I like the comical idea that governments actually have any useful control over the economy.
I mean, if they could actually do that, then why would they ever choose to have a shit economy at any point?
Like, some kind of masochism, because they just love losing elections?
There was a global oil crisis in the '70s. Labour happened to be in power at the time.
Things happening at the same time does not demonstrate any causal relationship between them at all. Indeed, that's a logical fallacy and a form of "magical thinking" (namely, a "cause without mechanism").
Equally, there was a global boom - from the Dot Com bubble - when Blair and Brown got into office. Again, not causally connected. Other countries - like America - was also living the good life at that point too.
But politicians love to flatter themselves - and, for some odd reason, we seem to indulge them in their delusions of grandeur - so Brown was claiming to be fiscally responsible and an economic genius...
Same guy who later presided over the 2008 Banking Crisis. Again, a global phenomenon that affected the entire world economy.
But, hey, when shit goes wrong, then it stops being all them. Then it's everyone else. At that point, Brown was delighted to start blaming global circumstances beyond his control.
Claim credit when it's good, blame everyone else when it's bad. Same old, same old.
Boris - he'd have you believe - "got Brexit done". Even though Liz Truss now wants to save Brexit. But if it was done, then it was done. It's over, it's happened and there's nothing to be "saved".
And let's ignore that the EU treaties have built-in deadlines, so
LITERALLY DOING NOTHING would automatically result in the UK leaving the EU on WTO terms. Indeed, what May did was ask for the deadline to be extended - and the EU agreed - because, frankly, we were absolutely nowhere near ready. So Boris shows up, does quite literally nothing and this was "getting Brexit done".
Other great Boris achievements that he wants to claim credit for was the vaccine roll-out. As if, you know, he personally invented the vaccine, personally administered all the shots and did it all single-handedly.
Truth is, that one was a hilarious accident - according to Dominic Cummings' version of events - in that they were just desperate to keep this shit out of Matt Hancock's hands... so handed the logistics over to the Army and, of course, the medical side to the NHS.
And what do you know? The second the government stops messing with shit, and just lets the experts do their fucking jobs, then it's a miracle of efficiency.
I want to repeat this experiment. Hand over education policy to the teachers, and keep the government's meddling hands out of it... and we'll probably return to the top of the world's academic leaderboard once more (and go back to making a shit ton of money from foreign students again, as everyone, globally, wants to go to UK universities).
Let's be clear. The only powers that governments have is to take money from here - taxes - and put it over there - social programmes.
By definition, their powers have no economic effect. Governments like to talk about "creating jobs". But companies create jobs. Citizens setting up businesses create jobs. The only jobs that governments can "create" are civil servants, who get paid out of taxpayer money. Therefore, are economically neutral - because every penny they're paid came from someone else's taxes.
Our lives get better when scientists and engineers invent new technologies. Businesses actually create jobs and, collectively, control the economy.
All politicians are ever doing is just shuffling deckchairs... too often, aboard the Titanic.
Heck, they implicitly have admitted this by their actions. They handed control of interest rates to the Bank of England. We have "the Office of Budgetary Responsibility" exactly to purposefully tie their own hands, so they don't do something really fucking stupid.
And every reshuffle I find ridiculous. The Health Secretary is now Transport Minister. The Foreign Secretary is Education Minister. They all just swap jobs, like they're fucking swapping hats. It's implicit: None of them know what they're doing - they're all unqualified - and they have no sphere of expertise in their chosen department at all. Because, fuck it, let's all swap hats for the shits and giggles. No regard whatsoever to any of them knowing any-fucking-thing about their chosen specialist subject here.
They're all a bunch of useless tossers. And they're implicitly all fucking narcissistic idiots - because anyone with a brain has the sense to run a mile from such an obvious poison chalice as running the country. You can't fucking win. You honestly can't really do anything useful (again, because if they could, then why haven't they done it already?).
No human being can be simultaneously qualified in economics, education, science, technology, medicine and biology, astrophysics, transport, defence strategy, etc..
The whole concept of an autocrat is completely preposterous in the modern world. It's an impossible job.
The democratic conceit here is that, the idea's sound, we've just got to find the right people and vote them into power.
Great. How's that gone for the last few thousand years? We've gone through a lot of ideological narcissistic simpletons in that time... did any of them ever do anything particularly useful and impressive at any point?
Party politics is inherently corruption. Democratic representatives bribed with jobs and perks, or punished with expulsion, for towing the party line... possibly against the democratic will of their constituents who actually employ them. To represent their interests.
The whole thing is a pointless pantomime. Just to satisfy some subservient impulse to "authority" that's clearly a few million years out of date.
Autocrats could work when there was barely a hundred of us, with nothing more complicated than starting a camp fire outside the cave entrance to cook the meat and fruit that the hunters and gatherers brought back. Back then, it was undoubtedly awesome and allowed our species to survive - but now it's just a legacy chain dragging us down, that we feel there has to be an "Alpha" at the top for us all to kow-tow to. We already worked out that this was a really fucking dumb move by 1215 - and the Yanks had the sense to copy that in 1776 - but yet it somehow uselessly persists, to our collective detriment.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes