomes a problem when people will insist on "testing" the money system to see if it really does have enough money for everyone. I think the answer, at all times - good and bad - was always simply "no". So, you know, don't panic and test the system - it will actually always fail to keep up, simply because the demand is too much.)
Don't panic. Panicking is what makes everything go to shit.
And, like with the toilet roll, once someone kicks off the "cascade", it just gets worse. Because everyone goes into "fuck everyone else" survival-mode and that actually clogs up trade... and trade is actually what you need to get the economy back on its feet again (no, not wealth. Wealth is actually a block on the flow of money. Trade is the thing you want).
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes